The 100 Greatest Songs of 1974 #5. Killer Queen (4 Viewers)

[timschochet]

28. Steely Dan “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number” (from Pretzel Logic)

RIKKI DON'T LOSE THAT NUMBER (1974) by Steely Dan

'Rikki Don't Lose That Number' was off Pretzel Logic, and appears to be a favourite of Steely Dan fans. It was released in 1974. It's intro is a nod to 'Song...

youtu.be

Getting into the biggies now. One of their most infectious melodies. But for some reason I know a couple of people who really hate this (including my wife who always demands that I “turn that **** off!” whenever it appears on one of my playlists…

 

[timschochet]

27. Lynyrd Skynyrd “The Ballad of Curtis Leow” (from Second Helping)

Lynyrd Skynyrd - The Ballad Of Curtis Loew (Audio)

Official Audio for The Ballad Of Curtis Loew performed by Lynyrd SkynyrdFollow Lynyrd Skynyrd:Facebook: https://facebook.com/LynyrdSkynyrdInstagram: https://...

youtu.be

Curtis Leow was the finest picker to ever play the blues

Really what more needs to be said? Except that this is one of the great rock ballads ever written.

 

[zamboni]

28. Steely Dan “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number” (from Pretzel Logic)

RIKKI DON'T LOSE THAT NUMBER (1974) by Steely Dan

'Rikki Don't Lose That Number' was off Pretzel Logic, and appears to be a favourite of Steely Dan fans. It was released in 1974. It's intro is a nod to 'Song...

youtu.be

Getting into the biggies now. One of their most infectious melodies. But for some reason I know a couple of people who really hate this (including my wife who always demands that I “turn that **** off!” whenever it appears on one of my playlists…

No one should say anything bad about it.

 

[timschochet]

26. Carl Douglas “Kung Fu Fighting” (from Kung Fu Fighting and Other Great Love Songs)

Carl Douglas Kung Fu Fighting (Original Music Video)

KUNG FU FIGHTING - CARL DOUGLASEverybody was a kung-fu fightingThose cats were fast as lightningIn fact it was a little bit frightningBut they fought with ex...

youtu.be

Funky China men from funky Chinatown

Not exactly the most politically correct lyrics but hey they’re awesome. I also love the album title, which steals from Layla, but how exactly is this a love song? Whatever. One of the greatest novelty tunes of all time.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

26. Carl Douglas “Kung Fu Fighting” (from Kung Fu Fighting and Other Great Love Songs)

Carl Douglas Kung Fu Fighting (Original Music Video)

KUNG FU FIGHTING - CARL DOUGLASEverybody was a kung-fu fightingThose cats were fast as lightningIn fact it was a little bit frightningBut they fought with ex...

youtu.be

Funky China men from funky Chinatown

Not exactly the most politically correct lyrics but hey they’re awesome. I also love the album title, which steals from Layla, but how exactly is this a love song? Whatever. One of the greatest novelty tunes of all time.

The album title is a joke, and the joke is that this is not a love song.

 

[timschochet]

25. Bad Company “Bad Company” (from Bad Company)

Bad Company - Bad Company (Official Audio)

You're listening to the official audio for "Bad Company" originally released on the band's 1974 eponymous debut album

youtu.be

I have no idea how many of these songs I was personally aware of in 1974- I was only 9 years old. But I know for sure I was aware of this one, because it was played a lot on the radio upon release and I can clearly recall being enamored by its lonesome cowboy message. Though I would have surprised at the time to learn that it was sung by a British guy. Anyhow, a classic.

 

[timschochet]

24. Joni Mitchell “Help Me” (from Court and Spark)

joni mitchell - help me (live in london 1974) HQ

joni mitchell - help me (live in london 1974)

youtu.be

This really is an extraordinary song. For one thing it’s a jazz melody, extremely complex, yet at the same time very accessible. And she sings it so effortlessly.
It seems to me that, up to this point Joni has been one of the great singer-songwriters (Blue being her masterpiece). And then in 1974 she surprised by changing direction and achieved true immortality. I have made the comparison between her and Taylor Swift many times and I think it’s apt. Court and Spark was Joni Mitchell’s Folklore.

