AwesomeAuger
Footballguy
I don't agree with it, but Flacco would not be available in the second round. If Flacco was his top player, he has to take him. For that reason, I can't criticize any of the picks so far.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Build a FRANCHISE draft (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter JMon348
- Start date
RBM
Footballguy
He's played 5 yrs and has 9 playoff wins. You're gonna downgrade him for not putting up video game stats? After what we just saw him do, I figured his doubters were long gone.
Instinctive
Footballguy
1.07 J.J. Watt, DE
ETA: Central Time Zone
We'll see how this goes.
At what point do I need to declare 3-4 or 4-3? I'd rather be able to be flexible depending on how the draft goes...
ETA: Central Time Zone
We'll see how this goes.
At what point do I need to declare 3-4 or 4-3? I'd rather be able to be flexible depending on how the draft goes...
Last edited by a moderator:
FUBAR
Footballguy
I don't deride the pick, although I didn't have him in this tier. I do find it somewhat funny though that 6 months (or less) ago, he probably wouldn't have even been considered in the first 20 picks - unless they are all QBs.He's played 5 yrs and has 9 playoff wins. You're gonna downgrade him for not putting up video game stats? After what we just saw him do, I figured his doubters were long gone.
Instinctive
Footballguy
There's got to be somewhere to put the draft as it goes. Perhaps a GoogleDoc to be thrown up on the Drive by our fearless leader? Only he can edit, anyone can view (avoid tampering)?
ETA: Perhaps get the order in the first post as well? Pain to find who I am supposed to PM.
PM going out to HellToupe now
ETA: Perhaps get the order in the first post as well? Pain to find who I am supposed to PM.
PM going out to HellToupe now
Last edited by a moderator:
There's at least 5 QBs that I would take before him. 3 of whom have won Super Bowls, if that is part of your criteria. Flacco is a fine player, but he's about the 12th-15th best QB in the league. Also would take JJ Watt and at least 2 other non QBs off the top of my head before him.He's played 5 yrs and has 9 playoff wins. You're gonna downgrade him for not putting up video game stats? After what we just saw him do, I figured his doubters were long gone.
Meecrob
Footballguy
I would have taken JJ #1 overall, but then again I'm a little biased.There's at least 5 QBs that I would take before him. 3 of whom have won Super Bowls, if that is part of your criteria. Flacco is a fine player, but he's about the 12th-15th best QB in the league. Also would take JJ Watt and at least 2 other non QBs off the top of my head before him.He's played 5 yrs and has 9 playoff wins. You're gonna downgrade him for not putting up video game stats? After what we just saw him do, I figured his doubters were long gone.
flc735
Footballguy
Then why didn't you take Eli over Flacco?He's played 5 yrs and has 9 playoff wins. You're gonna downgrade him for not putting up video game stats? After what we just saw him do, I figured his doubters were long gone.
Last edited by a moderator:
Instinctive
Footballguy
Nice to see others like the JJ pick. He's a beast. Super young. Couldn't pass him up.
The dropoff to the next defensive end is pretty big. He's a game changer.
flc735
Footballguy
HERE IS THE SPREADSHEETSpreadsheet link
Anyone can edit it. I am not going to keep it up to date. Just add in the picks as they happen.
Remember to snake back up at the end of the 1st. You are welcome to copy it if you want to edit it on your own.
Last edited by a moderator:
RBM
Footballguy
Considered him and 2 others, but age won out. Had all 4 as similar talents/leaders. Like his size, escapibility, can scramble a little bit. No throw he can't make. Probably the best deep ball in the league. I don't see much downside.Then why didn't you take Eli over Flacco?He's played 5 yrs and has 9 playoff wins. You're gonna downgrade him for not putting up video game stats? After what we just saw him do, I figured his doubters were long gone.
RBM
Footballguy
Care to explain the thinking here? Is it just the lack of stats?
Nate Blough
Footballguy
Flaccos more of an established QB than Russ Wilson. You put Wilson on a team with a weak Defense and running game like KC or Buffalo andI guarantee his year looks a lot different. Lets be honest, Flacco carried the offense in the playoffs.
I think he should go higher than 58th, but the 11th qb off the board sounds about right. Maybe player #20-25 overall. He's a good player, but there are much better QBs still available. Stats, yes, of course I would cite stats. How else would we judge players?
RBM
Footballguy
Watching them maybe? If I do this right, he would not be putting up big stats on my team either.
