Isn't the quality of the O-line causing problems for both Caddy and Simms? Besides, Rattay looks like he'll get a shot, and I wouldn't be surprised to see Garcia in that mix. While it's true that there's a lot of uncertainty as to exactly how things will shake out, Caddy's dynasty value can't be judged by just the downside risk that things don't get any better. There's a good chance that some aspects of the situation will improve. On the other hand, I would downgrade Willie Parker, Ahman Green, and Fred Taylor, despite their better-than-expected performance last season. There is a very good chance their situations will worsen considerably.