Chase Stuart
Footballguy
Let's get the basic analysis out of the way: theJets are better than the Colts in three of the four quarters of the game.
Jets pass defense > Colts pass defense
Jets rush defense > Colts rush defense
Jets rush offense > Colts rush offense
Colts pass offense > Jets pass offense
Alternatively, looking at matchups:
Jets pass defense vs. Colts pass offense = push/slight edge Jets
Jets rush defense vs. Colts rush offense = huge edge Jets
Colts pass defense vs. Jets offense = big edge Colts
Colts rush defense vs. Jets rush offense = big edge Jets
It would be too simple to say the Colts are a one man team, but they are a largely one-dimensional team. They pass very well, and it's not just Manning. I'm unimpressed with their OL, but I think Manning does a fantastic job covering for them before and after the snap. Pre-snap he knows how to redirect his receivers based on what the defense is showing and post-snap he processes things quickly, has fantastic arm strength and accuracy and a quick release. He went over 150 snaps without taking a sack earlier this year, and that's the basic reason why the Colts won so many games despite not being able to run. Manning and this Colts offense, perhaps more than any offense in NFL history, uses the passing game to move the chains.
Three of the top five teams in passing first downs per pass attempt are the '04, '06 and '05 Colts, with the first two teams being the top two in league history. This year's edition comes in a little lower than that, although through 15 weeks the Colts would have bumped the '05 Colts out of the top five. The takeaway? This team can pass efficiency and consistently well.
On the other hand, the Colts are not a big play offense. They don't make big plays. Wayne, Clark and Collie all average fewer than 13 yards per catch. How do they match up with the Jets? Wayne is a huge part of the offense, and obviously he's going to have a tough time getting any action against Revis. It's worth remember that in the first matchup, Manning was particularly cautious around Revis. He kept throwing low and outside, or high and outside, when throwing at Revis; he respects Revis, but in the first matchup he almost gave him too much respect by throwing very difficult balls towards Wayne.
Clark is the key for the offense. The first 100 catch, 10 TD TE in league history, will the Jets be able to contain him? Leonard and Rhodes are going to have their hands full, although they had good practice going against Gates last week. I expect Clark to lead the team in receptions and probably receiving yards, so it will depend on how well the Jets handle him. He's particularly tough to cover on short routes and Manning will find him; it will be up to the Jets to force 3rd and longs to require Clark to have to make more difficult catches to move the sticks.
Offensively, the Jets are a known quantity. They're going to do what they do, and that's run the ball out of power sets. I don't know if the Colts will be able to withstand the Jets push for four quarters, and that's going to be the key to the game. These two teams are polar opposites of each other -- both play much better with the lead than from behind, but for different reasons. The Colts are great when playing ahead because they have two great edge rushers and have Manning to pass to run the clock out. The Colts D is much better against the pass than the run and the Colts run D can get worn down, which is the Jets run O's specialty. The Jets play much better with the lead, too, because they have a running game that leans on you until you collapse, and because they can't pass. The Jets also have a much better pass D than run D.
One of the Colts big edges is HFA, but I think the Jets are very fortunate to have played at Lucas Oil already this season. That will help tremendously with knowing how the stadium plays, and it might help the Jets get out to a quick start, which leads me to:
1. Get out to a fast start. The Jets won't give up on their running game; Schottenheimer brings back visions of Denzel Washington -- it's like Novocaine; just give it time it always works. But the lead is crucial in this game, as both teams prefer to dictate things from ahead. The difference is, the Colts actually can come from behind, as evidenced by their 7 4th quarter comebacks this season. The Jets know this, and I expect some trickery early on, whether it's a flea flicker, a fake punt, Brad Smith, or a no-huddle passing offense. The Jets need to manufacture points early. This means passing early.
2. Go for it on 4th down in the red zone. 4th and 2 on the Colts 12? 4th and goal from the 1? 4th and 3 from the 8? Go for it, go for it, go for it. Three points is meaningless against the Colts, and you're not going to beat them by kicking field goals. This should dictate the Jets strategy in the earlier downs, as once they get inside the red zone, four runs has a much better chance to get a first down than two runs and a pass. If the Jets have three trips into the red zone, they need at least 14 points out of those trips. Against the Colts, you must be aggressive.
3. Shut down the run consistently. This should be easy, right? In '08, the Colts ranked 32st in YPC and 31st in rushing yards; this season, they ranked 32nd in rushing yards and 30th in YPC. Indianapolis can't run, but it's important not just to contain the rushing game, but shutting it down. Against SD, the Chargers rushed 18 times for 61 yards; throw out the draw plays against a prevent defense in the final seconds of the first half, and that's 30 yards on 16 carries for fewer than 2 YPC. The Jets run D is good but not great, but they played terrifically against the run on Sunday. By shutting down the Colts rush offense to the tune of 2 YPC you make them one dimensional. The Colts passing offense is great but not unstoppable; the Chargers passing offense was just as, if not more elite. But by making them so one dimensional, the Jets were able to really play to their strengths. Not only did they make SD pass more often (since they couldn't run) but they passed in worse down and distance situations.
