What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Peyton Manning HURT? Possible RUMOR but? (1 Viewer)

DonnyT33

Footballguy
Just found this at the NFFC MB and am hoping its BS..but its out there.. anyone hear anything about this???? DON'T KILL THE MESSENGER PLEASE...I am only trying to find out if this has any truth to it at all....

http://www.stampedeblue.com/2010/9/17/1694...manning-is-hurt

am so hoping this is some sort of BS hoax and or traffic generator but have no idea!! The one year i took some stock in any QB early and it was him!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
He's not hurt...BS ....I'm listeningt to NFL Sirius radio, no mention.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
He's not hurt...BS
Hope so guy...like i say i am just showing what i just noticed..and after checking just now again i see the post was made early today so i am hope its a non issue as if anything was up it would have blown up by now i would think since it was posted on the NFFC MB at 11:10 am today....I will say i didn't even know he had neck surgery this off season and i pretty much on top of all things FF related...must have been a very minor thing?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
He's not hurt...BS ....I'm listeningt to NFL Sirius radio, no mention.
well thats part of this...its being kept quiet intentionally perhaps? But now thinking the NFL would come down heavy if Indy made no such claims on the injury report this week.....no idea what to make of this..does anyone know of this website or the people who own/run it? Where is Indy Wayne when we need him!!! lol but Wayne might know about this site..
 
I guess I personally don't know for sure...but to me, this would get out somehow. + like you said, the NFL would tear the Colts a new one...you can't baltently hide injuries.

 
Just found this at the NFFC MB and am hoping its BS..but its out there.. anyone hear anything about this???? DON'T KILL THE MESSENGER PLEASE...I am only trying to find out if this has any truth to it at all....

http://www.stampedeblue.com/2010/9/17/1694...manning-is-hurt

am so hoping this is some sort of BS hoax and or traffic generator but have no idea!! The one year i took some stock in any QB early and it was him!
Ok, really, really not sending out alarms bells...

....but: I could not help but think of the THIRD manning brother, Cooper Manning, and his story is well known here in New Orleans.

Cooper played wide receiver with Peyton at Newman. He was a riser in high school and they formed a lethal on field combination together. He was MVP on a team on which Peyton Manning was the quarterback; think about that. Their high school challenged for state championships they previously could never even sniff before in their history. But then something happened. From a random article that pops up at the top of the google for --"Cooper Manning" injury--:

>>>>Cooper didn't drop a pass his entire junior year as an All-State wideout. Then came his senior season, when he and new varsity quarterback Peyton led the team to the state semifinals. Cooper caught 76 passes for 1,250 yards and was named the team's most valuable player.

"Being on the same team with Cooper was one of the best years I've ever had," says Peyton, who often communicated with his brother with their own set of hand signals.

Their father, meanwhile, remembers Cooper's intense dedication to excel. "He worked really hard at getting himself bigger and trying to be fast enough to be a college receiver," says Archie. "He probably had further to go than Peyton and Eli to become a college prospect. And I was so proud of his work ethic and accomplishing that. Then all of a sudden, it was taken away."

Cooper had started noticing his right pinky and ring finger going numb. Sometimes, the sensation felt more like pinpricks. Other times, the hand seemed to lose all its strength. Late in the season, Cooper dropped some passes uncharacteristically.

He kept the problem to himself. He was still so good, nobody suspected anything was wrong.

* * *

But there was something wrong, indeed.

At the start of basketball season, Cooper could tell his shots lacked the normal touch and control. He worked on dribbling and shooting left-handed and still averaged a dozen points on a team that won the state 2A championship. He remained mum about the problem, not wanting opponents to target him, but did confide in his father.

After the season, Archie took Cooper to a New Orleans surgeon, whose diagnosis was an injured ulnar nerve, a common ailment for football players that can cause numbness in the fingers and hand. Surgery was performed and Cooper worked through the pain after the cast was removed, excelling in a summer all-star football game. He left for Mississippi, hoping to get healthier as a freshman. But the pain and numbness persisted during August practices.

