1 point for 10 yards KR/PR.
2 pt solo tackles, 1 assisted tackle
2 pt pass defended
4 pt for sacks
Bob Sanders vs Chicago
Chris Carr vs Jacksonville
As you can see, my league rewards big or returns. What I'm trying to find out is if Carr returning both PR/KR will outperform Bob Sanders. I'm not sure if Chicago's offense can stay on the field long enough to give Bob enough chances and I'm not sure if Jacksonville will score fast enough to give Carr enough returns.
Full Version: Which DB to start? Bob Sanders vs Chris Carr
QUOTE (drew726 @ Sep 4 2008, 01:14 PM) 
1 point for 10 yards KR/PR.
2 pt solo tackles, 1 assisted tackle
2 pt pass defended
4 pt for sacks
Bob Sanders vs Chicago
Chris Carr vs Jacksonville
As you can see, my league rewards big or returns. What I'm trying to find out is if Carr returning both PR/KR will outperform Bob Sanders. I'm not sure if Chicago's offense can stay on the field long enough to give Bob enough chances and I'm not sure if Jacksonville will score fast enough to give Carr enough returns.
2 pt solo tackles, 1 assisted tackle
2 pt pass defended
4 pt for sacks
Bob Sanders vs Chicago
Chris Carr vs Jacksonville
As you can see, my league rewards big or returns. What I'm trying to find out is if Carr returning both PR/KR will outperform Bob Sanders. I'm not sure if Chicago's offense can stay on the field long enough to give Bob enough chances and I'm not sure if Jacksonville will score fast enough to give Carr enough returns.
Unfortunately, I don't follow these numbers enough to answer this question. My guess would be that Sanders is a threat to make five solos easily and has 7-2 upside with a PD or sack thrown in. I have no idea of Carr's status as a KR/PR or whether he's a lock to get 100 return yards at minimum and 150-170 yards to feel comfortable starting him over Sanders.
Mike Herman puts together a weekly analysis of returners on Thursdays in his Returnerguys column. There may be some help there later today.
QUOTE (Jene Bramel @ Sep 4 2008, 02:09 PM)
QUOTE (drew726 @ Sep 4 2008, 01:14 PM)
1 point for 10 yards KR/PR.
2 pt solo tackles, 1 assisted tackle
2 pt pass defended
4 pt for sacks
Bob Sanders vs Chicago
Chris Carr vs Jacksonville
As you can see, my league rewards big or returns. What I'm trying to find out is if Carr returning both PR/KR will outperform Bob Sanders. I'm not sure if Chicago's offense can stay on the field long enough to give Bob enough chances and I'm not sure if Jacksonville will score fast enough to give Carr enough returns.
2 pt solo tackles, 1 assisted tackle
2 pt pass defended
4 pt for sacks
Bob Sanders vs Chicago
Chris Carr vs Jacksonville
As you can see, my league rewards big or returns. What I'm trying to find out is if Carr returning both PR/KR will outperform Bob Sanders. I'm not sure if Chicago's offense can stay on the field long enough to give Bob enough chances and I'm not sure if Jacksonville will score fast enough to give Carr enough returns.
Unfortunately, I don't follow these numbers enough to answer this question. My guess would be that Sanders is a threat to make five solos easily and has 7-2 upside with a PD or sack thrown in. I have no idea of Carr's status as a KR/PR or whether he's a lock to get 100 return yards at minimum and 150-170 yards to feel comfortable starting him over Sanders.
Mike Herman puts together a weekly analysis of returners on Thursdays in his Returnerguys column. There may be some help there later today.
What he said.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.