If the Colts, with Wayne being blanketed by Revis, are forced to pass consistently on 2nd and 3rd and longs, this game could get out of hand. With the exotic blitzes Ryan brings and the opportunistic pass defense, the Jets could get seven or eight big plays (sacks/fumbles/INTs) and dominate the game. By selling out to stopping the run, and making the Colts forced to not only play to the Jets strength but do it without their #1 receiver, the Jets4 should be able to dictate the pace of the game.
4. Put the game on the shoulders of Faneca, Mangold and Moore. The Jets interior linemen are powerful, tough and love to have the game on their shoulders. The Jets should be able to push the Colts back, and if they can get a lead early, it's important to just stick with the power running game. The Colts are not going to want to be tackling Greene and Jones by the 4th quarter, just like most teams this year.
5. Watch out for the cheap scores at the end of the half. Against Baltimore, the Colts got a "cheap" TD Indy at the end of the first half that changed the whole game. The Chargers almost did the same thing to the Jets. I suspect the Jets pass defense will contain the Colts most of the time, but in that hurry up offense the Colts are very tough to stop. By keeping an eye on the clock and playing "2 for 1" or just draining the time, the Jets can avoid giving the Colts some free points.
Prediction
The Colts have played with fire all season. Sure, they've won 15 straight games that Manning has finished, but over half of them came by one score. The Colts haven't laid the hammer to teams, and it's not by choice; they're a good but not great team that lacks the ability to stop the run consistently, can't always get off the field defensively, and is an offense that requires perfection to succeed. They can't run consistently, and they need to manufacture several first downs to score TDs -- they don't score touchdowns in two plays very often.
Manning may appear to be like a robot, but you simply can't count on always being able to win games in that fashion. At some point you need your defense or your running game to take over for a half, or you need some big plays on offense. Against the Jets, I don't see any of those things happening. Look for the Jets to take the lead early, Manning and the Colts to come back, before imploding on both sides of the ball in the fourth quarter.
Jets 28, Colts 13
Jets pass defense > Colts pass defense
Jets rush defense > Colts rush defense
Jets rush offense > Colts rush offense
Colts pass offense > Jets pass offense
Alternatively, looking at matchups:
Jets pass defense vs. Colts pass offense = push/slight edge Jets
Jets rush defense vs. Colts rush offense = huge edge Jets
Colts pass defense vs. Jets offense = big edge Colts
Colts rush defense vs. Jets rush offense = big edge Jets
It would be too simple to say the Colts are a one man team, but they are a largely one-dimensional team. They pass very well, and it's not just Manning. I'm unimpressed with their OL, but I think Manning does a fantastic job covering for them before and after the snap. Pre-snap he knows how to redirect his receivers based on what the defense is showing and post-snap he processes things quickly, has fantastic arm strength and accuracy and a quick release. He went over 150 snaps without taking a sack earlier this year, and that's the basic reason why the Colts won so many games despite not being able to run. Manning and this Colts offense, perhaps more than any offense in NFL history, uses the passing game to move the chains.
Three of the top five teams in passing first downs per pass attempt are the '04, '06 and '05 Colts, with the first two teams being the top two in league history. This year's edition comes in a little lower than that, although through 15 weeks the Colts would have bumped the '05 Colts out of the top five. The takeaway? This team can pass efficiency and consistently well.
On the other hand, the Colts are not a big play offense. They don't make big plays. Wayne, Clark and Collie all average fewer than 13 yards per catch. How do they match up with the Jets? Wayne is a huge part of the offense, and obviously he's going to have a tough time getting any action against Revis. It's worth remember that in the first matchup, Manning was particularly cautious around Revis. He kept throwing low and outside, or high and outside, when throwing at Revis; he respects Revis, but in the first matchup he almost gave him too much respect by throwing very difficult balls towards Wayne.
Clark is the key for the offense. The first 100 catch, 10 TD TE in league history, will the Jets be able to contain him? Leonard and Rhodes are going to have their hands full, although they had good practice going against Gates last week. I expect Clark to lead the team in receptions and probably receiving yards, so it will depend on how well the Jets handle him. He's particularly tough to cover on short routes and Manning will find him; it will be up to the Jets to force 3rd and longs to require Clark to have to make more difficult catches to move the sticks.
