What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dynasty RB rankings (1 Viewer)

Bracie Smathers

Bracie Smathers

Footballguy
Dynasty, no PPR. Broken down in 12 player increments so owners can see where their players stack up in a twelve player league. RB has shorter time frame to make impact so the balancing act is of weighing elder players VS. long term upside of yute. Included some rookies due to the fact that some older RBs will be replaced. Really difficult to rank prior to draft when including rookies so take this with a huge grain of salt.

* denotes rookie

1. Adrian Peterson (MIN)

2. LaDainian Tomlinson

3. Steven Jackson

4. Willie Parker

5. Joseph Addai

6. Ryan Grant

7. Brian Westbrook

8. Marshawn Lynch

9. Larry Johnson

10. Frank Gore

11. Ronnie Brown

12. Marion Barber

I see LJ coming back with a vengeance and that Ryan Grant is the real deal and still think Ronnie Brown is a talent.

13. Laurence Maroney

14. Willis McGahee

15. Maurice Jones-Drew

16. Darren McFadden*

17. Clinton Portis

18. Selvyn Young

19. LenDale White

20. Reggie Bush

21. Michael Turner

22. Jamal Lewis

23. Rudi Johnson

24. DeAngelo Williams

McFadden should rank this high if he pans out and I think he will. Selyn Young's ranking should be controversial but I think he replaces Travis and produces numbers in the top 20. I like DeAngelo and think he takes over.

25. Thomas Jones

26. Kevin Jones

27. Rashad Mendenhall*

28. Cedric Benson

29. Edgerrin James

30. Brandon Jacobs

31. Earnest Graham

32. Chester Taylor

33. Jerious Norwood

34. Michael Bush

35. Jonathan Stewart*

36. Ladell Betts

Assuming the second rookie RB lands in the right situation they should put up top 30 production and I have Medenhall going second off the draft board but whichever rookie ends up in a decent place to start should rank right around 30 then assuming the third RB drafted can make an impact they would rank right around 40. I wanted to drink the Ahmad Bradshaw Cool Aide but I had to put Jacobs ahead of him. This was the most difficult portion of the rankings and since it effects the rest so much I'm sure it will be the most controversial.

37. Fred Taylor

38. Kevin Smith*

39. Ahmad Bradshaw

40. Deuce McAllister

41. Travis Henry

42. Leon Washington

43. Felix Jones*

44. Ahman Green

45. Justin Fargas

46. Kenny Watson

47. Chris Brown

48. DeShaun Foster

Had to find places for the vets who will more than likely produce better than most of the yute but soon I see Taylor and McAllister and others dropping out. I would imagine some of the latter rookie RBs get their shot and at least one makes a splash. Other rookies who don't end up starting are ranked for their position over time.

These players just missed as you can see I have SA falling down the rabbit hole and Maurice Morris also out of the top 50 meaning that I believe one of the rookies is taken by the Hawks and wins the starting gig.

Ray Rice*

Kenny Irons

Adrian Peterson (CHI)

Kolby Smith

LaMont Jordan

Jesse Chapman

Kenton Kieth

Sammy Morris

Chris Henry

Brandon Jackson

Chris Perry

Julius Jones

T-Bell

Reuben Droughns

Maurice Morris

Shaun Alexander

Mewelde Moore

Derrick Ward

Lorenzo Booker

Carnell Williams

 
Looking at the top tier, I personally am really down on Parker. The new offensive scheme just does not create many TD opportunities for the guy. With what I see as a low potential TD output and the injury I would not draft him as my RB#1.

 
At least get the spellings of the names correctly. It's SELVIN Young, not Selvyn or Selyn. It makes it look like you don't know what you are talking about.

 
Mr. Peterson said:
You have K.Smith of F.Jones?
Click to expand...
I do but I don't think anyone knows where or when they will go which also explains why I have the rooks, other than McFadden, ranked lower. To another reply, yeah, I have bought into Ryan Grant and think the Pack has as well since they offered him a long term contract.
 
Better than most of the lists I've seen.

Others are overvaluing back-up players (with no hope of ever starting) over starters and such.

Rookies are a tad low, but reasonable.

 
I applaud you for not overvaluing the rookies, but I agree that Willie Parker is way too high. Also, Portis is too low. I would have a hard time taking Parker over Portis at this point, especially in a non-PPR league. Portis is a year younger, in a better situation to score TDs, and has history on his side. I think both of those guys belong in the 7-15 range.

Good job on the rankings overall. :)

 
flat_earth said:
I applaud you for not overvaluing the rookies, but I agree that Willie Parker is way too high. Also, Portis is too low. I would have a hard time taking Parker over Portis at this point, especially in a non-PPR league. Portis is a year younger, in a better situation to score TDs, and has history on his side. I think both of those guys belong in the 7-15 range.

Good job on the rankings overall. :goodposting:
Click to expand...
C'mon, he's got ADP #1, Ryan Grant #6, Marshawn Lynch #8....weren't all these guys rookies in 2007? Depending on how you look at the 2008 situation there are about 8-14 RB & RBBC positions open. I'm gonna grab 2008 rookie RBs like halloween candy. The problem is we don't know the situation these guys will be drafted into, so its hard to value them right now, but they are too low.
 
Nice list and thanks to you and EBF for putting some rankings out there for us to chew on.

The Giants running game is too good to have Jacobs and Bradshaw so low imo. At least one of them will be a top 20 RB and possibly both of them.

I would like to hear more about your perspective on FWP. I like the ranking although I don't have the same confidence about him as you do, I do think that people are incorrect in most of their criticism of him. Curious what you see ahead for Fast Willie that causes you to rank him 4th?

 
Brewzers said:
flat_earth said:
I applaud you for not overvaluing the rookies, but I agree that Willie Parker is way too high. Also, Portis is too low. I would have a hard time taking Parker over Portis at this point, especially in a non-PPR league. Portis is a year younger, in a better situation to score TDs, and has history on his side. I think both of those guys belong in the 7-15 range.

Good job on the rankings overall. :shrug:
Click to expand...
C'mon, he's got ADP #1, Ryan Grant #6, Marshawn Lynch #8....weren't all these guys rookies in 2007? Depending on how you look at the 2008 situation there are about 8-14 RB & RBBC positions open. I'm gonna grab 2008 rookie RBs like halloween candy. The problem is we don't know the situation these guys will be drafted into, so its hard to value them right now, but they are too low.
Click to expand...
You really don't see a difference between complete unknowns and guys who performed at a high level as rookies?I wouldn't bump McFadden up at all, but Stewart and Mendenhall are too low. Top 24 IMO.

 
jonboltz said:
At least get the spellings of the names correctly. It's SELVIN Young, not Selvyn or Selyn. It makes it look like you don't know what you are talking about.
Click to expand...
In his defense, that's the only ranking I completely disagree with. (I think Grant's high and BW low, but it's understandable)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Brewzers said:
flat_earth said:
I applaud you for not overvaluing the rookies, but I agree that Willie Parker is way too high. Also, Portis is too low. I would have a hard time taking Parker over Portis at this point, especially in a non-PPR league. Portis is a year younger, in a better situation to score TDs, and has history on his side. I think both of those guys belong in the 7-15 range.

