58 replies to this topic

[Jeff Pasquino]

FYI:

Dynasty Rankings

Keeper Help - FBG Futures (PPR)

[toppshelff]

Thanks Coach, nicely done.

[I was in the pool]

H.Miller higher on the TE list than Graham? That's criminal. He is #5 on my list for 2011 at this point.

[indyram96]

J. Simpson is available in my dynasty league. Should I drop Obomanu for him?
start 3 wr 1/2ppr, pt./10 yds rec.
other rec. are wayne, owens, garcon, nicks, s. smith(car), cruz

Edited by indyram96, 03 January 2011 - 06:39 AM.

[griff321]

Why so low on this years top scoring PPR RB's?

[eaglesfan7]

H.Miller higher on the TE list than Graham? That's criminal. He is #5 on my list for 2011 at this point.

Yeah, doesn't make much sense but opinions vary and it's good to view different opinions to create your own set of rankings.

[eaglesfan7]

J. Simpson is available in my dynasty league. Should I drop Obomanu for him?
start 3 wr 1/2ppr, pt./10 yds rec.
other rec. are wayne, owens, garcon, nicks, s. smith(car), cruz

Yes definitely. Do you have anyone else you could drop? Obomanu is okay but you may have someone else less valuable.

[Taskmaster]

J. Simpson is available in my dynasty league. Should I drop Obomanu for him?
start 3 wr 1/2ppr, pt./10 yds rec.
other rec. are wayne, owens, garcon, nicks, s. smith(car), cruz

[Taskmaster]

I just added him to my dynasty team. With Green getting the attention of the other teams top db simpson should be able to make a ton of big plays....even from a rookie. Listed as #2 wr so that would help too!

[bcbc]

First post and I'm already asking for help. I'm in a 10 team 6 player keeper league. 0.5 PPR. QB,WR,WR,RB,RB,TE,WR/RB,WR/RB,def,k. Which 6 of the following would you keep:

1. Philip Rivers
2. McFadden
3. Turner
4. Bowe
5. Mike Williams (TB)
6. ?

options:
Jason Witten
Jeremy Maclin

Thoughts are greatly appreciated. If I can work out a two for one trade I will, but not counting on it. Thanks!

[Jeff Tefertiller]

First post and I'm already asking for help. I'm in a 10 team 6 player keeper league. 0.5 PPR. QB,WR,WR,RB,RB,TE,WR/RB,WR/RB,def,k. Which 6 of the following would you keep:

1. Philip Rivers
2. McFadden
3. Turner
4. Bowe
5. Mike Williams (TB)
6. ?

options:
Jason Witten
Jeremy Maclin

Thoughts are greatly appreciated. If I can work out a two for one trade I will, but not counting on it. Thanks!

witten with the maclin illness worries

[oudixon]

I have a couple of questions regarding player I could "franchise." It is a PPR league.

In my league You are able to franchise a player in the round you drafted him for the following year(s).

I was wondering who you would draft or which has a better value out of the two choices below

I. Ray Rice in the sixth round or Darren McFadden in the 13th round.

This is for a friend who is in a similar predicament in another league again a PPR Keeper league. I am saying McCoy.

II Michael Vick in the 4th round or LeSean McCoy in the 14th round.

[NOstyle]

12 Team keeper league; non-PPR. All teams keep 1QB, and any combination of 5 RB/WR/TE (however we can only keep a max of 3 RB’s) and 1 K. There is no draft pick penalty associated with keepers and no min/max number of years you can keep a player. Start 1 QB, any combination of 5 (maximum of 3 RB’s and TE is not required), 1 K.
Scoring as follows QB: 1 pt for every 20 yds. passing RB/WR/TE 1 pt for every 10 yds. Touchdowns (QB/RB/WR/TE): 0-9 yds: 6 pts, 10-39 yds: 9 pts, 40+ yds: 12 pts. Field Goals: 0-39 yds: 3 pts 40-49 yds: 5 pts 50-59 yds: 10 pts 60+ yds: 12 pts Return Yards: 2 points for 40, and then 1 point for every 10 thereafter

My Keepers:
Ryan
Mendy, Wells
Dez, Steve Johnson, S. Rice
N. Kaeding

We do not have a separate rookie draft, but the top rookies usually go first in our draft. Players who will available when I pick at 1.3
Shonn Greene
Kenny Britt
AJ Green or Julio Jones
Which one would you take in a keeper league for long term?