 

[Gr00vus]

24. Joni Mitchell “Help Me” (from Court and Spark)

joni mitchell - help me (live in london 1974) HQ

joni mitchell - help me (live in london 1974)

youtu.be

This really is an extraordinary song. For one thing it’s a jazz melody, extremely complex, yet at the same time very accessible. And she sings it so effortlessly.
It seems to me that, up to this point Joni has been one of the great singer-songwriters (Blue being her masterpiece). And then in 1974 she surprised by changing direction and achieved true immortality. I have made the comparison between her and Taylor Swift many times and I think it’s apt. Court and Spark was Joni Mitchell’s Folklore.

Allright, this one may actually be better than PIck Up The Pieces.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

24. Joni Mitchell “Help Me” (from Court and Spark)

joni mitchell - help me (live in london 1974) HQ

joni mitchell - help me (live in london 1974)

youtu.be

This really is an extraordinary song. For one thing it’s a jazz melody, extremely complex, yet at the same time very accessible. And she sings it so effortlessly.
It seems to me that, up to this point Joni has been one of the great singer-songwriters (Blue being her masterpiece). And then in 1974 she surprised by changing direction and achieved true immortality. I have made the comparison between her and Taylor Swift many times and I think it’s apt. Court and Spark was Joni Mitchell’s Folklore.

While we're pretty far into the countdown, I'm still gonna say this is too low (Binky: high).

 

[Brunell4MVP]

I won't argue the ranking, but Joni Mitchell makes me want to gouge my own eyes out. Painfully boring music.

 

[timschochet]

23. Elton John “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down On Me” (from Caribou)

Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995)

Provided to YouTube by Universal Music GroupDon't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995) · Elton JohnCaribouâ 1974 This Record Company Ltd.Released on: ...

youtu.be

Never my favorite Elton ballad, but I don’t turn it off either. This is a fine song. The original IMO, is much better than the George Michael duet but I was never a huge George Michael fan.

 

[pacman_fl]

23. Elton John “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down On Me” (from Caribou)

Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995)

Provided to YouTube by Universal Music GroupDon't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995) · Elton JohnCaribouâ 1974 This Record Company Ltd.Released on: ...

youtu.be

Never my favorite Elton ballad, but I don’t turn it off either. This is a fine song. The original IMO, is much better than the George Michael duet but I was never a huge George Michael fan.

I personally like the duet better, but I also like this song better than most Elton songs in general. Not seeing what's left, this ranking is well deserved, if not too low.

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

23. Elton John “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down On Me” (from Caribou)

Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995)

Provided to YouTube by Universal Music GroupDon't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995) · Elton JohnCaribouâ 1974 This Record Company Ltd.Released on: ...

youtu.be

Never my favorite Elton ballad, but I don’t turn it off either. This is a fine song. The original IMO, is much better than the George Michael duet but I was never a huge George Michael fan.

I personally like the duet better, but I also like this song better than most Elton songs in general. Not seeing what's left, this ranking is well deserved, if not too low.

Yeah Michael does it better imho too.
If you base your Michael opinion on the Wham and Faith LP, you are missing out

 

[timschochet]

22. Gordon Lightfoot “Sundown” (from Sundown)

Gordon Lightfoot - Sundown (1974)

Please visit the Oldies Music channel------------------------------------------------------------https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL7emTt_kkjlaUqJgChA0U...

youtu.be

One of the great soft rock classics of all time. So good. And I’ve always loved the bridge guitar solo

 

[Joe Schmo]

22. Gordon Lightfoot “Sundown” (from Sundown)

Gordon Lightfoot - Sundown (1974)

Please visit the Oldies Music channel------------------------------------------------------------https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL7emTt_kkjlaUqJgChA0U...

youtu.be

One of the great soft rock classics of all time. So good. And I’ve always loved the bridge guitar solo

"Sometimes I think it's a sin
When I feel like I'm winnin' when I'm losin' again"

Awesome

 

[Pip's Invitation]

22. Gordon Lightfoot “Sundown” (from Sundown)

Gordon Lightfoot - Sundown (1974)