Good job on the rankings overall. :rolleyes:
Click to expand...
C'mon, he's got ADP #1, Ryan Grant #6, Marshawn Lynch #8....weren't all these guys rookies in 2007? Depending on how you look at the 2008 situation there are about 8-14 RB & RBBC positions open. I'm gonna grab 2008 rookie RBs like halloween candy. The problem is we don't know the situation these guys will be drafted into, so its hard to value them right now, but they are too low.
Click to expand...
True yet if you look at recent top drafted RBs you'll see mixed results.Last year the top two RBs were special and off the board by the top dozen picks but, Chris Henry, Brandon Jackson, Lorenzo Booker, didn't do anything. Brian Leonard is back behind S-Jax. 2006 was a sensational year for RBs yet Reggie Bush hasn't and more likely never will live up to the hype, DeAngelo Williams still hasn't made his mark, and Maroney only recently began to live up to his draft position. Those were the top three RBs of that draft. Addai and MJD were the big hits from that RB to date. 05's top RBs, Ronnie Brown, Ced Benson, Cadillac Williams, and J.J. Arrington have yet to make a splash equal to having three taken in the top five picks of that draft. 04's first RB was S-Jax taken at 24 but Chris Perry has been a bust and then Kevin Jones and T-Bell have had mixed results to say the least.

The hit/miss rookie RB tune keeps playing down thru the draft ages so doing a dynasty RB ranking this early even before any rookies have gone thru Indy let alone have been drafted or gone thru camp or preseason is an excercise. Including rookies was done because some vets will fall yet I can't possibly position rookies higher when I know they won't all hit. Even if they do hit look at the difficulties that some RBs have had to stardom. Larry Johnson took years before he blew up. Many wrote him off and said he was a bust. Willis McGahee was gimped and took years to hit. Jamal Lewis has gone thru the ringer of blowing out a knee and an ankle to being incacerated and reclaimed from the scrap heap. Adrian Peterson had to overcome a vet, blew up to set the all-time single game record then over the last four games of 07 defenses stone walled him holding him to 121 yards in 54 carries over the last four games. Point of noting AP is that the RB widely considered the best can be stopped because he doesn't have a QB. Put in AP's situation with the others and the point is refined to stating the significance of the situations that these rookies end up in will play a large role in their abilty to produce.

That is why I can't rank any of them higher at this time. I guess that is why I stated to take the rookie rankings with a large dose of salt from the very first post.

 
Fantasy Football is about producing numbers/pts. Based on what Ryan Grant did this year, ranking him at #6 is certainly justifiable. It doesn't matter to me that he came out of nowhere to do so. Bottom line is, he got an opportunity and made the most of it. Addai had great rookie year in 2006, and was ranked in the top by most publications heading into 2007. So why shouldn't Grant heading into next season?

Let's put his numbers in perspective (I have posted this before)

Grant

215 carries for 1157 yards (5.3 YPC) 11 TDs. 30 Rec for 147 (Includes playoffs) Started 8 games including playoffs

Addai

280 carries for 1115 yards (3.9 YPC) 12 TDs. 50 rec for 431 (Includes playoffs) 3 Tds - Started 16 games including playoffs

Numbers don't lie

My $0.02

 
Ballsy call in Grant. I think he's a fluke, but the 200 yard game certainly got my attention.

Jonathan Stewart is WAYYYY too low. If I were drafting today I would consider him in the RB10-15 range. He's comparable in value to guys like Lynch, McGahee, and Portis.

Mendenhall is also too low. I'd take him over Grant, Young, White, Rudi, Lewis, Parker, TJ, and maybe KJ. I have White, Lewis, and TJ in some of my leagues. I'd be ecstatic if I could get the 1.03 rookie pick for one of those backs.

 
Bracie Smathers said:
Mr. Peterson said:
You have K.Smith of F.Jones?
Click to expand...
I do but I don't think anyone knows where or when they will go which also explains why I have the rooks, other than McFadden, ranked lower. To another reply, yeah, I have bought into Ryan Grant and think the Pack has as well since they offered him a long term contract.
Click to expand...
When did the Packers offer Grant a long-term deal? I've seen nothing on this - other than speculation by a local writer that the Packers might (maybe, someday, eventually) consider an extension for Grant.
 
Michael J Fox said:
Bracie Smathers said:
Mr. Peterson said:
You have K.Smith of F.Jones?
Click to expand...
I do but I don't think anyone knows where or when they will go which also explains why I have the rooks, other than McFadden, ranked lower. To another reply, yeah, I have bought into Ryan Grant and think the Pack has as well since they offered him a long term contract.
Click to expand...
When did the Packers offer Grant a long-term deal? I've seen nothing on this - other than speculation by a local writer that the Packers might (maybe, someday, eventually) consider an extension for Grant.
Click to expand...
Since Grant was a rookie in 2007, he is under contract for two more years. You are right that nothing is settled for a long term deal, but it would be in both side's best interest to get something worked out.
 
Overall good list but I question a few:

R. Grant- at 6? We have seen many one hit wonders, he just does not seem like a swing for the fences kind of back when we are talking dynasty, rather a one year re- draft.

S. Young- at 18? his coach has come out and said he will not be the feature back and dealing with the Denver RB musical chairs

Portis- too low at 17, no RBBC and has proven to be a stud

 
Brewzers said:
flat_earth said:
I applaud you for not overvaluing the rookies, but I agree that Willie Parker is way too high. Also, Portis is too low. I would have a hard time taking Parker over Portis at this point, especially in a non-PPR league. Portis is a year younger, in a better situation to score TDs, and has history on his side. I think both of those guys belong in the 7-15 range.

Good job on the rankings overall. :tinfoilhat:
Click to expand...
C'mon, he's got ADP #1, Ryan Grant #6, Marshawn Lynch #8....weren't all these guys rookies in 2007? Depending on how you look at the 2008 situation there are about 8-14 RB & RBBC positions open. I'm gonna grab 2008 rookie RBs like halloween candy. The problem is we don't know the situation these guys will be drafted into, so its hard to value them right now, but they are too low.
Click to expand...
And all three made a splash in their first season. Where as the rookies haven't even played a down yet. Remember these are dynasty rankings.
 
War Ensemble said:
With all due respect, but Portis at 17 is rediculous.
Click to expand...
I agree and add to that, that he has L. Betts at 36 above guys like Fred Taylor, Ahmad Bradshaw, and DeShaun Foster and the only thing I can think of is that he thinks Portis will be injured next year.
 
Arm Chair Express said:
Brewzers said:
flat_earth said:
I applaud you for not overvaluing the rookies, but I agree that Willie Parker is way too high. Also, Portis is too low. I would have a hard time taking Parker over Portis at this point, especially in a non-PPR league. Portis is a year younger, in a better situation to score TDs, and has history on his side. I think both of those guys belong in the 7-15 range.

Good job on the rankings overall. :shrug:
Click to expand...
C'mon, he's got ADP #1, Ryan Grant #6, Marshawn Lynch #8....weren't all these guys rookies in 2007? Depending on how you look at the 2008 situation there are about 8-14 RB & RBBC positions open. I'm gonna grab 2008 rookie RBs like halloween candy. The problem is we don't know the situation these guys will be drafted into, so its hard to value them right now, but they are too low.
Click to expand...
And all three made a splash in their first season. Where as the rookies haven't even played a down yet. Remember these are dynasty rankings.
Click to expand...
One year ago, ADP, Grant and Lynch hadn't played a down and yet one year later they are ranked 1, 6 & 8 respectively by the OP. There are going to be some golden tickets in this rookie class as well and DMC, Stewart & Mendenhall are good bets. IMO, the OP has over ranked first year performances of Grant & Young and under estimating the rookies. To his credit, he acknowledges that, its a gutsy call. However, on my dynasty team I would not hesitate to trade him Selvin Young for either Mendenhall or Stewart right now and I would trade Ryan Grant straight up for DMC. I think there is less bust risk with those three rookies than with Grant & Young despite the experience.

