Reggie Wayne 11/17/78 Wayne deserves consideration but I just don't see him as this elite.
Really depends on your time frame. Wayne is still Mannings #1 and will be for the next 3 years.
Andre Johnson 7/11/81 AJ is the most talented but he is ALWAYS getting hurt.
When he plays there are few better. Such as..
Randy Moss 2/13/77 Moss is best of all time of this group but he is too inconsistent and age is starting to show.
Inconsistent? Moss just made Cassell a LOT of money. Still the best there is period. With a healthy Brady back? How quickly Moss's record setting season has been forgotten. It happened in 2007.
Steve Smith Without Delhomme he is an average WR. Great speed and hands but not as complete a WR.

I don't know what SS would have to do to be considered a
complete WR. SS my ball skills are legendary.
Brandon Marshall 3/23/84 Youngest of this group (a fantasy consideration) who played hurt this year and who has been a very consistent top performer. I think he deserves strong consideration.
Still some questions about this guys attitude and work ethic. I think there are better options still before I would take Marshall.I voted for Moss. He should be ranked #1.