Please visit the Oldies Music channel------------------------------------------------------------https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL7emTt_kkjlaUqJgChA0U...

youtu.be

One of the great soft rock classics of all time. So good. And I’ve always loved the bridge guitar solo

One of the best examples of chill ‘70s music.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

26. Carl Douglas “Kung Fu Fighting” (from Kung Fu Fighting and Other Great Love Songs)

Carl Douglas Kung Fu Fighting (Original Music Video)

KUNG FU FIGHTING - CARL DOUGLASEverybody was a kung-fu fightingThose cats were fast as lightningIn fact it was a little bit frightningBut they fought with ex...

youtu.be

Funky China men from funky Chinatown

Not exactly the most politically correct lyrics but hey they’re awesome. I also love the album title, which steals from Layla, but how exactly is this a love song? Whatever. One of the greatest novelty tunes of all time.

Bruce Lee became a massive world-wide star in the early 70s. All kinds of media hopped on the bandwagon. There was the Kung Fu TV show starring David Carradine. Hong Kong Phooey, a Saturday morning cartoon. Marvel comics introduced a Chinese hero who specialized in beating the hell out of people using Eastern fighting arts. You had the Billy Jack movies and their descendants staring folks like Norris, Seagal, & Van Damme.

Then there was this song. First time it came on the radio within my earshot, I begged my mother to take me to a local general store to buy the record. I thought it was the coolest thing ever.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

28. Steely Dan “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number” (from Pretzel Logic)

RIKKI DON'T LOSE THAT NUMBER (1974) by Steely Dan

'Rikki Don't Lose That Number' was off Pretzel Logic, and appears to be a favourite of Steely Dan fans. It was released in 1974. It's intro is a nod to 'Song...

youtu.be

Getting into the biggies now. One of their most infectious melodies. But for some reason I know a couple of people who really hate this (including my wife who always demands that I “turn that **** off!” whenever it appears on one of my playlists…

This is - to me - when Steely Dan became Steely Dan.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

25. Bad Company “Bad Company” (from Bad Company)

Bad Company - Bad Company (Official Audio)

You're listening to the official audio for "Bad Company" originally released on the band's 1974 eponymous debut album

youtu.be

I have no idea how many of these songs I was personally aware of in 1974- I was only 9 years old. But I know for sure I was aware of this one, because it was played a lot on the radio upon release and I can clearly recall being enamored by its lonesome cowboy message. Though I would have surprised at the time to learn that it was sung by a British guy. Anyhow, a classic.

Another record I thought was cool as hell when I was 12. The whole kinda/sorta anti-hero thing appealed to me.

Bad Company has worn thin on me over the years. Even though they had some real talent in the band, they were basically a one-trick pony. Their first LP, though, is a good example of what the mid-70s sounded like played through electric guitars.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

24. Joni Mitchell “Help Me” (from Court and Spark)

joni mitchell - help me (live in london 1974) HQ

joni mitchell - help me (live in london 1974)

youtu.be

This really is an extraordinary song. For one thing it’s a jazz melody, extremely complex, yet at the same time very accessible. And she sings it so effortlessly.
It seems to me that, up to this point Joni has been one of the great singer-songwriters (Blue being her masterpiece). And then in 1974 she surprised by changing direction and achieved true immortality. I have made the comparison between her and Taylor Swift many times and I think it’s apt. Court and Spark was Joni Mitchell’s Folklore.

Hi, I'm Uruk and I have a Joni problem.

I should like her music more than I do. She's weird and soulful and talented. But I could never do more than appreciate her. I think the main issue is that her songs are about really complicated adult stuff and I wasn't about to try to understand that when I could throw on another Grand Funk album.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

23. Elton John “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down On Me” (from Caribou)

Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995)

Provided to YouTube by Universal Music GroupDon't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995) · Elton JohnCaribouâ 1974 This Record Company Ltd.Released on: ...

youtu.be

Never my favorite Elton ballad, but I don’t turn it off either. This is a fine song. The original IMO, is much better than the George Michael duet but I was never a huge George Michael fan.

