What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

****OFFICIAL**** Washington Redskins Offseason Thread (1 Viewer)

DCThunder

Footballguy
Since it's never too early to start gassing up Redskins One for the Free Agent season and all the rest, I might as well get the OFFICIAL thread up and posted.

First item up for discussion: Jason LaCanfora's (WaPo beat writer on the Skins) first of three articles in today's WaPo about what went wrong with the 2006 season. LaCanfora ususally knows what he's talking about and has excellent sources within the team and around the league. He gives an excellent analysis and discussion of the circumstances of the Brandon Lloyd trade of last offseason and the acquisition of TJ Duckett after Clinton Portis' injury in the preseason. He also gives the most cogent description I've read of the structure of the Skins front office and the decision making process on player acquistion.

Very enlightening and meshes well with what guys like Czabe, Riggo, BMitch and Doc Walker have been saying on the local TV and radio stations for most of the season. Tomorrow's article is on how the Al Saunders 700 page playbook never really sank in and the repercussions of that. (Go to www.Washingtonpost.com for the full text, it's way too long to post here and that's copyright infringement anyway.)

Redman, Bizkiteer and other Redskins homers, your thoughts and analysis?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for the article. It was interesting to read exactly how they decide on players.This was interesting:

Even after the benching, [brandon] Lloyd was problematic. One key exchange occurred Dec. 17 in New Orleans. The go route -- in which a wide receiver makes a quick move at the snap of the ball and sprints straight down the sideline -- was Lloyd's specialty. In the first half, Lloyd beat his man down the sideline and seemed to be wide open for a touchdown pass from Jason Campbell. But he could not locate the ball and it dropped to the turf.According to a member of the organization who witnessed the exchange, Saunders approached Lloyd at halftime."Tough one out there. Those lights are tough," Saunders said.Lloyd looked at him coldly."You're joking, right?" he said."No," said Saunders. "It looked like you lost it in the lights.""What? That ball was 10 yards underthrown," Lloyd said. "Go talk to the quarterback."
Ugh.
 
Thanks for the article. It was interesting to read exactly how they decide on players.This was interesting:

Even after the benching, [brandon] Lloyd was problematic. One key exchange occurred Dec. 17 in New Orleans. The go route -- in which a wide receiver makes a quick move at the snap of the ball and sprints straight down the sideline -- was Lloyd's specialty. In the first half, Lloyd beat his man down the sideline and seemed to be wide open for a touchdown pass from Jason Campbell. But he could not locate the ball and it dropped to the turf.According to a member of the organization who witnessed the exchange, Saunders approached Lloyd at halftime."Tough one out there. Those lights are tough," Saunders said.Lloyd looked at him coldly."You're joking, right?" he said."No," said Saunders. "It looked like you lost it in the lights.""What? That ball was 10 yards underthrown," Lloyd said. "Go talk to the quarterback."
Ugh.
I remember the play, and Campbell couldn't have thrown it any better. All Lloyd had to do was reach our and catch it and he'd have scored.
 
JLC's pieces have been damning, to say the least. And you know they are being read out in Ashburn. I would never expect a written piece by a beat reporter to be an agent for change, but it would amaze me if this organization does not try a different approach in light of the Friend article from earlier this year and JLC's continued dissections thru his blog and thru the regular Post pieces.

In short, these are a few things they should consider. It's beating a dead horse, but there's really nothing else to say:

1) Fire Cerrato. Enough is enough. This guy is a clown.

2) Hire a GM.

3) Draft DT (Branch) or DE (Adams) at 6, or trade down and get more Day 1 picks.

4) Keep Redskins One parked, swallow your medicine in 2007, again in 2008, and position for 2009. In other words, do not sign Nate Clements, do not trade the 1st rounder in 2007 and/or 2008 for Randy Moss, do not continue to go down this road of self-destruction and remain the joke of the league. Unfortunately, I know this will not be the case. As long as this organization continues to print money, Snyder will keep the status quo. They'll sweet-talk some vets to restructure and free up some cap space and then do the unthinkable in February and March again.

Truth be told, things might not be so bad if they keep it primarily intact this year. Even if you give some misfits a little time to gel, it can only get better. It doesn't take much in the pathetic NFC to make the playoffs. But long-term vitality won't be assured unless they make significant changes to their current operating processes. We'll see.

 
Thanks for the article. It was interesting to read exactly how they decide on players.

This was interesting:

Even after the benching, [brandon] Lloyd was problematic. One key exchange occurred Dec. 17 in New Orleans. The go route -- in which a wide receiver makes a quick move at the snap of the ball and sprints straight down the sideline -- was Lloyd's specialty. In the first half, Lloyd beat his man down the sideline and seemed to be wide open for a touchdown pass from Jason Campbell. But he could not locate the ball and it dropped to the turf.

