What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

JimboJim Mock Draft - Post Combine (1 Viewer)

JimboJim

Footballguy
Player comparisons are for playing styles/physical skills only. I.e, If I compare Adrian Peterson to Fred Taylor, that doesn't mean I think Peterson will have injury problems...

Round I

1. Oakland - JaMarcus Russell, QB, LSU

Golden rule of the draft is never pass on a possible franchise QB unless you already have one; the Raiders don't. I chose Russell over Quinn based on his athletic upside and the leadership/maturity he displayed throughout last season. Russell may not be as polished as Quinn, but he seems to possess more of a "field-general" quality, as evidenced in the bowl game against Notre Dame. I believe the only question with Russell is whether or not he will stay focused, as he showed up a little soft and out of shape at the combine. That never really seemed to hinder Daunte Culpepper too much.

NFL Comparison - Daunte Culpepper

2. Detroit - Joe Thomas, OT, Wisconsin

As of my first two mock drafts, I had Quinn going in this spot. If I was picking for the Lions, he would be my choice. Quinn is a franchise caliber QB, who I believe is getting a bad rap because of his bowl game performance. However, I'm not making the pick, and everything I've read and heard is that the Lions are heavily leaning towards drafting Joe Thomas. I have no doubt that Thomas could turn out to be an excellent pro, but I feel that if a team doesn't have a franchise QB and has the opportunity to draft one, they must. Enough of that though, Thomas is one of the highest rated offensive linemen to come out since Robert Gallery. His impressive showing at the combine (sub-5.00 40) cemented his status as a top-5 pick.

NFL Comparison - Orlando Pace

3. Cleveland - Brady Quinn, QB, Notre Dame

Many people are saying that the Browns need to draft a player that will have an immediate impact on the team so Romeo Crenel doesn't lose his job. Big news people, I really doubt the Cleveland front office is thinking that same way. They are going to do what's best for the team, period. I've heard that Quinn wants to play in Cleveland. Romeo has the Charlie Weis connection, so I think he'll get the true facts on Quinn; which will be very positive when all is said and done. However, the biggest reason for drafting Quinn is that Charlie Frye has not done anything to prove he is the answer. You could have great players at every other position on the field, but 10 TDs and 17 Ints on the year will kill you every time. Quinn will have an impact on this team, sooner than later.

NFL Comparison - Carson Palmer

4. Tampa Bay - Calvin Johnson, WR, Georgia Tech

I don't think there's any question Tampa would take Johnson if he were here. He fills a need at a position where Galloway is getting older and Clayton has underachieved and fought through injuries. Johnson appears to be the closest thing to a lock at WR in the draft since Larry Fitzgerald a few years ago. His performance at the combine was all-world. I would have loved to have put him in Oakland, Detroit or Cleveland, but both Oakland and Cleveland need QBs bad and getting Johnson wouldn't have the impact either Quinn or Russell would. CJ in Detroit would really make sense, but that team needs to build from the trenches out. Another skill player ain't going to right that ship.

NFL Comparison - Terrell Owens

5. Arizona - LaRon Landry, S, LSU

The Arizona Cardinals had a decent number of sacks last season (38) and finished with strong numbers against the run. Their biggest weakness was giving up the big play in the passing game. Bertrand Berry and Chike Okeafer aren't the best DEs in the league, but they're not the worst either. Drafting Jamaal Anderson or Gaines Adams would certainly upgrade their line, but it wouldn't solve this teams major problem, especially if Robert Griffith retires. LaRon Landry is a tall lean FS prospect who could team with Adrian Wilson to form the best safety combo in the league. Additionally, Landry's presence would go a long way towards taking pressure off the young Antrel Rolle and whoever mans the other corner spot. Some will say this is too high for Landry; NFL teams don't think that way. He won't be there when they pick in the second and I don't project trades.

NFL Comparison - Ed Reed

6. Washington - Jaamal Anderson, DE, Arkansas

I see Anderson as being a prospect similar to Richard Seymour; both are large DEs with excellent pass rush skills. This would fill the need of both a pass-rushing and run-stopping lineman for the Redskins. Branch and Adams are both considerations, but in the end, I feel Anderson is the best D-lineman on the board.

NFL Comparison - Richard Seymour

7. Minnesota Vikings - Adrian Peterson, RB, Oklahoma

BPA by far. Hear me out; we all want to pick players for teams based on what we think are needs. We look at the Vikings and say they have no good WRs, they need a QB… If I was the coach of the Vikings and knew I would be heading into the season with either Tavarius Jackson or a lesser tier free agent QB, I would want to lean on my running game as much as possible. Chester Taylor ended up with 1216 total yards last season, but look at his game logs. He had 7 out of 15 games where he averaged 3.5 yards or less a carry. Somewhat deceiving numbers. AD is a big time power runner that would absolutely crush people running behind McKinnie and Hutch and take a lot of pressure off whoever the passer is.

NFL Comparison - Fred Taylor

8. Houston - Marshawn Lynch, RB, Cal

The Texans need a playmaker other than AJ and I don't believe they can plan on having a healthy Davis/Williams/Whatever back. Lynch is a compact, shake-and-bake runner with speed, vision, toughness and durability. He can also catch the ball, something important in the Texans offense. The Texans have never had much of a problem racking up yards in the running game; put a premier prospect like Lynch back there and I believe this entire offense gets a significant boost.

NFL Comparison - Ladainian Tomlinson

9. Miami - Allen Branch, DT, Michigan

The Dolphins couldn't be happier; biggest need meets one of the top 2-3 BPAs.

NFL Comparison - Kevin Williams

10. Atlanta - Gaines Adams, DE, Clemson

Patrick Kearney may be gone, but even if he isn't, Adams still fills a need. A healthy D-line isn't something the Falcons have had in a number of years. Adams should team with Abraham to form a tenacious outside pass rush. This will ease up pressure on the secondary.

