[Dynasty] RBs - Top Dog (1 Viewer)

FUBAR · Feb 8, 2008

These 4 seem to be the only real options as the top RB. Some people may prefer Addai to a couple of these, but we don't see too many ratings without one of these 4 on top.

Please rate each of the canidates 1-5, 1 being lowest, 5 being uber-stud. You can vote two players as 5's if you wish.

if you think another RB should be the top RB, still please vote, but post your top RB. Same if you think someone else should be 2nd. Right now, I intend to keep these 4 and might add Addai to the next poll.

this technique will only go until the top four or five are rated, at the most. Maybe not even that, if this is overly confusing.

Burning Sensation · Feb 8, 2008

Peterson

1 [ 3 ] [50.00%]

2 [ 0 ] [0.00%]

3 [ 0 ] [0.00%]

4 [ 1 ] [16.67%]

5 [ 2 ] [33.33%]

I think there is some confusion here.

FUBAR · Feb 8, 2008

Burning Sensation said:
I think there is some confusion here.

Obviously; I have since editted the poll and title. hopefully nobody else will be confused. I'll consider all of the "1" and "2"'s discounted, won't be factored in.

Keys Myaths · Feb 8, 2008

Yitbos69 · Feb 8, 2008

KISS

Burning Sensation · Feb 8, 2008

I think we found our #1 :goodposting:

Yitbos69 · Feb 8, 2008

Could we please keep the Dynasty Poll Rankings for the RB's in the same format as the rankings for the Qb's and WR's from here on out?!

FUBAR · Feb 9, 2008

Yitbos69 said:
Could we please keep the Dynasty Poll Rankings for the RB's in the same format as the rankings for the Qb's and WR's from here on out?!

I seriously can't believe this is too difficult. After I editted it, there doesn't seem to be much confusion.Then again, I'm not sure we cleared up who's #1 either. I'll probably call AD and LT 1a and 1b, SJax #3 and Westbrook #4. From here on out, the polls will be the same as the others, unless we need a tiebreaker.

Burning Sensation · Feb 9, 2008

FUBAR said:
Yitbos69 said:

Could we please keep the Dynasty Poll Rankings for the RB's in the same format as the rankings for the Qb's and WR's from here on out?!

Click to expand...

I seriously can't believe this is too difficult. After I editted it, there doesn't seem to be much confusion.Then again, I'm not sure we cleared up who's #1 either. I'll probably call AD and LT 1a and 1b, SJax #3 and Westbrook #4. From here on out, the polls will be the same as the others, unless we need a tiebreaker.

I dont think it is the difficulty that has people concerned. It is the fact that nobody actually voted for anyone. Why dont we call AD #1, and move to the regular polling method?

Road Warriors · Feb 9, 2008

FUBAR said:
Yitbos69 said:

Could we please keep the Dynasty Poll Rankings for the RB's in the same format as the rankings for the Qb's and WR's from here on out?!

Click to expand...

I seriously can't believe this is too difficult. After I editted it, there doesn't seem to be much confusion.Then again, I'm not sure we cleared up who's #1 either. I'll probably call AD and LT 1a and 1b, SJax #3 and Westbrook #4. From here on out, the polls will be the same as the others, unless we need a tiebreaker.

I was one that misinterpreted, before the additional instructions. The main issue I see with the method, IMO, is that 2, 3, or all 4 should be rated at a 5 ( Uber Stud ), depending on your projections. It will be very difficult to separate the results. FWIW, I went with a 5, 4,3,2 system, so at least one of my votes is being discarded. I guess I'm one of the "not quite smart enough" crowd.

All 5sJacksonADPLTWestyin that order. IMO

loose circuits · Feb 9, 2008

Addai should be considered. I have him at 3

FUBAR · Feb 9, 2008

Burning Sensation said:
FUBAR said:

Yitbos69 said:

Could we please keep the Dynasty Poll Rankings for the RB's in the same format as the rankings for the Qb's and WR's from here on out?!