According to a member of the organization who witnessed the exchange, Saunders approached Lloyd at halftime.

"Tough one out there. Those lights are tough," Saunders said.

Lloyd looked at him coldly.

"You're joking, right?" he said.

"No," said Saunders. "It looked like you lost it in the lights."

"What? That ball was 10 yards underthrown," Lloyd said. "Go talk to the quarterback."
Ugh.
I remember the play, and Campbell couldn't have thrown it any better. All Lloyd had to do was reach our and catch it and he'd have scored.
I agree. The throw may have been to the wrong shoulder, but it was very catchable. Lloyd is a clown.I saw a postgame interview with Mike Sellars. He said Gibbs told them in the lockerroom that the coaching staff is going to review every play of the year and see who was really playing down the stretch and who wasn't. That should scare some on the defensive side of the ball.

 
I'm not a Skins or 49ers fan, but from reading posts by Niner fans here and elsewhere in previous years, I knew that Lloyd had an attitude problem and frequently blew routine plays. How no one from the Skins management could have known that is mindboggling.

 
I'm not a Skins or 49ers fan, but from reading posts by Niner fans here and elsewhere in previous years, I knew that Lloyd had an attitude problem and frequently blew routine plays. How no one from the Skins management could have known that is mindboggling.
im sure they knew that. However, they probably hoped that they would be able to change him, giving him a fresh start.
 
these are some great articles.

First and foremost, gibbs and saunders need to decide who will be running things.... and then let that person have full control.

then, they need to handle the defensive issues.

most of all, i think we need stability. the core of the team is solid. IMO.

 
Next year's opponents.

Home: Dallas, N.Y. Giants, Philadelphia, Chicago, Detroit, Buffalo, Miami, Arizona

Away: Dallas, N.Y. Giants, Philadelphia, Green Bay, Minnesota, New England, N.Y. Jets, Tampa Bay
link
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Personally I think the Redskins offense will be fine next year. They started to get things going under Campbell and another year together in the same system with JC getting all the #1QB work will do wonders. Despite being criticized a lot, the OL played well down the stretch and should be kept together (though getting some quality depth sure wouldn't hurt). The only issue I see will be finding the right balance between Portis/Betts. Obviously Portis can't hold up with the huge workload the Redskins have been giving him and it's also obvious Betts can hold his own. If they all play nice, the Skins O should be just fine, with or without Brandon Lloyd being a cluck head.

Defensively, they have their work cut out for them. This is actually surprising as the defense seemed to have been the thing the Skins could count on. But it's obvious they're lacking in all areas and even the system needs tweaking. The D is aging quickly and they still need people that can get to the QB. The lack of sacks/turnovers this past year was record setting (for the wrong reasons). I think the Skins will use free agency and the draft to address this. Despite some Redskins fans wanting them to stop the free agent method, they won't since they've given up so many draft picks. I'd anticipate Redskins One to be visiting Nate Clements, Justin Smith, and some others. With the draft pick, I'm thinking (hoping) they look at the DL. Guys like Alan Branch (DT from Michigan), Gaines Adams (Clemson) and Glen Dorsey (LSU) need to declare, but they'd be high on my preference list.

Oh yes, and Gregg Williams needs to get his head out of his butt and go back to what got him the job in the first place. His coaching effort has been terrible this year and now all these reports coming out make it sound even worst. He's been a bad coach AND a ##### at the same time.

 
I worry that Portis and Al Saunders can't co-exist. And i'd rather the Skins cut ties with Al than Portis, even after Betts big season.

 
Live and Die by the Redskins every week, on a Monday after a loss, don't even talk to me! So you can imagine my grouchy Mondays this season! :goodposting:

Anyway, let's start with some bright spots to take away from this season:

1) Jason Campbell - His numbers haven't been spectacular, but he has been very good. He's big, strong and has a cannon for an arm. He can break tackles and keep drives alive using his various skills. He can definitely hit the deep routes and needs some work on his passes over the middle, but all in all, I am very pleased by what this kid has shown so far.

2) Ladell Betts - We've all known he has the skills to be a good runner and when given the opportunity he came through. A 1-2 punch of Portis and Betts can be very promising for the Redskins next season. Not to mention Betts had another 400+ yds receiving.

3) The O-Line - Big change from last season, esp towards the end of this season. The O-Line held it's own and did a great job protecting the QB and opening the holes for Portis and/or Betts.

4) Andre Carter - Carter came on real strong towards the end of the season, actually looking like the player the Redskins believed they were signing.

5) Chris Cooley - Had another nice season with 700+ yds.

No some bad ones:

1) Brandon Lloyd - Ah yes, brought in to be our #2. 23 catches for 365 yds!?!?! ugh. He's terrible, has no heart and needs to be sent packing.