NFL Comparison - John Abraham

11. San Fran - Dwayne Jarrett, WR, USC

I absolutely love Jarrett and think all of the Mike Williams/Keyshawn Johnson comparisons are ridiculous. In my opinion, he's somewhat similar athletically to Plaxico Burress; the main difference is Jarrett doesn't have the attitude. Tall, great body control and a leaper. He needs to work on his drops and play a little more physical, but his college production cannot be overlooked. 216 catches for 3138 yards and 41 TDs; Jarrett is a player. With Alex Smith, Frank Gore and Jarrett to play with, my guess is Norv Turner will be having Troy/Emmitt/Irvin flashbacks.

NFL Comparison - Plaxico Burress

12. Buffalo - Amobi Okoye, DT, Louisville

Stopping the run has been a problem ever since Pat Williams left. Okoye is a little undersized, but because of his age, I believe he has room to grow.

NFL Comparison - LaRoi Glover

13. St. Loius - Patrick Willis, LB, Ole Miss

It seems like the Rams have been looking for a playmaking LB for years now. They need a defensive leader and someone that stuff the run and cover RBs and TEs out of the backfield. Willis appears to be the best in a fairly mediocre LB crop.

NFL Comparison - Keith Bulluck

14. Carolina - Reggie Nelson, S, Florida

Reggie Nelson will be the eventual starter once Minter moves on; he has the ball hawk skills they need at safety

NFL Comparison - Jermaine Phillips

15. Pittsburgh - Levi Brown, T, Penn State

There is a good chance that Max Starks leaves in free-agency, even if he doesn't he might not be the answer at tackle. Pittsburgh gave up 49 sacks last season. That certainly didn't help Big Ben get back on track much. The defense actually finished quite well against the run and doesn't appear to be losing any starters up front this off-season. An upgrade at S would help, but there aren't any at this point that provide the value that Levi Brown does. He's a big strong OT that fits the Pittsburgh mold.

NFL Comparison - Jaamal Brown

16. Green Bay - Leon Hall, CB, Michigan

Both the top RBs are gone, and while Ginn would be tempting, WR isn't that big of a concern. Driver is top-notch, Jennings played well as a rookie, and they can sign a free-agent to be the #3. Plus, Koren Robinson might be back. There is no depth after Harris and Woodson at CB.

NFL Comparison - Chris McAllister

17. Jacksonville - Ted Ginn, WR, Ohio State

BPA. This team has no explosive players on offense aside from Jones-Drew. Finally, a WR that can stretch the field.

NFL Comparison - Donte Stallworth

18. Cincinatti - Adam Carriker, DE, Nebraska

Carriker is a big 6-6, 300 lb D-lineman who could either rush the passer from inside or fill in at DE. Carriker saw his stock jump significantly at the Senior Bowl. The Bengals could go a lot of ways on D with this pick, but at the end of the day, Carriker is probably the BPA who fits a need.

NFL Comparison - Aaron Smith

19. Tennessee - Chris Houston, CB, Arkansas

I believe the Titans top needs are WR, CB and OT. With Brown, Jarrett and Ginn off the board, I feel the pick here is the best available CB. That would be Chris Houston IMO; Houston put on an impressive show at the combine bench pressing 225 only one time less than Joe Thomas. He's a strong, smart CB who would be a good complement to Adam Jones in the defensive backfield.

NFL Comparison - Nate Clements

20. NY Giants - Paul Posluzny, LB, Penn State

Puz would immediately help out a LB core that missed a ton of time due to injuries over the last couple of years. With the loses of Carlos Emmons and Arrington, LB is a big-time need for the G-men. Puz may not have the measurables of a Patrick Willis, but neither did Zach Thomas.

NFL Comparison - Al Wilson

21. Denver - Charles Johnson, DE, Georgia

Some additional help for the Denver front four. A DT would be the best option, but with Okoye and Branch gone, there are none worth taking here. Although they tragically lost Darrent Williams, don't expect them to draft another CB; D-line is a greater need and Johnson is a playmaker.

NFL Comparison - Bryan Thomas

22 Dallas - Aaron Ross, CB, Texas

With Wade Phillips coming to town and the Cowboys staying in the 3-4, shoring up that secondary will be task #1. Anthony Henry will be moved to FS and while Aaron Glenn is a good nickel CB, he's not a starter anymore. Ross burst on to the scene in 2006 winning the Jim Thorpe award. He has good size at 6-1, 190 lbs, but is still raw in terms of technique. I think the move to a faster, more dynamic corner to pair with Newman is the right one.

NFL Comparison - Terrance Newman

23. Kansas City - Dwayne Bowe , WR, LSU

The Chiefs take a shot at finally getting a true #1 WR with a guy that has been rising as of late. I'm not sold on Bowe personally. He drops too many balls and doesn't run great routes, but overall, he has the best overall skill set of any WR left on the board.

NFL Comparison - Eric Moulds

24. New England - Michael Griffin, S, Texas

The Pats luck out again. Griffin will be a good replacement for Rodney Harrison; I actually like him much better than Nelson.

NFL Comparison - Chris Hope

25. NY Jets - Jarvis Moss, DE, Florida

Moss is an imposing DE who can at the very least share reps with Ellis and Thomas and keep the D-line fresh. His Jr. and Sr. seasons, he combined for 20 tackles for loss and 15 sacks. Looking up and down this roster, the Jets are fairly solid across the board.

NFL Comparison - Kalimba Edwards

26. Philadelphia - Brandon Merriweather, S, Miami

Brian Dawkins is getting old and the other safety spot was a mess last season. Merriweather's big Senior Bowl week moved him into round one and he might even jump Griffin and/or Nelson (probably not). This pick would fill a need while still taking one of the BPAs.