FUBAR
Footballguy
Aside from an elite few - most of which are older than I'd select to be my franchise QB heading into the future, this can be said about all QBs. Wilson, I believe, is the 3rd best young QB in the NFL. He isn't neccessarily better than many that are close to 30 or older, but he has room to improve.
HellToupee
Footballguy
1.8 Pittsburgh Steelers Cam Newton QB
sorry was caught in the commute home
was targeting JJ Watt or a QB. With Watt going I'm shocked at the QB decision I had . Choice came down to Cam , the other guy & the elephant in the room Q that is still out there. Cam & the other guy do what I want to do offensively. I just think Newton is more polished & refined.
sorry was caught in the commute home
was targeting JJ Watt or a QB. With Watt going I'm shocked at the QB decision I had . Choice came down to Cam , the other guy & the elephant in the room Q that is still out there. Cam & the other guy do what I want to do offensively. I just think Newton is more polished & refined.
HellToupee
Footballguy
I think Wilson trumps Cam in leadership
Instinctive
Footballguy
I also had the choice between JJ Watt and Cam staring me in the face. I'm not sure why, or what it is, but something just nags at me about Cam. I have no idea, but it was enough to sway my decision.
AwesomeAuger
Footballguy
After reading the original post, I have some questions.
1. Are we sticking to 32 rounds or going to go for 53?
2. Is there a specific quota on the number of college players? Do we HAVE to have 2? Can we have more/less?
3. Can we go away with the limitations per position. What if I want my base defense to be nickel?
1. Are we sticking to 32 rounds or going to go for 53?
2. Is there a specific quota on the number of college players? Do we HAVE to have 2? Can we have more/less?
3. Can we go away with the limitations per position. What if I want my base defense to be nickel?
Meecrob
Footballguy
My Preferences:1. 322. No limit3. No limitations as long as you can field a legal formation on O and D.
HellToupee
Footballguy
I'm all for 32
gandalas
Footballguy
Apologize for the wait - I was out at dinner last night when I got the text, and completely forgot about it when we got home. 
1.09 - 49ers take Drew Brees, QB (Saints)
Will PM commish and next person.
EDIT: Can't go wrong with Brees. Younger than Brady, and just as accomplished of a passer. Debated another guy here who is younger and faster, but Brees should have another good 3-4 years of championship-worthy play in him.
Records
1.09 - 49ers take Drew Brees, QB (Saints)
Will PM commish and next person.
EDIT: Can't go wrong with Brees. Younger than Brady, and just as accomplished of a passer. Debated another guy here who is younger and faster, but Brees should have another good 3-4 years of championship-worthy play in him.
Records
Last edited by a moderator:
JMon348
Footballguy
I'm hoping everyone stays interested to go for a full 53 man roster.There is no limitations on positions or college players.
Nate Blough
Footballguy
Did the person that picks 9th pick yet??? Seems it went Cam at 8 Brees at 10. Did I miss something?
Duckboy
IBL Representative
Several directions to go here. Calvin would have been an option here as we'll as one other from a positional scarcity standpoint. But you can't pick from here and not get a quality QB when there are still a few to choose from depending on your opinion.
That said I'm going with upside here as opposed to safety with the other I considered:
1.10 QB Colin Kaepernick
Has the arm and the legs that give me options constructing the offense moving forward. Shorter body of work but I will take the risk here.
That said I'm going with upside here as opposed to safety with the other I considered:
1.10 QB Colin Kaepernick
Has the arm and the legs that give me options constructing the offense moving forward. Shorter body of work but I will take the risk here.
Duckboy
IBL Representative
I'm an early bird
JMon348
Footballguy
1st post is being updated with draft order and google spreadsheet link.
I will also try and link everyone's page so it will be easier to PM.
When we get into the 2nd round and beyond, please list who is on your team, then into the later rounds give a mini depth chart.
I will also try and link everyone's page so it will be easier to PM.
When we get into the 2nd round and beyond, please list who is on your team, then into the later rounds give a mini depth chart.
Last edited by a moderator:
RBM
Footballguy
Wow. Maybe I'm in the minority on this read option being a fad?
AwesomeAuger
Footballguy
I'm shocked that Drew Brees was available at 1.09 and taken after Flacco, Watt, and Newton. He's one of those quarterbacks that makes your team playoff bound even if your draft outside of the first round is only average compared to the rest of the teams. He just turned 34 so he still has a good 5 or so years left. Gandalas has to be thrilled.
AwesomeAuger
Footballguy
His ability to run the RO is a huge asset but he has the arm strength to make any throw and good accuracy. He's still extremely young and has his best football still ahead of him. I like the pick.
Meecrob
Footballguy
Megatron; I need say nothing more.
