What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dynasty WR #6 (1 Viewer)

Who would you rank as the #6 dynasty WR?

  • Reggie Wayne 11/17/78

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Randy Moss 2/13/77

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Steve Smith 5/12/79

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Anquan Boldin 10/3/80

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Roddy White 11/2/81

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Marques Colston 6/5/83

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Dwayne Bowe 9/21/84

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Braylon Edwards 2/21/83

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Wes Welker 5/1/81

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Other

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    0
For me, this 4-10 range is VERY tough right now... there is little that separates any of this group from the next guy in the group. I went with Roddy because I like his relative youth, his QB situation on a going-forward-basis and White's overall skill set.

 
I went with Moss, but I'm very tempted to start considering Boldin here. He's still on the right side of 30 and I think he'll produce wherever he winds up. The guy is a playmaker, plain and simple.

ETA: I went with Moss because over the next 3 years, his floor is higher than pretty much anyone else that remains and he's the only remaining player with the potential to singlehandedly win you a title over that span. I see at least one more monster season from Randy before he begins his decline.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
thatguy said:
I went with Moss, but I'm very tempted to start considering Boldin here. He's still on the right side of 30 and I think he'll produce wherever he winds up. The guy is a playmaker, plain and simple.

ETA: I went with Moss because over the next 3 years, his floor is higher than pretty much anyone else that remains and he's the only remaining player with the potential to singlehandedly win you a title over that span. I see at least one more monster season from Randy before he begins his decline.
Click to expand...
If he didn't come with major durability issues I'd have him 6th.
 
mlball77 said:
For me, this 4-10 range is VERY tough right now... there is little that separates any of this group from the next guy in the group. I went with Roddy because I like his relative youth, his QB situation on a going-forward-basis and White's overall skill set.
Click to expand...
TDs seperates these elite WR from one another. Only one of them left has a floor of double digit TDs. Your a smart guy so I am sure you know who I am talkin about.
 
Biabreakable said:
mlball77 said:
For me, this 4-10 range is VERY tough right now... there is little that separates any of this group from the next guy in the group. I went with Roddy because I like his relative youth, his QB situation on a going-forward-basis and White's overall skill set.
Click to expand...
TDs seperates these elite WR from one another. Only one of them left has a floor of double digit TDs. Your a smart guy so I am sure you know who I am talkin about.
Click to expand...
TD production is an area where White fails to make a strong showing... this is an area he definitely needs to improve in. That conceded, Moss being 4-6 years older than most on this list doesn't concern you? Further, the 2009 QB situation isn't worrisome at all on the Moss front? With a healthy Brady, he is money... but will we see that in 2009?I like Moss a ton, but only 68 recs (in PPR) for 1008 yards with Cassel has me a bit concerned... and then the age thing on top of this. There are some question marks around Moss, in my view. But maybe I'm making more out of them than they actually merit...
 
mlball77 said:
Biabreakable said:
mlball77 said:
For me, this 4-10 range is VERY tough right now... there is little that separates any of this group from the next guy in the group. I went with Roddy because I like his relative youth, his QB situation on a going-forward-basis and White's overall skill set.
Click to expand...
TDs seperates these elite WR from one another. Only one of them left has a floor of double digit TDs. Your a smart guy so I am sure you know who I am talkin about.
Click to expand...
TD production is an area where White fails to make a strong showing... this is an area he definitely needs to improve in. That conceded, Moss being 4-6 years older than most on this list doesn't concern you? Further, the 2009 QB situation isn't worrisome at all on the Moss front? With a healthy Brady, he is money... but will we see that in 2009?I like Moss a ton, but only 68 recs (in PPR) for 1008 yards with Cassel has me a bit concerned... and then the age thing on top of this. There are some question marks around Moss, in my view. But maybe I'm making more out of them than they actually merit...
Click to expand...
Your points and others are valid.However Moss has prooven to produce despite the QB over and over again. Cassell being the most recent example. The only part of his career I would throw out is the Raider years when he clearly was not trying.I will take 3 years of Moss over anyone here and over anyone but Andre and Fitz.Maybe White or other players available here play well longer than Moss does and that certainly has to be factored in. The key to me here is will any of them outperform Moss over the next 3 years?I greatly doubt it.22 TD is a lot of points even in PPR (which I hate and my perspective is not based in that flawed scoring system).
 