NFL Comparison - Keith Lewis

27. New Orleans - Greg Olsen, TE, Miami

A CB would be the ideal selection for New Orleans, but with the top three off the board and the depth at the position, New Orleans can wait until later in the draft. Greg Olsen clearly established himself as the top tight end with his combine showing and would round out this potent New Orleans offense.

NFL Comparison - Todd Heap

28. New England - Robert Meachem, WR, Tennessee

Reche Caldwell came on at the end of last year, but other than him, the Pats didn't have a single consistent WR all season. Chad Jackson has great potential, but is still a developmental type player and coming off of an injury. Meachem would give New England another weapon to distribute the ball to; an excellent replacement for Deion Branch.

NFL Comparison - Javon Walker

29. Baltimore - Lawerence Timmons, LB, Florida State

Baltimore really doesn't have a lot of holes. The interior offensive line could be upgraded, but with Adalius Thomas leaving town, Timmons just seems like the perfect fit.

NFL Comparison - Warrick Holdman

30. San Diego - Justin Blalock, OG, Texas

Blalock would probably be an upgrade at either guard position. He could also fill in at tackle if need-be. I would have loved to put Sidney Rice here, but I don't think the Chargers are looking for another WR that will take a few years to develop. Additionally, Rice actually somewhat reminds me of Vincent Jackson; he is a tall leaper that doesn't have great outside speed or do a ton after the catch. Meachem or Ginn is the type of stretch-the-field WR the Chargers need and they are both gone.

NFL Comparison - Ruben Brown

31. Chicago - Jon Beason, LB, Miami

Beason is a little fireball that would fit this attacking defensive scheme perfectly. Beason would be an upgrade over Hunter Hillenmeyer, who was often the focal point of opposing offenses attack plans.

NFL Comparison - London Fletcher

32. Indianapolis - Darrelle Revis, CB, Pittsburgh

The Indy defensive backfield is a mess aside from Sanders. If they can develop Marlin Jackson, these two could make their pass defense respectable. Revis was once my #1 rated CB. However, he ran slow at the combine and doesn't have the upside of Hall, Ross or Houston.

NFL Comparison - Marcus Trufant

Round II

33. Oakland - Aaron Sears, OT, Tennessee

34. Detroit - Marcus McCauley, CB, Fresno State

35. Tampa Bay - Ryan Kalil, C, USC

36. Cleveland - Tank Tyler, DT, NC State

37. NY Jets - Brain Leonard, RB, Rutgers

38. Arizona - Tony Ugoh, OT, Arkansas

39. Houston - Ben Grubbs, OG, Auburn

40. Miami - Sidney Rice, WR, South Carolina

41. Minnesota - Joe Staley, OT, Central Michigan

42. San Fran - Justin Harrell, DT, Tennessee

43. Buffalo - Justin Hill, WR, Washington State

44. Atlanta - Eric Weddle, S, Utah

45. Carolina - Drew Stanton, QB, Michigan State

46. Pittsburgh - Stewart Bradley, LB, Nebraska

47. Green Bay - Kenny Irons, RB, Auburn

48. Jacksonville - Anthony Spencer, DE, Purdue

49. Cincinatti - Josh Wilson, CB, Maryland

50. Tennessee - Craig Davis, WR, LSU

51. NY Giants - Tony Hunt, RB, Penn State

52. St. Louis - Anthony Gonzalez, WR, Ohio State

53. Dallas - Buster Davis, LB, Florida State

54. Kansas City - Josh Beekman, OG, Boston College

55. Seattle - Fred Bennett, CB, South Carolina

56. Denver - Quinn Pitcock, DT, Ohio State

57. Philadelphia - Michael Bush, RB, Louisville

58. New Orleans - Brandon Siler, LB, Florida State

59. NY Jets - Manuel Ramirez, OG, Texas Tech

60. New England - Victor Abiamiri, DE, Notre Dame

61. Baltimore - Tim Crowder, DE, Texas

62. San Diego - HB Blades, LB, Pittsburgh

63. Chicago - Ben Patrick, TE, Deleware

64. Tampa Bay - LaMarr Woodley, DE, Michigan

Fire away... ;)

 
As a Packer I would be perfectly fine with getting Hall and Irons in the first two rounds. I do think that if Lynch and both the safeties are gone that Thompson might try and trade down and pick up either Olson or Meachum. I am intrigued by Carriker but with Kampman, KGB, and Jenkins don't know if he would go that way.

 
Ron_Mexico said:
Interesting, but no way does Jarrett go at #11.I actually think he will fall out of the first round.
Please explain; up until a couple of weeks ago, most mock drafts had him going to Minnesota at #7. He hasn't worked out yet, so poor measurables can't be it. Out of all of the top WRs in the draft, he produced the most at the college level, with two different QBs.I feel kinda like Brady Quinn was the en-vogue "falling" player a few weeks ago, it's now Jarrett. If he comes out and runs a 4.7 at his pro day, I will concede. However, nothing to this point proves anything contrary to him still being a top prospect.
 
JimboJim said:
3. Cleveland - Brady Quinn, QB, Notre Dame

Many people are saying that the Browns need to draft a player that will have an immediate impact on the team so Romeo Crenel doesn't lose his job. Big news people, I really doubt the Cleveland front office is thinking that same way. They are going to do what's best for the team, period. I've heard that Quinn wants to play in Cleveland. Romeo has the Charlie Weis connection, so I think he'll get the true facts on Quinn; which will be very positive when all is said and done. However, the biggest reason for drafting Quinn is that Charlie Frye has not done anything to prove he is the answer. You could have great players at every other position on the field, but 10 TDs and 17 Ints on the year will kill you every time. Quinn will have an impact on this team, sooner than later.
While I can understand your line of thinking, I just don't see it happening. Not if the Browns stay at #3 anyway. If they end up trading down and Quinn falls in their lap I think they pull the trigger. If they stay at #3, IMO it's either AD, Joe Thomas or one of the top DT/DE (Branch, Okoye, Adams, Anderson).Could be just GM-speak, but take a look at what Savage said a couple weeks back:

So what does Savage view as his top priorities?

