29 replies to this topic

[zorg222]

This is from another board. I want to get the answr from a neutral point of view.

So which would you raher have? Drew Bledsoe, or Donovan McNabb?

[KnowledgeReignsSupreme]

As a scarecrow or NFL QB?

[fridayfrenzy]

Hands down Drew Bledsoe. No contest. Someone choosing McNabb really doesn't know much about FF.

Edited by fridayfrenzy, 29 May 2005 - 07:13 PM.

[Phlash]

Drew Bledsoe can throw the ball farther.

So I choose Drew.

[Phlash]

Oh, and Bledsoe got to the Superbowl way before McNabb did.

[zorg222]

in response to fridayfrenzy, why do you say that

[zorg222]

Drew Bledsoe can throw the ball farther.

So I choose Drew.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

That is because Bledsoe is way older than McNabb

[Whatevaman15]

Bledsoe has 39808 career passing yards while McNabb only has 16926. Bledsoe=STUD, McNabb=glorified running back.

[zorg222]

Bledsoe has 39808 career passing yards while McNabb only has 16926. Bledsoe=STUD, McNabb=glorified running back.

I'm not bashing you or anything, but think about how many years Bledsoe has played and how many years McNabb has played. Those are two very different numbers. Just consider that.

Edited by zorg222, 29 May 2005 - 07:33 PM.

[zorg222]

Drew Bledsoe can throw the ball farther.

McNabb has a really good deep ball. Bledsoe doesn't necessarily 'throw the ball frther'.

[Phlash]

Drew Bledsoe can throw the ball farther.

McNabb has a really good deep ball. Bledsoe doesn't necessarily 'throw the ball frther'.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

First of all, Bledsoe throws the ball farther than McNabb ever will.

McNabb = glorified running back.

Now if you want a REAL talented guy who can throw the ball, look no further than Michael Vick. He can really bomb that ball.

[zorg222]

Drew Bledsoe can throw the ball farther.

McNabb has a really good deep ball. Bledsoe doesn't necessarily 'throw the ball frther'.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

First of all, Bledsoe throws the ball farther than McNabb ever will.

McNabb = glorified running back.

Now if you want a REAL talented guy who can throw the ball, look no further than Michael Vick. He can really bomb that ball.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Vick, I have to disagree with the statement that he has an arm. Vick is one of the worst arms in the NFL. His legs are what make him great, not his arm.
He may have distance, but without accuracy what's the point?

EDIT: If you were being sarcastic then I feel like an idiot right now ...

Edited by zorg222, 29 May 2005 - 08:01 PM.

[Ozymandias]

I think it's Bledsoe hands down. He has the requisite experience. Quarterbacks struggle in the NFL until they have enough experience.

[Wberry]

Drew Bledsoe can throw the ball farther.

McNabb has a really good deep ball. Bledsoe doesn't necessarily 'throw the ball frther'.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

First of all, Bledsoe throws the ball farther than McNabb ever will.

McNabb = glorified running back.

Now if you want a REAL talented guy who can throw the ball, look no further than Michael Vick. He can really bomb that ball.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think Phlash is right on with Vick. I saw that Powerade commercial where he throws the ball clear out of the stadium. The only two other guys I've ever heard of doing that were John Elway and Rico (in 1983).
As far as Bledsoe versus McNabb goes I think it's a bit closer than the guys are letting on--but I'd still go with Bledsoe. He was a Cougar at Washington State and McNabb was an Orangeman. I think cougars are way fiercer than orange dudes. Plus Bledsoe mentored Tom Brady in New England and he's won three SuperBowls now, so in a sense Drew has won three SuperBowls and McNabb hasn't won any.

[Portis 26]

It's got to be Bledsoe. McNabb just isn't accurate. Bledsoe zips it in there. Plus, McNabb gets tired. And throws up. Has to be Bledsoe.

[KnowledgeReignsSupreme]

It's got to be Bledsoe. McNabb just isn't accurate. Bledsoe zips it in there. Plus, McNabb gets tired. And throws up. Has to be Bledsoe.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Bledsoe loses 5 gallons of blood after being sacked.

[Zaphod]

Ask a stupid question and get a ...

[15325]

[joffer]

must be in the bizarro shark pool

[Ever Present Lurker]

How could anyone even suggest McNabb? Drew Bledsoe is going to pass-happy Bill Parcells, to take over for young stud Drew Henson. I haven't seen McNabb take over for any young studs lately.

[fridayfrenzy]

I hope you found the answer you were looking for

Draft Bledose over McNabb

[KnowledgeReignsSupreme]

How could anyone even suggest McNabb?  Drew Bledsoe is going to pass-happy Bill Parcells, to take over for young stud Drew Henson.  I haven't seen McNabb take over for any young studs lately.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Bobby Hoying.

[Chaka]

Bledsoe.

But I hate Chunky soup so I may be biased.

[Wberry]

And if it's a dynasty league, bump Bledsoe up a few more notches.

[FreeBaGeL]

This isn't even close...

Bledsoe.

Mcnabb's WR's have carried him for years and made him look better than he really is. Just imagine if Bledsoe had Freddy Mitchell and/or Todd Pinkston. He would've won 4 super bowls by now.

[Disturbed01]

It's got to be Bledsoe. McNabb just isn't accurate. Bledsoe zips it in there. Plus, McNabb gets tired. And throws up. Has to be Bledsoe.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think all you fools are smokin something good.... if you are talking about in thier prime, ok, but if you all are saying you take Bledsoe over McNabb right now, all I can say is give me some of that Stuff.... it must be GOOD...

[czar7]

Hands down Drew Bledsoe.  No contest.  Someone choosing McNabb really doesn't know much about FF.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Hands down, LOL. I'd take McNabb any day, he's a playmaker and wins games. As for someone choosing McNabb doesn't know FF, I laugh at you . In my league last year McNabb ended 3rd overall(and pretty much didn't play the last 2 games) and Bledsoe ended up 19th overall. With logic like that good luck next year in your leagues friday.

[fridayfrenzy]

It's got to be Bledsoe. McNabb just isn't accurate. Bledsoe zips it in there. Plus, McNabb gets tired. And throws up. Has to be Bledsoe.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think all you fools are smokin something good.... if you are talking about in thier prime, ok, but if you all are saying you take Bledsoe over McNabb right now, all I can say is give me some of that Stuff.... it must be GOOD...

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Maybe you aren't aware that Bledose is back with Parcells. He will play lights out football.

[KnowledgeReignsSupreme]

Hands down Drew Bledsoe.  No contest.  Someone choosing McNabb really doesn't know much about FF.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Hands down, LOL. I'd take McNabb any day, he's a playmaker and wins games. As for someone choosing McNabb doesn't know FF, I laugh at you . In my league last year McNabb ended 3rd overall(and pretty much didn't play the last 2 games) and Bledsoe ended up 19th overall. With logic like that good luck next year in your leagues friday.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

You obviously have no idea what you're talking about.

[czar7]

This isn't even close...

Bledsoe.

Mcnabb's WR's have carried him for years and made him look better than he really is.  Just imagine if Bledsoe had Freddy Mitchell and/or Todd Pinkston.  He would've won 4 super bowls by now.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA, please tell me your joking, HAHAHAHAHA. They have had argueably the worst receiving corp for years (with the exception of TO)