What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

[Dynasty] - RB #22 (1 Viewer)

Who would you draft as the #22 RB, standard FBG scoring

  • Kevin Jones DET 8/21/1982

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • DeAngelo Williams CAR 4/25/1983

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Brandon Jacobs NYG 7/6/1982

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • LenDale White TEN 12/20/1984

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Earnest Graham TBB 1/15/1980

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Other - WHO?

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Jamal Lewis CLE 8/29/1979

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    0
FUBAR

FUBAR

Footballguy
1. Adrian Peterson MIN 3/21/1985 75% (SJax 15%)

2. SJax STL 7/22/1983 44% (LT 41%)

3. LT SD 6/23/1979 (Addai 4%)

4. Addai IND 5/3/1983 72% (Westbrook 26%)

5. Westbrook PHI 9/2/1979 51% (Gore 12%)

6. Frank Gore SF 5/14/1983 36% (Lynch 23%)

7. Marshawn Lynch BUF 4/22/1986 29% (LJ 22%)

8a. Larry Johnson KCC 11/19/1979

8b. Clinton Portis WAS 9/1/1981

10. Maurice Jone-Drew JAX 3/23/1985 33% (MB3 15%)

11. Marion Barber III DAL 6/10/1983 36% (McGahee 13%)

12a. Reggie Bush NO 3/2/1985

12b. Ronnie Brown MIA 12/12/1981

12c. Willis McGahee BAL 10/21/1981

15. Willie Parker PIT 11/11/1980 28% (Grant, Maroney, McFadden 20%)

16. Laurence Maroney NE 2/5/1985 29% (Grant 26%)

17. Ryan Grant GB 12/9/1982 34% (D-Mac 28%)

18. Darren McFadden ROOK 8/27/1987

19a. Michael Turner, SD? 2/13/1982

19b. Jonathan Stewart, ROOK 3/21/1987

21. Rashard Mendenhall ROOK 6/21/1987

FUBAR said:
BTW, just so it's out there now, I won't be doing tiebreakers; if any RB is within 3% of the top choice, I'll be listing them as 8a and 8b (maybe even 8c)
Click to expand...
OTHERS that may be added next: Amhad Bradshaw, Jerious Norwood, Ray Rice, Edge, and Felix Jones
 
Last edited by a moderator:
D. Williams? I've been voting for Graham for about 5 picks now but D. Williams? Anybody watch Tampa Bay this year? D. Williams can put all his crummy seasons together and wouldn't look as good as E. Graham did this year.

D. Williams isn't in my top 25, dynasty, redraft,,,,,,just in my nightmares.

 
Iwannabeacowboybaby! said:
D. Williams? I've been voting for Graham for about 5 picks now but D. Williams? Anybody watch Tampa Bay this year? D. Williams can put all his crummy seasons together and wouldn't look as good as E. Graham did this year.D. Williams isn't in my top 25, dynasty, redraft,,,,,,just in my nightmares.
Click to expand...
Last year Graham averaged 4 yards per carry, Williams averaged 5. Graham is a 28 year old journeyman RB. Williams is a young first round pick. As of right now, both are their teams starting RB's, Williams is pretty much the only RB on the Panthers right now.
 
I'll take Jacobs as well. All these guys have question marks around their long-term value, so I'll take a guy I KNOW will get at least 15 carries and all of the goal line for the rest of his career.

 
JPeso said:
I'll take Jacobs as well. All these guys have question marks around their long-term value, so I'll take a guy I KNOW will get at least 15 carries and all of the goal line for the rest of his career.
Click to expand...
Thats why I did NOT take him, I think his career will be a very short one.
 
Burning Sensation said:
Iwannabeacowboybaby! said:
D. Williams? I've been voting for Graham for about 5 picks now but D. Williams? Anybody watch Tampa Bay this year? D. Williams can put all his crummy seasons together and wouldn't look as good as E. Graham did this year.D. Williams isn't in my top 25, dynasty, redraft,,,,,,just in my nightmares.
Click to expand...
Last year Graham averaged 4 yards per carry, Williams averaged 5. Graham is a 28 year old journeyman RB. Williams is a young first round pick. As of right now, both are their teams starting RB's, Williams is pretty much the only RB on the Panthers right now.
Click to expand...
I like Graham but went with Lewis. I'm just not sure Gruden won't try to bring in someone. I think Lewis has two very good years left. It's pretty close between the two for me.No way Williams gets my vote for a while. He couldn't even beat out Foster for the job and is only starting because they cut foster to save some cap space.
 
It looks like many have been bullied away from picking KJ any more, I'm still taking him. Being in Detroit I have watched just about all his games, his downfalls have been injuries, Mariucci, Martz, and the offensive line. If this was 10 years ago I would be more concerned with his injuries, look how he came back from the lisfranc, but with modern medicine and technology, players are bouncing back quick and just as strong. With Martz gone all signs are pointing to the Lions going to more of a power running game, and KJ is still a great threat in the passing game = a true 3 down back.

Before his injury this year he was being talked about as a top 12 RB in dynasty going forward, he is still only 26 years old.

 
I don't understand the hate for Lendale. He is a 1,000 yard rusher in only his second year and doesn't have much competition for the job.

 
AtomicDogg97 said:
I don't understand the hate for Lendale. He is a 1,000 yard rusher in only his second year and doesn't have much competition for the job.
Click to expand...
Probably the most pedestrian 1,000 yard rusher that DIDN'T have competition. 304/1108 for a 3.6 YPC. That screams replacement long-term, and at least competition.
 
JPeso said:
AtomicDogg97 said:
I don't understand the hate for Lendale. He is a 1,000 yard rusher in only his second year and doesn't have much competition for the job.
Click to expand...
Probably the most pedestrian 1,000 yard rusher that DIDN'T have competition. 304/1108 for a 3.6 YPC. That screams replacement long-term, and at least competition.
Click to expand...
:yes: Chris Brown had a 4.6 ypc. Henry had 3.8.White isn't a good receiver, while Henry has that potential. so, not the best runner on the team, not the best receiving RB, he lacks breakaway speed... not the recipe for future greatness.
 
FUBAR said:
footballguy#1 said:
Maybe Caddy should be added soon?
Click to expand...
I personally wouldn't just yet, but if others agree with you, this is a consensus, not just my thread.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't take him yet either, but I think it is almost time that he starts to enter the discussion. If he comes back healthy and regains his form from 06, he would easily warrant a pick in the mid 20's range. Definitely a question mark with him, but he does have some upside too.
 
footballguy#1 said:
FUBAR said:
footballguy#1 said:
Maybe Caddy should be added soon?
Click to expand...
I personally wouldn't just yet, but if others agree with you, this is a consensus, not just my thread.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't take him yet either, but I think it is almost time that he starts to enter the discussion. If he comes back healthy and regains his form from 06, he would easily warrant a pick in the mid 20's range. Definitely a question mark with him, but he does have some upside too.
Click to expand...
Of course this all changes if he doesn't play this year. I just read the other Caddy thread, didn't read that before I posted here.
 
footballguy#1 said:
footballguy#1 said:
FUBAR said:
footballguy#1 said:
Maybe Caddy should be added soon?
Click to expand...
I personally wouldn't just yet, but if others agree with you, this is a consensus, not just my thread.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't take him yet either, but I think it is almost time that he starts to enter the discussion. If he comes back healthy and regains his form from 06, he would easily warrant a pick in the mid 20's range. Definitely a question mark with him, but he does have some upside too.
Click to expand...
Of course this all changes if he doesn't play this year. I just read the other Caddy thread, didn't read that before I posted here.
Click to expand...
that's alright. At this point though, I might be more inclined to include Benson. :)
 
footballguy#1 said:
FUBAR said:
footballguy#1 said:
Maybe Caddy should be added soon?
Click to expand...
I personally wouldn't just yet, but if others agree with you, this is a consensus, not just my thread.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't take him yet either, but I think it is almost time that he starts to enter the discussion. If he comes back healthy and regains his form from 06, he would easily warrant a pick in the mid 20's range. Definitely a question mark with him, but he does have some upside too.
Click to expand...
Caddy seems like such a wild card to me. Personally I'd add him before Norwood. If I felt he were healthy enough to play this year(which shouldn't be ruled out) then I'd say he should be very close to Graham. With the injury uncertainty I'd add F.Jones, Bradshaw and maybe Edge before him.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
travdogg said:
Caddy seems like such a wild card to me. Personally I'd add him before Norwood. If I felt he were healthy enough to play this year(which shouldn't be ruled out) then I'd say he should be very close to Graham. With the injury uncertainty I'd add F.Jones, Bradshaw and maybe Edge before him.
Click to expand...
Come on trav, don't give me that "would have, could have." He didn't. He wasn't healthy. He hasn't been good since the first half of his rookie year. When he got injured, he was supposed to be ready by training camp, and now he miss the entire 08 season. Domanick Davis 2.0 is a strong possibility with this guy. Loads of talent, but derailed by injuries. I will take Norwood over Caddy any day of the week.
 