 
1) Complainien Tomlinson

2) Adrian Peterson

3) Steven Jackson

4) Joseph Addai

5) Larry Johnson

6) Frank Gore

7) Brian Westbrook

8) Marion Barber

9) Marshawn Lynch

10) Darren McFadden

11) Lawrence Maroney

12) Reggie Bush

13) Clinton Portis

14) Maurice Jones-Drew

15) Ronnie Brown

16) Jonathan Stewart

17) Travis Henry

18) Willie Parker

19) Lendale White

20) Brandon Jacobs

21) Ryan Grant

22) Edge James

23) Ernest Graham

24) Thomas Jones

25) Rudi Johnson

 
Bracie Smathers said:
Dynasty, no PPR. Broken down in 12 player increments so owners can see where their players stack up in a twelve player league. RB has shorter time frame to make impact so the balancing act is of weighing elder players VS. long term upside of yute. Included some rookies due to the fact that some older RBs will be replaced. Really difficult to rank prior to draft when including rookies so take this with a huge grain of salt.

* denotes rookie

1. Adrian Peterson (MIN)

2. LaDainian Tomlinson

3. Steven Jackson

4. Willie Parker--way too high here. I'd still take Addai, Westbrook, Gore and Lynch ahead of him.

5. Joseph Addai

6. Ryan Grant--he still has to prove something to me over more than 8 games before being bumped up here. His playoff performances are going to bump his value too high.

7. Brian Westbrook

8. Marshawn Lynch

9. Larry Johnson

10. Frank Gore

11. Ronnie Brown

12. Marion Barber--too low. Yes, we don't know if he can handle the load, but the reward here is enormous.

I see LJ coming back with a vengeance and that Ryan Grant is the real deal and still think Ronnie Brown is a talent.

13. Laurence Maroney

14. Willis McGahee--too low. He was very, very good this year and Baltimore can only improve from here.

15. Maurice Jones-Drew

16. Darren McFadden*--too low. You're ranking him as the average RB, when he's a stud waiting to happen. Risk is high, but reward is one of the best RBs in FF.

17. Clinton Portis--this is a joke, right?

18. Selvyn Young--no.

19. LenDale White--Yeah, Tennessee's RB situation is messed up, but again, reward is too high for him to be this low.

20. Reggie Bush--Way, WAY too low. I really hope we're not talking PPR here, but even if we aren't, Bush is involved in the passing game enough, he's young with upside, and NO isn't going to give up on him.

21. Michael Turner

22. Jamal Lewis

23. Rudi Johnson--Way too high. I'm of the opinion he's just about done.

24. DeAngelo Williams

McFadden should rank this high if he pans out and I think he will. Selyn Young's ranking should be controversial but I think he replaces Travis and produces numbers in the top 20. I like DeAngelo and think he takes over.

25. Thomas Jones

26. Kevin Jones

27. Rashad Mendenhall*

28. Cedric Benson

29. Edgerrin James

30. Brandon Jacobs--Again, way too low. You'd really rather have Benson? Seriously?

31. Earnest Graham

32. Chester Taylor

33. Jerious Norwood

34. Michael Bush

35. Jonathan Stewart*

36. Ladell Betts

Assuming the second rookie RB lands in the right situation they should put up top 30 production and I have Medenhall going second off the draft board but whichever rookie ends up in a decent place to start should rank right around 30 then assuming the third RB drafted can make an impact they would rank right around 40. I wanted to drink the Ahmad Bradshaw Cool Aide but I had to put Jacobs ahead of him. This was the most difficult portion of the rankings and since it effects the rest so much I'm sure it will be the most controversial.

37. Fred Taylor

38. Kevin Smith*

39. Ahmad Bradshaw

40. Deuce McAllister

41. Travis Henry

42. Leon Washington

43. Felix Jones*

44. Ahman Green

45. Justin Fargas

46. Kenny Watson

47. Chris Brown

48. DeShaun Foster

Had to find places for the vets who will more than likely produce better than most of the yute but soon I see Taylor and McAllister and others dropping out. I would imagine some of the latter rookie RBs get their shot and at least one makes a splash. Other rookies who don't end up starting are ranked for their position over time.

These players just missed as you can see I have SA falling down the rabbit hole and Maurice Morris also out of the top 50 meaning that I believe one of the rookies is taken by the Hawks and wins the starting gig.

Ray Rice*

Kenny Irons

Adrian Peterson (CHI)

Kolby Smith

LaMont Jordan

Jesse Chapman

Kenton Kieth

Sammy Morris

Chris Henry

Brandon Jackson

Chris Perry

Julius Jones

T-Bell

Reuben Droughns

Maurice Morris

Shaun Alexander

Mewelde Moore

Derrick Ward

Lorenzo Booker

Carnell Williams
Click to expand...
 
Bossman said:
1) Complainien Tomlinson2) Adrian Peterson3) Steven Jackson4) Joseph Addai5) Larry Johnson6) Frank Gore7) Brian Westbrook8) Marion Barber9) Marshawn Lynch10) Darren McFadden11) Lawrence Maroney12) Reggie Bush13) Clinton Portis14) Maurice Jones-Drew15) Ronnie Brown16) Jonathan Stewart17) Travis Henry18) Willie Parker19) Lendale White20) Brandon Jacobs21) Ryan Grant22) Edge James23) Ernest Graham24) Thomas Jones25) Rudi Johnson
Click to expand...
Was the omission of McGahee a mistake, or on purpose? If a mistake, where would you rank him?
 
Brewzers said:
Arm Chair Express said:
Brewzers said:
flat_earth said:
I applaud you for not overvaluing the rookies, but I agree that Willie Parker is way too high. Also, Portis is too low. I would have a hard time taking Parker over Portis at this point, especially in a non-PPR league. Portis is a year younger, in a better situation to score TDs, and has history on his side. I think both of those guys belong in the 7-15 range.

Good job on the rankings overall. :confused:
Click to expand...
C'mon, he's got ADP #1, Ryan Grant #6, Marshawn Lynch #8....weren't all these guys rookies in 2007? Depending on how you look at the 2008 situation there are about 8-14 RB & RBBC positions open. I'm gonna grab 2008 rookie RBs like halloween candy. The problem is we don't know the situation these guys will be drafted into, so its hard to value them right now, but they are too low.
Click to expand...
And all three made a splash in their first season. Where as the rookies haven't even played a down yet. Remember these are dynasty rankings.
Click to expand...
One year ago, ADP, Grant and Lynch hadn't played a down and yet one year later they are ranked 1, 6 & 8 respectively by the OP. There are going to be some golden tickets in this rookie class as well and DMC, Stewart & Mendenhall are good bets. IMO, the OP has over ranked first year performances of Grant & Young and under estimating the rookies. To his credit, he acknowledges that, its a gutsy call. However, on my dynasty team I would not hesitate to trade him Selvin Young for either Mendenhall or Stewart right now and I would trade Ryan Grant straight up for DMC. I think there is less bust risk with those three rookies than with Grant & Young despite the experience.
Click to expand...
Here's what seems to happen every season with the incoming crop of prominent rookie RBs:1. People rank them RB15-25. They say you can't rank him them higher because they're not "proven" at the NFL level.