At the urging of the team doctor, Archie took his son to specialists at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., and the Baylor Medical Clinic. Cooper was tested by a half-dozen doctors through September. One of them from Baylor finally called Archie with the shocking news. Cooper suffered from a congenital condition called spinal stenosis, a narrowing of the spinal canal. The upshot: He needed surgery and had to quit football immediately. .... <<<

http://www.sptimes.com/2004/11/07/Sports/T...r_Manning.shtml

This is just an fyi for interested football fans maybe, an interesting story about the "third Manning brother".... but I also could not help but notice the similarity with the above linked report: "If you're still intrigued, the neck injury is shooting pain down Peyton's throwing arm." And from the linked source, "Peyton Manning yesterday underwent a procedure to relieve pain in his neck caused by a pinched nerve. This condition has existed intermittently for the past four years."

Cooper's condition was described as "congenital," I have no idea if that equates to hereditary.

 
Cooper's condition was described as "congenital," I have no idea if that equates to hereditary.
It means he's had it since birth, not something he acquired later.
Hereditary would be since birth, no?Point being, in case it's not clear... that Manning could have a hereditary condition and it just takes the right/wrong hit (or enough of them) to bring it out.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
i think hereditary implies it was passed from your parents genes. congenital would imply something else like a defective gene or such. not necessarily for your parents but something that happened during development.

i'm not a doctor but I stayed in a Holiday Inn Express once.

 
i think hereditary implies it was passed from your parents genes. congenital would imply something else like a defective gene or such. not necessarily for your parents but something that happened during development. i'm not a doctor but I stayed in a Holiday Inn Express once.
Ok, this makes sense, thanks.
 
Congenital conditions refer to conditions with which an individual is born. Cleft palate, spina bifida, and various anatomical deformities are examples.

Hereditary conditions refer to conditions which are conferred due to genetics but not necessarily present at the time of birth. Risk for heart disease, baldness, certain cancers, and MS are examples.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
richn said:
He's not hurt...BS ....I'm listeningt to NFL Sirius radio, no mention.
FWIW last time 'stampede blue' had a like rumor people laughed and scoffed. some of us adjusted our boards and were handsomely paid off, as Peyton opened with prolly his worst half season/slowest start of his career (as he and the team did hide a second surgery-- and that website called it 2-3 months early)

2008 Manning thread: Props again to djcolts for that one!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
richn said:
I guess I personally don't know for sure...but to me, this would get out somehow. + like you said, the NFL would tear the Colts a new one...you can't baltently hide injuries.
They did in 2008. explicitly. This was about 2.5 months after the stampede blue post. ;)
Colts coach Tony Dungy confirmed Monday that Peyton Manning had a second surgery on his knee this offseason.Clearly, it is not a concern any longer, but this helps explain Manning's relatively slow start to the season. Manning's first surgery was to remove an inflamed bursa sac. There were rumors at the time that he developed an infection after the first surgery, which may have prompted the second. Manning threw for three touchdowns against the Ravens in Week 6. Source: Associated Press
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Cooper wasn't fast enough to be a studly WR but everything I have read He would of been good enough to make an NFL roster.

 
richn said:
He's not hurt...BS ....I'm listeningt to NFL Sirius radio, no mention.
FWIW last time 'stampede blue' had a like rumor people laughed and scoffed. some of us adjusted our boards and were handsomely paid off, as Peyton opened with prolly his worst half season/slowest start of his career (as he and the team did hide a second surgery-- and that website called it 2-3 months early)

2008 Manning thread: Props again to djcolts for that one!
Oh boy...this is NOT what i wanted to hear Hip...you mean this site has been known to be right and reputable? F me!!! Could it be that he isn't telling anyone other than some relatives or buddies? He looked OK talking about this weeks match up with his brother in the one clip Ive seen of him so far this week...what the #%#$##$$ is going on here now!???
 
richn said:
He's not hurt...BS ....I'm listeningt to NFL Sirius radio, no mention.
FWIW last time 'stampede blue' had a like rumor people laughed and scoffed. some of us adjusted our boards and were handsomely paid off, as Peyton opened with prolly his worst half season/slowest start of his career (as he and the team did hide a second surgery-- and that website called it 2-3 months early)

2008 Manning thread: Props again to djcolts for that one!
Oh boy...this is NOT what i wanted to hear Hip...you mean this site has been known to be right and reputable? F me!!! Could it be that he isn't telling anyone other than some relatives or buddies? He looked OK talking about this weeks match up with his brother in the one clip Ive seen of him so far this week...what the #%#$##$$ is going on here now!???
The site and author are. Reading into this story it sounds like it's not a 'trusted informant'/ie someone they have gotten news from, but the 'anonymous source' had enough info that fit what this guy sees in Peyton, for him to call it that way. These guys are nut's for the colts. Honestly if you even think this has a 40% chance of being true, trade peyton now. You'll still command top dollar, and so you won't suffer too bad. If wrong, you just traded peyton for a different stud. If right, you've rid yourself of a potential HUGE bust/harm to your team, and maybe in 2-3 weeks it's too late as the news is out.