2) D Line - I mean, there was just NO pass rush whatsoever! None! And they couldn't plug up a hole to make a run stop. And if they did, the LBs were out of position.

3) Sean Taylor - It's like he regressed this year, at times he was on point, but there were many games where he was caught out of position or missed a tackle. How about the 15th game of the season, in OT, Steven Jackson breaks into the backfield and rather than going right at him, Taylors backs off on an angle and Jackson blows by him! Last season, Taylor stuffs that hole.

4) Adam Archuleta - Honestly, need I say anymore? I think any sane Redskins fan shunned this deal from day one.

5) Carlos Rogers - Up and down all season long. Makes a big play and then gets burned a series later.

In my opinion, the Skins need to concentrate on their D line - they need pass rushers and run stoppers more than anything else.

 
The critique of Gregg Williams and the defense is in today's paper and washingtonpost.com.
Gregg Williams did a #### job this year. I don't know why they're so quick to evaluate the players to see "who's making an effort and who's not", yet so quick to say all the coaches will return. This team had too many coaches and assistant coaches this year, and some of them did badly, including Williams. His defenses were laughable in some games. By the way, Philip Daniels had surgery. Brunell, Marcus Washington, and Todd Yoder will be having surgery as well. Daniels was playing with one, then two, bad ankles. He didn't miss a game.

Link

 
Last edited by a moderator:
i've read multiple places that Portis and Saunders don't even speak to each other. And Saunders was pissed that Portis would pull himself from a game if he was banged up or needed a breather. Obviously he and Gibbs have confidence in Betts, but it still bothered Saunders that Portis had the freedom to do this. Plus, Al is a HUGE Betts fan.

 
Portis was on the John Thomspson Show last night and said Brandon Lloyd has alienated everyone in the organization. He said Lloyd just doesn't let things go. He continues to bring things up from the past and that alienated himself from everyone.

I can see why Saunders would be ticked with Portis taking himself out a lot. I'm guessing Saunders has certain Portis plays and certain Betts plays. If he doesn't know who's going to be in when, it can mess him up. A lot of Skins fans wondered why Portis took himself out so much.

 
1) Fire Cerrato. Enough is enough. This guy is a clown.
Vinny Cerrato, more than any other person, IMO was responsible for the fall of the 49ers dynasty. I will never know how he got another job with responsibility for player evaluation/
 
1) Fire Cerrato. Enough is enough. This guy is a clown.
Vinny Cerrato, more than any other person, IMO was responsible for the fall of the 49ers dynasty. I will never know how he got another job with responsibility for player evaluation/
Snyder hired him, for some reason, then Marty fired him his one year with the Redskins. After working for ESPN for a year doing online chats, or whatever, Sndyer hired him back. Mr. Snyder, if he was so valuable, why didn't another team hire him away from that ESPN gig?
 
dgreen said:
Portis was on the John Thomspson Show last night and said Brandon Lloyd has alienated everyone in the organization. He said Lloyd just doesn't let things go. He continues to bring things up from the past and that alienated himself from everyone.

I can see why Saunders would be ticked with Portis taking himself out a lot. I'm guessing Saunders has certain Portis plays and certain Betts plays. If he doesn't know who's going to be in when, it can mess him up. A lot of Skins fans wondered why Portis took himself out so much.
Listen to the whole interview. Portis did a good job of ripping Lloyd, Gibbs, Saunders and more. Sort of shocking...Link

 
Brunell has surgery; Albright re-signed

Also included in the article is some info. on other contract talks:

...starting guard Derrick Dockery and the Redskins are not close on a new deal at this point, according to sources with knowledge of the situation, and the team may not want to bring back former starting linebacker Warrick Holdman and part-time starting cornerback Kenny Wright
Hopefully they can resign Dockery and keep the O-line together at least another year. It seems rare to have that much continuity in the line from year to year in the NFL these days, but it can be vital to the success of the offense.Holdman and Wright are expendable.

 
Portis was on the John Thomspson Show last night and said Brandon Lloyd has alienated everyone in the organization. He said Lloyd just doesn't let things go. He continues to bring things up from the past and that alienated himself from everyone.

I can see why Saunders would be ticked with Portis taking himself out a lot. I'm guessing Saunders has certain Portis plays and certain Betts plays. If he doesn't know who's going to be in when, it can mess him up. A lot of Skins fans wondered why Portis took himself out so much.
Listen to the whole interview. Portis did a good job of ripping Lloyd, Gibbs, Saunders and more. Sort of shocking...Link
wow, very interesting interview even though the first 1/2 is a bit slow at times.
 
