What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dynasty QB Rankings- QB13 (1 Viewer)

Who would you rank as the #13 dynasty QB?

  • Derek Anderson (6-15-1983)

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • David Garrard (2-14-1978)

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Matt Schaub (6-25-1981)

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Phillip Rivers (12-8-1981)

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Matt Leinart (5-11-1983)

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Other

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    0
jeter23

jeter23

Footballguy
1. Peyton Manning, Colts (3-24-1976) 59% [brady 37%]

2. Tom Brady, Patriots (8-3-1977) 37% [Romo 3%] **QB1 and 2 used the same poll**

3. Carson Palmer, Bengals (12-27-1979) 44% [Romo 21%]

4. Drew Brees, Saints (1-15-1979) 43% [Romo 34%]

5. Tony Romo, Cowboys (4-21-1980) 50% [Roethlisberger 47%]

6. Ben Roethlisberger, Steelers (3-2-1982) 47% **Same poll used for QB5 and 6**

7. Jay Cutler, Broncos (4-29-1983) 29% [E Manning 18%]

8. Eli Manning, Giants (1-3-1981) 26% [McNabb 20%]

9. Donovan McNabb, Eagles (11-25-1976) 28% [Hasselbeck 26%]

10. Matt Hasselbeck, Seahawks (9-25-1975) 41% [bulger 25%]

11. Marc Bulger, Rams (4-5-1977) 28% [Young 20%]

12. Vince Young, Titans (5-18-1983) 26% [schaub 22%]

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Derek Anderson is EASILY the most underrated player in all of dynasty football. 3500 yards, 29 TD's, 19 Int's, only started 15 games, not to mention the Browns went 10-5 with him behind center. Guy is only 24, and has a very good, young, supporting cast. I know he fell off a bit during the end of the season, but he was playing in some bad weather.

 
Seriously... again, Schaub? Garard? Both have played only ONE very average season! Garard is 3 years older than Phil, and is in a "run-First" offense. Granted PR plays in a run-first as well, but it clearly opens it up much more to a passing game than does JAC! IMO this isn't even close - Phill by a mile! My rankings...

Rivers

Schaub

Leinart

Garrard

 
Burning Sensation said:
Derek Anderson is EASILY the most underrated player in all of dynasty football. 3500 yards, 29 TD's, 19 Int's, only started 15 games, not to mention the Browns went 10-5 with him behind center. Guy is only 24, and has a very good, young, supporting cast. I know he fell off a bit during the end of the season, but he was playing in some bad weather.
Click to expand...
Where's he playing next season? When does Quinn get a shot?I know things worked out for Brees, but that's not always the case.
 
Shaub I can see, but I don't understand all of the love for DA. His numbers were OK...but there are a ton of vey good arguments against him. DA comes with a ton of risk....but NOT a ton of potential reward. If he keeps his job, and his numbers are a good indication of his real talent (arguable, but possible), then he's still AT BEST hanging around the 10-12 spot. Too soon for this level of risk without more upside.

I like Garrard as an NFL QB, and he is very safe here, but his ceiling is too low compared to the others.

I went with Rivers, but I can see Shaub pretty easily.

 
Rivers is a horrible QB. This poll should be up in the air except for Rivers who should be last on the list without question.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
renesauz said:
Shaub I can see, but I don't understand all of the love for DA. His numbers were OK...but there are a ton of vey good arguments against him. DA comes with a ton of risk....but NOT a ton of potential reward. If he keeps his job, and his numbers are a good indication of his real talent (arguable, but possible), then he's still AT BEST hanging around the 10-12 spot. Too soon for this level of risk without more upside.

I like Garrard as an NFL QB, and he is very safe here, but his ceiling is too low compared to the others.

I went with Rivers, but I can see Shaub pretty easily.
Click to expand...
If DA keeps his numbers, he'll be top 6, since that's what he was this year. Depending on the exact scoring method, he was very close to Drew Brees and Ben this past season.He has excellent targets, a good offensive line, and a strong running game to back him. I see no reason why he won't be a solid fantasy QB this season. I do think he is overrated as a QB, but Cleveland will throw the ball a lot, and Winslow and Braylon are great targets.

On a side note, it is ######ed that someone like Vince Young is rated above QBs with actual NFL potential.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Burning Sensation said:
Derek Anderson is EASILY the most underrated player in all of dynasty football. 3500 yards, 29 TD's, 19 Int's, only started 15 games, not to mention the Browns went 10-5 with him behind center. Guy is only 24, and has a very good, young, supporting cast. I know he fell off a bit during the end of the season, but he was playing in some bad weather.
Click to expand...
And unless they build a dome this offseason, we can all expect more of this. Bad weather is just part of the equation here. I like DA and think he has alot of potential. But you have to factor in his contract situation too. Kind of hard to put him ahead of Rivers, Schaub, and Garrard, when we really don't know if he'll even be in Cleveland next year. If this poll was being done in 3-4 weeks, we might have a different view.
 
I was just reading this morning about how the Browns owner really wants Quinn to start playing soon. They didnt spend all that money on him to have him sit on the bench.

 
Get Schaub while you can, after this year everyone will know how good he and the Houston offense is.

 
Tick said:
Burning Sensation said:
Derek Anderson is EASILY the most underrated player in all of dynasty football. 3500 yards, 29 TD's, 19 Int's, only started 15 games, not to mention the Browns went 10-5 with him behind center. Guy is only 24, and has a very good, young, supporting cast. I know he fell off a bit during the end of the season, but he was playing in some bad weather.
Click to expand...
Where's he playing next season? When does Quinn get a shot?I know things worked out for Brees, but that's not always the case.
Click to expand...
When does a QB who threw for 29 TD's in his first year as a starter end up being replaced the following year by an uproven rookie, and not succeed on his new team?Speaking of DA's 29 TD passes in one year, guess how many total seasons with 29 or more TD passes each of these "top 10" QB's have?

Brady - 1 in 7 seasons

Palmer - 1 in 4 seasons

Brees - 0 in 6 seasons

Big Ben - 1 in 4 seasons

Hasselbeck - 0 in 9 seasons

Eli - 0 in 4 seasons

Mcnabb - 1 in 9 seasons

Bulger - 0 in 6 seasons

Thats 8 top 10 QB's, a total of 49 seasons, that have combined for a grand total of 4 seasons with 29 or more TD's, something Anderson did in his first full year.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Scoresman
2024 SoS Analysis - Why this metric is not very useful
Replies
1
Views
164
TheWinz
TheWinz
Yogibear
Yogi's 2025 Mock Draft (1st Round)
Replies
9
Views
707
Leroy Hoard
Leroy Hoard
socrates
Early 2025 Dynasty Rookie Draft Rankings (Single QB)
2 3
Replies
130
Views
14K
socrates
socrates

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top