I recall reading an essay about Elton that was probably written in the late 70s or early 80s. I can't remember who wrote it (pretty sure it was one of the big rock critics at the time), but they described this song as "overripe". It took me a bit to understand what they were trying to say, but I eventually got it (I think). Even though it's a ballad, it's so full of hooks it almost becomes unwieldy. Except that it's Elton John who did it, and he was on one of music's all-time heaters so it fits right in with everything else he was doing.

I like the George Michael version, too.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

22. Gordon Lightfoot “Sundown” (from Sundown)

Gordon Lightfoot - Sundown (1974)

Please visit the Oldies Music channel------------------------------------------------------------https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL7emTt_kkjlaUqJgChA0U...

youtu.be

One of the great soft rock classics of all time. So good. And I’ve always loved the bridge guitar solo

This song has always driven me crazy. I don't know what it is - vocal melody, Lightfoot's weird cadence, the lyrics...... It's my least-favorite of his hits. It's still pretty good, though.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

End Hippling

 

[timschochet]

21. Joe Cocker “You Are So Beautiful” (from I Can Stand A Little Rain)

Joe Cocker - You Are So Beautiful

youtu.be

I expect a bit of pushback on this selection only because I always get pushback whenever I choose one of Cocker’s covers- I guess I appreciate him more than the crowd here does as a general rule. But this is arguably his greatest song, and he sings it with a soulful energy that I love and I know that many others can’t stand. And it’s a beautiful ballad. it was written by a couple of guys I won’t mention here because they have another hit from 1974 that I have slotted extremely high in this draft and J don’t want to spotlight- you’re welcome to look it up. In addition to those two guys, Beach Boy Dennis Wilson also received songwriting credits.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

28. Steely Dan “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number” (from Pretzel Logic)

RIKKI DON'T LOSE THAT NUMBER (1974) by Steely Dan

'Rikki Don't Lose That Number' was off Pretzel Logic, and appears to be a favourite of Steely Dan fans. It was released in 1974. It's intro is a nod to 'Song...

youtu.be

Getting into the biggies now. One of their most infectious melodies. But for some reason I know a couple of people who really hate this (including my wife who always demands that I “turn that **** off!” whenever it appears on one of my playlists…

This is - to me - when Steely Dan became Steely Dan.

This or the Katy Lied album.

Their first album was their own recordings of songs Becker and Fagen had shopped around in a failed attempt to become songwriters-for-hire. Their second was a deliberate attempt to write and record songs that could be played live. Pretzel Logic, the third, was neither of those, but nor was it as hyper-perfectionist as their subsequent albums. And as I mentioned earlier in this thread, it has no consistency in terms of genre or production style. But the success of "Rikki" probably gave them enough clout to stop touring and to make their albums the way they wanted to.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

23. Elton John “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down On Me” (from Caribou)

Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995)

Provided to YouTube by Universal Music GroupDon't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995) · Elton JohnCaribouâ 1974 This Record Company Ltd.Released on: ...

youtu.be

Never my favorite Elton ballad, but I don’t turn it off either. This is a fine song. The original IMO, is much better than the George Michael duet but I was never a huge George Michael fan.

I recall reading an essay about Elton that was probably written in the late 70s or early 80s. I can't remember who wrote it (pretty sure it was one of the big rock critics at the time), but they described this song as "overripe". It took me a bit to understand what they were trying to say, but I eventually got it (I think). Even though it's a ballad, it's so full of hooks it almost becomes unwieldy. Except that it's Elton John who did it, and he was on one of music's all-time heaters so it fits right in with everything else he was doing.

I like the George Michael version, too.

In other words, it shouldn't work, but it does. I agree with that.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

End Hippling

You Hippled without taking any shots at Billy Joel or Jackson Browne.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

End Hippling

You Hippled without taking any shots at Billy Joel or Jackson Browne.

I almost slid a Paul Simon dig in

 

[Uruk-Hai]

23. Elton John “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down On Me” (from Caribou)

Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995)

Provided to YouTube by Universal Music GroupDon't Let The Sun Go Down On Me (Remastered 1995) · Elton JohnCaribouâ 1974 This Record Company Ltd.Released on: ...

youtu.be

Never my favorite Elton ballad, but I don’t turn it off either. This is a fine song. The original IMO, is much better than the George Michael duet but I was never a huge George Michael fan.