I don't own him, so I don't have too, but I would hate to be in your shoes right now.

 
SaintsInDome2006 said:
DonnyT33 said:
Just found this at the NFFC MB and am hoping its BS..but its out there.. anyone hear anything about this???? DON'T KILL THE MESSENGER PLEASE...I am only trying to find out if this has any truth to it at all....

http://www.stampedeblue.com/2010/9/17/1694...manning-is-hurt

am so hoping this is some sort of BS hoax and or traffic generator but have no idea!! The one year i took some stock in any QB early and it was him!
Ok, really, really not sending out alarms bells...

....but: I could not help but think of the THIRD manning brother, Cooper Manning, and his story is well known here in New Orleans.

Cooper played wide receiver with Peyton at Newman. He was a riser in high school and they formed a lethal on field combination together. He was MVP on a team on which Peyton Manning was the quarterback; think about that. Their high school challenged for state championships they previously could never even sniff before in their history. But then something happened. From a random article that pops up at the top of the google for --"Cooper Manning" injury--:

>>>>Cooper didn't drop a pass his entire junior year as an All-State wideout. Then came his senior season, when he and new varsity quarterback Peyton led the team to the state semifinals. Cooper caught 76 passes for 1,250 yards and was named the team's most valuable player.

"Being on the same team with Cooper was one of the best years I've ever had," says Peyton, who often communicated with his brother with their own set of hand signals.

Their father, meanwhile, remembers Cooper's intense dedication to excel. "He worked really hard at getting himself bigger and trying to be fast enough to be a college receiver," says Archie. "He probably had further to go than Peyton and Eli to become a college prospect. And I was so proud of his work ethic and accomplishing that. Then all of a sudden, it was taken away."

Cooper had started noticing his right pinky and ring finger going numb. Sometimes, the sensation felt more like pinpricks. Other times, the hand seemed to lose all its strength. Late in the season, Cooper dropped some passes uncharacteristically.

He kept the problem to himself. He was still so good, nobody suspected anything was wrong.

* * *

But there was something wrong, indeed.

At the start of basketball season, Cooper could tell his shots lacked the normal touch and control. He worked on dribbling and shooting left-handed and still averaged a dozen points on a team that won the state 2A championship. He remained mum about the problem, not wanting opponents to target him, but did confide in his father.

After the season, Archie took Cooper to a New Orleans surgeon, whose diagnosis was an injured ulnar nerve, a common ailment for football players that can cause numbness in the fingers and hand. Surgery was performed and Cooper worked through the pain after the cast was removed, excelling in a summer all-star football game. He left for Mississippi, hoping to get healthier as a freshman. But the pain and numbness persisted during August practices.

At the urging of the team doctor, Archie took his son to specialists at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., and the Baylor Medical Clinic. Cooper was tested by a half-dozen doctors through September. One of them from Baylor finally called Archie with the shocking news. Cooper suffered from a congenital condition called spinal stenosis, a narrowing of the spinal canal. The upshot: He needed surgery and had to quit football immediately. .... <<<

http://www.sptimes.com/2004/11/07/Sports/T...r_Manning.shtml

This is just an fyi for interested football fans maybe, an interesting story about the "third Manning brother".... but I also could not help but notice the similarity with the above linked report: "If you're still intrigued, the neck injury is shooting pain down Peyton's throwing arm." And from the linked source, "Peyton Manning yesterday underwent a procedure to relieve pain in his neck caused by a pinched nerve. This condition has existed intermittently for the past four years."

Cooper's condition was described as "congenital," I have no idea if that equates to hereditary.
Thanks. That was interesting. I always wondered what the third Manning brother felt about being the 'non superbowl winning qb' in the family

 
Fwiw here's the 2008 back story. Peyton had the bursa sac removed in the offseason. But had been 'hiding' his rehab. So there were a LOT of rumors swirling (why I started the thread as I was debating keeping Manning vs Keeping ). DJcolts found this Stampede Blue blog post in august, which wasn't officially confirmed until 2.5 months later. I still remember being ROYALLY mocked at the draft when I switched from the manning keeper and stated after someone else drafted manning that "I didn't draft Manning because 'my sources' say that Manning had a second surgery.' I was roundly ridiculed for the rest of the draft. People asking me 'inside info from my sources on every pick etc...