[jimmypage]

I am in a 10 team 3-5 keeper league with standard scoring system.
flex allows a QB, so QB are worth a ton.

my 3 keepers are Arian Foster, Mike Williams and Dwayne Bowe and I have the first 2 picks in the draft. I am taking Stafford with the first pick and can choose between Ingram, Felix Jones, and Ryan Matthews for my other pick. We can keep 3-5 without limit to years, so the career of Ingram intrigues me to take him.

Lastly, my next pick should be a 2nd QB, thoughts on Mark Sanchez, Cutler, Cassel, Orton... maybe rank the 4...

[toppshelff]

I lost Jamal for the year, so I only have MJD and JStew as decent RBs and we can start up to 4.
PPR league, keep 4 each year.

I was offered Felix and Fred Davis for Cam Newton and Gresham.

My 2nd QB is Kolb (ugh, I know, but my strength is at WR (Calvin, Dez, SSmith (Car), etc.). My other TE is Finley, but we can start a TE as a flex.

I like the deal in the short term, but does Cam have serious keeper potential? Does Felix?

[rickyg]

Please see my trade querstion: http://forums.footba...pic=615827&st=0

[glock]

Where does a 30 year old "C+" keeper player like Fred Jackson fall now??

[Cipherchris]

Better keeper for the next 3 years: Baldwin or Little?

[beerbuff]

.5 PPR 2 player keeper with draft pick penalty. Get to keep 2 players. Slam dunk on the first one, DeMarco Murray in the 18th round but the question is who else to keep.

AJ Green- 12th round
Gronkowski- 9th round
Beanie Wells- 7th round
Marshawn Lynch- 7th round

Thoughts? TIA

[Jeff Tefertiller]

.5 PPR 2 player keeper with draft pick penalty. Get to keep 2 players. Slam dunk on the first one, DeMarco Murray in the 18th round but the question is who else to keep.

AJ Green- 12th round
Gronkowski- 9th round
Beanie Wells- 7th round
Marshawn Lynch- 7th round

Thoughts? TIA

i would prefer green and gronk over murray

[mrredskin]

When might we be looking forward to this year's version of the keeper tiers and rankings? Unfortunately it's time for me to build towards next year.

[FinHead]

12 team keeper league.
1 point for every 3 Passing Completions
1 point for every 25 Passing Yards
2 points for every 2 Pt Conversion
6 points for every Passing TD
-2 points for every Interception

I'm ending the season with Ryan, Schaub, Bradford, and Dalton
Keeping Ryan and either Bradford or Dalton.
Any thoughts? Thanks

[Jeff Tefertiller]

12 team keeper league.
1 point for every 3 Passing Completions
1 point for every 25 Passing Yards
2 points for every 2 Pt Conversion
6 points for every Passing TD
-2 points for every Interception

I'm ending the season with Ryan, Schaub, Bradford, and Dalton
Keeping Ryan and either Bradford or Dalton.
Any thoughts? Thanks

I like Dalton more but I may be in minority ... might look to trade both and keep the you get the least offered in return

[Terminator Stout]

.5 PPR 2 player keeper with draft pick penalty. Get to keep 2 players. Slam dunk on the first one, DeMarco Murray in the 18th round but the question is who else to keep.

AJ Green- 12th round
Gronkowski- 9th round
Beanie Wells- 7th round
Marshawn Lynch- 7th round

Thoughts? TIA

i would prefer green and gronk over murray

I would look at keeping D Murray and AJ Green. Gronkowski would also be a possibility.

[Terminator Stout]

12 team keeper league.
1 point for every 3 Passing Completions
1 point for every 25 Passing Yards
2 points for every 2 Pt Conversion
6 points for every Passing TD
-2 points for every Interception

I'm ending the season with Ryan, Schaub, Bradford, and Dalton
Keeping Ryan and either Bradford or Dalton.
Any thoughts? Thanks

I also have Dalton but not sure I am going to roster him as a keeper. May be available in the draft. I would also look for a trade.

[Cabby]

12 team H2H keeper auction league
Can keep 3 players for max 3 years
$200 salary
Rookie draft annually(3 rounds). Can keep many rookie keepers as we want. Can also franchise 1 player for $10(must be rookie pick)

I just won my league but traded away all my rookie picks next year. I am also losing Rodgers$4, Adrian peterson$50 and Calvin Johnson$20. I have chris Johnson$10, mike Williams $5 as rookie keepers( have 1 more year on contracts). So it's a rebuilding year. Possible keepers fro
This past draft include Cutler $10, Denarious Moore $6, Vareen $1, bill powel $2, Pierre Garcon $10, McGahee $10. Poor keepers but with my salary I was just adding pieces in hopes of winning this year. The question I have is should I try to trade chris Johnson for some rookie picks and if so what should I try to get? (rookies are valuable). Also, I know it's a long time till next year but do you think Peterson is someone you might get on the cheap with the injury . He may miss some games next year but if he can return to form would be nice to get him on The cheap. Thanks

[mikel0254]

I'm not sure if I missed it, but has the Footballguys Futures article for 2012 keepers come out yet?