I recall reading an essay about Elton that was probably written in the late 70s or early 80s. I can't remember who wrote it (pretty sure it was one of the big rock critics at the time), but they described this song as "overripe". It took me a bit to understand what they were trying to say, but I eventually got it (I think). Even though it's a ballad, it's so full of hooks it almost becomes unwieldy. Except that it's Elton John who did it, and he was on one of music's all-time heaters so it fits right in with everything else he was doing.

I like the George Michael version, too.

In other words, it shouldn't work, but it does. I agree with that.

The only Elton contemporary would could consistently pull this off that I can think of is Stevie Wonder (who may have done it more than even Reg did). The Bee Gees, too, I guess.

 

[Don Quixote]

Quite the tease to say a bunch of funk coming up, and then post songs by Gordon Lightfoot and Joe Cocker.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

21. Joe Cocker “You Are So Beautiful” (from The Kids ‘N’ Me)

Joe Cocker - You Are So Beautiful

youtu.be

I expect a bit of pushback on this selection only because I always get pushback whenever I choose one of Cocker’s covers- I guess I appreciate him more than the crowd here does as a general rule. But this is arguably his greatest song, and he sings it with a soulful energy that I love and I know that many others can’t stand. And it’s a beautiful ballad. it was written by a couple of guys I won’t mention here because they have another hit from 1974 that I have slotted extremely high in this draft and J don’t want to spotlight- you’re welcome to look it up. In addition to those two guys, Beach Boy Dennis Wilson also received songwriting credits.

I don't mind this song (or Cocker himself), but this isn't the most diverse song. Hearing this on AM Top 40 Radio twice an hour, it could get repetitive really fast.

 

[timschochet]

20. The Ohio Players “Fire” (from Fire)

Ohio Players - Fire ⢠TopPop

Watch our great music videos ⯠https://goo.gl/feVLNNMore TopPop? Subscribe here ⯠https://goo.gl/X9FOAUMore info on Wikipedia ⯠https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki...

youtu.be

Bringing the funk. Love this video: the trombone player appears to be about 7 feet tall or so. These guys are excellent.

 

[northern exposure]

21. Joe Cocker “You Are So Beautiful” (from The Kids ‘N’ Me)

Joe Cocker - You Are So Beautiful

youtu.be

I expect a bit of pushback on this selection only because I always get pushback whenever I choose one of Cocker’s covers- I guess I appreciate him more than the crowd here does as a general rule. But this is arguably his greatest song, and he sings it with a soulful energy that I love and I know that many others can’t stand. And it’s a beautiful ballad. it was written by a couple of guys I won’t mention here because they have another hit from 1974 that I have slotted extremely high in this draft and J don’t want to spotlight- you’re welcome to look it up. In addition to those two guys, Beach Boy Dennis Wilson also received songwriting credits.

Two things. First, the Joe Cocker album this song appears on is not "The Kids ‘N’ Me". That is the name of the album from one of the songwriters version of the song.
The title of the Joe Cocker album this song appears on is "I Can Stand A Little Rain".
Second, my favorite Joe Cocker cover is his version of the Randy Newman song "You Can Leave Your Hat On".

 

[timschochet]

21. Joe Cocker “You Are So Beautiful” (from The Kids ‘N’ Me)

Joe Cocker - You Are So Beautiful

youtu.be

I expect a bit of pushback on this selection only because I always get pushback whenever I choose one of Cocker’s covers- I guess I appreciate him more than the crowd here does as a general rule. But this is arguably his greatest song, and he sings it with a soulful energy that I love and I know that many others can’t stand. And it’s a beautiful ballad. it was written by a couple of guys I won’t mention here because they have another hit from 1974 that I have slotted extremely high in this draft and J don’t want to spotlight- you’re welcome to look it up. In addition to those two guys, Beach Boy Dennis Wilson also received songwriting credits.

