Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Vilma
Footballguys Forums > Our Forums > IDP Forum > IDP Assistant Coach
djb916420
Dynasty PPR league
I'm in need of some LB's and have quite a bit of DB depth.
I give:
Deangelo Hall/1.08
for
Vilma/8th rounder

2pt tackles
1pt assist
3pt INT
3pt sacks
1pt PD

TIA
Jene Bramel
If you don't get points for PD, Hall is a replacement level talent and, I'm assuming, wouldn't have any trade value other than as a throw-in -- as I'm also assuming the 8th rounder would be. So, it becomes the 1.08 for Vilma.

For me, a potential mid LB1+ for a late first rounder is a gimme. That's the best you can hope for with a rookie IDP in that slot. Of course, your league might be one that regularly leaves nice offensive talent at 1.08. I routinely make trades like this because I'd rather have the sure thing (IDP or otherwise) over the crapshoot that much of the Tier 1A offensive players become.
djb916420
QUOTE (Jene Bramel @ Mar 27 2008, 11:19 AM) *
If you don't get points for PD, Hall is a replacement level talent and, I'm assuming, wouldn't have any trade value other than as a throw-in -- as I'm also assuming the 8th rounder would be. So, it becomes the 1.08 for Vilma.

For me, a potential mid LB1+ for a late first rounder is a gimme. That's the best you can hope for with a rookie IDP in that slot. Of course, your league might be one that regularly leaves nice offensive talent at 1.08. I routinely make trades like this because I'd rather have the sure thing (IDP or otherwise) over the crapshoot that much of the Tier 1A offensive players become.

sorry, 1 point per PD..
In 05' Vilma put up 322 points in this league(6th overall)
Hall put up 166 in 06, 189 in 07'
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.