[Abspara]

I'm not sure if I missed it, but has the Footballguys Futures article for 2012 keepers come out yet?

Ive not seen it

[Cripster]

In a dynasty format, 1 point per 10 yards, non-ppr, return yardage , who would you want:

1. Roddy White
2. Antonio Brown

[Jeff Tefertiller]

In a dynasty format, 1 point per 10 yards, non-ppr, return yardage , who would you want:

1. Roddy White
2. Antonio Brown

roddy

[craggt]

In a dynasty format, 1 point per 10 yards, non-ppr, return yardage , who would you want:

1. Roddy White
2. Antonio Brown

With return yardage I'd probably take Brown.

[mrredskin]

still no 2012 keeper league piece? last year's was developed nearly a month earlier, respectively.

[Jeff Tefertiller]

still no 2012 keeper league piece? last year's was developed nearly a month earlier, respectively.

Which article in particular are you seeking?

[mrredskin]

still no 2012 keeper league piece? last year's was developed nearly a month earlier, respectively.

Which article in particular are you seeking?

The FootballGuy Futures, like the one in the first post of this thread. Keeper info for next season

[Leroy Hoard]

In a keeper format, 1 point per 20 yards, non-ppr, no return yardage, which 2 would you want:

Roddy White
Nicks
Bowe
Dez Bryant

[Jeff Tefertiller]

In a keeper format, 1 point per 20 yards, non-ppr, no return yardage, which 2 would you want:

Roddy White
Nicks
Bowe
Dez Bryant

nicks and either dez or roddy depending how long of a viewpoint you take

[Cabby]

Hey Jeff, can you take a look at my post about 10 posts up. Thanks

[Jeff Tefertiller]

12 team H2H keeper auction league
Can keep 3 players for max 3 years
$200 salary
Rookie draft annually(3 rounds). Can keep many rookie keepers as we want. Can also franchise 1 player for $10(must be rookie pick)

I just won my league but traded away all my rookie picks next year. I am also losing Rodgers$4, Adrian peterson$50 and Calvin Johnson$20. I have chris Johnson$10, mike Williams $5 as rookie keepers( have 1 more year on contracts). So it's a rebuilding year. Possible keepers fro
This past draft include Cutler $10, Denarious Moore $6, Vareen $1, bill powel $2, Pierre Garcon $10, McGahee $10. Poor keepers but with my salary I was just adding pieces in hopes of winning this year. The question I have is should I try to trade chris Johnson for some rookie picks and if so what should I try to get? (rookies are valuable). Also, I know it's a long time till next year but do you think Peterson is someone you might get on the cheap with the injury . He may miss some games next year but if he can return to form would be nice to get him on The cheap. Thanks

Congrats on the championship. That is what matters. I would keep CJ and Williams as rookie keepers, then Moore, Garcon, and prob Willis even though he is way overprices and OLD. I would only trade Johnson if you can get a couple of very good, cheap players in return.

[solorca]

One of my leagues just switched to a keeper league this season, so we're kind of dipping our toes into the water with just two guys. We are allowed to keep them for only one season, then they are a free agent...so anything beyond next year doesn't help me. We can keep them at the price we paid in the draft. I have a few good options, with the following guys being considered...

1st rounder - Lesean McCoy
2nd rounder - Roddy White
6th rounder - Percy Harvin
9th rounder - Marshawn Lynch
17th rounder - Demarco Murray

I expect probably 10 RB's, 6 WR's, 2 TE's, and 6 QB's to be kept, give or take a pick or two. It's a fairly standard keeper league.

My gut says McCoy and Lynch, even though McCoy costs a first and Lynch is more expensive than Murray. Murray's pricetag is so nice though, it makes it tough.

Thoughts?

[Jeff Tefertiller]

One of my leagues just switched to a keeper league this season, so we're kind of dipping our toes into the water with just two guys. We are allowed to keep them for only one season, then they are a free agent...so anything beyond next year doesn't help me. We can keep them at the price we paid in the draft. I have a few good options, with the following guys being considered...

