The ongoing state investigation into whether Adam Vinatieri qualifies as a resident hunter also will determine if the Super Bowl champion broke the law in obtaining a license to hunt pheasants and other game birds. GF&P records show that the Indianapolis Colts kicker, a Rapid City native who owns a house outside of town but lives for most of the year in homes in Florida and Indiana, bought a resident small-game license in 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002 and 2004. In buying those licenses, which are typically used to hunt pheasants and other game birds, Vinatieri listed his parents’ address in Rapid City rather than the address of one of his homes in other states.
GF&P investigators who are trying to determine if Vinatieri qualifies for residency status as a hunter are also checking whether he violated an agency rule against making “false representations on applications,” when he bought the small-game licenses. Applicants for licenses are supposed to provide an address that represents their “place of residence,” GF&P spokesman Emmett Keyser of Pierre said Monday. Vinatieri also used his parents’ address in 2005 and 2006 in applying for “preference points” in big-game license drawings that are open to residents only. After Vinatieri applied for those preference points, which would increase his chances of being drawn for high-demand resident big-game licenses in future years, the state began its investigation.
Keyser said Vinatieri and his father, Paul, have cooperated fully in the investigation, which began late last summer or early fall. But Vinatieri hasn’t yet provided all of the information, including tax materials, that investigators requested, Keyser said. “Our investigator has since visited with him again and recommended that he or his attorney need to provide that information to us so we can make a final determination,” Keyser said. “It’s sort of getting to the point where we really need to make a determination based on the evidence.”
Keyser said it wasn’t immediately clear whether Vinatieri’s use of his parents’ address to apply for big-game preference points or buy the small-game licenses was a criminal violation — or, if so, whether it was a violation worthy of a charge. License application fraud can lead to penalties of up to a year in jail and a $1,000 fine. Keyser said Vinatieri has taken a number of steps to maintain his resident status. He owns a house south of Rapid City, which is typically rented to someone else. He also licenses vehicles here and maintains his South Dakota drivers license. And Vinatieri is registered to vote in Pennington County and lists his parents’ address, where he still receives mail, with the Pennington County auditor’s office.
Auditor Julie Pearson said it’s legal for voters to keep their original voter registration address long after they move away to other towns or states. “The rules are kind of odd in South Dakota,” she said. “When you register to vote, you actually have to reside at that address. Once you’re registered there, you can maintain that as your voter address for the rest of your life.”
The official Web site of the Indianapolis Colts says Vinatieri lives in Orlando, Fla., with his wife, Valerie, and their two children. But Vinatieri and his family live for much of the year at their home in Indianapolis, spend part of the year in Florida and occasionally visit South Dakota. The 34-year-old graduate of Rapid City Central High School is an active hunter who has expressed plans to someday buy a ranch in western South Dakota. He is currently on a hunting trip in Argentina. His father didn’t want to speak on his son’s behalf.
To meet the general requirements for a resident hunting license, people must have a South Dakota drivers license or expiration-dated state ID, license motor vehicles in South Dakota, make no resident-hunting claims in other states and “actually live within and be a bona fide South Dakota resident for at least 90 days with the intent to make it home.” Vinatieri contends that he has never given up his residency and plans to make a home here after his football career ends. “In Adam’s defense, he felt like he’s tried to do his best to maintain his residency, yet there’s some question whether he has done that,” Keyser said.
Vinatieri’s residency question is likely to cause GF&P officials to consider ways to clarify its laws and regulations on resident-hunting status, Keyser said. “We had some of those discussions as we were looking at legislative topics for this calendar year,” he said. “Is there a way that we can make some of this more clear? I think we’ll look at that.”