2. The RBs come in and put up a couple 100 yard games in their rookie season.

3. People rank the rookie RB5-15 now that they've "proven" they can play at the NFL level.

This has happened in recent seasons with Michael Bennett, Anthony Thomas, LaDainian Tomlinson, William Green, Willis McGahee, Julius Jones, Kevin Jones, Cadillac Williams, Ronnie Brown, Laurence Maroney, Reggie Bush, Joseph Addai, Adrian Peterson, and Marshawn Lynch. It will happen next year with whichever rookie RBs get immediate playing time and have decent seasons. They'll show enough flashes to "prove" themselves at the NFL level and they'll be bumped up 10 spots in consensus dynasty rankings.

I can't really say that this makes a lick of sense to me. If you're going to rank Jonathan Stewart in your top 15 once he puts up a couple decent games, then why don't you just put him in your top 15 right now? A few good games prove nothing. I don't think you should be surprised when a first round rookie RB has a couple decent games and I don't think it should affect your rankings of that player much.

I have Stewart as a fringe top 15 type RIGHT NOW because he's better than the guys below him and I know he's going to be a consensus top 10-15 dynasty RB next offseason if he even sniffs a decent rookie year (see: Maroney, Lynch, Ronnie, Cadillac, Julius, KJ, Green).

 
mikel0254 said:
Bossman said:
1) Complainien Tomlinson2) Adrian Peterson3) Steven Jackson4) Joseph Addai5) Larry Johnson6) Frank Gore7) Brian Westbrook8) Marion Barber9) Marshawn Lynch10) Darren McFadden11) Lawrence Maroney12) Reggie Bush13) Clinton Portis14) Maurice Jones-Drew15) Ronnie Brown16) Jonathan Stewart17) Travis Henry18) Willie Parker19) Lendale White20) Brandon Jacobs21) Ryan Grant22) Edge James23) Ernest Graham24) Thomas Jones25) Rudi Johnson
Click to expand...
Was the omission of McGahee a mistake, or on purpose? If a mistake, where would you rank him?
Click to expand...
oops, I missed him. I may have missed others as I banged this out pretty quick.I think he'd fit nicely just after Portis... so #14.
 
Biabreakable said:
I would like to hear more about your perspective on FWP. I like the ranking although I don't have the same confidence about him as you do, I do think that people are incorrect in most of their criticism of him. Curious what you see ahead for Fast Willie that causes you to rank him 4th?
Click to expand...
 
Biabreakable said:
Biabreakable said:
I would like to hear more about your perspective on FWP. I like the ranking although I don't have the same confidence about him as you do, I do think that people are incorrect in most of their criticism of him. Curious what you see ahead for Fast Willie that causes you to rank him 4th?
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Wasn't trying to dodge the question but I don't have any one big earthshattering insight but a few smaller points. First off, the Steelers will more than likely lose Faneca so that isn't good but mostly I see that loss as a killer to Big Ben who ate turf a lot last year. That line is a good run blocking line but even with Faneca wasn't a good pass protecting line. They will more than likely reload on the offensive line and I wouldn't be surprised to see them using their first pick on an offensive lineman. Rookie O-Linemen tend to be better at run blocking their first years and that line is already a solid run blocking unit so I think the Steelers will be forced to run the ball if they lose Faneca and I think they do.It took me awhile to buy into Parker, after the Bus he just didn't 'look' or 'feel' like a big bruising Pittsbrugh RB so I tended to overlook him till I couldn't ignore his production. I still harbored some doubts about the 'type' of RB I felt would fit in with the Pittsburgh power rush attack but Willie was working and I couldn't deny it.Pittsburgh switched gears last year with the coaching change and Parker's number plunged in terms of scoring from his high of 16 combined TDs in 06, 13 rushing and 3 recieving. Parker was still a highly productive runner.FWP was leading the league in rushing when he broke his leg last year. The Steelers went with big back Najeh Davenport who I felt 'fit' better with the 'type' of RB for Pittsburgh and that he might even end up nudging into a heavier workload once Parker returned if he produced. Davenport blew up against St. Louis but laid an egg against Baltimore. Basically he didn't take over as I thought he might. Losing Parker impacted the Steelers more than I think they imagined and I think they took Parker's production for granted and realize they need him in there to be effective. I think this is the key, the Steelers tried using Davenport as their goal line RB earlier in the year and had limited success but went away from that because Najeh just isn't that tough or durable.Parker broke his leg, he didn't have a knee injury or ligament tear. I haven't heard of any complications so I expect a full recovery. He should be healthy and he'll be as productive rushing the ball as he was last year. I see him healthy and the primary rusher in a run heavy attack. I see him scoring more TDs this year because I'm not sure Tomlin was using him as effectively as they could have last year in the red zone. I know Big Ben wants bigger WRs to use in the redzone but they have Parker and he did the job in 06 and he's not a 'great' receiving threat but he's ok and I think Tolmin and his staff will work more with Parker in the red zone. He's only 27, he has three straight 1,200+ rushing seasons in a row. I think for dynasty purposes he's a lock for two to three more 1,200 to 1,400 yard seasons with 20 to 30 receptions and at least 10 combined TDs. The fourth ranked player was tough because I think the Colts want to split their backfield. I see FWP as thee main guy for the next thee years in Pittsburgh and that he'll produce. He just seemed like the safest pick for the third ranked player for non PPR dynasty RBs as long as he stays healthy.
 
Warhogs said:
Let me say hats off to all those willing to post their rankings and deal with the critics.
Click to expand...
I second that thought. There are a number of us that posted our lists and I can disagree with parts of all of them (including, in retrospedt, my own list). The problem is that there IS NO perfect list or magic formula. And if there was, I sure wouldn't be based on what we know in January.When it comes to these lists, opinions are like anal orifices......everybody has their own. Having said that, personally i agree with many of the criticisms of this list. But one thing I agree with: IMO he has got the approximate level for the rookies just about right, considering that we really do not know where they will end up, how they will fare against NFL level defenses, or how early they will contribute. This is true of ALL of them, even McFadden may be OVER-valued.
 
Bracie Smathers said:
Dynasty, no PPR. Broken down in 12 player increments so owners can see where their players stack up in a twelve player league. RB has shorter time frame to make impact so the balancing act is of weighing elder players VS. long term upside of yute. Included some rookies due to the fact that some older RBs will be replaced. Really difficult to rank prior to draft when including rookies so take this with a huge grain of salt.

* denotes rookie

1. Adrian Peterson (MIN)

2. LaDainian Tomlinson

3. Steven Jackson

4. Willie Parker

5. Joseph Addai

6. Ryan Grant

7. Brian Westbrook

8. Marshawn Lynch

9. Larry Johnson

10. Frank Gore

11. Ronnie Brown

12. Marion Barber

I see LJ coming back with a vengeance and that Ryan Grant is the real deal and still think Ronnie Brown is a talent.

13. Laurence Maroney

14. Willis McGahee

15. Maurice Jones-Drew

16. Darren McFadden*

17. Clinton Portis

18. Selvyn Young

19. LenDale White

20. Reggie Bush

21. Michael Turner

22. Jamal Lewis

23. Rudi Johnson

24. DeAngelo Williams

McFadden should rank this high if he pans out and I think he will. Selyn Young's ranking should be controversial but I think he replaces Travis and produces numbers in the top 20. I like DeAngelo and think he takes over.