Not only did I win that year, but it was especially sweet to post the news story about the second surgery on the page, and tell them that any future info from my sources would only be available by a subscription based newsletter. Funny not one reply to that one!

Report: Peyton Manning had second surgery on his knee last month

by BigBlueShoe on Aug 21, 2008 11:56 AM EDT in Colts News

The more I read on this subject, the more I get the feeling the Colts have flat out lied to the fans and the media. Michael Lombardi, the former personnel head for the Oakland Raiders, does a column for The National Football Post. He's a knowledgeable guy with friends and contacts throughout the NFL. His column dated for today reveals from very serious information on Peyton Manning's surgery and recovery:

Apparently Manning had to go through another procedure on his knee to clean things out after having his bursa sac removed last month. What is the most concerning is not the second operation (which the Colts are denying), but that they cannot control the swelling in Manning's knee and any physical movement causes MORE swelling. Once he returns to the game, gets hit, has to place a load on the knee, and drive the ball, there can be swelling. All I know is that there is MUCH more here than meets the eye. Manning has the trainer come over to HIS home for rehab and is rarely seen. Now, I have been with some big-time quarterbacks in my career like Joe Montana and Rich Gannon and never have they rehabbed from home. I thought this was not an issue and that Manning would be back.

Unless Lombardi is lying, or his sources are full of i

t, the Colts have been fibbing to fans and media about Peyton Manning's recovery. A second procedure is a pretty big friggin' deal, even if it was to clean up some minor stuff in the knee. Even if the knee is fine, and has no structural damage, it's pretty damn important to tell your fans (who are bought tickets to the opening of their public funded stadium at $160 bucks a pop).

The more you read into this, with players and coaches getting quoted as saying they'd like Peyton back for the opener, but... the more I get the sense the Colts are softening the fanbase up to the prospect that Jim Sorgi will start Week One against the Chicago Bears. We're hearing players saying things like "We'd like to have him back, but he just needs to not miss any playoff games."

Ugh.

Again, there is also encouraging news, like Peyton leading the offense through a walk through yesterday. But if Peyton did indeed have a second "routine procedure," then all this stuff Bill Polian has fed to us about everything being fine and right on schedule is complete and utter bullsh*t.

I certainly hope I'm wrong. I hope Lombardi is wrong and he is totally full of it. But, from the looks of it, Lombardi looks credible, and the Colts are not credible when it comes to reporting injury updates. They are also just flat our BAD at rehabbing their players and getting them ready to play. They screwed it up for Bob Sanders in 2006, Marvin Harrison in 2007, and now maybe Peyton Manning in 2008.

Again, I hope this is false. It just doesn't seem false, and Bill Polian and the Colts crappy PR department might have a lot of explaining to do.
THis was my response and was the previous last post of the old thread

BUMP for MAD PROPS TO DJCOLTS. It was based on this info unearthed from the muck of prseasons bloggers that led me to pass on (and not keep manning in a 10 team keeper at a second round value) Instead I tossed Manning back and was roundly ridculed when I said matter of factly "my sources say Manning had a second surgery and will struggle much worse than people think". So I drafted Andre Johnson, and then some guy named Jay Cutler (when I never would have taken Cutler if I had Manning. It's collective work like this thread that is why FBG is the BOMB.

DJColtss. I (and many others here I am guessing) Owe you a nice cold drink! :popcorn:

Now if you ever leave that boring ####hole and come to Atlanta like I've been screaming for years this might happen. :nerd:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Who is his backup?
Last I heard Sorgi, but IIRC he's dinged too.The implication of the blogger was that although he's hurt, he's not OUT hurt, but that it affects his accuracy and causes him a lot of pain etc, which would just make it harder to play, one play closer to the play that ends your day/week/month/season. But he was somewhat ambiguous as to what the net effect of the injury is.
 
Who is his backup?
Last I heard Sorgi, but IIRC he's dinged too.The implication of the blogger was that although he's hurt, he's not OUT hurt, but that it affects his accuracy and causes him a lot of pain etc, which would just make it harder to play, one play closer to the play that ends your day/week/month/season. But he was somewhat ambiguous as to what the net effect of the injury is.
Sorgi is the backup for the other Manning. Not this week, though.
 