Two things. First, the Joe Cocker album this song appears on is not "The Kids ‘N’ Me". That is the name of the album from one of the songwriters version of the song.
The title of the Joe Cocker album this song appears on is "I Can Stand A Little Rain".
Second, my favorite Joe Cocker cover is his version of the Randy Newman song "You Can Leave Your Hat On".

Appreciate the correction.

 

[northern exposure]

21. Joe Cocker “You Are So Beautiful” (from The Kids ‘N’ Me)

Joe Cocker - You Are So Beautiful

youtu.be

I expect a bit of pushback on this selection only because I always get pushback whenever I choose one of Cocker’s covers- I guess I appreciate him more than the crowd here does as a general rule. But this is arguably his greatest song, and he sings it with a soulful energy that I love and I know that many others can’t stand. And it’s a beautiful ballad. it was written by a couple of guys I won’t mention here because they have another hit from 1974 that I have slotted extremely high in this draft and J don’t want to spotlight- you’re welcome to look it up. In addition to those two guys, Beach Boy Dennis Wilson also received songwriting credits.

Two things. First, the Joe Cocker album this song appears on is not "The Kids ‘N’ Me". That is the name of the album from one of the songwriters version of the song.
The title of the Joe Cocker album this song appears on is "I Can Stand A Little Rain".
Second, my favorite Joe Cocker cover is his version of the Randy Newman song "You Can Leave Your Hat On".

Appreciate the correction.

No problem. Keep up the good work.

 

[timschochet]

19. Jethro Tull “Skating Away (On the Thin Ice of the New Day)” (from War Child)

Skating Away on the Thin Ice of the New Day (2002 Remaster)

Provided to YouTube by Parlophone UKSkating Away on the Thin Ice of the New Day (2002 Remaster) · Jethro TullWar Childâ 1974, 2002 Parlophone Records Ltd, a ...

youtu.be

Meanwhile back in the year one…

I’ve always associated this song in my mind with “Thick As a Brick”: two of the best acoustic rock tunes to come out of the early 70s. And such a distinctive sound.

I was recently made aware of the fact that Jethro Tull is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. How is that even possible?

 

[zamboni]

I was recently made aware of the fact that Jethro Tull is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. How is that even possible?

Too metal

 

[squistion]

I was recently made aware of the fact that Jethro Tull is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. How is that even possible?

Too metal

I would say too progressive and/or too eclectic. They are definitely an acquired taste. I am still amazed that a band fronted by a flute player could have been that successful in the 70s.

 

[zamboni]

I was recently made aware of the fact that Jethro Tull is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. How is that even possible?

Too metal

I would say too progressive and/or too eclectic. They are definitely an acquired taste. I am still amazed that a band fronted by a flute player could have been that successful in the 70s.

That was a joke about them winning a Grammy for best metal performance back in 1989.

 

[timschochet]

I was recently made aware of the fact that Jethro Tull is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. How is that even possible?

Too metal

I would say too progressive and/or too eclectic. They are definitely an acquired taste. I am still amazed that a band fronted by a flute player could have been that successful in the 70s.

That was a joke about them winning a Grammy for best metal performance back in 1989.

I didn’t get it either- I didn’t know that story. A Grammy for Metal? How did that happen?

 

[squistion]

I was recently made aware of the fact that Jethro Tull is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. How is that even possible?

Too metal

I would say too progressive and/or too eclectic. They are definitely an acquired taste. I am still amazed that a band fronted by a flute player could have been that successful in the 70s.

That was a joke about them winning a Grammy for best metal performance back in 1989.

I didn’t get it either- I didn’t know that story. A Grammy for Metal? How did that happen?

It gets better, they beat out Metallica, AC/DC and Jane's Addiction.

How did that happen? Well, the category that year was actually Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance Vocal or Instrumental, (they later split it into two categories, Hard Rock and Metal).

I think they won for two reasons, 1) There probably weren't that many Metal fans among Grammy Voters in those days and 2) Name recognition (and they had been erroneously labeled by many fans and critics as being Hard Rock in the 70s).

 

[zamboni]

I was recently made aware of the fact that Jethro Tull is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. How is that even possible?

Too metal

I would say too progressive and/or too eclectic. They are definitely an acquired taste. I am still amazed that a band fronted by a flute player could have been that successful in the 70s.