RBM
Footballguy
Very hard for me to choose Flacco over him, but the age and size were the deciding factors. I disagree with the 5 good yrs comment. I'd say more like 2-3 at his current level.
JMon348
Footballguy
Ok first post has been updated. I have linked the Google spreadsheet. I have also linked everyone's page so PMs should be easy.
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE PM the drafter after you, after you have picked. Very important!!!!! I will stay on top of texting as much as possible, but PMs are still important.
Remember we are doing 3RR.
DRAFT ORDER
1st Round
1.Saints Awesomeauger
2.Giants WuBanger
3.Eagles SkeletoreEh
4.Titans Fubar
5.Vikings 8ebok24
6.Bears RBM
7.Rams Instinctive
8.Steelers HellToupe
9.49ers Gandalas
10.Seahawks Duckboy
11.Cowboys Meecrob
12.Bengals ExaltedOne
13.Pats Late225
14.Raiders Warrior
15.Cardinals Whicker
16.Skins NateBlough
17.Packers Shakezula
18.Lions Fubar
19.Jets Duckboy
20.Bucs Bamac
21.Chargers WuBanger
22.Browns ExaltedOne
23.Falcons HellToupee
24.Dolphins Dolfan
25.Chiefs Awesomauger
26.Bills RBM
27.Colts Gandalas
28.Ravens NateBlough
29.Texans Meecrob
30.Panthers SkeletoreEh
31.Broncos Instinctive
32.Jaguars 8ebok24
Google Spreadsheet with updated picks:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Ag68aKS2xJNodDZjc0dHaEhKMGZkclJ6R0QtNTluTWc&usp=sharing#gid=0
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE PM the drafter after you, after you have picked. Very important!!!!! I will stay on top of texting as much as possible, but PMs are still important.
Remember we are doing 3RR.
DRAFT ORDER
1st Round
1.Saints Awesomeauger
2.Giants WuBanger
3.Eagles SkeletoreEh
4.Titans Fubar
5.Vikings 8ebok24
6.Bears RBM
7.Rams Instinctive
8.Steelers HellToupe
9.49ers Gandalas
10.Seahawks Duckboy
11.Cowboys Meecrob
12.Bengals ExaltedOne
13.Pats Late225
14.Raiders Warrior
15.Cardinals Whicker
16.Skins NateBlough
17.Packers Shakezula
18.Lions Fubar
19.Jets Duckboy
20.Bucs Bamac
21.Chargers WuBanger
22.Browns ExaltedOne
23.Falcons HellToupee
24.Dolphins Dolfan
25.Chiefs Awesomauger
26.Bills RBM
27.Colts Gandalas
28.Ravens NateBlough
29.Texans Meecrob
30.Panthers SkeletoreEh
31.Broncos Instinctive
32.Jaguars 8ebok24
Google Spreadsheet with updated picks:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Ag68aKS2xJNodDZjc0dHaEhKMGZkclJ6R0QtNTluTWc&usp=sharing#gid=0
gandalas
Footballguy
Yes, I was VERY happy.
Now that I have a complete stud at the QB position, I can go wherever the draft takes me with my later picks.
ExaltedOne
Footballguy
1.12 Bengals select QB Matt Ryan
I was hoping Calvin would continue to fall, but I think Ryan is a top 5 QB.
I was hoping Calvin would continue to fall, but I think Ryan is a top 5 QB.
AwesomeAuger
Footballguy
I think quarterbacks like Brady and Brees will play longer than they would have had they been born 20 years earlier for a couple of reasons.
[*]The rule shift to favoring offenses heavily and discouraging big hits. The emphasis of protecting the players will extend his career.
[*]Brees has a playing style that doesn't allow big hits often. He plays with a great internal clock and has great pocket presence.
[*]Brees has some of the best anticipation in the league. He has never had a cannon and doesn't need one
[*]The rule shift to favoring offenses heavily and discouraging big hits. The emphasis of protecting the players will extend his career.
[*]Brees has a playing style that doesn't allow big hits often. He plays with a great internal clock and has great pocket presence.
[*]Brees has some of the best anticipation in the league. He has never had a cannon and doesn't need one
AwesomeAuger
Footballguy
Exactly. I feel the same way. Rodgers and Brees don't need grade A talent around them on offense to be successful. If I started with a Flacco or a Newton for example I would feel like I would have to invest early on offense to put them in a position to succeed. With Rodgers, I feel like I could focus on defense early if the board dictated that and still have one of the best offenses in the league.Yes, I was VERY happy.