Who is his backup?
Last I heard Sorgi, but IIRC he's dinged too.The implication of the blogger was that although he's hurt, he's not OUT hurt, but that it affects his accuracy and causes him a lot of pain etc, which would just make it harder to play, one play closer to the play that ends your day/week/month/season. But he was somewhat ambiguous as to what the net effect of the injury is.
Sorgi is the backup for the other Manning. Not this week, though.
Painter.Makes Sorgi look like Bart Starr.
 
SaintsInDome2006 said:
DonnyT33 said:
Just found this at the NFFC MB and am hoping its BS..but its out there.. anyone hear anything about this???? DON'T KILL THE MESSENGER PLEASE...I am only trying to find out if this has any truth to it at all....

http://www.stampedeblue.com/2010/9/17/1694...manning-is-hurt

am so hoping this is some sort of BS hoax and or traffic generator but have no idea!! The one year i took some stock in any QB early and it was him!
Ok, really, really not sending out alarms bells...

....but: I could not help but think of the THIRD manning brother, Cooper Manning, and his story is well known here in New Orleans.

Cooper played wide receiver with Peyton at Newman. He was a riser in high school and they formed a lethal on field combination together. He was MVP on a team on which Peyton Manning was the quarterback; think about that. Their high school challenged for state championships they previously could never even sniff before in their history. But then something happened. From a random article that pops up at the top of the google for --"Cooper Manning" injury--:

>>>>Cooper didn't drop a pass his entire junior year as an All-State wideout. Then came his senior season, when he and new varsity quarterback Peyton led the team to the state semifinals. Cooper caught 76 passes for 1,250 yards and was named the team's most valuable player.

"Being on the same team with Cooper was one of the best years I've ever had," says Peyton, who often communicated with his brother with their own set of hand signals.

Their father, meanwhile, remembers Cooper's intense dedication to excel. "He worked really hard at getting himself bigger and trying to be fast enough to be a college receiver," says Archie. "He probably had further to go than Peyton and Eli to become a college prospect. And I was so proud of his work ethic and accomplishing that. Then all of a sudden, it was taken away."

Cooper had started noticing his right pinky and ring finger going numb. Sometimes, the sensation felt more like pinpricks. Other times, the hand seemed to lose all its strength. Late in the season, Cooper dropped some passes uncharacteristically.

He kept the problem to himself. He was still so good, nobody suspected anything was wrong.

* * *

But there was something wrong, indeed.

At the start of basketball season, Cooper could tell his shots lacked the normal touch and control. He worked on dribbling and shooting left-handed and still averaged a dozen points on a team that won the state 2A championship. He remained mum about the problem, not wanting opponents to target him, but did confide in his father.

After the season, Archie took Cooper to a New Orleans surgeon, whose diagnosis was an injured ulnar nerve, a common ailment for football players that can cause numbness in the fingers and hand. Surgery was performed and Cooper worked through the pain after the cast was removed, excelling in a summer all-star football game. He left for Mississippi, hoping to get healthier as a freshman. But the pain and numbness persisted during August practices.

At the urging of the team doctor, Archie took his son to specialists at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., and the Baylor Medical Clinic. Cooper was tested by a half-dozen doctors through September. One of them from Baylor finally called Archie with the shocking news. Cooper suffered from a congenital condition called spinal stenosis, a narrowing of the spinal canal. The upshot: He needed surgery and had to quit football immediately. .... <<<

http://www.sptimes.com/2004/11/07/Sports/T...r_Manning.shtml

This is just an fyi for interested football fans maybe, an interesting story about the "third Manning brother".... but I also could not help but notice the similarity with the above linked report: "If you're still intrigued, the neck injury is shooting pain down Peyton's throwing arm." And from the linked source, "Peyton Manning yesterday underwent a procedure to relieve pain in his neck caused by a pinched nerve. This condition has existed intermittently for the past four years."

Cooper's condition was described as "congenital," I have no idea if that equates to hereditary.
Thanks. That was interesting. I always wondered what the third Manning brother felt about being the 'non superbowl winning qb' in the family
Archie doesn't have a ring either.