25. Thomas Jones

26. Kevin Jones

27. Rashad Mendenhall*

28. Cedric Benson

29. Edgerrin James

30. Brandon Jacobs

31. Earnest Graham

32. Chester Taylor

33. Jerious Norwood

34. Michael Bush

35. Jonathan Stewart*

36. Ladell Betts

Assuming the second rookie RB lands in the right situation they should put up top 30 production and I have Medenhall going second off the draft board but whichever rookie ends up in a decent place to start should rank right around 30 then assuming the third RB drafted can make an impact they would rank right around 40. I wanted to drink the Ahmad Bradshaw Cool Aide but I had to put Jacobs ahead of him. This was the most difficult portion of the rankings and since it effects the rest so much I'm sure it will be the most controversial.

37. Fred Taylor

38. Kevin Smith*

39. Ahmad Bradshaw

40. Deuce McAllister

41. Travis Henry

42. Leon Washington

43. Felix Jones*

44. Ahman Green

45. Justin Fargas

46. Kenny Watson

47. Chris Brown

48. DeShaun Foster

Had to find places for the vets who will more than likely produce better than most of the yute but soon I see Taylor and McAllister and others dropping out. I would imagine some of the latter rookie RBs get their shot and at least one makes a splash. Other rookies who don't end up starting are ranked for their position over time.

These players just missed as you can see I have SA falling down the rabbit hole and Maurice Morris also out of the top 50 meaning that I believe one of the rookies is taken by the Hawks and wins the starting gig.

Ray Rice*

Kenny Irons

Adrian Peterson (CHI)

Kolby Smith

LaMont Jordan

Jesse Chapman

Kenton Kieth

Sammy Morris

Chris Henry

Brandon Jackson

Chris Perry

Julius Jones

T-Bell

Reuben Droughns

Maurice Morris

Shaun Alexander

Mewelde Moore

Derrick Ward

Lorenzo Booker

Carnell Williams
Click to expand...
Hadn't attempted an update from January so here goes. Both redraft and dyanasty, no PPR. Just zeroing in on which prospects should make it into the top forty on each list. I'm trying to refine my list so I would appreciate any feedback. Thanks!
Redraft rank Player Team Bye wk Age Ht. - Wt. BMI1 LaDanian Thomlinson SD 9 29 5'10" 221 31.72 Adrian Peterson MIN 8 23 6'1" 217 28.63 Joseph Addai IND 4 25 5'11" 214 29.84 Brian Westbrook PHI 7 29 5'10" 203 29.15 Steven Jackson STL 5 25 6'2" 231 29.76 Clinton Portis WAS 10 27 5'11" 223 31.17 Frank Gore SF 9 25 5'9" 223 32.98 Marshawn Lynch BUF 6 22 5'11" 215 30.09 Marion Barber III DAL 10 25 6'0" 220 29.810 Larry Johnson KC 6 28 6'1" 230 30.311 Maurice Jones-Drew JAX 7 23 5'7" 212 33.212 Ryan Grant GB 8 25 6'1" 218 28.813 Jamal Lewis CLE 5 28 5'11" 245 34.214 *Darren McFadden OAK 5 21 6'1" 211 27.815 Thomas Jones NYJ 5 30 5'10" 215 30.816 Willie Parker PIT 6 25 5'10" 209 30.017 *Jonathan Stewart CAR 9 21 5'11" 234 32.618 Reggie Bush NO 9 23 6'0" 203 27.519 Michael Turner ATL 7 26 5'10" 237 34.020 Willis McGahee BAL 10 27 6'0" 232 31.521 LenDale White TEN 4 23 6'1" 235 31.022 Brandon Jacobs NYG 4 26 6'4" 264 32.123 Selvin Young DEN 8 25 6'0" 210 28.524 Edgrin James ARI 7 30 6'0" 220 29.825 *Matt Forte CHI 8 22 6'1" 222 29.326 Earnest Graham TB 10 28 5'9" 225 33.227 Laurence Maroney NE 4 23 5'11" 220 30.728 Kevin Smith DET 8 21 6'1" 211 27.829 Ahmad Bradshaw NYG 4 22 5'9" 198 29.230 Rudi Johnson CIN 8 29 5'10" 214 30.731 Julius Jones SEA 4 27 5'10" 211 30.332 Ronnie Brown MIA 6 26 6'0" 232 31.533 *Felix Jones DAL 10 21 5'10" 207 29.734 DeAngelo Williams CAR 8 25 5'9" 217 32.035 *Rashard Mendenhall PIT 6 21 5'11" 225 31.436 Chester Taylor MIN 8 29 5'11" 213 29.737 Ahman Green HOU 8 31 6'0" 218 29.638 Justin Fargas OAK 5 28 6'1" 220 29.039 *Chris Johnson TEN 6 23 5'11" 197 27.540 Maurice Morris SEA 4 28 5'11" 216 30.141 *Ray Rice BAL 10 21 5'9" 209 30.942 Chris Perry CIN 8 26 6'0" 224 30.443 Fred Taylor JAX 7 32 6'1" 226 29.844 Jerious Norwood ATL 7 25 5'11" 204 28.445 Tatum Bell DET 4 27 5'11" 213 29.746 Ricky Williams MIA 4 31 5'10" 226 32.447 Leon Washington NYJ 5 26 5'8" 202 30.748 Kenny Watson CIN 8 30 6'0" 218 29.6 Chris Brown HOU 8 *Steve Slayton HOU 8 Dynasty rank Player Team Age Ht. - Wt. BMI1 Adrian Peterson MIN 23 6'1 217 28.62 Steven Jackson STL 25 6'2" 231 29.73 Joseph Addai IND 25 5'11" 214 29.84 Marshawn Lynch BUF 22 5'11" 215 30.05 LaDanian Thomlinson SD 29 5'10 221 31.76 Maurice Jones-Drew JAX 23 5'7" 212 33.27 Frank Gore SF 25 5'9" 223 32.98 Marion Barber III DAL 25 6'0" 220 29.89 Brian Westbrook PHI 29 5'10" 203 29.110 *Darren McFadden OAK 21 6'1" 211 27.811 Clinton Portis WAS 27 5'11" 223 31.112 Ryan Grant GB 25 6'1" 218 28.813 *Jonathan Stewart CAR 21 5'11" 234 32.614 Larry Johnson KC 28 6'1" 230 30.315 *Rashard Mendenhall PIT 21 5'11" 225 31.416 Reggie Bush NO 23 6'0" 203 27.517 Jamal Lewis CLE 28 5'11" 245 34.218 Michael Turner ATL 26 5'10" 237 34.019 *Matt Forte CHI 22 6'1" 222 29.320 Willie Parker PIT 25 5'10" 209 30.021 *Kevin Smith DET 21 6'1" 211 27.822 Willis McGahee BAL 27 6'0" 232 31.523 Laurence Maroney NE 23 5'11" 220 30.724 LenDale White TEN 23 6'1" 235 31.025 *Ray Rice BAL 21 5'9" 209 30.926 *Felix Jones DAL 21 5'10" 207 29.727 Ronnie Brown MIA 26 6'0" 232 31.528 *Chris Johnson TEN 23 5'11" 197 27.529 Brandon Jacobs NYG 26 6'4" 264 32.130 Ahmad Bradshaw NYG 22 5'9" 198 29.231 Thomas Jones NYJ 30 5'10" 215 30.832 Selvin Young DEN 25 6'0" 210 28.533 Julius Jones SEA 27 5'10" 211 30.334 DeAngelo Williams CAR 25 5'9" 217 32.035 Earnest Graham TB 28 5'9" 225 33.236 Justin Fargas OAK 28 6'1" 220 29.037 Pierre Thomas NO 23 5'11" 210 29.338 Chester Taylor MIN 29 5'11" 213 29.739 Kolby Smith KC 23 5'11" 218 30.440 Michael Bush OAK 24 6'2" 247 31.741 Edgrin James ARI 30 6'0" 220 29.842 Maurice Morris SEA 28 5'11" 216 30.143 Chris Perry CIN 26 6'0" 224 30.444 Rudi Johnson CIN 29 5'10" 214 30.745 Tatum Bell DET 27 5'11" 213 29.746 *Tim Hightower ARI 22 6'1" 225 29.747 Kevin Jones CHI 26 6'0" 228 30.948 *Mike Hart IND 22 5'9" 195 28.8 Jason Wright CLE 26 5'10" 214 30.7 Leon Washington NYJ 26 5'8" 202 30.7~~~ transfered from a spreadsheet and the formatting appears to have kablooey. I include BMI for one purpose. If the medium is in the 29-31 BMI range then standard deviations would fall in the 28-27 and lower range and high standard deviations from the norm would be in the 32-33-34 and up range. Hieght only seems to count against tall RB's so the only RB who is sticks out like a sore thumb being well above normal is Bradon Jacobs at 6'4" Feedback?

