Dynasty WR #7 (1 Viewer)

jeter23

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #1

For ranking purposes, I am assuming PPR.

If you vote other, please let me know who you would like added for the next poll.

1. Larry Fitzgerald 8/31/83 65% (Cal. Johnson, 23%)

2. Calvin Johnson 9/25/85 60% (A. Johnson, 30%)

3. Andre Johnson 7/11/81 73% (Marshall, 12%)

4. Brandon Marshall 3/23/84 33% (Smith, 13%)

5. Greg Jennings 9/21/83 61% runoff (Smith, 39%)

6. Steve Smith 5/12/79 25% (Colston, 17%)

 

Last edited by a moderator: Feb 16, 2009

LBH

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #2

Colston again for me

 

ratbast

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #3

Took Colston because of his TD prowess, youth and team. I think Wayne, Moss and White could all fall in this tier, which in my opinion already includes AJ, Marshal, Smith and Jennings. 8 in the 2nd tier with 2 in the 1st.

 

gorf

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #4

pretty surprised boldin isn't getting more votes...

 

FavreCo

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #5

gorf said:

pretty surprised boldin isn't getting more votes...

Click to expand...

Status up in the air. Where would you rank him if he got traded to Jax. for instance. He wouldn't even be on my radar then.

 

fruity pebbles

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #6

I'll take Roddy White fairly easily. About on par with Greg Jennings imo.

 

Chunky Soup

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #7

FavreCo said:

gorf said:

pretty surprised boldin isn't getting more votes...

Click to expand...

Status up in the air. Where would you rank him if he got traded to Jax. for instance. He wouldn't even be on my radar then.

Click to expand...

Agreed, so why not hold these rankings a bit later? In a month or two these rankings could be turned nearly upside-down.

 

F

footballguy#1

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #8

Wayne for the money here.

 

JPeso

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #9

MC for the win.

 

bcr8f

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #10

Wayne.

 

vikingdave

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #11

Roddy all day...

Ryan to White for many years...

 

eric rymer

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #12

LBH said:

Colston again for me

Click to expand...

 

MAC_32

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #13

Randy Moss is nearing steal of the draft status.

 

M

moderated

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #14

vikingdave said:

Roddy all day...

Click to expand...

 

A

Ariakis

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #15

Went with Roddy ... MC has never been consistent enough for me. I think Wayne and Moss are too close in age although they should be coming up soon.

As I mentioned in a previous vote ... if we are ignoring TO then especially as the Welkers and Edwards of the world are mentioned it's time to atleast consider listing Roy Williams.

 

gorf

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #16

FavreCo said:

gorf said:

pretty surprised boldin isn't getting more votes...

Click to expand...

Status up in the air. Where would you rank him if he got traded to Jax. for instance. He wouldn't even be on my radar then.

Click to expand...

wouldn't even be on your radar? he's the #1 WR pretty much anywhere he goes (and realistically, you can take the "pretty much" qualifier out of there), was the #1 PPR WR this year, even missing games, and that was sharing with fitzgerald. granted, that cuts both ways.

 

P

puckalicious

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #17

If Colston is #7, then Moore should be #8 since he had about the same points per game as Colston last year. Further, Colston has never finished higher than 8th overall in non-PPR. Looking at the 2007 stats he might have been 9th in PPR?

 

comfortably numb

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #18

Considering many people thought I was nuts for trading my 1.1 pick for Colston, should we see Crabtree here already?

 

M

Mustang Man

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #19

fruity pebbles said:

I'll take Roddy White fairly easily. About on par with Greg Jennings imo.

Click to expand...

Me too, been voting for him sense 5

 

C

Crippler

IBL Representative

• Feb 15, 2009

• #20

Man this is preference time. I dont trade Boldin for any of these guys or the couple above him in a league where I own him. But than others would say the same about their guy. Apples for Oranges here.

 

jeter23

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #21

comfortably numb said:

Considering many people thought I was nuts for trading my 1.1 pick for Colston, should we see Crabtree here already?

Click to expand...

Thought about including him here. Crabtree and Royal soon?

 

Biabreakable

Footballguy

• Feb 15, 2009

• #22

Thanks for doing these jeter23.

For whoever said why don't we wait until after free agency we want to know what people think NOW. Everyone should be factoring in how free agency/draft/injuries/supporting cast might affect player value later.

A lot of people are going to be :( for passing on Moss.

 

A

Ariakis

Footballguy

• Feb 16, 2009

• #23

At this pont in the 6-15 range they are all pretty interchangeable. If your team is competing now then Moss and Wayne are worth more. If you are rebuilding then a younger player might top them. You could put Boldin 7th or 15th and noone would bat an eye.

 

gianmarco

Footballguy

• Feb 16, 2009

• #24

MAC_32 said:

Randy Moss is nearing steal of the draft status.

Click to expand...

 

B

broncofan13000

Footballguy

• Feb 16, 2009

• #25

this poll is quite close, lets keep it running for a bit

 

bcr8f

Footballguy

• Feb 16, 2009

• #26

Wow Greg Jennings above Wayne? That's a surprise.

 

B

Buckna

Footballguy

• Feb 16, 2009

• #27

gianmarco said:

MAC_32 said:

Randy Moss is nearing steal of the draft status.

Click to expand...

Click to expand...

Not at 32 years old he isn't. He's right around where he should be.

 

B

Buckna

Footballguy

• Feb 16, 2009

• #28

bcr8f said:

Wow Greg Jennings above Wayne? That's a surprise.

Click to expand...

I love Wayne but he is perpetually overrated. Only 3 finishes in the top 10 in 8 seasons and he's played nearly every game so no free passes for injury shortened seasons. On top of that, he's going to be 31 in November.