3) Sean Taylor - It's like he regressed this year, at times he was on point, but there were many games where he was caught out of position or missed a tackle. How about the 15th game of the season, in OT, Steven Jackson breaks into the backfield and rather than going right at him, Taylors backs off on an angle and Jackson blows by him! Last season, Taylor stuffs that hole.
I think Taylor was fine. Most of the times he was out of position, or missing a tackle he was trying to cover up someone else's mistake. The secondary was banged up all year, he did miss some tackles, but that is just the way he plays, he goes in trying blow people up and does miss from time to time.
 
The safeties were asked to play deeper this year, but were also supposed to watch more for running plays. That's pretty much guaranteed failure, and an admission the other 9 players on the defense were trusted less to stop the run and defend the pass.

The safeties also held separate meetings from the cornerbacks (different coaches who didn't get along). That's why you saw safeties "out of position" so many times this year, and talking with the cornerbacks after a (usually-successful) offensive play by the opponents.

"You were supposed to be here."

"No, I was supposed to be there."

"That's not what my coach said."

"Oh yeah? Well it's what my coach said."

 
The safeties were asked to play deeper this year, but were also supposed to watch more for running plays. That's pretty much guaranteed failure, and an admission the other 9 players on the defense were trusted less to stop the run and defend the pass.

The safeties also held separate meetings from the cornerbacks (different coaches who didn't get along). That's why you saw safeties "out of position" so many times this year, and talking with the cornerbacks after a (usually-successful) offensive play by the opponents.

"You were supposed to be here."

"No, I was supposed to be there."

"That's not what my coach said."

"Oh yeah? Well it's what my coach said."
True --> not to mention with such a weak D Line, the safeties did have to worry about the rb breaking into the open at any point.
 
The safeties also held separate meetings from the cornerbacks (different coaches who didn't get along). That's why you saw safeties "out of position" so many times this year, and talking with the cornerbacks after a (usually-successful) offensive play by the opponents.

"You were supposed to be here."

"No, I was supposed to be there."

"That's not what my coach said."

"Oh yeah? Well it's what my coach said."
Actually, I heard Jason LaCanfora on the radio last week and he said the S and CB held separate meetings in 2005, too. So, I'm not sure how much that contributed to the fall of the D in 2006.
 
Positive doings on the Redskins front...they've fired LB's Coach Dale Lindsey!!!

See the News Blogger for lead-in and link...

Brian Mitchell & Co, and later today Rick 'Doc' Walker & John Thompson, will be discussing this at length on local talk radio.

LONG OVERDUE MOVE, for non-football reasons. I want to listen to what the boys have to say this afternoon, and comment later, but I'm not blowing smoke when I tell you that Lindsey and both his personality and way of doing things were a significant source of irritation to both the players and other members of the Coaching Staff, and deteriorated the environment in the locker room. No one on the team, with the possible exception of Gregg Williams is going to be sorry to see him go.

 
Positive doings on the Redskins front...they've fired LB's Coach Dale Lindsey!!!See the News Blogger for lead-in and link...Brian Mitchell & Co, and later today Rick 'Doc' Walker & John Thompson, will be discussing this at length on local talk radio.LONG OVERDUE MOVE, for non-football reasons. I want to listen to what the boys have to say this afternoon, and comment later, but I'm not blowing smoke when I tell you that Lindsey and both his personality and way of doing things were a significant source of irritation to both the players and other members of the Coaching Staff, and deteriorated the environment in the locker room. No one on the team, with the possible exception of Gregg Williams is going to be sorry to see him go.
Was it Lindsey who told the safties and cornerbacks not to talk to each other? Or who spent a gazillion dollars on Archeleta? The ought to can the DB coaches, but those guys are tight with Greggy boy. I'm not saying Lindsey didn't deserve to get whacked, but so do a bunch of other defensive coaches.
 
Was it Lindsey who told the safties and cornerbacks not to talk to each other? Or who spent a gazillion dollars on Archeleta? The ought to can the DB coaches, but those guys are tight with Greggy boy. I'm not saying Lindsey didn't deserve to get whacked, but so do a bunch of other defensive coaches.
I think it was a situation where there was a DB coach. Then they brought in another DB coach, needed a job for him, and put him in charge of the safeties. That DB coach didn't get along with the other DB coach, so they met separately.Like high school girls.
 