Offensively, the Jets are a known quantity. They're going to do what they do, and that's run the ball out of power sets. I don't know if the Colts will be able to withstand the Jets push for four quarters, and that's going to be the key to the game. These two teams are polar opposites of each other -- both play much better with the lead than from behind, but for different reasons. The Colts are great when playing ahead because they have two great edge rushers and have Manning to pass to run the clock out. The Colts D is much better against the pass than the run and the Colts run D can get worn down, which is the Jets run O's specialty. The Jets play much better with the lead, too, because they have a running game that leans on you until you collapse, and because they can't pass. The Jets also have a much better pass D than run D.
One of the Colts big edges is HFA, but I think the Jets are very fortunate to have played at Lucas Oil already this season. That will help tremendously with knowing how the stadium plays, and it might help the Jets get out to a quick start, which leads me to:
1. Get out to a fast start. The Jets won't give up on their running game; Schottenheimer brings back visions of Denzel Washington -- it's like Novocaine; just give it time it always works. But the lead is crucial in this game, as both teams prefer to dictate things from ahead. The difference is, the Colts actually can come from behind, as evidenced by their 7 4th quarter comebacks this season. The Jets know this, and I expect some trickery early on, whether it's a flea flicker, a fake punt, Brad Smith, or a no-huddle passing offense. The Jets need to manufacture points early. This means passing early.
2. Go for it on 4th down in the red zone. 4th and 2 on the Colts 12? 4th and goal from the 1? 4th and 3 from the 8? Go for it, go for it, go for it. Three points is meaningless against the Colts, and you're not going to beat them by kicking field goals. This should dictate the Jets strategy in the earlier downs, as once they get inside the red zone, four runs has a much better chance to get a first down than two runs and a pass. If the Jets have three trips into the red zone, they need at least 14 points out of those trips. Against the Colts, you must be aggressive.
3. Shut down the run consistently. This should be easy, right? In '08, the Colts ranked 32st in YPC and 31st in rushing yards; this season, they ranked 32nd in rushing yards and 30th in YPC. Indianapolis can't run, but it's important not just to contain the rushing game, but shutting it down. Against SD, the Chargers rushed 18 times for 61 yards; throw out the draw plays against a prevent defense in the final seconds of the first half, and that's 30 yards on 16 carries for fewer than 2 YPC. The Jets run D is good but not great, but they played terrifically against the run on Sunday. By shutting down the Colts rush offense to the tune of 2 YPC you make them one dimensional. The Colts passing offense is great but not unstoppable; the Chargers passing offense was just as, if not more elite. But by making them so one dimensional, the Jets were able to really play to their strengths. Not only did they make SD pass more often (since they couldn't run) but they passed in worse down and distance situations.
If the Colts, with Wayne being blanketed by Revis, are forced to pass consistently on 2nd and 3rd and longs, this game could get out of hand. With the exotic blitzes Ryan brings and the opportunistic pass defense, the Jets could get seven or eight big plays (sacks/fumbles/INTs) and dominate the game. By selling out to stopping the run, and making the Colts forced to not only play to the Jets strength but do it without their #1 receiver, the Jets4 should be able to dictate the pace of the game.
4. Put the game on the shoulders of Faneca, Mangold and Moore. The Jets interior linemen are powerful, tough and love to have the game on their shoulders. The Jets should be able to push the Colts back, and if they can get a lead early, it's important to just stick with the power running game. The Colts are not going to want to be tackling Greene and Jones by the 4th quarter, just like most teams this year.
5. Watch out for the cheap scores at the end of the half. Against Baltimore, the Colts got a "cheap" TD Indy at the end of the first half that changed the whole game. The Chargers almost did the same thing to the Jets. I suspect the Jets pass defense will contain the Colts most of the time, but in that hurry up offense the Colts are very tough to stop. By keeping an eye on the clock and playing "2 for 1" or just draining the time, the Jets can avoid giving the Colts some free points.
Prediction
The Colts have played with fire all season. Sure, they've won 15 straight games that Manning has finished, but over half of them came by one score. The Colts haven't laid the hammer to teams, and it's not by choice; they're a good but not great team that lacks the ability to stop the run consistently, can't always get off the field defensively, and is an offense that requires perfection to succeed. They can't run consistently, and they need to manufacture several first downs to score TDs -- they don't score touchdowns in two plays very often.
Manning may appear to be like a robot, but you simply can't count on always being able to win games in that fashion. At some point you need your defense or your running game to take over for a half, or you need some big plays on offense. Against the Jets, I don't see any of those things happening. Look for the Jets to take the lead early, Manning and the Colts to come back, before imploding on both sides of the ball in the fourth quarter.
Jets 28, Colts 13
Last edited by a moderator: