What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dynasty WR Rankings - WR#21 (1 Viewer)

Who would you rank as the #21 dynasty WR?

  • Laveranues Coles - 12/29/77

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Jerricho Cotchery - 6/16/82

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Anthony Gonzalez - 9/18/84

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Santana Moss - 6/1/79

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Hines Ward - 3/8/76

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Wes Welker - 5/1/81

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Roddy White - 11/2/81

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Other

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    0
Duckboy

Duckboy

IBL Representative
1. Larry Fitzgerald 8/31/83 33% [Wayne 28%]

2. Reggie Wayne 11/17/78 28% [Moss 15%] (WR1 and 2 used same poll)

3. Andre Johnson 7/11/81 41% [Moss 29%]

4. Braylon Edwards 2/21/83 46% [Moss 29%]

5. Randy Moss 2/13/77 44% [Colston 23%]

6. Marques Colston 6/5/83 39% [sSmith 29%]

7. Steve Smith 5/12/79 46% [Chad Johnson 23%]

8. Chad Johnson 1/9/78 46% [Marshall 28%]

9. Brandon Marshall 3/23/84 51% [boldin 18%]

10. Anquan Boldin 10/3/80 31% [Calvin Johnson 17%]

11. Calvin Johnson 9/25/85 23% [Roy Williams 21%]

12. Roy Williams 12/20/81 28% [TJ Houshmandzadeh 23%]

13. Santonio Holmes 3/3/84 27% [TJ Houshmandzadeh 22%]

14. TJ Houshmandzadeh 9/26/77 32% [Greg Jennings 16%]

15. Torry Holt 6/5/76 [23-20% - tiebreaker with Owens and Jennings]

16. Terrell Owens 12/7/73 [23-20% - tiebreaker]

17. Greg Jennings 9/21/83 [23-20% - Plaxico Burress 11%]

18. Plaxico Burress 8/12/77 34% [Dwayne Bowe 28%]

19/20. Dwayne Bowe/Lee Evans [38% each - Wes Welker 8%]

If you vote other, please let me know who you would like added for the next poll.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I like Chris Chambers now. #1 on potent O that really gelled with Rivers down the stretch. And still many years left in him for dynasty.

 
duece2626 said:
Countdown until "James Hardy needs to be on this list"........ :wall:
Click to expand...
I know some will think it's nuts, but i'd take him over any of the guys listed right now.***edited to add that i'd probably take Roddy White over him, but after White i'd definitely go with Hardy.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
looks like another slugfest between 2 leaving everyone else in their dust. I like Cotchery as long as he starts gettting some looks in the endzone.

 
duece2626 said:
moderated said:
duece2626 said:
Countdown until "James Hardy needs to be on this list"........ :no:
Click to expand...
I know some will think it's nuts, but i'd take him over any of the guys listed right now.***edited to add that i'd probably take Roddy White over him, but after White i'd definitely go with Hardy.
Click to expand...
WOW!!
Click to expand...
Look at it this way, Hardy will go in the mid-late 1st round of rookie drafts.What players on that list could garner a mid-late 1st round rookie pick? Very few if any of those guys could in my dynasty leagues, outside of Roddy.
 
moderated said:
duece2626 said:
moderated said:
duece2626 said:
Countdown until "James Hardy needs to be on this list"........ :lmao:
Click to expand...
I know some will think it's nuts, but i'd take him over any of the guys listed right now.***edited to add that i'd probably take Roddy White over him, but after White i'd definitely go with Hardy.
Click to expand...
WOW!!
Click to expand...
Look at it this way, Hardy will go in the mid-late 1st round of rookie drafts.What players on that list could garner a mid-late 1st round rookie pick? Very few if any of those guys could in my dynasty leagues, outside of Roddy.
Click to expand...
take it a step farther. I'm in a salary/cap league and I cannot imagine anyone spending a mid first round pick on a rookie WR for the cost involved.
 
I like Cotchery best because of the combination of proven performance, age, and situation. But here you can start to go almost anyway with these guys.

If Ward and Coles can play another three years at their current levels they are hard to overlook==but they are getting old.

White had been abysmal and now had a break out year; new coach and system and can he do it again?

Moss has been up and down; I probably like him second best out of this group as he isn't that old yet and he has had several really solid years.

