This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
TO will be 34 next year and Glenn will be 33. He's going to need some new blood to throw to very soon.I'll go with Palmer as well. He's 3 years younger than Peyton and I think will likely put up similar (although likely less) production to Manning over the next 3 seasons. After that point I expect Manning's age to start catching up to him.
injuries are a key consideration when evaluating this topic.
agreed. mcnabb's upside is roughly commensurate with his injury risk. given that he had the same numbers as manning before he got hurt, and this was without a true #1 WR, i think they're a dead heat. do you take the upside, or the safe play? depends on the person, i guess. i'm a gambler
seriously? QBs of his caliber play for 13 years or more, there's no indication that Peyton is slowing down (although his best WR may be). I'll take 4 years of Peyton, no contest.Carson, I can understand taking ahead. Nobody else is close.
I take the safe play and the upside play - Manning. Not even a contest considering both are the same age and one is injury prone. I assume you are fishing but Ill bite regardless.Seasons over 4000 yards passing: Peyton 6 McNabb 0Seasons with more then 25 combined TDs: Peyton 8 McNabb 316 Game Seasons: Peyton 8 Donovan 3How can you possibly see Donovan with more upside?agreed. mcnabb's upside is roughly commensurate with his injury risk. given that he had the same numbers as manning before he got hurt, and this was without a true #1 WR, i think they're a dead heat. do you take the upside, or the safe play? depends on the person, i guess. i'm a gambler
not fishing, unless you consider my assumption that Philly will do what they can to get a top WR in the door. that was the upside my rather brief analysis was based on. he was neck-and-neck with manning with the likes of Reggie Brown and LJ Smith. Reggie brown enters his 3rd year next year, and should become a top WR, and i'd expect them to try and sign someone since no one can depend on Stallworth evidently. manning has no upside, in my opinion. where are you deriving this idea from?? he's a flat play if i ever saw one....I take the safe play and the upside play - Manning. Not even a contest considering both are the same age and one is injury prone. I assume you are fishing but Ill bite regardless.Seasons over 4000 yards passing: Peyton 6 McNabb 0Seasons with more then 25 combined TDs: Peyton 8 McNabb 316 Game Seasons: Peyton 8 Donovan 3How can you possibly see Donovan with more upside?agreed. mcnabb's upside is roughly commensurate with his injury risk. given that he had the same numbers as manning before he got hurt, and this was without a true #1 WR, i think they're a dead heat. do you take the upside, or the safe play? depends on the person, i guess. i'm a gambler
not fishing, unless you consider my assumption that Philly will do what they can to get a top WR in the door. that was the upside my rather brief analysis was based on. he was neck-and-neck with manning with the likes of Reggie Brown and LJ Smith. Reggie brown enters his 3rd year next year, and should become a top WR, and i'd expect them to try and sign someone since no one can depend on Stallworth evidently. manning has no upside, in my opinion. where are you deriving this idea from?? he's a flat play if i ever saw one....I take the safe play and the upside play - Manning. Not even a contest considering both are the same age and one is injury prone. I assume you are fishing but Ill bite regardless.Seasons over 4000 yards passing: Peyton 6 McNabb 0Seasons with more then 25 combined TDs: Peyton 8 McNabb 316 Game Seasons: Peyton 8 Donovan 3How can you possibly see Donovan with more upside?agreed. mcnabb's upside is roughly commensurate with his injury risk. given that he had the same numbers as manning before he got hurt, and this was without a true #1 WR, i think they're a dead heat. do you take the upside, or the safe play? depends on the person, i guess. i'm a gambler
so because Mcnabbs was having his best year in your mind before he got hurt, and that best year is comparable to Mannings 2006 season which is average for him, you think Mcnabb has more upside. Gotcha.
Peyton Manning is 30 years old now. But he is so good and never gets injured. His uniform stays pretty clean almost all the time. I think he could still be playing at this level for another 10 years honestly before age finaly catches up with him. He is a machine. A total student of the game. Born and bred to be a NFL Qb. I don't see him ever losing passion for the game. I like a lot of these other guys too. But if I can have any Qb Peyton is definitly my choice. Keep in mind that no answer is wrong when it comes to this. We all have different ideas and philosophies in how we play dynasty and how we value players. If you think differently than the majority than so be it. Thats another thing that is useful about these consensus rankings. Is figuring out how the majority values players and based off of that how we can use it to our advantage.
What ATC1 said! 