I worry that Portis and Al Saunders can't co-exist. And i'd rather the Skins cut ties with Al than Portis, even after Betts big season.
Pro Football Weekly mentioned something about Portis recently, saying that the Redskins owe him a lot of money and its possible they trade him to avoid a big salary cap hit. Brunell is gone, Patten is too..there's just something fishy about Betts signing a multi year deal with the Redskins, before he even tested the free agent waters. He was set to potentially make a LOT of money in a free agent market that is fairly weak at the RB position. He would've been a priority signing for a number of teams.the fact that he didn't try free agency, if NOT for the sake of raising the Redskins ante to keep him, imo, says something about Portis' future in Washington. granted, he's hurt ( shoulder), but this whole things stands out like a sore thumb..did they say anything to Betts to get him to sign, i.e., promise him a starting role or a chance to compete for it?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You can keep up with some offseason thoughts on the Redskins in Rich Tandler's blog: Link

A few times since the season ended I’ve started to write long pieces on what went wrong with the Redskins in ’06. It’s really too simple, though, to ramble on about it for very long. The bottom line is that they weren’t ready to play. Training camp was too easy; it started late, ended early, there were just a few two-a-days, some practices were held under the lights to keep them out of the heat of the day and there wasn’t much contact. The “vanilla” schemes and plays during the preseason deprived the team of the opportunity to practice under live fire. Compounding the problem was the fact that the players thought that they were ready. They literally were shocked that the Vikings beat them in the season opener. They never developed any confidence and they never recovered.
 
Scout.com has some ongoing discussion of the Redskins during the offseason: Link

There's an analysis of the defense there currently, and it's quite gory.

DEFENSIVE LINE:

Starters -- LE Phillip Daniels, LT Cornelius Griffin, RT Kedric Golston, RE Andre Carter. Backups -- DE Renaldo Wynn, DT Joe Salave'a, DE/DT Demetric Evans, DT Anthony Montgomery, DT/DE Ryan Boschetti, DE Joe Sykes.

Daniels, who finished 2005 with a rush to lead the team with eight sacks, played most of 2006 with a sprained wrist and sprained ankle and slipped to three sacks. He'll be 34 in March and could be cut. Griffin battled chronic hip problems the last two years and wasn't close to the force he was in 2004. He'll be 31 and probably needs to redo his contract. Sixth-round pick Golston was a pleasant surprise as a rookie but needs to continue to improve. Carter, signed away from the 49ers for $30 million, was a bust at midseason but finished strong with four sacks in the last five games. Carter led the team with six sacks and has the speed to make plays behind the line but isn't strong enough to be a reliable run defender. Wynn, who'll be 33 this year, can't stick as a backup at $4.03 million but would be a valuable reserve with a lower cap figure. Salave'a, who" be 32 in March, was beaten out by Golston and could be done, but is cheap enough to bring to camp. Evans is a decent backup. Fifth-rounder Montgomery needs to work hard if he's going to succeed Griffin one day. Boschetti is an overachiever whose playing time slipped dramatically in 2006. Sykes was activated for the finale after being on the practice squad all year. Look for the Redskins to use their top pick on a pass rushing defensive end.

LINEBACKERS:

Starters -- SLB Rocky McIntosh, MLB Lemar Marshall, WLB Warrick Holdman. Backups -- SLB Jeff Posey, MLB Khary Campbell. Injured reserve: SLB Marcus Washington.

McIntosh was a disappointment in not following the pattern of FS Sean Taylor and CB Carlos Rogers in becoming starters during his rookie season. Maybe the dismissal of LBs coach Dale Lindsey and McIntosh's solid play in his two December starts will make the difference because he should take over for over-the-hill free agent Holdman at WLB in 2007. Marshall's play slipped considerably from his productive 2004-05 seasons. He probably belongs at WLB, but he's the best MLB the Redskins have. If the Redskins can sign a reliable veteran MLB, Marshall could battle McIntosh to start at WLB. Washington, too, had a down year from his superb seasons in 2004-05 and finished the year on injured reserve with a knee that didn't require surgery. He remains the Redskins' top defender. Posey, who had played for defensive coaches Gregg Williams and Jerry Gray in Buffalo, played almost exclusively on teams, is a free agent and will be 32 in August. Campbell, Washington's top special teams tackler, played in some short yardage and goal line situations at MLB but isn't considered starter material. The Redskins need to add some quality, youthful depth here after 2005 draft picks Robert McCune and Jared Newberry failed to establish themselves.

DEFENSIVE BACKS:

Starters - LCB Kenny Wright, RCB Carlos Rogers, SS Vernon Fox, FS Sean Taylor. Backups - CB Ade Jimoh, SS Troy Vincent, SS Adam Archuleta, FS Reed Doughty, CB John Eubanks, CB Leigh Torrence. Injured reserve: LCB Shawn Springs, SS Pierson Prioleau.

