The two NFL guys (good players) who had incredible timed speed, but have low YPC and don't play as fast as the number suggest are L. coles who ran 4.3 ish and Andre Johnson who was a legitimate track sprinter. Hill's production suggests that he is capable of big plays, so the timed speed actually matches that giving him what seem to be a more complete profile. I am not going to say that he is shooting up the boards, but he at least deserves another glance.He did not show that kind of separation speed at the Senior Bowl practices
Not sure if those are good comparisons. I think Coles is slower now. He averaged 14+ ypr before he got that toe issue in Washington and has been between 10-12 ypr since then, although maybe he is starting to get over the issue as his ypr has steadily climbed the past 3 years.As for AJ, he also was 14+ ypr when he wasn't getting force fed the ball short, like the last 2 years where he isn't getting any downfield looks. I think Houston's problem is Carr and the ridiculous number of sacks. As as AJ owner, it gets pretty frustrating watching those garbage time drives where you hope for good AJ production and it seems like every play is a sack or a 1 yard run by Carr.Aside from the injury marred 2005, AJ has averaged 16 20+ yard gains and 3-4 40+ yard gains. Reggie Wayne in comparison has averaged 14 and 2.5 in his starter years and Javon Walker had 16 and 4 last year for Denver, so AJ still has potential. Problem is that even though 2006 looked similar to 2003 & 2004 in long gains, he had 103 receptions in 2006, compared to 72.5 in 2003/2004. The passing game in 2006 shortened up, but I think AJ could easily get back to the 14-15 ypr average if the Carr/OL (not sure % of blame to throw around) problem is solved.The two NFL guys (good players) who had incredible timed speed, but have low YPC and don't play as fast as the number suggest are L. coles who ran 4.3 ish and Andre Johnson who was a legitimate track sprinter. Hill's production suggests that he is capable of big plays, so the timed speed actually matches that giving him what seem to be a more complete profile. I am not going to say that he is shooting up the boards, but he at least deserves another glance.He did not show that kind of separation speed at the Senior Bowl practices
I think you have the right idea, but are off base a bit. A typical player will have a .3-.35 difference. If is is more, than you are quick in and out of your breaks. If it less, it means you need to gather yourself and slow down in the turns. However, very few players that run a sub 4.4 will ever have a .3-.35 difference. You can only run the shuttle so fast. I don't think any wr ran faster than a 4.08 shuttle at the combine this year.Hill ran a 4.32 40, but just a 4.22 20yd shuttle.I mentioned this on The Audible for Sunday, but one of the commentators (I believe Mike Mayock) mentioned that scouts have told him that there should be 0.3 to 0.35 difference between those two numbers. This tells me that there's something wrong with the times of one of the two - the gap is way too small at just a tenth.A smaller gap means that the guy is straightline fast but not that quick, whereas a bigger gap (say 0.4+) means he is quick but not straightline fast. So in this case I'd question his quickness, OR I'd call the 4.32 time questionable.
I heard he did well at the Senior Bowl Practices, and caught a TD in the game? I assume Bloom is more informed than I.He did not show that kind of separation speed at the Senior Bowl practices
He did well but he was not able to separate consistently from the DBs on deep routes.I heard he did well at the Senior Bowl Practices, and caught a TD in the game? I assume Bloom is more informed than I.He did not show that kind of separation speed at the Senior Bowl practices
I agree with you about the "physical limit" thing to his time, but 0.1 is a "tell" towards checking into how he did.For example, if he ran a 4.32, he should have had a 4.1-ish shuttle.rabidfireweasel said:I think you have the right idea, but are off base a bit. A typical player will have a .3-.35 difference. If is is more, than you are quick in and out of your breaks. If it less, it means you need to gather yourself and slow down in the turns. However, very few players that run a sub 4.4 will ever have a .3-.35 difference. You can only run the shuttle so fast. I don't think any wr ran faster than a 4.08 shuttle at the combine this year.Jeff Pasquino said:Hill ran a 4.32 40, but just a 4.22 20yd shuttle.I mentioned this on The Audible for Sunday, but one of the commentators (I believe Mike Mayock) mentioned that scouts have told him that there should be 0.3 to 0.35 difference between those two numbers. This tells me that there's something wrong with the times of one of the two - the gap is way too small at just a tenth.A smaller gap means that the guy is straightline fast but not that quick, whereas a bigger gap (say 0.4+) means he is quick but not straightline fast. So in this case I'd question his quickness, OR I'd call the 4.32 time questionable.
Just reviewed the WRs. Of 19 times in the 20 yd shuffle, he was 4th worst (16th) despite having the 2nd best 40 yard time. That tells me there's an issue.Also for comparison sake, take a look at other WRs:Name (40/20)David Clowney (4.36/4.15)Anthony Gonzalez (4.44/4.08)Steve Smith (4.44/4.19)James Jones (4.53/4.2)Yes there were two other WRs that had small spreads (Figurs and L. Robinson), but when I saw him clip the line with his hand all of his numbers were questionable to me.Mind you, 4.32 or 4.4, he's speedy. I just want to see his 2nd 40 time somewhere and I'm not buying 4.32 blazing speed.I agree with you about the "physical limit" thing to his time, but 0.1 is a "tell" towards checking into how he did.For example, if he ran a 4.32, he should have had a 4.1-ish shuttle.rabidfireweasel said:I think you have the right idea, but are off base a bit. A typical player will have a .3-.35 difference. If is is more, than you are quick in and out of your breaks. If it less, it means you need to gather yourself and slow down in the turns. However, very few players that run a sub 4.4 will ever have a .3-.35 difference. You can only run the shuttle so fast. I don't think any wr ran faster than a 4.08 shuttle at the combine this year.Jeff Pasquino said:Hill ran a 4.32 40, but just a 4.22 20yd shuttle.I mentioned this on The Audible for Sunday, but one of the commentators (I believe Mike Mayock) mentioned that scouts have told him that there should be 0.3 to 0.35 difference between those two numbers. This tells me that there's something wrong with the times of one of the two - the gap is way too small at just a tenth.A smaller gap means that the guy is straightline fast but not that quick, whereas a bigger gap (say 0.4+) means he is quick but not straightline fast. So in this case I'd question his quickness, OR I'd call the 4.32 time questionable.
I saw 4.32/4.35 posted yesterday at NFL Network.Mind you, 4.32 or 4.4, he's speedy. I just want to see his 2nd 40 time somewhere and I'm not buying 4.32 blazing speed.