"Both [offensive and defensive] lines, quite honestly, are priorities for us," he said.

In another context, he also indicated the team wants to at least explore a new running back.

When Savage was pressed repeatedly about the quarterback position, he defended Charlie Frye and backup Derek Anderson and said he would be content to bring back both to compete for the starting job.

"As I sit here today, I can pretty confidently say I'll feel OK about [the quarterbacks] because I feel we'll have done some things around them to make them more of a success," he said.

Savage said that Matt Leinart, Jay Cutler and Vince Young - quarterbacks taken in the first round in the 2006 draft - would have fared no better than Frye and Anderson, given the team's circumstances at offensive line and running back.

"I just think there are a lot of issues that go beneath whether a guy can just throw the ball or not," he said.

"That's what the offensive staff really is trying to work through right now. If it's Charlie, we can do this list of things. If it's Derek, we can do this list of things. If it's somebody else, what are those guys strengths and weaknesses?"
Granted, FA starts at Midnight, so whoever they can get will certainly impact their draft strategy.
 
I think Seattle's needs will be more focused along the lines of a big DT or a safety as there is a good chance Hamlin will be gone.

 
JimboJim said:
32. Indianapolis - Darrelle Revis, CB, Pittsburgh

The Indy defensive backfield is a mess aside from Sanders. If they can develop Marlin Jackson, these two could make their pass defense respectable. Revis was once my #1 rated CB. However, he ran slow at the combine and doesn't have the upside of Hall, Ross or Houston.

NFL Comparison - Marcus Trufant
Considering that the Colts have spent a 1st and 2 2nds on DBs in the last 2 drafts (and got their starting FS in Bethea in round 6 last year), I don't think they are going to spend another 1st on a DB this time. I see the Colts picking either an LB, DT or now a WR (because of Stokely being cut and Harrison's age) in round 1 - whoever is highest on their draft board.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ron_Mexico said:
Interesting, but no way does Jarrett go at #11.I actually think he will fall out of the first round.
Please explain; up until a couple of weeks ago, most mock drafts had him going to Minnesota at #7. He hasn't worked out yet, so poor measurables can't be it. Out of all of the top WRs in the draft, he produced the most at the college level, with two different QBs.I feel kinda like Brady Quinn was the en-vogue "falling" player a few weeks ago, it's now Jarrett. If he comes out and runs a 4.7 at his pro day, I will concede. However, nothing to this point proves anything contrary to him still being a top prospect.
From what I've seen broken down of Jarrett it's the fact that he can't handle aggressive bump coverage. He does well when given a cushion in coverage, but if he plays an aggressive corner in man/bump coverage, he doesn't have the ability to lose the defender or fight off the coverage. Factor that in with his expected pedestrian 40 time and I could see him falling. He really does sound like another Mike Williams (so far).
 
JimboJim said:
Player comparisons are for playing styles/physical skills only. I.e, If I compare Adrian Peterson to Fred Taylor, that doesn't mean I think Peterson will have injury problems...

Round I

15. Pittsburgh - Levi Brown, T, Penn State

There is a good chance that Max Starks leaves in free-agency, even if he doesn't he might not be the answer at tackle. Pittsburgh gave up 49 sacks last season. That certainly didn't help Big Ben get back on track much. The defense actually finished quite well against the run and doesn't appear to be losing any starters up front this off-season. An upgrade at S would help, but there aren't any at this point that provide the value that Levi Brown does. He's a big strong OT that fits the Pittsburgh mold.

NFL Comparison - Jaamal Brown
Max Starks is a RFA, therefore its going to cost a team some draft picks if they want to swoop him up. Realistically, I believe that the Steelers will look more to the way of a 4-3 DE that they can use as an OLB in certain situations in the 3-4. In any case, if he is there, this could also be an option to either supplant Starks or just add great depth to the position. Good read :wub: .
 
JimboJim said:
3. Cleveland - Brady Quinn, QB, Notre Dame

Many people are saying that the Browns need to draft a player that will have an immediate impact on the team so Romeo Crenel doesn't lose his job. Big news people, I really doubt the Cleveland front office is thinking that same way. They are going to do what's best for the team, period. I've heard that Quinn wants to play in Cleveland. Romeo has the Charlie Weis connection, so I think he'll get the true facts on Quinn; which will be very positive when all is said and done. However, the biggest reason for drafting Quinn is that Charlie Frye has not done anything to prove he is the answer. You could have great players at every other position on the field, but 10 TDs and 17 Ints on the year will kill you every time. Quinn will have an impact on this team, sooner than later.
While I can understand your line of thinking, I just don't see it happening. Not if the Browns stay at #3 anyway. If they end up trading down and Quinn falls in their lap I think they pull the trigger. If they stay at #3, IMO it's either AD, Joe Thomas or one of the top DT/DE (Branch, Okoye, Adams, Anderson).Could be just GM-speak, but take a look at what Savage said a couple weeks back:

So what does Savage view as his top priorities?

"Both [offensive and defensive] lines, quite honestly, are priorities for us," he said.

In another context, he also indicated the team wants to at least explore a new running back.

When Savage was pressed repeatedly about the quarterback position, he defended Charlie Frye and backup Derek Anderson and said he would be content to bring back both to compete for the starting job.

"As I sit here today, I can pretty confidently say I'll feel OK about [the quarterbacks] because I feel we'll have done some things around them to make them more of a success," he said.