Welker IMO is totally situation. I don't like him going forward long term.

Gonzo I like but he hasn't proven enough to even be considered yet IMO. Show me a season of 800 yards at least before you get put at 21.

 
Welker may be a product of good system, but it doesn't mean the kid can't play. You guys are underrating him big time. He gets open, catches the ball well, has great moves after the catch, has Tom Brady throwing to him, has Randy Moss on the other side....

...As JPeso would say..."WAKE UP!"

 
King of the Jungle said:
Welker may be a product of good system, but it doesn't mean the kid can't play. You guys are underrating him big time. He gets open, catches the ball well, has great moves after the catch, has Tom Brady throwing to him, has Randy Moss on the other side.......As JPeso would say..."WAKE UP!"
Click to expand...
Maybe, but I want to see him have another year like this one. I will be surprised if he comes close. If he does, then he deserves to be in or near the top 20 dynasty WRs.His size, 5'9'' and 185 are borderline IMO and so that makes me even more leery and more interested in seeing him do it again.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
King of the Jungle said:
Welker may be a product of good system, but it doesn't mean the kid can't play. You guys are underrating him big time. He gets open, catches the ball well, has great moves after the catch, has Tom Brady throwing to him, has Randy Moss on the other side.......As JPeso would say..."WAKE UP!"
Click to expand...
For some reason I cannot knock my leeriness when it comes to Welker. In a PPR league, I wouldn't think twice of ranking Welker at the bottom of my top 25, but in my opinion, his upside is rather limited, especially in no-PPR. Teams started defending the Patriots differently as the year progressed, and so the offense adjusted. With guys like Evans, Bowe, and even Cotchery, there is a certain potential that Welker doesn't possess. What you see is what you get, and sometimes that causes owners to look elsewhere for the lightning in the bottle - even I am guilty. Another argument for Welker is the fact that he was productive at TT. If he came in to the league unheard of and had this one year, yes, I am skeptical. He did have 59 receptions for 3,069 yards and 21 touchdowns, as well as 559 yards rushing.
 
moderated said:
duece2626 said:
moderated said:
duece2626 said:
Countdown until "James Hardy needs to be on this list"........ :goodposting:
Click to expand...
I know some will think it's nuts, but i'd take him over any of the guys listed right now.***edited to add that i'd probably take Roddy White over him, but after White i'd definitely go with Hardy.
Click to expand...
WOW!!
Click to expand...
Look at it this way, Hardy will go in the mid-late 1st round of rookie drafts.What players on that list could garner a mid-late 1st round rookie pick? Very few if any of those guys could in my dynasty leagues, outside of Roddy.
Click to expand...
Really don't see Hardy that high in most drafts. I figure, there's 8 RBs that should go in the first, Ryan and maybe Brohm, is Hardy a top 2 rookie WR? I like the guy, but wouldn't put him above Thomas, Jackson, Doucet, or Kelly - maybe if he goes to a team with a good QB, but not right now. At best, I see Hardy as an early 2nd round pick in most leagues.OTOH, I'd easily trade a late 1st for anyone on this list.
 
Smizzy said:
Clemens didn't look in anyones direction. He rendered Cotch & Coles useless most of the game.
Click to expand...
Cotchery - 127 targets, 82 catches, 1129 yards, 2 TDs is hardly useless. Sounds like a bitter Jets fan in my opinion. Give Clemens time before you jump the gun and call for his head.
 
JPeso said:
Smizzy said:
Clemens didn't look in anyones direction. He rendered Cotch & Coles useless most of the game.
Click to expand...
Cotchery - 127 targets, 82 catches, 1129 yards, 2 TDs is hardly useless. Sounds like a bitter Jets fan in my opinion. Give Clemens time before you jump the gun and call for his head.
Click to expand...
I'm not bitter about anything. I actually watched the games. Every single snap of every single one of them and Clemens didn't target Cotch more than Coles. Coles was hurt for a couple games and Clemens looked for Justin McCareins just as much as Cotchery.I'm a die hard Jets fan and I own Jerricho Cotchery on my Main Dynasty team. I would trade him right now for Wes Welker without giving it a second thought.The Jets have a terrible o-line and a ? at QB. Cotchery was more productive with Penny throwing the football.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Even if you think Welker is a product of the system...the system isn't going anywhere for a long time.