1st rounder - Lesean McCoy
2nd rounder - Roddy White
6th rounder - Percy Harvin
9th rounder - Marshawn Lynch
17th rounder - Demarco Murray

I expect probably 10 RB's, 6 WR's, 2 TE's, and 6 QB's to be kept, give or take a pick or two. It's a fairly standard keeper league.

My gut says McCoy and Lynch, even though McCoy costs a first and Lynch is more expensive than Murray. Murray's pricetag is so nice though, it makes it tough.

Thoughts?

mccoy is a gimme and i would prefer murray to lynch

[Gandalf]

I have a salary cap dynasty question for you. It is who would you sign and for how many years? We start 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR and 1 Flex.

He salary cap is a sliding scale. Total cap is $170. I'm thinking of signing he following players.

QB Tom Brady $18 for one year and plan to sign for 3-4 years at $23 to $25 annually.

RB Lesean McCoy $26 for one year and plan to sign for 5 years at $39 annually. Trent Richardson to a 10 year deal at $15 annually.

WR Julio Jones at $2. I can sign him for 10 years at $15 annually. And Justin Blackmon signed to a 10 year deal at $15 annually.

This gives me a lot to spend in the auction every year.

Thoughts?

G

[Jeff Tefertiller]

I have a salary cap dynasty question for you. It is who would you sign and for how many years? We start 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR and 1 Flex.

He salary cap is a sliding scale. Total cap is $170. I'm thinking of signing he following players.

QB Tom Brady $18 for one year and plan to sign for 3-4 years at $23 to $25 annually.

RB Lesean McCoy $26 for one year and plan to sign for 5 years at $39 annually. Trent Richardson to a 10 year deal at $15 annually.

WR Julio Jones at $2. I can sign him for 10 years at $15 annually. And Justin Blackmon signed to a 10 year deal at $15 annually.

This gives me a lot to spend in the auction every year.

Thoughts?

G

hey, I took a shot at this ? in the wannabee thread

[I was in the pool]

Auction Keeper League - $200 cap, 12 teams, 18-man rosters. PPR, start 1/1/2/1 with 2 RB/WR/TE flex positions. Salary for a keeper is +$5 then 10% for the following season. Here are players that could be considerations for keepers and their respective 2012 salary.

Brees - $33
Locker - $6.60

MJD - $48
Charles - $22
DMC - $20
B.Wells - $11
Spiller - $7
Q.Rodgers-$6.50

Dez - $23
Green - $18
Little - $7.50
D.Thomas- $7
Cobb - $6
Hankerson-$6

Graham - $13
Hernandez - $8

That's 16 potential players - I also have to roster the obligatory K and DEF. I could actually keep everyone but MJD and be $6 under the cap prior to the auction (would need K, DST, and 1 other player). I have to think that keeping this many players would be a detriment to mining value in the annual auction with potential rookies and that I project most other teams to have 5 or less viable keepers at a reasonable price.

In terms of past auction values in this league....

Top QBs can get into the low $40s (bottom of QB1's are usually around $10)

Top RBs over $50 ($20 is a middle of the road RB2)

Top WRs between $40-$45 (WR24 around $10-$15)

Top TEs between $20-$25, but maybe that changes with Graham/Gronk explosion (both likely to be kept in 2012 however).

[I was in the pool]

Auction Keeper League - $200 cap, 12 teams, 18-man rosters. PPR, start 1/2/3/1 with 1 RB/WR/TE flex. Salary for a keeper is +$5 then a 10% increase for the following season. Here are players that could be considerations for keepers and their respective 2012 salary.

M.Ryan - $11
Locker - $7

Best - $20
Ingram - $20
M.Bush - $14
Spiller- $8
Hunter - $8
Quizz - $6
Vereen - $6
Ridley - $6
D.Carter-$6

Julio - $16
Little - $12
Harvin - $9
S.Rice - $9
D.Thomas-$6
T.Young - $6
Baldwin - $6
Hankerson-$6
DHB -$6

Graham - $15

[I was in the pool]

Auction Keeper League - $200 cap, 12 teams, 18-man rosters. PPR, start 1/1/2/1 with 2 RB/WR/TE flex. Salary for a keeper is +$5 then a 10% increase for the following season. Here are players that could be considerations for keepers and their respective 2012 salary:

Locker - $6
Tebow - $6

Charles - $26
Ingram - $20
Spiller - $8
Vereen - $7
Ry.williams- $7
LeShoure - $7
Carter - $6
Rodgers - $6

A.J. Green -$13
S.Rice - $11
Garcon - $9
T.Smith - $7
Hankerson - $7
Cruz - $7
D.Thomas - $6

Thanks in advance for the advice.