Wright, a starter for Jacksonville's fine defense in 2005, was a liability as a fill-in when Springs missed half of last year and even as the nickel corner. Wright was beaten often and doesn't figure to be re-signed. After a promising rookie year, Rogers regressed in 2006. He allowed way too much of a cushion yet was beaten deep regularly and dropped plenty of balls. Rogers excelled against Carolina and New Orleans but that wasn't enough to overshadow all the work he needs to do if he's going to prove he was worthy of being the ninth pick in 2005. Career special-teamer Fox was signed off waivers from Detroit in August to help on teams but wound up starting the last six games. The free agent might be re-signed but should only start in an emergency. Taylor, a terrific athlete who was near Pro Bowl status in 2005, floundered in 2006 after the Redskins didn't re-sign former SS Ryan Clark. Taylor has great range and delivers jarring hits, but he forgot how to cover last year and missed way too many tackles. He needs a partner he can trust. Vincent, signed in October with Archuleta having faltered so miserably, might have been that man, but he re-injured a hamstring soon after moving into the lineup at midseason and isn't much of a long-term answer at 35. Jimoh is a good gunner on teams but struggles in coverage and might not be re-signed. Archuleta was the worst free agent signing of 2006 and should be cut despite the cap consequences. Doughty saw almost all of his time on teams and that might be his niche. Eubanks was on the practice squad all year until suiting up for the finale. Former Falcon Torrence signed in the final week and didn't play. Springs played well when healthy but he missed the first five weeks following pelvic surgery, sat out with a hamstring on Dec. 3 and broke a shoulder on Dec. 24. Springs will be 32 in March and probably needs to rework his contract to remain despite the Redskins' struggles in the secondary. The heady Prioleau was going to start the opener ahead of Archuleta but suffered a season-ending knee injury on the opening kickoff. He, Taylor, Rogers and Springs should be the starters in 2007, assuming Springs isn't a cap casualty.
 
Thom Loverro in the Washington Times I don't agree with all of these, by the way, but on some of them he's on the money.

If Gibbs is serious about changes, he might want to consider some of these moves. They certainly would change the way the franchise does business, and, anyway, how much worse could the results be than they were this season?

1. Revamp the entire front-office system. Hire a general manager or at least put better-qualified personnel men in charge with the authority to make definitive decisions about the roster. It is difficult when the head coach also is the team president, but if Gibbs hires someone with spelled-out responsibilities, he will let that person do the job.

2. Along those same lines, reassign Vinny Cerrato. Put him in charge of the Tilt-A-Whirl concession at Six Flags -- anything to get him away from Redskin Park. If there ever were a symbol of everything wrong with the Snyder regime, it is the presence of Cerrato.

3. Some players have complained about Gibbs' year-round training requirements at Redskin Park. Fine. He should give them some time off, let them train at home. Then tell them to report in July to Dickinson College for training camp -- no distractions, nothing but football and teammates locked together in the shared misery of Carlisle, Pa. It will send a powerful message.

4. The Redskins should trade Clinton Portis for as many draft choices as possible. They remember the draft, right? If not, they should take a look at the Chargers, Patriots, Steelers and Ravens -- all teams very familiar with the draft. That's how you build a hungry, deep football team.

Gibbs made a mistake and misjudged Ladell Betts before he ever got here, and Rock Cartwright, given the opportunity, provides the Redskins with a reliable second back (the only season he has gotten the ball with any regularity was 2003, when he gained 411 yards on 107 carries, a 3.8-yard average).

5. Gibbs should use those draft picks and any others he can scrounge to draft defensive help -- pass rushers and defensive backs. The defense needs a drastic change. If they can find a way to keep Shawn Springs, fine, but he isn't going to get any more durable with each passing year.

Why not get crazy, consider a 3-4 defense and move Sean Taylor to linebacker? It's clear he has been exposed on pass coverage. Why not make the most of what he does -- hit and go after the ball -- and put him outside as a linebacker? He is the same size as Lemar Marshall, and he could be terror there.

6. Now, a 3-4 might not be assistant head coach Gregg Williams' idea of defense, but that brings us to the next recommendation -- fewer coaches on the sideline and more coaches on the field.

There are way too many voices vying for authority in the coaching ranks at Redskin Park, and some of them simply have to go. What they need are more coaches on the field [-] players with leadership and intelligence. Some observers who were around for Gibbs' first tenure as Redskins coach say the biggest difference this time around is he has no Russ Grimms on the roster.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Here's the scout.com analysis of the offense:

