Last year, I won the Fantasy Sports Trade Association division III fantasy football league - some of the guys in division III were Ryan Houston, John Georgeopolus, Ted Kasten - so that was an interesting league playing other writers for/owners of FF sites and businesses.
I was in the playoffs in 50% of my private (friends and old business associates) leagues, and missed the playoffs in one other by 3 pts on the final weekend of fantasy regular season (I actually won the head-to-head game and tied for the divisional championship on record, but the guy I beat that day had split with me and he won the division on the total points tie break by 2pt)
However, in Footballguys expert staff league last year I got nuked.
Trying to determine who is "best" at Footballguys.com among the staff is not going to be revealed by our performance in the myriad of leagues we all play in, though - as many have pointed out in the thread, it depends on what thing or things you value most in terms of FF analysis. I am not a professional mathematician like Dr. Drinen or Dave Shick, so I am not as strong at statistical analysis as they are - numbers come to them as naturally as breathing does to me - but I encompass a lot of qualitative information in my perspective.
I write the Monday Injury report for the site each week during regular season, do the weekly injury podcast with Cecil Lammey, and I also co-write the Rushing and Passing matchups each week with Joe Bryant (which, aside from watching as many games as humanly possible on Sundays/MNF, exposes me to the week-to-week statistical production of all the offensive fantasy football skill position players as well as the predominant IDP players, just as a by-product of reading every box score and game summary each week, studying our weekly and "Who's Hot" reports that David Dodds produces after the games, and also studying our weekly game recaps that Joe B. and Cathy Fazio and their excellent staff of recappers produce, among some of the resources I use to write the rushing/passing matchups).
Thus, I tend to write articles like this one (
Managing Risk 2006), when I'm not doing faceoffs or spotlights, etc.
I respect all of the members of the Footballguys.com staff, and can say from experience that they are extremely tough to play FF against.
My .02.