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Auction Keeper League - $200 cap, 12 teams, 18-man rosters. PPR, start 1/1/2/1 with 2 RB/WR/TE flex positions. Salary for a keeper is +$5 then 10% for the following season. Here are players that could be considerations for keepers and their respective 2012 salary.

Brees - $33
Locker - $6.60

MJD - $48
Charles - $22
DMC - $20
B.Wells - $11
Spiller - $7
Q.Rodgers-$6.50

Dez - $23
Green - $18
Little - $7.50
D.Thomas- $7
Cobb - $6
Hankerson-$6

Graham - $13
Hernandez - $8

That's 16 potential players - I also have to roster the obligatory K and DEF. I could actually keep everyone but MJD and be $6 under the cap prior to the auction (would need K, DST, and 1 other player). I have to think that keeping this many players would be a detriment to mining value in the annual auction with potential rookies and that I project most other teams to have 5 or less viable keepers at a reasonable price.

In terms of past auction values in this league....

Top QBs can get into the low $40s (bottom of QB1's are usually around $10)

Top RBs over $50 ($20 is a middle of the road RB2)

Top WRs between $40-$45 (WR24 around $10-$15)

Top TEs between $20-$25, but maybe that changes with Graham/Gronk explosion (both likely to be kept in 2012 however).

Toss back MJD, Quizz, Little and Hankerson.

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Auction Keeper League - $200 cap, 12 teams, 18-man rosters. PPR, start 1/2/3/1 with 1 RB/WR/TE flex. Salary for a keeper is +$5 then a 10% increase for the following season. Here are players that could be considerations for keepers and their respective 2012 salary.

M.Ryan - $11
Locker - $7

Best - $20
Ingram - $20
M.Bush - $14
Spiller- $8
Hunter - $8
Quizz - $6
Vereen - $6
Ridley - $6
D.Carter-$6

Julio - $16
Little - $12
Harvin - $9
S.Rice - $9
D.Thomas-$6
T.Young - $6
Baldwin - $6
Hankerson-$6
DHB -$6

Graham - $15

I would drop Ingram, QUizz, Carter and Vereen. Ridley is questionable and I would lean toward dropping him. Also, I would drop Little, Young, and Hankerson. I like most of these guys but the roster space is tight.

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Auction Keeper League - $200 cap, 12 teams, 18-man rosters. PPR, start 1/1/2/1 with 2 RB/WR/TE flex. Salary for a keeper is +$5 then a 10% increase for the following season. Here are players that could be considerations for keepers and their respective 2012 salary:

Locker - $6
Tebow - $6

Charles - $26
Ingram - $20
Spiller - $8
Vereen - $7
Ry.williams- $7
LeShoure - $7
Carter - $6
Rodgers - $6

A.J. Green -$13
S.Rice - $11
Garcon - $9
T.Smith - $7
Hankerson - $7
Cruz - $7
D.Thomas - $6

Thanks in advance for the advice.

I would drop Ingram, Vereen, Carter and Rodgers ... along with Hankerson. You need to make space for a QB upgrade

[Drezden]

Santonio Holmes in PPR ? I need WR help and Holmes owner offering me Santonio Holmes for 1.08 OR Holmes -Helu ???
Would you do any of this two for Holmes ? Thanks

[Fire the Fat Man]

Auction Keeper League - $288 cap, 10 teams, 18-man rosters. PPR, start 1/2/3/1 with 1 RB/WR/TE flex positions.

Stafford - $7
Romo - $15

DeMarco Murray - $6
Delone Carter - $6

Dez - $42
Welker - $16
Julio Jones - $11
Little - $4
David Nelson- $3


Owen Daniels - $9
Fred Davis - $3

Total spent $122, free $166

Rookie picks 1.5, 2.5, 3.5

Trade Offered to me:

I give: Stafford

I receive: Sproles and pick 1.9

I would receive a much needed running back in return and pick 1.9 would probably land me Wright or Polk (1.5 i would take Martin)

It should also be noted I have by far the most in FA to spend. Notable FA's available:

McFadden (i would get him)
Steven Jackson
Turner
Gore
Lynch
Redman
Best

Cruz
Steve Smith (car)
Vincet Jackson
Antonio Brown
Wayne
Lloyd

So with by far the most FA $ to spend and those notable FA's to bid on, would you make that trade???