Redskins Position Analysis: Offense -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Warpath StaffWarpathInsiders.com Jan 18, 2007 Washington Redskins Position Analysis: The OffenseQUARTERBACK: Starter -- Jason Campbell. Backups -- Mark Brunell, Todd Collins.Campbell, for whom the Redskins dealt three draft picks to choose in 2005, flashed some serious potential after replacing Brunell for the final seven games last season. Campbell has a strong arm and throws crossing patterns well. At 6-foot-4, 230 pounds, Campbell has the strength to fend off pass rushers and enough speed to make some plays with his feet. Like many young QBs, Campbell struggled with touch on short passes and made some foolish throws that were intercepted. Still, he's clearly the starter for 2007. Brunell, 36, couldn't recapture the magic of the first half of 2005. He had decent numbers but was very risk-adverse while going 3-6 before being benched. He's facing 4-5 months of rehab following January shoulder surgery as well a major salary reduction but is willing to remain a backup. Todd Collins, 35, was signed from Kansas City because he knew new play-caller Al Saunders' offense so well. Collins didn't play a snap yet again but figures to be back because he's under contract and is a good soldier. The Redskins could use a young QB on the practice squad.RUNNING BACKS: Starters -- RB Ladell Betts, FB Mike Sellers. Backups -- RB T.J. Duckett, RB Rock Cartwright, FB Nehemiah Broughton. Injured reserve: RB Clinton Portis.The flashy Portis had been the focal point of the offense in 2004 and 2005 but was having a sub-par year with 523 yards (albeit with a team-best seven TDs) after returning too soon from an August dislocated shoulder when he broke a hand on Nov. 12 and was done for the season. Betts, mostly a third-down back and KR during his first four years, took over and ran wild. Betts tied Portis' team record of five straight 100-yard games, averaged 130 yards over the final six games and is the kind of power runner that coach Joe Gibbs prefers. Assuming that the Redskins don't try to trade Portis (or fail to do so), it will be interesting to see if Saunders can keep both backs happy in 2007. Sellers is a bruising lead blocker at 278 pounds and a reliable weapon when given touches. Free agent-to-be Duckett, acquired from Atlanta in August for a third-rounder in a panic move when Portis and Betts were both ailing, was a bust as a power back and won't return. The short but strong Cartwright has had big games in the past but won't see the ball if Portis and Betts are healthy. Broughton, also undersized, spent most of the last two seasons on the practice squad and is just a guy.TIGHT END: Starter -- Chris Cooley. Backups -- Todd Yoder, Brian Kozlowski. Injured reserve -- Christian Fauria.Cooley's numbers dropped from his superb 2005 season but that was as much or more about the passing game's struggles as it was his fault. The third-year starter still led the team in catches and TDs and was just 56 yards behind WR Santana Moss for the lead in that category.Cooley has become a better blocker and is quick enough to get downfield for big plays. As he and Campbell develop chemistry, he can become a bigger weapon especially if Moss remains the only reliable WR. Yoder was a good September pickup, stepping in when free agent bust Fauria went down with a chronic ankle injury in November after catching just two passes. Yoder even caught Campbell's first TD pass. Yoder is a free agent and might be re-signed. So is the 36-year-old Kozlowski, who re-signed in November. He and Fauria, 35, both might be finished. The Redskins could use a young TE although Sellers can play here, too.WIDE RECEIVERS: Starters -- Santana Moss, Antwaan Randle El. Backups -- Brandon Lloyd, James Thrash, David Patten, Mike Espy.Moss didn't come close to matching his breakout season of his Washington debut in 2005. He battled a hamstring for a month, missed two games and wound up with 29 fewer catches and 693 fewer yards than the previous season. However, Moss showed that he still has it with three TDs of at least 30 yards during the final five games so he should be fine in 2007. Randle El (32 catches, 351 yards, three TDs) wasn't as productive as hoped after coming over from Pittsburgh for a huge contract with just three catches, two runs and one pass over 20 yards. But at least Randle El hustled and returned punts. Lloyd, who received an equally astronomical contract after being acquired from San Francisco for two draft picks, caught just 23 passes, didn't score and was benched for the final four games after throwing his helmet near the end of the Dec. 3 loss to Atlanta. He'll only be back because of his contract. Thrash is a solid veteran who also plays teams and is a Gibbs favorite. Patten, a disappointing starter in 2005, caught just one pass in five games and won't be back at 33. Undrafted rookie Espy got into just one game and will try to win a backup job next summer.OFFENSIVE LINE: Starters -- LT Chris Samuels, LG Derrick Dockery, C Casey Rabach, RG Randy Thomas, RT Jon Jansen. Backups -- T Todd Wade, C/G Mike Pucillo, T/G Jim Molinaro, C/G Taylor Whitley.Samuels made his fourth Pro Bowl in six years despite a sometimes-balky knee. He has improved as a run blocker and remains elite in pass protection. Dockery, previously inconsistent, had his best season and is one of the top free agents. The Redskins want to re-sign him, largely because of the chemistry he has with Samuels. However, once players hit the market, they usually don't return to Washington. Rabach is a battler who works well with the rest of the line and played down the stretch with a broken thumb. Thomas was having a Pro Bowl year when he broke a leg in December 2005. He had a solid 2006 as the line made the Redskins one of just three teams to rank in the top 10 in yards per carry and fewest sacks per dropback. Jansen struggled much of the way with a torn calf but still shut down Julius Peppers and Trent Cole among other defensive ends. Former Miami/Houston starter Wade filled in ably when Jansen sat out in New Orleans but is a free agent and wants to start. Pucillo was the extra lineman in short yardage. Molinaro played in just one game and won't get any offers as a restricted free agent. Whitley, signed off the street in October, started 11 games for Miami in 2004.
It's pretty much spot on. The only details I'd quibble with are:- RB Broughton's problem is not that he's "undersized"; he's over 230 lbs! He's from a small school, the Citadel, and as a 7th rounder he was always going to be a project. He just didn't pan out. - Resigning Dockery IMHO is a priority, and it will likely get done because I think the team wants it and because I don't believe Dockery will command a huge contract as a FA. If he's back, next year will be the third consecutive year that the same 5 linemen have played together. They need depth, though.
 
