I like to play one Yahoo autodraft a year just to help take the emotion or more accurately, the heartstrings out of the equation. Following a hybrid of the various threads linked to Doug's initial posting including Todd Conrad's great 2005 article linked by Pasquino I set up my pre-draft for a ten team as follows:
1) Top 50 - VBD
2) Player #51 begins all RBs not in my top 50 VBD up to 40 total RBs ranked
3) After 40 TOTAL RBs ranked begin ranking ALL WRs not in VBD 50 up to 50 TOTAL WRs ranked
4) After 50 TOTAL WRs ranked begin ranking ALL QBs not in VDB 50 up to 20 TOTAL QBs ranked - Move all remaining QBs to EXCLUDE list.
5) After 20 TOTAL QBs ranked and all remaining QBs are excluded, rank up to TEN total TEs including those in your VBD 50. Move all remaining TEs to EXCLUDE list.
6) After 10 TOTAL TEs ranked and all remaining TEs are excluded, rank your top 10 TOTAL PKs and EXCLUDE all remaining PKs.
7) After 10 TOTAL PKs ranked and all remaining PKs are excluded, rank your top 10 TOTAL Team DEF/ST and EXCLUDE all remaining Team DEF/STs.
Don't overlook the value and/or the extra work invloved in that Exclude function; that seems to be a key to a successful draft. In addition to removing frivolous players from your draft eligibility pool, use it to remove guys you simply don't want to deal with this season. I moved anyone on my personal fringe list to Exclude as well. I.E. I don't want to deal with the Kevin Jones-Tatum Bell situation - GONE; I'm not keen on the Portis-Betts thing - GONE; Fred Taylor in a ten team autodraft? No thanks - GONE. I don't care about CLE QBs - GONE...you get my drift.
I set my status to Ready and in about 36 hours returned the following roster:
QBs: Roethlisberger, Delhomme
RBs: LT2, McGahee, Norwood
WRs: Owens, L. Evans, J. Walk, S. Holmes, Horn
TEs: V. Davis, D. Graham
PKs: Elam, Kasay
DEF: Denver
That's about as good a team as one can hope to yoke out of a Yahoo autodraft in my opinion. Certainly one of the better ones I've seen. I got my top to upper ranked players at most positions except QB which I pushed down my list to begin with as I personally like Ben to have a nice season, and with these other skill players I don't need a dominant QB. There is tons of talent left in free agency which I can pound when waivers clear and dump Graham, Horny and Kasay to add a little depth.
Notice too that I did not get pinned with a spare DEF, which the autodraft algorithm is supposed to select. By excluding those DEF/STs outside of my top-10, I gave the algorithm no option but to skip over the 2nd Team DEF/ST. I got burned by the algorithm at PK because I selected a PK (likely Kasay) in my top-10 that was not drafted in the top-10 players (min) at the position. I might suggest only ranking 5-7 PKs and obvious ones at that and excluding even more.
All in all, a very solid draft and again, the best I've managed in this format.
U