Rank the 2012 Rookies: Late August Polls (1 Viewer)

I am curious what the Shark Pool thinks about this year's rookies now, so let's have one last round of polls before the season starts. We'll do this rapid-fire style, with a new post each day and 3 polls per post. Vote in all 3, and pick a different player in each one.

Bump. 20 votes so far.

I'm closing this poll now, with 30 votes, and putting up the poll for picks 4-6. #1 & #2 are runaways; 3 is close between Griffin & Martin but as a quick-and-dirty poll this is good enough. The results are:

1. Trent Richardson 57%

2. Andrew Luck 54%

3. Robert Griffin III 36%

In deciding #2, I'm giving Luck the votes for him at #1 (since I assume that those people would've voted for him again at #2 once Richardson was off the board) and the votes for him at #2, and the same for everyone else. Luck gets 14 of the 28 non-Richardson votes at #2, and 8 of the 13 non-Richardson votes at #1, for a total of 22/41 = 54% of the vote once Richardson is off the board. Similarly for Griffin at #3. It's not a perfect way to run a poll, but it's good enough.

Interesting to note that Doug Martin is now the choice for the #3 rookie pick now with a few more votes!