 
Bracie Smathers said:
Dynasty, no PPR. Broken down in 12 player increments so owners can see where their players stack up in a twelve player league. RB has shorter time frame to make impact so the balancing act is of weighing elder players VS. long term upside of yute. Included some rookies due to the fact that some older RBs will be replaced. Really difficult to rank prior to draft when including rookies so take this with a huge grain of salt.

* denotes rookie

1. Adrian Peterson (MIN)

2. LaDainian Tomlinson

3. Steven Jackson

4. Willie Parker

5. Joseph Addai

6. Ryan Grant

7. Brian Westbrook

8. Marshawn Lynch

9. Larry Johnson

10. Frank Gore

11. Ronnie Brown

12. Marion Barber

I see LJ coming back with a vengeance and that Ryan Grant is the real deal and still think Ronnie Brown is a talent.

13. Laurence Maroney

14. Willis McGahee

15. Maurice Jones-Drew

16. Darren McFadden*

17. Clinton Portis

18. Selvyn Young

19. LenDale White

20. Reggie Bush

21. Michael Turner

22. Jamal Lewis

23. Rudi Johnson

24. DeAngelo Williams

McFadden should rank this high if he pans out and I think he will. Selyn Young's ranking should be controversial but I think he replaces Travis and produces numbers in the top 20. I like DeAngelo and think he takes over.

25. Thomas Jones

26. Kevin Jones

27. Rashad Mendenhall*

28. Cedric Benson

29. Edgerrin James

30. Brandon Jacobs

31. Earnest Graham

32. Chester Taylor

33. Jerious Norwood

34. Michael Bush

35. Jonathan Stewart*

36. Ladell Betts

Assuming the second rookie RB lands in the right situation they should put up top 30 production and I have Medenhall going second off the draft board but whichever rookie ends up in a decent place to start should rank right around 30 then assuming the third RB drafted can make an impact they would rank right around 40. I wanted to drink the Ahmad Bradshaw Cool Aide but I had to put Jacobs ahead of him. This was the most difficult portion of the rankings and since it effects the rest so much I'm sure it will be the most controversial.

37. Fred Taylor

38. Kevin Smith*

39. Ahmad Bradshaw

40. Deuce McAllister

41. Travis Henry

42. Leon Washington

43. Felix Jones*

44. Ahman Green

45. Justin Fargas

46. Kenny Watson

47. Chris Brown

48. DeShaun Foster

Had to find places for the vets who will more than likely produce better than most of the yute but soon I see Taylor and McAllister and others dropping out. I would imagine some of the latter rookie RBs get their shot and at least one makes a splash. Other rookies who don't end up starting are ranked for their position over time.

These players just missed as you can see I have SA falling down the rabbit hole and Maurice Morris also out of the top 50 meaning that I believe one of the rookies is taken by the Hawks and wins the starting gig.

Ray Rice*

Kenny Irons

Adrian Peterson (CHI)

Kolby Smith

LaMont Jordan

Jesse Chapman

Kenton Kieth

Sammy Morris

Chris Henry

Brandon Jackson

Chris Perry

Julius Jones

T-Bell

Reuben Droughns

Maurice Morris

Shaun Alexander

Mewelde Moore

Derrick Ward

Lorenzo Booker

Carnell Williams
Click to expand...
great list!
 
johntorn said:
great list!
Click to expand...
The updated list is here for dynasty, none PPR.I was looking for feedback on this one and trying to tweak this updated list.Dynasty rank Player Team Age Ht. - Wt. BMI1 Adrian Peterson MIN 23 6'1 217 28.62 Steven Jackson STL 25 6'2" 231 29.73 Joseph Addai IND 25 5'11" 214 29.84 Marshawn Lynch BUF 22 5'11" 215 30.05 LaDanian Thomlinson SD 29 5'10 221 31.76 Maurice Jones-Drew JAX 23 5'7" 212 33.27 Frank Gore SF 25 5'9" 223 32.98 Marion Barber III DAL 25 6'0" 220 29.89 Brian Westbrook PHI 29 5'10" 203 29.110 *Darren McFadden OAK 21 6'1" 211 27.811 Clinton Portis WAS 27 5'11" 223 31.112 Ryan Grant GB 25 6'1" 218 28.813 *Jonathan Stewart CAR 21 5'11" 234 32.614 Larry Johnson KC 28 6'1" 230 30.315 *Rashard Mendenhall PIT 21 5'11" 225 31.416 Reggie Bush NO 23 6'0" 203 27.517 Jamal Lewis CLE 28 5'11" 245 34.218 Michael Turner ATL 26 5'10" 237 34.019 *Matt Forte CHI 22 6'1" 222 29.320 Willie Parker PIT 25 5'10" 209 30.021 *Kevin Smith DET 21 6'1" 211 27.822 Willis McGahee BAL 27 6'0" 232 31.523 Laurence Maroney NE 23 5'11" 220 30.724 LenDale White TEN 23 6'1" 235 31.025 *Ray Rice BAL 21 5'9" 209 30.926 *Felix Jones DAL 21 5'10" 207 29.727 Ronnie Brown MIA 26 6'0" 232 31.528 *Chris Johnson TEN 23 5'11" 197 27.529 Brandon Jacobs NYG 26 6'4" 264 32.130 Ahmad Bradshaw NYG 22 5'9" 198 29.231 Thomas Jones NYJ 30 5'10" 215 30.832 Selvin Young DEN 25 6'0" 210 28.533 Julius Jones SEA 27 5'10" 211 30.334 DeAngelo Williams CAR 25 5'9" 217 32.035 Earnest Graham TB 28 5'9" 225 33.236 Justin Fargas OAK 28 6'1" 220 29.037 Pierre Thomas NO 23 5'11" 210 29.338 Chester Taylor MIN 29 5'11" 213 29.739 Kolby Smith KC 23 5'11" 218 30.440 Michael Bush OAK 24 6'2" 247 31.741 Edgrin James ARI 30 6'0" 220 29.842 Maurice Morris SEA 28 5'11" 216 30.143 Chris Perry CIN 26 6'0" 224 30.444 Rudi Johnson CIN 29 5'10" 214 30.745 Tatum Bell DET 27 5'11" 213 29.746 *Tim Hightower ARI 22 6'1" 225 29.747 Kevin Jones CHI 26 6'0" 228 30.948 *Mike Hart IND 22 5'9" 195 28.8 Jason Wright CLE 26 5'10" 214 30.7 Leon Washington NYJ 26 5'8" 202 30.7
 
just did a pretty good 10 team keeper (all smart dudes from law school) so even the biggest dolt in FF is pretty smart in general (yet blinded by ties to ND)

