I have all of my information on a single sheet constructed in Excel -- except for bye weeks -- and it has served me well. I'm much less frantic, and developing the sheet has forced me to examine every single piece of data in advance and also made me confront player comparisons, both interpositional and intrapositional, so that very little of that remains to consume my time during the draft itself. To rank players, I use projections (either Dodds alone or modified in Projections Dominator) fed through the Draft Dominator with a user customizable position rank to get one set of data, then I get another set of data from a second source. I merge the data, using a weighted average (different each year, depends on my feeling on which set of data is better, at each position; sometimes 50/50, sometimes as far off as 75/25). I actually list both sources overall rank (top 100 or so) or position rank (100+ or so) on the sheet, along with the merged average, and finally their ADP round.
I rank the players in a tiered manner, so it's by position but also staggered by value into tiers. Left to right goes QB, RB, WR, TE. So I already have a lot of the interpositional sorting accomplished.
Another aspect to this spreadsheet is that I try to have tier breaks close to where my overall draft pick is for each round.
This year I was 11th of 12, so I actually only attempted to "force" tiers at the 14 spot (for separating rounds 1 and 2 players), the 38 spot (for rounds 3 and 4), the 62 spot, and so on.
I ended up with more tiers than that, but creating those tiers, which are based on previous drafts in the same league where available, helps me to see the consequences of passing on each position on each pass, essentially creating a peek at DVBD. And really, I think I get a BETTER overview with the paper, due to my ability to see all the way to the 10th round or so, then I do with the DVBD window on Draft Dominator.
I know this doesn't apply to everyone, but if you have league drafts from the previous season or two, using those to get an estimate of your league tendencies can be very useful in terms of forming tiers and using those tiers to help inform your early round draft strategy.