Savage said that Matt Leinart, Jay Cutler and Vince Young - quarterbacks taken in the first round in the 2006 draft - would have fared no better than Frye and Anderson, given the team's circumstances at offensive line and running back.

"I just think there are a lot of issues that go beneath whether a guy can just throw the ball or not," he said.

"That's what the offensive staff really is trying to work through right now. If it's Charlie, we can do this list of things. If it's Derek, we can do this list of things. If it's somebody else, what are those guys strengths and weaknesses?"
Granted, FA starts at Midnight, so whoever they can get will certainly impact their draft strategy.
It's tough to argue with an article like that. For my own sake, I'll call in a smoke-screen.If the draft were to play out such that only Russell and Thomas were gone, I personally think the Browns would be foolish to pass on Quinn for I can only assume Branch, Peterson or Anderson.

Out of those three, I beleive Anderson would be the best choice. Branch is an excellent super-athletic DT, but doesn't a 3-4 scheme only require a space-eater like a Ted Washington or Jamal Williams. Not to say that's not important, but I would think one of those players could be had as a free-agent or later in the draft. Same with RB. I just don't see an upgrade at RB getting the Browns anywhere. You can always plug in a banger to get a few yards here and there; it's not like their O-line is going to carry them to the playoffs anyways.

We've seen what a good QB upgrade can do for a team (Bledsoe to Romo...) It just seems to me like the choice of Brady Quinn would give this team the best short and long term value.

My opinion only... I'm probably wrong though.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
JimboJim said:
Player comparisons are for playing styles/physical skills only. I.e, If I compare Adrian Peterson to Fred Taylor, that doesn't mean I think Peterson will have injury problems...

Round I

15. Pittsburgh - Levi Brown, T, Penn State

There is a good chance that Max Starks leaves in free-agency, even if he doesn't he might not be the answer at tackle. Pittsburgh gave up 49 sacks last season. That certainly didn't help Big Ben get back on track much. The defense actually finished quite well against the run and doesn't appear to be losing any starters up front this off-season. An upgrade at S would help, but there aren't any at this point that provide the value that Levi Brown does. He's a big strong OT that fits the Pittsburgh mold.

NFL Comparison - Jaamal Brown
Max Starks is a RFA, therefore its going to cost a team some draft picks if they want to swoop him up. Realistically, I believe that the Steelers will look more to the way of a 4-3 DE that they can use as an OLB in certain situations in the 3-4. In any case, if he is there, this could also be an option to either supplant Starks or just add great depth to the position. Good read :nerd: .
There is no way in Hades that a)Levi Brown goes past the Panthers and b)makes it out of the top 10.the dude is sick and nasty and teams realize that and are playing possum on him (ie not talking about him)

 
JimboJim said:
32. Indianapolis - Darrelle Revis, CB, Pittsburgh

The Indy defensive backfield is a mess aside from Sanders. If they can develop Marlin Jackson, these two could make their pass defense respectable. Revis was once my #1 rated CB. However, he ran slow at the combine and doesn't have the upside of Hall, Ross or Houston.

NFL Comparison - Marcus Trufant
Considering that the Colts have spent a 1st and 2 2nds on DBs in the last 2 drafts (and got their starting FS in Bethea in round 6 last year), I don't think they are going to spend another 1st on a DB this time. I see the Colts picking either an LB, DT or now a WR (because of Stokely being cut and Harrison's age) in round 1 - whoever is highest on their draft board.
The Cowboys have spent a lot of high round picks on offensive lineman over the last few years; doesn't mean they won't draft one this season considering they still have problems.Even if Bethea and Sanders are set at safety, who will man the two corner spots? Is Nick Harper signed through next year? Does Indy beleive that Jackson is the answer? Any homer info would be appreciated.

 
Nice pick for the Redskins. We need a pass rushing DE and a run stuffing DT but to me, Adams and Branch are the extremes of both. I think Anderson is nice middle ground. I don't think Skins fan would complain about getting any of these 3 though.

 
JimboJim said:
32. Indianapolis - Darrelle Revis, CB, Pittsburgh

The Indy defensive backfield is a mess aside from Sanders. If they can develop Marlin Jackson, these two could make their pass defense respectable. Revis was once my #1 rated CB. However, he ran slow at the combine and doesn't have the upside of Hall, Ross or Houston.

NFL Comparison - Marcus Trufant
Considering that the Colts have spent a 1st and 2 2nds on DBs in the last 2 drafts (and got their starting FS in Bethea in round 6 last year), I don't think they are going to spend another 1st on a DB this time. I see the Colts picking either an LB, DT or now a WR (because of Stokely being cut and Harrison's age) in round 1 - whoever is highest on their draft board.
The Cowboys have spent a lot of high round picks on offensive lineman over the last few years; doesn't mean they won't draft one this season considering they still have problems.Even if Bethea and Sanders are set at safety, who will man the two corner spots? Is Nick Harper signed through next year? Does Indy beleive that Jackson is the answer? Any homer info would be appreciated.
I expect them to tender Jason David for one year and have Jackson and Kelvin Hayden compete for the other CB spot. Harper's going elsewhere.LB is a much bigger problem than CB for the Colts. Cato June will go elsewhere. If they lose June AND Rob Morris it will get ugly at LB with only Gary Brackett (not exactly a great LB) as their only returning starting LB.

 
Good stuff. I think you are pretty close on most of your picks, I disagree with a number of your NFL comparisons but overall I think this is a well put together mock.

One small note - Norv Turner is no longer the OC for the 49ers. If he has any flashbacks he'll need to have them in SD.

 
JimboJim said:
2. Detroit - Joe Thomas, OT, Wisconsin

NFL Comparison - Orlando Pace
Anybody that compares Joe Thomas to Orlando Pace has clearly never watched a Badger game truly studying Joe Thomas. Thomas isn't a mauler like Pace was at OSU. I RARELY saw Thomas dominate anyone.