 
SaintsInDome2006 said:
DonnyT33 said:
Just found this at the NFFC MB and am hoping its BS..but its out there.. anyone hear anything about this???? DON'T KILL THE MESSENGER PLEASE...I am only trying to find out if this has any truth to it at all....

http://www.stampedeblue.com/2010/9/17/1694...manning-is-hurt

am so hoping this is some sort of BS hoax and or traffic generator but have no idea!! The one year i took some stock in any QB early and it was him!
Ok, really, really not sending out alarms bells...

....but: I could not help but think of the THIRD manning brother, Cooper Manning, and his story is well known here in New Orleans.

Cooper played wide receiver with Peyton at Newman. He was a riser in high school and they formed a lethal on field combination together. He was MVP on a team on which Peyton Manning was the quarterback; think about that. Their high school challenged for state championships they previously could never even sniff before in their history. But then something happened. From a random article that pops up at the top of the google for --"Cooper Manning" injury--:

>>>>Cooper didn't drop a pass his entire junior year as an All-State wideout. Then came his senior season, when he and new varsity quarterback Peyton led the team to the state semifinals. Cooper caught 76 passes for 1,250 yards and was named the team's most valuable player.

"Being on the same team with Cooper was one of the best years I've ever had," says Peyton, who often communicated with his brother with their own set of hand signals.

Their father, meanwhile, remembers Cooper's intense dedication to excel. "He worked really hard at getting himself bigger and trying to be fast enough to be a college receiver," says Archie. "He probably had further to go than Peyton and Eli to become a college prospect. And I was so proud of his work ethic and accomplishing that. Then all of a sudden, it was taken away."

Cooper had started noticing his right pinky and ring finger going numb. Sometimes, the sensation felt more like pinpricks. Other times, the hand seemed to lose all its strength. Late in the season, Cooper dropped some passes uncharacteristically.

He kept the problem to himself. He was still so good, nobody suspected anything was wrong.

* * *

But there was something wrong, indeed.

At the start of basketball season, Cooper could tell his shots lacked the normal touch and control. He worked on dribbling and shooting left-handed and still averaged a dozen points on a team that won the state 2A championship. He remained mum about the problem, not wanting opponents to target him, but did confide in his father.

After the season, Archie took Cooper to a New Orleans surgeon, whose diagnosis was an injured ulnar nerve, a common ailment for football players that can cause numbness in the fingers and hand. Surgery was performed and Cooper worked through the pain after the cast was removed, excelling in a summer all-star football game. He left for Mississippi, hoping to get healthier as a freshman. But the pain and numbness persisted during August practices.

At the urging of the team doctor, Archie took his son to specialists at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., and the Baylor Medical Clinic. Cooper was tested by a half-dozen doctors through September. One of them from Baylor finally called Archie with the shocking news. Cooper suffered from a congenital condition called spinal stenosis, a narrowing of the spinal canal. The upshot: He needed surgery and had to quit football immediately. .... <<<

http://www.sptimes.com/2004/11/07/Sports/T...r_Manning.shtml

This is just an fyi for interested football fans maybe, an interesting story about the "third Manning brother".... but I also could not help but notice the similarity with the above linked report: "If you're still intrigued, the neck injury is shooting pain down Peyton's throwing arm." And from the linked source, "Peyton Manning yesterday underwent a procedure to relieve pain in his neck caused by a pinched nerve. This condition has existed intermittently for the past four years."

Cooper's condition was described as "congenital," I have no idea if that equates to hereditary.
Thanks. That was interesting. I always wondered what the third Manning brother felt about being the 'non superbowl winning qb' in the family
Archie doesn't have a ring either.
Archie's their dad, dude.
 
SaintsInDome2006 said:
DonnyT33 said:
Just found this at the NFFC MB and am hoping its BS..but its out there.. anyone hear anything about this???? DON'T KILL THE MESSENGER PLEASE...I am only trying to find out if this has any truth to it at all....

http://www.stampedeblue.com/2010/9/17/1694...manning-is-hurt

am so hoping this is some sort of BS hoax and or traffic generator but have no idea!! The one year i took some stock in any QB early and it was him!
Ok, really, really not sending out alarms bells...

....but: I could not help but think of the THIRD manning brother, Cooper Manning, and his story is well known here in New Orleans.