Figured I'd post so people could see how things feel as far as dynasty Rbs go

1 Brett Perriman's Posse* LaDainian Tomlinson (RB SD) 20 sec

2 Scarlet Knights Brian Westbrook (RB PHI) 5 min 6 sec

3 Public Enemy Steven Jackson (RB STL) 1 min 41 sec

4 The Bedford Wasps Frank Gore (RB SF) 37 sec

5 Touchdown Jesus Joseph Addai (RB IND) 43 sec

6 General's Revenge Randy Moss (WR NE) 43 sec

7 The Show Ryan Grant (RB GB) 58 sec

8 Tuscan Raiders Reggie Wayne (WR IND) 1 min 6 sec

9 TLG Larry Johnson (RB KC) 49 sec

10 The Swamp Jamal Lewis (RB CLE) 1 min 42 sec

Round 2

11 The Swamp Peyton Manning (QB IND) 41 sec

12 TLG Willis McGahee (RB BAL) 20 sec

13 Tuscan Raiders Kevin Smith (RB DET) 58 sec

14 The Show Reggie Bush (RB NO) 4 min 10 sec

15 General's Revenge Darren McFadden (RB OAK) 60 sec

16 Touchdown Jesus Laurence Maroney (RB NE) 31 sec

17 The Bedford Wasps (Keeper) Clinton Portis (RB WAS)

18 Public Enemy Earnest Graham (RB TB) 2 min 29 sec

19 Scarlet Knights Willie Parker (RB PIT) 1 min 2 sec

20 Brett Perriman's Posse Andre Johnson (WR HOU) 7 min 33 sec

Round 3

21 Brett Perriman's Posse Thomas Jones (RB NYJ) 5 min 41 sec

22 Scarlet Knights Torry Holt (WR STL) 1 min 29 sec

23 Public Enemy (Keeper) T.J. Houshmandzadeh (WR CIN)

24 The Bedford Wasps Carson Palmer (QB CIN) 1 min 7 sec

25 Touchdown Jesus (Keeper) Larry Fitzgerald (WR ARI)

26 General's Revenge Chad Johnson (WR CIN) 2 min 31 sec

27 The Show (Keeper) Adrian Peterson (RB MIN)

28 Tuscan Raiders (Keeper) Marshawn Lynch (RB BUF)

29 TLG Roy Williams (WR DET) 1 min 35 sec

30 The Swamp (Keeper) Terrell Owens (WR DAL)

Round 4

31 The Swamp Calvin Johnson (WR DET) 1 min 8 sec

32 TLG (Keeper) Tom Brady (QB NE)

33 Tuscan Raiders Santonio Holmes (WR PIT) 2 min 10 sec

34 The Show Edgerrin James (RB ARI) 2 min 12 sec

35 General's Revenge Anquan Boldin (WR ARI) 45 sec

36 Touchdown Jesus Julius Jones (RB SEA) 51 sec

37 The Bedford Wasps Jerricho Cotchery (WR NYJ) 1 min 26 sec

38 Public Enemy Antonio Gates (TE SD) 1 min 12 sec

39 Scarlet Knights Selvin Young (RB DEN) 1 min 4 sec

40 Brett Perriman's Posse Steve Smith (WR CAR) 3 min 59 sec

Round 5

41 Brett Perriman's Posse Jonathan Stewart (RB CAR) 6 min 11 sec

42 Scarlet Knights (Keeper) Plaxico Burress (WR NYG)

43 Public Enemy Greg Jennings (WR GB) 1 min 6 sec

44 The Bedford Wasps Tony Gonzalez (TE KC) 46 sec

45 Touchdown Jesus Marvin Harrison (WR IND) 1 min 16 sec

46 General's Revenge Ronnie Brown (RB MIA) 1 min 17 sec

47 The Show Matt Forte (RB CHI) 2 min 23 sec

48 Tuscan Raiders Fred Taylor (RB JAC) 5 min 17 sec

49 TLG Ricky Williams (RB MIA) 1 min 58 sec

50 The Swamp Lee Evans (WR BUF) 1 min 42 sec

Round 6

51 The Swamp LenDale White (RB TEN) 6 sec

52 TLG (Keeper) Marques Colston (WR NO)

53 Tuscan Raiders Roddy White (WR ATL) 4 min 50 sec

54 The Show Dallas Clark (TE IND) 42 sec

55 General's Revenge Donald Driver (WR GB) 5 min 13 sec

56 Touchdown Jesus Derek Anderson (QB CLE) 14 sec

57 The Bedford Wasps Hines Ward (WR PIT) 2 min 2 sec

58 Public Enemy (Keeper) Maurice Jones-Drew (RB JAC)

59 Scarlet Knights Vernon Davis (TE SF) 2 min 48 sec

60 Brett Perriman's Posse DeAngelo Williams (RB CAR) 1 min 41 sec

Round 7

61 Brett Perriman's Posse Rashard Mendenhall (RB PIT) 20 sec

62 Scarlet Knights Ben Roethlisberger (QB PIT) 33 sec

63 Public Enemy Laveranues Coles (WR NYJ) 1 min 34 sec

64 The Bedford Wasps Santana Moss (WR WAS) 21 sec

65 Touchdown Jesus Bernard Berrian (WR MIN) 2 min 14 sec

66 General's Revenge Anthony Gonzalez (WR IND) 13 sec

67 The Show (Keeper) Tony Romo (QB DAL)

68 Tuscan Raiders (Keeper) Marion Barber (RB DAL)

69 TLG DeSean Jackson (WR PHI) 12 sec

70 The Swamp (Keeper) Braylon Edwards (WR CLE)

Round 8

71 Brett Perriman's Posse Vikings (DST MIN) 7 min 25 sec

72 TLG Chris Cooley (TE WAS) 18 sec

73 Tuscan Raiders Todd Heap (TE BAL) 60 sec

74 The Show Justin Fargas (RB OAK) 39 sec

75 General's Revenge (Keeper) Matt Hasselbeck (QB SEA)

76 Touchdown Jesus (Keeper) Kellen Winslow (TE CLE)

77 The Bedford Wasps Chris Johnson (RB TEN) 1 min 27 sec

78 Public Enemy Jerious Norwood (RB ATL) 4 min 23 sec

79 Scarlet Knights Nate Burleson (WR SEA) 1 min 7 sec

80 The Swamp Felix Jones (RB DAL) 31 sec

Round 9

81 Brett Perriman's Posse Ray Rice (RB BAL) 6 min 54 sec

82 Scarlet Knights Chris Perry (RB CIN) 2 min 1 sec

83 Public Enemy Chester Taylor (RB MIN) 1 min 6 sec

84 The Bedford Wasps (Keeper) Chris Chambers (WR SD)

85 Touchdown Jesus Patrick Crayton (WR DAL) 2 min 15 sec

86 General's Revenge Ted Ginn Jr. (WR MIA) 51 sec

87 The Show Devin Hester (WR CHI) 1 min 26 sec

88 Tuscan Raiders Donovan McNabb (QB PHI) 1 min 53 sec

89 TLG Donte' Stallworth (WR CLE) 1 min 45 sec

90 The Swamp Rudi Johnson (RB CIN) 4 min 57 sec

Round 10

91 The Swamp (Keeper) Eli Manning (QB NYG)

92 TLG Deuce McAllister (RB NO) 2 min 28 sec

93 Tuscan Raiders Justin Gage (WR TEN) 3 min 9 sec

94 The Show Ahmad Bradshaw (RB NYG) 49 sec

