Dynasty WR Rankings - WR#3 (1 Viewer)

Duckboy · Feb 9, 2008

1. Larry Fitzgerald 8/31/83 33% [Wayne 28%]

2. Reggie Wayne 11/17/78 28% [Moss 15%] (WR1 and 2 used same poll)

I took a few options out that didn't get significant support from the WR#1 poll.

sheerterror · Feb 9, 2008

Randy Moss. He's not going to repeat his performance, but if he stays in NE no reason to believe he won't put up another few great seasons before calling it quits. There's a couple of other WRs I'd be more comfortable with over the AJ and Edwards.

ATRAIN56 · Feb 9, 2008

AJ and its not close

redman · Feb 9, 2008

Operating on the assumption that Moss remains in NE, then you can't not vote for him. If he leaves and goes anywhere but a handful of good passing teams, then I'd go with AJ.

FBGPoker · Feb 9, 2008

AJ at this point.

Moss is way too risky as we'll all heard the same things before about how so and so doesn't care about the money. Then the contract actually starts getting talked about and said player's outlook changes.

Very few players don't care about the money, and IMO Moss isn't one of them.

I also doubt NE would tag him as it would cause a scene that would blow up the team chemistry.

Yitbos69 · Feb 9, 2008

redman said:
Operating on the assumption that Moss remains in NE, then you can't not vote for him. If he leaves and goes anywhere but a handful of good passing teams, then I'd go with AJ.

I have to say that no matter where Randy ends up I like AJ more....and it's not close

Brewzers · Feb 9, 2008

redman said:
Operating on the assumption that Moss remains in NE, then you can't not vote for him. If he leaves and goes anywhere but a handful of good passing teams, then I'd go with AJ.

I with Redman. If Moss remains in NE he would be my hands down choice here (I voted him #1). Moss is an elite NFL WR and he will only be 31 next year.

sheerterror · Feb 9, 2008

ATRAIN56 said:
AJ and its not close

How is it not close? I'd like to see Johnson stay healthy for an entire season AND put up monster numbers - not one or the other, or else why would you want him as the anchor of your receiving corp over some much more consistent options?

awesomeness · Feb 9, 2008

sheerterror said:
ATRAIN56 said:

AJ and its not close

Click to expand...

How is it not close? I'd like to see Johnson stay healthy for an entire season AND put up monster numbers - not one or the other, or else why would you want him as the anchor of your receiving corp over some much more consistent options?

thats ATRAIN's shtick. All of his posts end with "and its not close". He realizes his shtick makes him sound like he didnt graduate out of secondary school, but he doesnt mind. So neither should we.

sheerterror · Feb 9, 2008

awesomeness said:
sheerterror said:

ATRAIN56 said:

AJ and its not close

Click to expand...

How is it not close? I'd like to see Johnson stay healthy for an entire season AND put up monster numbers - not one or the other, or else why would you want him as the anchor of your receiving corp over some much more consistent options?

Click to expand...

thats ATRAIN's shtick. All of his posts end with "and its not close". He realizes his shtick makes him sound like he didnt graduate out of secondary school, but he doesnt mind. So neither should we.

Touche.

redman · Feb 9, 2008

awesomeness said:
sheerterror said:

ATRAIN56 said:

AJ and its not close

Click to expand...

How is it not close? I'd like to see Johnson stay healthy for an entire season AND put up monster numbers - not one or the other, or else why would you want him as the anchor of your receiving corp over some much more consistent options?

Click to expand...

thats ATRAIN's shtick. All of his posts end with "and its not close". He realizes his shtick makes him sound like he didnt graduate out of secondary school, but he doesnt mind. So neither should we.

(and it's not close)

Crippler · Feb 9, 2008

Chad Johnson

Ketamine Dreams · Feb 9, 2008

Crippler said:
Chad Johnson

FUBAR · Feb 9, 2008

Crippler said:
Chad Johnson

should be included next round. Along with S.Smith TOColston Holt Boldin IMO, but can see where you'd leave them off

laxicoMarshall CalvinHoush

ratbast · Feb 9, 2008

FUBAR said:
Crippler said:

Chad Johnson

Click to expand...

should be included next round. Along with S.Smith TOColston Holt Boldin IMO, but can see where you'd leave them offlaxicoMarshall CalvinHoush

I might have taken SSmith, Colsten or Chad next.

Fear & Loathing · Feb 9, 2008

Steve Smith should definitely be included here.

Duckboy · Feb 10, 2008

AJ's had a pretty good lead for a while here, so I'll close this one. Adding SSmith, Colston, and Chad back for the next poll.

Dynasty WR Rankings - WR#3 (1 Viewer)

Who would you rank as the #3 dynasty WR?

Braylon Edwards - 2/21/83

Andre Johnson - 7/11/81

Randy Moss - 2/13/77

Other

IBL Representative

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Fruitcake

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

awesomeness

Guest

Footballguy

Footballguy

IBL Representative

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

Footballguy

IBL Representative

Similar threads

Users who are viewing this thread