I hope they learned their lesson w/ Gallery. Everyone wanted to trade up to get him and Davis turned down some pretty good offers 'cause Gallery was the "can't miss, franchise LT." I'd love to see Joe Thomas so Gallery could move back to guard where he was effective and can carry on the #76. A.P. would take enough heat off of the passing game that the QB MAY be able to make a 3 step drop w/o being hit (during the 1st half when they haven't fallen behind by 17). In reality, Calvin is a need w/ Moss & Porter being run out of town, but without the running game/O-line, who cares. I say look at the greatest need of the top 10 teams, and spew about how bad you need/want the player that the top 10 teams will be going for and hope to force a draft-day trade to move down a few picks, get A.Branch and an extra top 10 2nd rounder, maybe more.
If they make a trade down, the #1 pick should net more than a 2nd rounder, for sure.As to learning their lesson, i can't agree with that. 1st round O-linemen are still the surest bet there is.
I really don't want to take a RB, just cause I think you can always get one.
Calvin johnson fills a need with Porter and Moss gone, but I hate the track record of 1st round WR's. Probably only second to DL as far as busts go.
massraider, which OLineman do you think is worth the #1 overall? Or do you see a trade down and then draft the best OL? Is that the Raiders' wisest course? They need to fill seats, too.It appears the Jets did a great job building their OL with the draft - completely revamped OL that is now playing pretty well. If the team commits to moving Gallery to guard, who do you all think the Raiders should take, and should they be looking to trade down to do so?
On Quinn, I think the Raiders' HC will determine whether Quinn will be a good pick. He is extraordinarily well coached (unlike Rick Mirer), so the right HC/OC/QBC in Oakland could make Quinn an excellent system QB. A QB wityh a head on his shoulders seems to be the Raiders' need more than a physically gifted, but immature, athlete. Thoughts?
First, let me say: I don't watch much college football, so my player evaluation is based on prevelant sentiment. I have no strong opinions on which of these players will bust, or break out, or whatever. I love the draft, but don't pretend to know crap about these players.I'm generally speaking in the abstract.
When we were thinking we were going to get the #2 pick, with Quinn going to the Lions, I was a little alarmed that no one was talking about the top OT (Joe Thomas right now, I think) as a possibility. Not taking a player at our greatest need because Gallery has disappointed is a pretty dumb strategy, IMO. Harrington didn't work out in Detroit, should the Lions pass on a QB because of him? Of course not.
Now that we have the #1 pick, Quinn is in play. And if he's rated a franchise QB, then that's who I want to take.
I don't think a trade down is really a possibility. All Raider jokes aside, Davis has a good trading record, and I'm sure he'd be asking for a king's ransom. I don't see it happening.
The RB talk has been generated by fans who are sick of seeing Lamont hesitate behind the line, and getting dropped for a loss. I wonder if a RB is even on the Raiders radar.
It's also
so early, everything needs to be taken with a grain of salt. We know someone is going to fall down the draft board, and someone is going to rise. Quinn could have a bad Senior Bowl week, Jamarcus could declare and knock everyone's socks off in workouts, health questions could push Peterson down, etc.
Everyone tends to talk in absolutes this time of year about prospects, and every year, it's proven that things change. The combine, personal workouts, Senior Bowl, there's still a lot of shaking and baking to go on.