95 General's Revenge (Keeper) Wes Welker (WR NE)

96 Touchdown Jesus Brandon Jackson (RB GB) 2 min 4 sec

97 The Bedford Wasps Leon Washington (RB NYJ) 24 sec

98 Public Enemy (Keeper) Drew Brees (QB NO)

99 Scarlet Knights Joey Galloway (WR TB) 13 sec

100 Brett Perriman's Posse Jay Cutler (QB DEN) 3 min 58 sec

Round 11

101 The Swamp Jeremy Shockey (TE NO) 8 min 39 sec

102 Scarlet Knights Kevin Walter (WR HOU) 19 sec

103 Public Enemy Reggie Brown (WR PHI) 45 sec

104 The Bedford Wasps Steve Slaton (RB HOU) 1 min 5 sec

105 Touchdown Jesus Dominic Rhodes (RB IND) 58 sec

106 General's Revenge Marc Bulger (QB STL) 1 min 35 sec

107 The Show (Keeper) Michael Turner (RB ATL)

108 Tuscan Raiders Chargers (DST SD) 20 sec

109 TLG Steelers (DST PIT) 4 min 7 sec

110 Brett Perriman's Posse Isaac Bruce (WR SF) 2 min 12 sec

Round 12

111 Brett Perriman's Posse Javon Walker (WR OAK) 2 min 1 sec

112 TLG Ahman Green (RB HOU) 1 min 17 sec

113 Tuscan Raiders Reggie Williams (WR JAC) 3 min 12 sec

114 The Show Bears (DST CHI) 38 sec

115 General's Revenge Heath Miller (TE PIT) 2 min 3 sec

116 Touchdown Jesus Stephen Gostkowski (K NE) 7 sec

117 The Bedford Wasps Derrick Mason (WR BAL) 1 min 26 sec

118 Public Enemy David Garrard (QB JAC) 2 min 10 sec

119 Scarlet Knights (Keeper) Brandon Marshall (WR DEN)

120 Brett Perriman's Posse (Keeper) Jason Witten (TE DAL)

Round 13

121 The Swamp Jerry Porter (WR JAC) 45 sec

122 Scarlet Knights Derrick Ward (RB NYG) 27 sec

123 Public Enemy Maurice Morris (RB SEA) 1 min 34 sec

124 The Bedford Wasps Jamaal Charles (RB KC) 2 min 29 sec

125 Touchdown Jesus James Hardy (WR BUF) 1 min 16 sec

126 General's Revenge Cowboys (DST DAL) 11 sec

127 The Show Andre Hall (RB DEN) 39 sec

128 Tuscan Raiders (Keeper) Brett Favre (QB NYJ)

129 TLG Robert Meachem (WR NO) 46 sec

130 The Swamp Jaguars (DST JAC) 1 min 23 sec

Round 14

131 The Swamp Vincent Jackson (WR SD) 7 sec

132 TLG Aaron Rodgers (QB GB) 25 sec

133 Tuscan Raiders Marty Booker (WR CHI) 2 min 45 sec

134 The Show D.J. Hackett (WR CAR) 2 min 4 sec

135 General's Revenge Tim Hightower (RB ARI) 3 min 0 sec

136 Touchdown Jesus Colts (DST IND) 1 min 37 sec

137 The Bedford Wasps Eagles (DST PHI) 4 sec

138 Public Enemy Owen Daniels (TE HOU) 1 min 15 sec

139 Scarlet Knights (Keeper) Brandon Jacobs (RB NYG)

140 Brett Perriman's Posse Ronald Curry (WR OAK) 2 min 16 sec

Round 15

141 Brett Perriman's Posse (Keeper) Sidney Rice (WR MIN)

142 Scarlet Knights Giants (DST NYG) 1 min 32 sec

143 Public Enemy Nick Folk (K DAL) 1 min 24 sec

144 The Bedford Wasps Michael Bush (RB OAK) 1 min 27 sec

145 Touchdown Jesus (Keeper) Adrian Peterson (RB CHI)

146 General's Revenge Benjamin Watson (TE NE) 2 min 11 sec

147 The Show Jon Kitna (QB DET) 7 sec

148 Tuscan Raiders Tatum Bell (RB DET) 45 sec

149 TLG (Keeper) Dwayne Bowe (WR KC)

150 The Swamp Patriots (DST NE) 1 min 52 sec

Round 16

151 The Swamp Tony Scheffler (TE DEN) 27 sec

152 TLG DeShaun Foster (RB SF) 25 sec

153 Tuscan Raiders Shayne Graham (K CIN) 3 min 23 sec

154 The Show Brandon Stokley (WR DEN) 17 sec

155 General's Revenge Cadillac Williams (RB TB) 3 min 5 sec

156 Touchdown Jesus Philip Rivers (QB SD) 13 sec

157 The Bedford Wasps Ladell Betts (RB WAS) 34 sec

158 Public Enemy Limas Sweed (WR PIT) 1 min 34 sec

159 Scarlet Knights Kevin Jones (RB CHI) 27 sec

160 Brett Perriman's Posse Nate Kaeding (K SD) 5 min 35 sec

Round 17

161 Brett Perriman's Posse Matt Ryan (QB ATL) 48 sec

162 Scarlet Knights Laurent Robinson (WR ATL) 53 sec

163 Public Enemy Drew Bennett (WR STL) 8 sec

164 The Bedford Wasps Phil Dawson (K CLE) 12 sec

165 Touchdown Jesus Chris Henry (WR CIN) 3 min 48 sec

166 General's Revenge Adam Vinatieri (K IND) 34 sec

167 The Show Rob Bironas (K TEN) 1 min 28 sec

168 Tuscan Raiders Fred Jackson (RB BUF) 24 sec

169 TLG LaMont Jordan (RB NE) 2 min 17 sec

170 The Swamp Mason Crosby (K GB) 15 sec

Round 18

171 The Swamp Darren Sproles (RB SD) 5 sec (24 min 20 sec)

172 TLG Josh Brown (K STL) 52 sec (19 min 34 sec)

173 Tuscan Raiders Earl Bennett (WR CHI) 1 min 16 sec (32 min 28 sec)

174 The Show Mike Hart (RB IND) 45 sec (19 min 17 sec)

175 General's Revenge Deion Branch (WR SEA) 2 min 14 sec (27 min 26 sec)

176 Touchdown Jesus Brady Quinn (QB CLE) 56 sec (19 min 3 sec)

177 The Bedford Wasps (Keeper) Jason Campbell (QB WAS)

178 Public Enemy Seahawks (DST SEA) 38 sec (22 min 59 sec)

179 Scarlet Knights Neil Rackers (K ARI) 15 sec (19 min 16 sec)

180 Brett Perriman's Posse Mark Clayton (WR BAL) 2 min 20 sec (59 min 14 sec)
Click to expand...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

miqws
Rookie RB WR opportunity value index
Replies
5
Views
433
miqws
miqws
Scoresman
2025 Shark Pool Rankings Contest - Taking Submissions - Consensus Rankings are here! Sort of...
Replies
11
Views
356
Scoresman
Scoresman
T
Which division would win?
Replies
0
Views
130
travdogg
T

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top