Comparing the last 2 years at the top: RB#2 (1 Viewer)

Wanted to look at the top consensus picks at the skills positions(mostly 1st two round guys, used the Bloom 100 for the 07 group).

The RBs...based upon their/your draft grades...how do you rank them if it was one draft will these players. Try not to heavily weigh last years rookie performances too much. How did these guys grade out of college to you? Hopefully we can get some good discussion here

Ranking the RBs..06 vs 07

RBs

Reggie Bush

Laurence Maroney

DeAngelo Williams

Joseph Addai

Lendale White

Maurice Drew

….................................

Adrian Peterson

Marshawn Lynch

Antonio Pittman

Michael Bush

Lorenzo Booker

Kenny Irons

1. Reggie Bush

2.

I picked All Day. I think that guy is going to be the next (fill in the blank)

I think Maroney takes this if we are talking about NFL potential...he has STUD rb written all over him.

I would say:

BUSH

MARONEY

A.P.

J.ADDAI

M.LYNCH

I think this will be very tight when looking at potential...not including height...I think MJD has all the tools also

Wasn't there a big debate 18 months ago as to who is better Bush or Peterson? Has Peterson fallen that far?

All Day is surely well thought of..bumping for more votes

From a grade out talent type position it's Adrian Peterson and it's not even that close. Think you can debate between him and Reggie Bush for #1 actually.

(Without knowing what team Peterson ends up with) I would agree with the consensus so far...AD is the #2 on this list. The real debate is who's #3. I'd side with Addai but the ranking for spots 3-7 are very, very close.

AD's one of the most talented college backs I've ever seen play. Guy does some things that just make your jaw drop.