Biabreakable said:
mlball77 said:
Biabreakable said:
mlball77 said:
For me, this 4-10 range is VERY tough right now... there is little that separates any of this group from the next guy in the group. I went with Roddy because I like his relative youth, his QB situation on a going-forward-basis and White's overall skill set.
Click to expand...
TDs seperates these elite WR from one another. Only one of them left has a floor of double digit TDs. Your a smart guy so I am sure you know who I am talkin about.
Click to expand...
TD production is an area where White fails to make a strong showing... this is an area he definitely needs to improve in. That conceded, Moss being 4-6 years older than most on this list doesn't concern you? Further, the 2009 QB situation isn't worrisome at all on the Moss front? With a healthy Brady, he is money... but will we see that in 2009?I like Moss a ton, but only 68 recs (in PPR) for 1008 yards with Cassel has me a bit concerned... and then the age thing on top of this. There are some question marks around Moss, in my view. But maybe I'm making more out of them than they actually merit...
Click to expand...
Your points and others are valid.However Moss has prooven to produce despite the QB over and over again. Cassell being the most recent example. The only part of his career I would throw out is the Raider years when he clearly was not trying.I will take 3 years of Moss over anyone here and over anyone but Andre and Fitz.Maybe White or other players available here play well longer than Moss does and that certainly has to be factored in. The key to me here is will any of them outperform Moss over the next 3 years?I greatly doubt it.22 TD is a lot of points even in PPR (which I hate and my perspective is not based in that flawed scoring system).
Click to expand...
I am very much with you that trying to consider the production of a player beyond 3 years is not really a worthwhile endeavor. And Moss probably has another couple big years left in the tank, should he decide to keep playing (trying) that long. Often youth is given far too much value in keeper and dynasty leagues, in my experience... and maybe I am falling victim to that sort of thinking when it comes to Moss (and even Wayne). But again, it's not age alone with Moss that has me concerned about his production in the next couple of years... Brady's health in 2009 will have a big impact on what Moss can produce. If I get a good feeling Brady will be fine in 2009, Moss climbs several spots up on the list for me.
 
mlball77 said:
Biabreakable said:
mlball77 said:
Biabreakable said:
mlball77 said:
For me, this 4-10 range is VERY tough right now... there is little that separates any of this group from the next guy in the group. I went with Roddy because I like his relative youth, his QB situation on a going-forward-basis and White's overall skill set.
Click to expand...
TDs seperates these elite WR from one another. Only one of them left has a floor of double digit TDs. Your a smart guy so I am sure you know who I am talkin about.
Click to expand...
TD production is an area where White fails to make a strong showing... this is an area he definitely needs to improve in. That conceded, Moss being 4-6 years older than most on this list doesn't concern you? Further, the 2009 QB situation isn't worrisome at all on the Moss front? With a healthy Brady, he is money... but will we see that in 2009?I like Moss a ton, but only 68 recs (in PPR) for 1008 yards with Cassel has me a bit concerned... and then the age thing on top of this. There are some question marks around Moss, in my view. But maybe I'm making more out of them than they actually merit...
Click to expand...
Your points and others are valid.However Moss has prooven to produce despite the QB over and over again. Cassell being the most recent example. The only part of his career I would throw out is the Raider years when he clearly was not trying.I will take 3 years of Moss over anyone here and over anyone but Andre and Fitz.Maybe White or other players available here play well longer than Moss does and that certainly has to be factored in. The key to me here is will any of them outperform Moss over the next 3 years?I greatly doubt it.22 TD is a lot of points even in PPR (which I hate and my perspective is not based in that flawed scoring system).
Click to expand...
I am very much with you that trying to consider the production of a player beyond 3 years is not really a worthwhile endeavor. And Moss probably has another couple big years left in the tank, should he decide to keep playing (trying) that long. Often youth is given far too much value in keeper and dynasty leagues, in my experience... and maybe I am falling victim to that sort of thinking when it comes to Moss (and even Wayne). But again, it's not age alone with Moss that has me concerned about his production in the next couple of years... Brady's health in 2009 will have a big impact on what Moss can produce. If I get a good feeling Brady will be fine in 2009, Moss climbs several spots up on the list for me.
Click to expand...
I swear, once Crabtree comes out, if he even gets close to 70 Rec & 900 yrds in 2009, he will instantly go up to top 8 as folks value youth in WR's too often... SS & Wayne are easily better than Marshall & Jennings... But i guess if you factor more than 3 yrs into your evaluation, you'll favor youth over production/situation every time
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

socrates
Early 2025 Dynasty Rookie Draft Rankings (Single QB)
2 3
Replies
129
Views
13K
socrates
socrates
TheWinz
When do the good WR's break out?
Replies
22
Views
2K
Biabreakable
Biabreakable
TheWinz
2023 OFFENSE/DEFENSE Contest - Week 10
2
Replies
74
Views
4K
heckmanm
heckmanm

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top