Cooper played wide receiver with Peyton at Newman. He was a riser in high school and they formed a lethal on field combination together. He was MVP on a team on which Peyton Manning was the quarterback; think about that. Their high school challenged for state championships they previously could never even sniff before in their history. But then something happened. From a random article that pops up at the top of the google for --"Cooper Manning" injury--:

>>>>Cooper didn't drop a pass his entire junior year as an All-State wideout. Then came his senior season, when he and new varsity quarterback Peyton led the team to the state semifinals. Cooper caught 76 passes for 1,250 yards and was named the team's most valuable player.

"Being on the same team with Cooper was one of the best years I've ever had," says Peyton, who often communicated with his brother with their own set of hand signals.

Their father, meanwhile, remembers Cooper's intense dedication to excel. "He worked really hard at getting himself bigger and trying to be fast enough to be a college receiver," says Archie. "He probably had further to go than Peyton and Eli to become a college prospect. And I was so proud of his work ethic and accomplishing that. Then all of a sudden, it was taken away."

Cooper had started noticing his right pinky and ring finger going numb. Sometimes, the sensation felt more like pinpricks. Other times, the hand seemed to lose all its strength. Late in the season, Cooper dropped some passes uncharacteristically.

He kept the problem to himself. He was still so good, nobody suspected anything was wrong.

* * *

But there was something wrong, indeed.

At the start of basketball season, Cooper could tell his shots lacked the normal touch and control. He worked on dribbling and shooting left-handed and still averaged a dozen points on a team that won the state 2A championship. He remained mum about the problem, not wanting opponents to target him, but did confide in his father.

After the season, Archie took Cooper to a New Orleans surgeon, whose diagnosis was an injured ulnar nerve, a common ailment for football players that can cause numbness in the fingers and hand. Surgery was performed and Cooper worked through the pain after the cast was removed, excelling in a summer all-star football game. He left for Mississippi, hoping to get healthier as a freshman. But the pain and numbness persisted during August practices.

At the urging of the team doctor, Archie took his son to specialists at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., and the Baylor Medical Clinic. Cooper was tested by a half-dozen doctors through September. One of them from Baylor finally called Archie with the shocking news. Cooper suffered from a congenital condition called spinal stenosis, a narrowing of the spinal canal. The upshot: He needed surgery and had to quit football immediately. .... <<<

http://www.sptimes.com/2004/11/07/Sports/T...r_Manning.shtml

This is just an fyi for interested football fans maybe, an interesting story about the "third Manning brother".... but I also could not help but notice the similarity with the above linked report: "If you're still intrigued, the neck injury is shooting pain down Peyton's throwing arm." And from the linked source, "Peyton Manning yesterday underwent a procedure to relieve pain in his neck caused by a pinched nerve. This condition has existed intermittently for the past four years."

Cooper's condition was described as "congenital," I have no idea if that equates to hereditary.
Thanks. That was interesting. I always wondered what the third Manning brother felt about being the 'non superbowl winning qb' in the family
Archie doesn't have a ring either.
Archie's their dad, dude.
The bolded was the claim.

Besides, Cooper was a wide receiver.

 
With the amount of money that's in this game (Fantasy Football) these days, I'm starting get suspicious of some of these "rumors" from "anonymous sources."

 
Last edited by a moderator:
He's not hurt...BS ....I'm listeningt to NFL Sirius radio, no mention.
FWIW last time 'stampede blue' had a like rumor people laughed and scoffed. some of us adjusted our boards and were handsomely paid off, as Peyton opened with prolly his worst half season/slowest start of his career (as he and the team did hide a second surgery-- and that website called it 2-3 months early)

2008 Manning thread: Props again to djcolts for that one!
Oh boy...this is NOT what i wanted to hear Hip...you mean this site has been known to be right and reputable? F me!!! Could it be that he isn't telling anyone other than some relatives or buddies? He looked OK talking about this weeks match up with his brother in the one clip Ive seen of him so far this week...what the #%#$##$ is going on here now!???
The site and author are. Reading into this story it sounds like it's not a 'trusted informant'/ie someone they have gotten news from, but the 'anonymous source' had enough info that fit what this guy sees in Peyton, for him to call it that way. These guys are nut's for the colts. Honestly if you even think this has a 40% chance of being true, trade peyton now. You'll still command top dollar, and so you won't suffer too bad. If wrong, you just traded peyton for a different stud. If right, you've rid yourself of a potential HUGE bust/harm to your team, and maybe in 2-3 weeks it's too late as the news is out.

I don't own him, so I don't have too, but I would hate to be in your shoes right now.
:grad:
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top