Joe Thomas is a tactician who understands leverage and uses his athetic ability to seal the defender in the run game ... not MAUL them like Pace did.

NFL Draft Scout compares Thomas to Jordan Gross ... I'd probably compare him to a Chad Clifton (with more athletic ability).

 
JimboJim said:
Player comparisons are for playing styles/physical skills only. I.e, If I compare Adrian Peterson to Fred Taylor, that doesn't mean I think Peterson will have injury problems...

Round I

1. Oakland - JaMarcus Russell, QB, LSU

Golden rule of the draft is never pass on a possible franchise QB unless you already have one; the Raiders don't. I chose Russell over Quinn based on his athletic upside and the leadership/maturity he displayed throughout last season. Russell may not be as polished as Quinn, but he seems to possess more of a "field-general" quality, as evidenced in the bowl game against Notre Dame. I believe the only question with Russell is whether or not he will stay focused, as he showed up a little soft and out of shape at the combine. That never really seemed to hinder Daunte Culpepper too much.

NFL Comparison - Daunte Culpepper

2. Detroit - Joe Thomas, OT, Wisconsin

As of my first two mock drafts, I had Quinn going in this spot. If I was picking for the Lions, he would be my choice. Quinn is a franchise caliber QB, who I believe is getting a bad rap because of his bowl game performance. However, I'm not making the pick, and everything I've read and heard is that the Lions are heavily leaning towards drafting Joe Thomas. I have no doubt that Thomas could turn out to be an excellent pro, but I feel that if a team doesn't have a franchise QB and has the opportunity to draft one, they must. Enough of that though, Thomas is one of the highest rated offensive linemen to come out since Robert Gallery. His impressive showing at the combine (sub-5.00 40) cemented his status as a top-5 pick.

NFL Comparison - Orlando Pace

3. Cleveland - Brady Quinn, QB, Notre Dame

Many people are saying that the Browns need to draft a player that will have an immediate impact on the team so Romeo Crenel doesn't lose his job. Big news people, I really doubt the Cleveland front office is thinking that same way. They are going to do what's best for the team, period. I've heard that Quinn wants to play in Cleveland. Romeo has the Charlie Weis connection, so I think he'll get the true facts on Quinn; which will be very positive when all is said and done. However, the biggest reason for drafting Quinn is that Charlie Frye has not done anything to prove he is the answer. You could have great players at every other position on the field, but 10 TDs and 17 Ints on the year will kill you every time. Quinn will have an impact on this team, sooner than later.

NFL Comparison - Carson Palmer

4. Tampa Bay - Calvin Johnson, WR, Georgia Tech

I don't think there's any question Tampa would take Johnson if he were here. He fills a need at a position where Galloway is getting older and Clayton has underachieved and fought through injuries. Johnson appears to be the closest thing to a lock at WR in the draft since Larry Fitzgerald a few years ago. His performance at the combine was all-world. I would have loved to have put him in Oakland, Detroit or Cleveland, but both Oakland and Cleveland need QBs bad and getting Johnson wouldn't have the impact either Quinn or Russell would. CJ in Detroit would really make sense, but that team needs to build from the trenches out. Another skill player ain't going to right that ship.

NFL Comparison - Terrell Owens

5. Arizona - LaRon Landry, S, LSU

The Arizona Cardinals had a decent number of sacks last season (38) and finished with strong numbers against the run. Their biggest weakness was giving up the big play in the passing game. Bertrand Berry and Chike Okeafer aren't the best DEs in the league, but they're not the worst either. Drafting Jamaal Anderson or Gaines Adams would certainly upgrade their line, but it wouldn't solve this teams major problem, especially if Robert Griffith retires. LaRon Landry is a tall lean FS prospect who could team with Adrian Wilson to form the best safety combo in the league. Additionally, Landry's presence would go a long way towards taking pressure off the young Antrel Rolle and whoever mans the other corner spot. Some will say this is too high for Landry; NFL teams don't think that way. He won't be there when they pick in the second and I don't project trades.

NFL Comparison - Ed Reed

6. Washington - Jaamal Anderson, DE, Arkansas

I see Anderson as being a prospect similar to Richard Seymour; both are large DEs with excellent pass rush skills. This would fill the need of both a pass-rushing and run-stopping lineman for the Redskins. Branch and Adams are both considerations, but in the end, I feel Anderson is the best D-lineman on the board.

NFL Comparison - Richard Seymour

7. Minnesota Vikings - Adrian Peterson, RB, Oklahoma

BPA by far. Hear me out; we all want to pick players for teams based on what we think are needs. We look at the Vikings and say they have no good WRs, they need a QB… If I was the coach of the Vikings and knew I would be heading into the season with either Tavarius Jackson or a lesser tier free agent QB, I would want to lean on my running game as much as possible. Chester Taylor ended up with 1216 total yards last season, but look at his game logs. He had 7 out of 15 games where he averaged 3.5 yards or less a carry. Somewhat deceiving numbers. AD is a big time power runner that would absolutely crush people running behind McKinnie and Hutch and take a lot of pressure off whoever the passer is.

NFL Comparison - Fred Taylor

8. Houston - Marshawn Lynch, RB, Cal

The Texans need a playmaker other than AJ and I don't believe they can plan on having a healthy Davis/Williams/Whatever back. Lynch is a compact, shake-and-bake runner with speed, vision, toughness and durability. He can also catch the ball, something important in the Texans offense. The Texans have never had much of a problem racking up yards in the running game; put a premier prospect like Lynch back there and I believe this entire offense gets a significant boost.

NFL Comparison - Ladainian Tomlinson

9. Miami - Allen Branch, DT, Michigan

The Dolphins couldn't be happier; biggest need meets one of the top 2-3 BPAs.