That being said the guy is not a system player. He's a phemonenal slot WR who guys are going to downgrade because he's a little white guy. That's too bad because he's a great route-runner, with very reliable hands and he's absolutely fearless. He's only 26 years old (27 in May) and with the style he plays I see him being productive for quite sometime, especially as he and Brady get more and more comfortable with each other.

With Brady in his prime and a very good O line signed long term I just don't see how you can rank someone like Cotchery (who I think is a solid WR) over Welker when you compare the situation both WRs are in.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Boston said:
Even if you think Welker is a product of the system...the system isn't going anywhere for a long time. That being said the guy is not a system player. He's a phemonenal slot WR who guys are going to downgrade because he's a little white guy. That's too bad because he's a great route-runner, with very reliable hands and he's absolutely fearless. He's only 26 years old (27 in May) and with the style he plays I see him being productive for quite sometime, especially as he and Brady get more and more comfortable with each other. With Brady in his prime and a very good O line signed long term I just don't see how you can rank someone like Cotchery (who I think is a solid WR) over Welker when you compare the situation both WRs are in.
Click to expand...
I knew a guy who had a dog...and BINGO was his name-o
 
I don't get the Cotchery love, yeah he's a good WR but he's on the Jets!

You know that team that threw for 30 less TD's than the Patriots.

 
travdogg said:
I don't get the Cotchery love, yeah he's a good WR but he's on the Jets!You know that team that threw for 30 less TD's than the Patriots.
Click to expand...
He's finished in the Top 20 in PPR leagues two years in a row, and is only 26 years old. His TD #'s should improve (kinda hard to do worse than 2 TD's) and sometimes you have to look at the player and not the team he's on.
 
i went with cotch.

i thought about welker, but in dynasty, i downgrade patriots in general (except brady).

1-if he keeps putting up "star" statistics, i assume the patriots won't re-sign him

2-if any of us were good at forecasting what the pats will do offensively, randy moss wouldn't have made it to the 4th round in every draft. they flung it all over the field this season (and didn't win the SB), but i wouldn't be surprised at all if they went more ball control next year.

3-randy may be gone soon

i like welker's talent, but i wouldn't rest my dynasty hopes on my abilty to predict what the pats will do.

 
travdogg said:
I don't get the Cotchery love, yeah he's a good WR but he's on the Jets!You know that team that threw for 30 less TD's than the Patriots.
Click to expand...
my thought is, if he can be a productive young WR with jets then i can trust him to be productive over the course of his career no matter what his situation is.
 
pollardsvision said:
travdogg said:
I don't get the Cotchery love, yeah he's a good WR but he's on the Jets!You know that team that threw for 30 less TD's than the Patriots.
Click to expand...
my thought is, if he can be a productive young WR with jets then i can trust him to be productive over the course of his career no matter what his situation is.
Click to expand...
Productive but not great.I think Welker can be a borderline top-10 guy. I don't think Cotch can until he leaves NY.Edit to add: I agree with a previous poster that Walker should probably be on the next list.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would be pretty happy if any of these guys or the extras mentioned in this list like Driver, Chambers, Berrian, Walker where my 3 WR's in a 16 team league. Would work

 
went with Cotchery here. young and productive to this point. no reason to see why that would drop off. I like Welker here too though. You can say he's only productive because of the system he is in, but he is going to be in that system for a while and that can't be ignored.

 
Crotchrotty '07 / REC 82 / YDS 1129 / 2 TD's (and who is his QB next season?)

Welker '07 /.... REC 112 / YDS 1175 / 8 TD's (Moss will be back to once again free up Welker)

:thumbup:

 
Another 2 man race here. Cotchery and Welker will be 21/22 per tiebreaker; will add Javon Walker and Chris Chambers to the next round.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Scoresman
2024 SoS Analysis - Why this metric is not very useful
Replies
1
Views
164
TheWinz
TheWinz
Yogibear
Yogi's 2025 Mock Draft (1st Round)
Replies
9
Views
707
Leroy Hoard
Leroy Hoard
socrates
Early 2025 Dynasty Rookie Draft Rankings (Single QB)
2 3
Replies
130
Views
14K
socrates
socrates

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top