JPeso said:
travdogg said:
Caddy seems like such a wild card to me. Personally I'd add him before Norwood. If I felt he were healthy enough to play this year(which shouldn't be ruled out) then I'd say he should be very close to Graham. With the injury uncertainty I'd add F.Jones, Bradshaw and maybe Edge before him.
Click to expand...
Come on trav, don't give me that "would have, could have." He didn't. He wasn't healthy. He hasn't been good since the first half of his rookie year. When he got injured, he was supposed to be ready by training camp, and now he miss the entire 08 season. Domanick Davis 2.0 is a strong possibility with this guy. Loads of talent, but derailed by injuries. I will take Norwood over Caddy any day of the week.
Click to expand...
That's really not true about Caddy's rookie year. He finished just about as well as he started,his week 16 won me my league that year when Edge sat out. Plus he had like 4 very good games after week 8 that year.I agree(and am worried) about the possibility of him being another Davis. Though Davis had a long history of knee trouble dating back to college while this is Caddy's 1st major injury.There are at least 10 more guys(Caddy included) I'd take over Norwood. Norwood is kinda like Hester at WR, sure he'll make a big play eventually but he'll never be even remotely consistent or useful to a fantasy team.
 
I dont think this list is very accurate. In a startup dynasty draft I think all 3 rookies will be gone by the time the 15th RB is selected. I've seen people trading Lynch and MJD for the 1.3 rookie pick already.

 
Brutis said:
I dont think this list is very accurate. In a startup dynasty draft I think all 3 rookies will be gone by the time the 15th RB is selected. I've seen people trading Lynch and MJD for the 1.3 rookie pick already.
Click to expand...
WOW! I would never have a top-3 pick in that league.
 
Brutis said:
I dont think this list is very accurate. In a startup dynasty draft I think all 3 rookies will be gone by the time the 15th RB is selected. I've seen people trading Lynch and MJD for the 1.3 rookie pick already.
Click to expand...
Lynch AND MJD for the 1.03?!? That would be one of the worst trades I have ever seen. I agree the rooks are too low, but Lynch AND MJD for a guy who has proven nothing and does not even have his team decided yet?
 
Brutis said:
I dont think this list is very accurate. In a startup dynasty draft I think all 3 rookies will be gone by the time the 15th RB is selected. I've seen people trading Lynch and MJD for the 1.3 rookie pick already.
Click to expand...
Umm...who said that this list was meant to reflect initial dynasty? It was my assumption that it's a redraft list, in which case the rookies are probably TOO HIGH...and certainly impossible to accurately rank without knowing where they land.
 
renesauz said:
Brutis said:
I dont think this list is very accurate. In a startup dynasty draft I think all 3 rookies will be gone by the time the 15th RB is selected. I've seen people trading Lynch and MJD for the 1.3 rookie pick already.
Click to expand...
Umm...who said that this list was meant to reflect initial dynasty? It was my assumption that it's a redraft list, in which case the rookies are probably TOO HIGH...and certainly impossible to accurately rank without knowing where they land.
Click to expand...
[Dynasty] - RB #22
Click to expand...
:pickle:
 
renesauz said:
Umm...who said that this list was meant to reflect initial dynasty? It was my assumption that it's a redraft list, in which case the rookies are probably TOO HIGH...and certainly impossible to accurately rank without knowing where they land.
Click to expand...
sadly, I'm guessing that many voters are voting this same way. every poll has had DYNASTY in front of it. I dont think they were referencing the tv show.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Scoresman
2024 SoS Analysis - Why this metric is not very useful
Replies
1
Views
164
TheWinz
TheWinz
Yogibear
Yogi's 2025 Mock Draft (1st Round)
Replies
9
Views
707
Leroy Hoard
Leroy Hoard
Yogibear
Projected Week 18 Scores involving games with playoff implications
Replies
10
Views
1K
BobbyLayne
BobbyLayne

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top