NFL Comparison - Kevin Williams

10. Atlanta - Gaines Adams, DE, Clemson

Patrick Kearney may be gone, but even if he isn't, Adams still fills a need. A healthy D-line isn't something the Falcons have had in a number of years. Adams should team with Abraham to form a tenacious outside pass rush. This will ease up pressure on the secondary.

NFL Comparison - John Abraham

11. San Fran - Dwayne Jarrett, WR, USC

I absolutely love Jarrett and think all of the Mike Williams/Keyshawn Johnson comparisons are ridiculous. In my opinion, he's somewhat similar athletically to Plaxico Burress; the main difference is Jarrett doesn't have the attitude. Tall, great body control and a leaper. He needs to work on his drops and play a little more physical, but his college production cannot be overlooked. 216 catches for 3138 yards and 41 TDs; Jarrett is a player. With Alex Smith, Frank Gore and Jarrett to play with, my guess is Norv Turner will be having Troy/Emmitt/Irvin flashbacks.

NFL Comparison - Plaxico Burress

12. Buffalo - Amobi Okoye, DT, Louisville

Stopping the run has been a problem ever since Pat Williams left. Okoye is a little undersized, but because of his age, I believe he has room to grow.

NFL Comparison - LaRoi Glover

13. St. Loius - Patrick Willis, LB, Ole Miss

It seems like the Rams have been looking for a playmaking LB for years now. They need a defensive leader and someone that stuff the run and cover RBs and TEs out of the backfield. Willis appears to be the best in a fairly mediocre LB crop.

NFL Comparison - Keith Bulluck

14. Carolina - Reggie Nelson, S, Florida

Reggie Nelson will be the eventual starter once Minter moves on; he has the ball hawk skills they need at safety

NFL Comparison - Jermaine Phillips

15. Pittsburgh - Levi Brown, T, Penn State

There is a good chance that Max Starks leaves in free-agency, even if he doesn't he might not be the answer at tackle. Pittsburgh gave up 49 sacks last season. That certainly didn't help Big Ben get back on track much. The defense actually finished quite well against the run and doesn't appear to be losing any starters up front this off-season. An upgrade at S would help, but there aren't any at this point that provide the value that Levi Brown does. He's a big strong OT that fits the Pittsburgh mold.

NFL Comparison - Jaamal Brown

16. Green Bay - Leon Hall, CB, Michigan

Both the top RBs are gone, and while Ginn would be tempting, WR isn't that big of a concern. Driver is top-notch, Jennings played well as a rookie, and they can sign a free-agent to be the #3. Plus, Koren Robinson might be back. There is no depth after Harris and Woodson at CB.

NFL Comparison - Chris McAllister

17. Jacksonville - Ted Ginn, WR, Ohio State

BPA. This team has no explosive players on offense aside from Jones-Drew. Finally, a WR that can stretch the field.

NFL Comparison - Donte Stallworth

18. Cincinatti - Adam Carriker, DE, Nebraska

Carriker is a big 6-6, 300 lb D-lineman who could either rush the passer from inside or fill in at DE. Carriker saw his stock jump significantly at the Senior Bowl. The Bengals could go a lot of ways on D with this pick, but at the end of the day, Carriker is probably the BPA who fits a need.

NFL Comparison - Aaron Smith

19. Tennessee - Chris Houston, CB, Arkansas

I believe the Titans top needs are WR, CB and OT. With Brown, Jarrett and Ginn off the board, I feel the pick here is the best available CB. That would be Chris Houston IMO; Houston put on an impressive show at the combine bench pressing 225 only one time less than Joe Thomas. He's a strong, smart CB who would be a good complement to Adam Jones in the defensive backfield.

NFL Comparison - Nate Clements

20. NY Giants - Paul Posluzny, LB, Penn State

Puz would immediately help out a LB core that missed a ton of time due to injuries over the last couple of years. With the loses of Carlos Emmons and Arrington, LB is a big-time need for the G-men. Puz may not have the measurables of a Patrick Willis, but neither did Zach Thomas.

NFL Comparison - Al Wilson

21. Denver - Charles Johnson, DE, Georgia

Some additional help for the Denver front four. A DT would be the best option, but with Okoye and Branch gone, there are none worth taking here. Although they tragically lost Darrent Williams, don't expect them to draft another CB; D-line is a greater need and Johnson is a playmaker.

NFL Comparison - Bryan Thomas

22 Dallas - Aaron Ross, CB, Texas

With Wade Phillips coming to town and the Cowboys staying in the 3-4, shoring up that secondary will be task #1. Anthony Henry will be moved to FS and while Aaron Glenn is a good nickel CB, he's not a starter anymore. Ross burst on to the scene in 2006 winning the Jim Thorpe award. He has good size at 6-1, 190 lbs, but is still raw in terms of technique. I think the move to a faster, more dynamic corner to pair with Newman is the right one.

NFL Comparison - Terrance Newman

23. Kansas City - Dwayne Bowe , WR, LSU

The Chiefs take a shot at finally getting a true #1 WR with a guy that has been rising as of late. I'm not sold on Bowe personally. He drops too many balls and doesn't run great routes, but overall, he has the best overall skill set of any WR left on the board.

NFL Comparison - Eric Moulds

24. New England - Michael Griffin, S, Texas

The Pats luck out again. Griffin will be a good replacement for Rodney Harrison; I actually like him much better than Nelson.

NFL Comparison - Chris Hope

25. NY Jets - Jarvis Moss, DE, Florida

Moss is an imposing DE who can at the very least share reps with Ellis and Thomas and keep the D-line fresh. His Jr. and Sr. seasons, he combined for 20 tackles for loss and 15 sacks. Looking up and down this roster, the Jets are fairly solid across the board.