Click to expand...

I seriously can't believe this is too difficult. After I editted it, there doesn't seem to be much confusion.Then again, I'm not sure we cleared up who's #1 either. I'll probably call AD and LT 1a and 1b, SJax #3 and Westbrook #4. From here on out, the polls will be the same as the others, unless we need a tiebreaker.

Click to expand...

I dont think it is the difficulty that has people concerned. It is the fact that nobody actually voted for anyone. Why dont we call AD #1, and move to the regular polling method?

Votes changed a little since I looked, but I'm going to leave this up for a few more hours, and then, because IMO it's pretty clear where people value these players, I'll go withAD

LT

SJax

Westbrook

The list I will include, alphabetically:

Joseph Addai 5/3/1983

Marion Barber 6/10/1983

Reggie Bush 3/2/1985

Frank Gore 5/14/1983

Larry Johnson 11/19/1979

Maurice Jones-Drew 3/23/1985

Marshawn Lynch 4/22/1986

Laurence Maroney 2/5/1985

Darren McFadden 8/27/1987

Willie Parker 11/11/1980

Clinton Portis 9/1/1981

Michael Turner 2/13/1982

If anyone else should be, let's hear it.

Yitbos69 · Feb 9, 2008

FUBAR said:
Yitbos69 said:

Could we please keep the Dynasty Poll Rankings for the RB's in the same format as the rankings for the Qb's and WR's from here on out?!

Click to expand...

I seriously can't believe this is too difficult. After I editted it, there doesn't seem to be much confusion.Then again, I'm not sure we cleared up who's #1 either. I'll probably call AD and LT 1a and 1b, SJax #3 and Westbrook #4. From here on out, the polls will be the same as the others, unless we need a tiebreaker.

For me it really has nothing to do with how difficult the poll is.....I just think we should keep them uniform...thanks

FUBAR · Feb 9, 2008

CLOSED:

1. Adrian Peterson (AD) MN 3/21/85

1 [ 7 ] ** [5.93%]

2 [ 0 ] ** [0.00%]

3 [ 0 ] ** [0.00%]

4 [ 26 ] ** [22.03%]

5 [ 85 ] ** [72.03%]

2. Ladanian Tomlinson SD 6/23/79

1 [ 2 ] ** [1.69%]

2 [ 3 ] ** [2.54%]

3 [ 8 ] ** [6.78%]

4 [ 33 ] ** [27.97%]

5 [ 72 ] ** [61.02%]

3. Stephen Jackson STL 7/22/83

1 [ 0 ] ** [0.00%]

2 [ 4 ] ** [3.39%]

3 [ 9 ] ** [7.63%]

4 [ 48 ] ** [40.68%]

5 [ 57 ] ** [48.31%]

4. Brian Westbrook PHI 9/2/79

1 [ 1 ] ** [0.85%]

2 [ 6 ] ** [5.08%]

3 [ 16 ] ** [13.56%]

4 [ 71 ] ** [60.17%]

5 [ 24 ] ** [20.34%]

phthalatemagic · Feb 9, 2008

Keys Myaths said:

FUBAR · Feb 9, 2008

phthalatemagic said:
Keys Myaths said:

Click to expand...

Thanks for sharing. Move along.

snorlax · Feb 10, 2008

I'm not sure how Westbrook got handed the 4th slot. Addai would probably be 4th at the least if polls were conducted.

FUBAR · Feb 10, 2008

snorlax said:
I'm not sure how Westbrook got handed the 4th slot. Addai would probably be 4th at the least if polls were conducted.

And yet, only one person posted that before I called the polls. I'll go ahead and restart, no need to rush these, but I'm betting 4 to donuts that the top 4 turn out the same.

[Dynasty] RBs - Top Dog (1 Viewer)

Stephen Jackson STL 7/22/83

1

2

3

4

5

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Pokerguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Zzzzzzzzzzzz.

Footballguy

Similar threads

Users who are viewing this thread