Hi, I need to choose 3 out of these 6 for the year. The scoring is:


Tackle Solo (2.5)
Tackle Assist (1.25)
Sack (4)
Interception (4)
Fumble Force (1)
Fumble Recovery (2)
Touchdown (6)
Safety (6)
Pass Defended (2.5)
Block Kick (4)

Barrett Ruud
David Harris
Curtis Lofton
Karlos Dansby
Jonathon Vilma
Lance Briggs

David Harris
Jonathan Vilma
Lance Briggs
-
-
-
Barrett Ruud
Karlos Dansby
-
-
Curtis Lofton

Tackle heavy I go Harris, Vilma, Ruud.

I would definitely want Vilma and Harris. After that, I have Briggs and Ruud rated basically even, so it's personal preference there, but it would be one of the two, with a very slight edge to Briggs.

David Harris are Barrett Ruud are clear keepers. Then, it helps to consider how many you'll start each week and whether you're in a dynasty situation. Since the three players you'll be cutting will be on the wire, I'd guess that it's a deep free agent list. Given that fact, I'd take Vilma's higher upside. If you'd prefer a safer bet, Briggs would be the choice. Lofton is a consideration only if you start one backer (or two) and are in a dynasty league with a very solid roster overall.

Harris, Ruud, Vilma in dynasty. Briggs can replace one of Vilmaor Ruud in redraft if you prefer.

How many do you start, and depending on that answer, you might want to look into trades.

Thank you for the responses. I will be starting 2 out of the 3 and it is a redraft league.

I would look into trading one of them if a team is needy. If not, I'll stick with my above answer. You should be in very good shape regardless. Good luck.

Thanks. I was offered trades. With my scoring system, should I trade Briggs for Ernie Sims or Lofa Tatupu

I'd trade Briggs for Tatupu, but only after checking on Tatupu's injury status.

I like Harris Ruud Briggs - used to love Vilma...but now am afraid of his injury.