NFL Comparison - Kalimba Edwards

26. Philadelphia - Brandon Merriweather, S, Miami

Brian Dawkins is getting old and the other safety spot was a mess last season. Merriweather's big Senior Bowl week moved him into round one and he might even jump Griffin and/or Nelson (probably not). This pick would fill a need while still taking one of the BPAs.

NFL Comparison - Keith Lewis

27. New Orleans - Greg Olsen, TE, Miami

A CB would be the ideal selection for New Orleans, but with the top three off the board and the depth at the position, New Orleans can wait until later in the draft. Greg Olsen clearly established himself as the top tight end with his combine showing and would round out this potent New Orleans offense.

NFL Comparison - Todd Heap

28. New England - Robert Meachem, WR, Tennessee

Reche Caldwell came on at the end of last year, but other than him, the Pats didn't have a single consistent WR all season. Chad Jackson has great potential, but is still a developmental type player and coming off of an injury. Meachem would give New England another weapon to distribute the ball to; an excellent replacement for Deion Branch.

NFL Comparison - Javon Walker

29. Baltimore - Lawerence Timmons, LB, Florida State

Baltimore really doesn't have a lot of holes. The interior offensive line could be upgraded, but with Adalius Thomas leaving town, Timmons just seems like the perfect fit.

NFL Comparison - Warrick Holdman

30. San Diego - Justin Blalock, OG, Texas

Blalock would probably be an upgrade at either guard position. He could also fill in at tackle if need-be. I would have loved to put Sidney Rice here, but I don't think the Chargers are looking for another WR that will take a few years to develop. Additionally, Rice actually somewhat reminds me of Vincent Jackson; he is a tall leaper that doesn't have great outside speed or do a ton after the catch. Meachem or Ginn is the type of stretch-the-field WR the Chargers need and they are both gone.

NFL Comparison - Ruben Brown

31. Chicago - Jon Beason, LB, Miami

Beason is a little fireball that would fit this attacking defensive scheme perfectly. Beason would be an upgrade over Hunter Hillenmeyer, who was often the focal point of opposing offenses attack plans.

NFL Comparison - London Fletcher

32. Indianapolis - Darrelle Revis, CB, Pittsburgh

The Indy defensive backfield is a mess aside from Sanders. If they can develop Marlin Jackson, these two could make their pass defense respectable. Revis was once my #1 rated CB. However, he ran slow at the combine and doesn't have the upside of Hall, Ross or Houston.

NFL Comparison - Marcus Trufant

Round II

33. Oakland - Aaron Sears, OT, Tennessee

34. Detroit - Marcus McCauley, CB, Fresno State

35. Tampa Bay - Ryan Kalil, C, USC

36. Cleveland - Tank Tyler, DT, NC State

37. NY Jets - Brain Leonard, RB, Rutgers

38. Arizona - Tony Ugoh, OT, Arkansas

39. Houston - Ben Grubbs, OG, Auburn

40. Miami - Sidney Rice, WR, South Carolina

41. Minnesota - Joe Staley, OT, Central Michigan

42. San Fran - Justin Harrell, DT, Tennessee

43. Buffalo - Justin Hill, WR, Washington State

44. Atlanta - Eric Weddle, S, Utah

45. Carolina - Drew Stanton, QB, Michigan State

46. Pittsburgh - Stewart Bradley, LB, Nebraska

47. Green Bay - Kenny Irons, RB, Auburn

48. Jacksonville - Anthony Spencer, DE, Purdue

49. Cincinatti - Josh Wilson, CB, Maryland

50. Tennessee - Craig Davis, WR, LSU

51. NY Giants - Tony Hunt, RB, Penn State

52. St. Louis - Anthony Gonzalez, WR, Ohio State

53. Dallas - Buster Davis, LB, Florida State

54. Kansas City - Josh Beekman, OG, Boston College

55. Seattle - Fred Bennett, CB, South Carolina

56. Denver - Quinn Pitcock, DT, Ohio State

57. Philadelphia - Michael Bush, RB, Louisville

58. New Orleans - Brandon Siler, LB, Florida State

59. NY Jets - Manuel Ramirez, OG, Texas Tech

60. New England - Victor Abiamiri, DE, Notre Dame

61. Baltimore - Tim Crowder, DE, Texas

62. San Diego - HB Blades, LB, Pittsburgh

63. Chicago - Ben Patrick, TE, Deleware

64. Tampa Bay - LaMarr Woodley, DE, Michigan

Fire away... :banned:
Pretty good effort! ;) Now for some (hopefully constructive) critisism. :no: Not crazy about your picks for either the NYJ or NYG. First, the Jets. You said Moss could be nice in a rotation with B Thomas and Ellis. One is an OLB in the 3-4, the other is a DE in the same 3-4. Moss isn't very well suited for either position. He's a bit slow for an OLB, and a bit small for a 3-4 DE. If the Jets go for a DE, and Carricker is off the board, I see them taking Mebane with the 2.5. If the Jets go with an RB at 2.5, I don't think it will be Leonard... Hunt maybe. Timmons as an OLB would make more sense for the Jets at 1.25 I think. I love the Ramirez pick at 2.25.

If the Giants take Posluzny, do they move Pierce to WLB? I can't see Pos playing anywhere but MLB or ILB in a 3-4. If the G men go LB instead of CB, I think they will look for a replacement for Arrington at WLB, and that rules out Pos. Hunt to the G men makes little sense, given they already have a big bruising RB in Jacobs. I could see Booker in the second, if Irons is off the board. Or even Leonard if he's there, but Hunt makes little sense to me. They should be looking for some speed at RB, and a guy who can make for a safety outlet for Manning as a reciever.

To be honest, I think you missed the whole target on these two teams, but overall, I like the mock.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top