That was a joke about them winning a Grammy for best metal performance back in 1989.

I didn’t get it either- I didn’t know that story. A Grammy for Metal? How did that happen?

It gets better, they beat out Metallica, AC/DC and Jane's Addiction.

How did that happen? Well, the category that year was actually Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance Vocal or Instrumental, (they later split it into two categories, Hard Rock and Metal).

I think they won for two reasons, 1) There probably weren't that many Metal fans among Grammy Voters in those days and 2) Name recognition (and they had been erroneously labeled by many fans and critics as being Hard Rock in the 70s).

The perennial doosh Lars Ulrich had a humorous line referencing Tull when Metallica won a few years later.

Metallica won Best Metal Performance for 'Metallica' | 34th Annual Grammy Awards (1992)

From the Main Ceremony of the 34th Annual Grammy Awards.I DO NOT MAKE ANY MONEY FROM THIS VIDEO.All rights belong to The Recording Academy.Metallica won Best...

youtu.be

 

[timschochet]

18. Big Star “September Gurls” (from Radio City)

https://youtu.be/BNKSs1J38EA?si=Ag13O1zOPyL_iR1x

For years this was one of my favorite Bangles’ songs. I had no idea it was a cover. I had no idea who Big Star was. I can’t remember when I found out but it must have been about 20 years ago. Anyhow I’ve listened to a lot of Big Star since and I really enjoy their Power Pop. “The Ballad of El Goodo” is constantly on my playlists, But “September Gurls” was probably their most well known tune.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

I was recently made aware of the fact that Jethro Tull is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. How is that even possible?

Too metal

I would say too progressive and/or too eclectic. They are definitely an acquired taste. I am still amazed that a band fronted by a flute player could have been that successful in the 70s.

That was a joke about them winning a Grammy for best metal performance back in 1989.

I didn’t get it either- I didn’t know that story. A Grammy for Metal? How did that happen?

Old people.

The category was actually hard rock/heavy metal but the Tull album that won, Crest of a Knave, didn’t really qualify as either.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

18. Big Star “September Gurls” (from Radio City)

https://youtu.be/BNKSs1J38EA?si=Ag13O1zOPyL_iR1x

For years this was one of my favorite Bangles’ songs. I had no idea it was a cover. I had no idea who Big Star was. I can’t remember when I found out but it must have been about 20 years ago. Anyhow I’ve listened to a lot of Big Star since and I really enjoy their Power Pop. “The Ballad of El Goodo” is constantly on my playlists, But “September Gurls” was probably their most well known tune.

I would have at least three songs from this album in my top 100 from 1974.

 

[northern exposure]

18. Big Star “September Gurls” (from Radio City)

https://youtu.be/BNKSs1J38EA?si=Ag13O1zOPyL_iR1x

For years this was one of my favorite Bangles’ songs. I had no idea it was a cover. I had no idea who Big Star was. I can’t remember when I found out but it must have been about 20 years ago. Anyhow I’ve listened to a lot of Big Star since and I really enjoy their Power Pop. “The Ballad of El Goodo” is constantly on my playlists, But “September Gurls” was probably their most well known tune.

I didn't discover Big Star until The Replacements released the song "Alex Chilton" and I searched to find out who he was.
The tragedy of Big Star is on par with that of Badfinger. Mismanagement by the record company, band members dying far too young, etc.

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

I was recently made aware of the fact that Jethro Tull is not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. How is that even possible?

Too metal

I would say too progressive and/or too eclectic. They are definitely an acquired taste. I am still amazed that a band fronted by a flute player could have been that successful in the 70s.

That was a joke about them winning a Grammy for best metal performance back in 1989.

I didn’t get it either- I didn’t know that story. A Grammy for Metal? How did that happen?

Old people.

The category was actually hard rock/heavy metal but the Tull album that won, Crest of a Knave, didn’t really qualify as either.

Flutes are made of metal.

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

the vast majority of these songs are killin' it tim - good job!

 

[krista4]

I'm here for the Big Star.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

I'm here for the Big Star.

I can't get a license
To drive in my car
But I don't really need it
If I'm a big star