Let me give you a outsider's opinion. I just posted something similar in another post.

I think alot of people are looking way to deep into the Betts deal. Portis is still the man in Washington and the fact the Skins signed Betts to a solid deal not "GREAT"(RB#1) deal very solid deal in any case was smart.

The Skins had to make a decision on Betts and why not get that done early and take the FA shopping out of the equation. Washington now can focus on other needs WR or Defense.

Campbell looks to be very solid and I think Washington really goes defense in FA/Draft.

I think as a outsider, I would appauld what Washington has done the last 3 years and are a team on the rise as long as they don't self destruct. Washington taking their time with Campbell and to me the Betts deal shows a real solid plan was laid out and if I was a Redskins fan and I'm not, I would just hope they continue on this path and don't let pettiness destroy what has taken 3-4 years to build.
I generally agree, although their actions are certainly deserving of some criticism. However I think that if they resign Dockery, all 11 offensive starters from the end of this year will be back and this could be a potent offensive unit. They found a winning formula down the stretch on offense and that will carry over. They have some major problems on defense, particularly with a group of players who are showing their age with durability problems. Springs, Salave'a, Griffin and Washington all wore down as the season went on and missed time, and all of those guys have been mainstays on that defense the last couple of years. Still, if they can get sign a good veteran CB, and draft one of the good DE's in the draft then they should be able to improve. I'd also like them to get a true MLB to replace Marshall, but that may be asking too much.

 
Shawn Springs to try safety?

http://www.redskins.com/news/newsDetail.jsp?id=24549

This is the same Springs who can't stay healthy, right?
He missed one game last year, one in 04, four in 03, one in 02, 8 in 01, played all games 98-00. He has been banged up before, but has been pretty reliable so far, I'd love to see him at saftey, it is the natural progresion.
:confused: :unsure: 1 game last year? Guess you only watched 1 game yourself. Dude can't stay healthy, when he does play he good, but you cant count on him being there 16 games. I like Samuel as well, and also wouldn't mind bringing in L. Flecther for a year or 2 to teach Rocky, then we need a KICKER, that can make Fg's and make it to the ENDZONE ON KICKOFFS!!!!!

 
London Fletcher would be an excellent pickup. He could dominate the middle and allow McIntosh and Marshall to compete on the weak side.

 
Shawn Springs to try safety?

http://www.redskins.com/news/newsDetail.jsp?id=24549

This is the same Springs who can't stay healthy, right?
He missed one game last year, one in 04, four in 03, one in 02, 8 in 01, played all games 98-00. He has been banged up before, but has been pretty reliable so far, I'd love to see him at saftey, it is the natural progresion.
:confused: :confused: 1 game last year? Guess you only watched 1 game yourself. Dude can't stay healthy, when he does play he good, but you cant count on him being there 16 games. I like Samuel as well, and also wouldn't mind bringing in L. Flecther for a year or 2 to teach Rocky, then we need a KICKER, that can make Fg's and make it to the ENDZONE ON KICKOFFS!!!!!
I watch every game, here are how many games he has started throughout his career1997 Seattle Seahawks 10

1998 Seattle Seahawks 16

1999 Seattle Seahawks 16

2000 Seattle Seahawks 16

2001 Seattle Seahawks 8

2002 Seattle Seahawks 15

2003 Seattle Seahawks 12

2004 Washington Redskins 15

2005 Washington Redskins 15

2006 Washington Redskins 9

He is starting to show his age however, I would love to see him make the transition to safety. It would really free Taylor up to play more around the LOS. I couldn't agree more with you that a stud like Fletcher would be awesome if we could get him. Samuel and any other CB we could get would be a help, depth is such a huge issue.

 
When healthy, Springs is still one of the better cover CB's in the league. What makes you think he'd be more durable at safety than at CB?

Anyway, I don't want to see Sean Taylor near the LOS. He had a bad year but he's far too athletic playing "centerfield" to devote him to blitzing and run support in the "box".

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top