What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

PDSL 3 Teams (1 Viewer)

Domination

Footballguy
Tex

4.16 Michael Vick, ATL, QB6, Bye-8

9.01 Byron Leftwich, JAX, QB20, Bye-4

1.01 LaDainian Tomlinson, SD, RB1, Bye-7

3.01 Thomas Jones, NYJ, RB20, Bye-10

8.16 Mike Bell, DEN, RB47, Bye-6

17.01 Najeh Davenport, PIT, RB67, Bye-6

19.01 Sammy Morris, NE, RB70, Bye-10

2.16 Donald Driver, GB, WR10, Bye-7

6.16 Deion Branch, SEA, WR34, Bye-8

7.01 Santonio Holmes, PIT, WR35, Bye-6

11.01 Wes Welker, NE, WR61, Bye-10

15.01 Sidney Rice, MIN, WR83, Bye-5

18.16 Peerless Price, BUF, WR94, Bye-6

5.01 L.J. Smith, PHI, TE8, Bye-5

12.16 David Thomas, NEP, TE23, Bye-10

20.16 George Wrightster, JAC, TE37, Bye-4

14.16 Shayne Graham, CIN, K6, Bye-5

16.16 Stephen Gostkowski, NE, K14, Bye-10

10.16 Baltimore Ravens, DST2, Bye-8

13.01 Pittsburgh Steelers, DST6, Bye-6

Bruno2

4.15 Tom Brady, NE, QB5, Bye-10

9.02 Alex Smith, SF, QB21, Bye-6

1.02 Steven Jackson, STL, RB2, Bye-9

3.02 Chester Taylor, MIN, RB21, Bye-5

6.15 Julius Jones, DAL, RB37, Bye-8

12.15 Kenny Irons, CIN, RB57, Bye-5

19.02 Jerome Harrison, CLE, RB71, Bye-7

2.15 Roy Williams, DET, WR9, Bye-6

5.02 Braylon Edwards, CLE, WR22, Bye-7

8.15 Drew Bennett, STL, WR47, Bye-9

11.02 Hank Baskett, PHI, WR62, Bye-5

13.02 Terrance Copper, NO, WR73, Bye-4

16.15 Brandon Lloyd, WAS, WR89, Bye-4

20.15 Maurice Stovall, TB, WR102, Bye-10

7.02 Desmond Clark, CHI, TE12, Bye-9

10.15 Owen Daniels, HOU, TE18, Bye-10

15.02 Jason Elam, DEN, K7, Bye-6

18.15 Sebastian Janikowski, OAK, K21, Bye-5

14.15 Oakland Raiders, DST11, Bye-5

17.02 Tampa Bay Buccaneers, DST20, Bye-10

Pimpin Ain't Easy

5.03 Marc Bulger, STL, QB7, Bye-9

9.03 JP Losman, BUF, QB22, Bye-6

20.14 Gus Frerotte, STL, QB39, Bye-9

1.03 Larry Johnson, KC, RB3, Bye-8

7.03 Tatum Bell, DET, RB38, Bye-6

8.13 Ricky Williams, MIA, RB46, Bye-9

11.03 Chris Brown, ???, RB51,

13.03 Michael Bennett, KC, RB58, Bye-8

2.14 Anquan Boldin, ARI, WR8 , Bye-8

3.03 Andre Johnson, HOU, WR11, Bye-10

4.14 Randy Moss, NE, WR21, Bye-10

10.14 Ted Ginn Jr., MIA, WR60, Bye-9

12.14 Drew Carter, CAR, WR72, Bye-7

14.14 Eric Moulds, ???, WR82,

18.14 Steve Smith, NYG, WR93, Bye-9

6.14 Ben Watson, NEP, TE11, Bye-10

19.03 Jermaine Wiggins, JAC, TE35, Bye-4

16.14 Olindo Mare, NO, K13, Bye-4

15.03 Carolina Panthers, DST12, Bye-7

17.03 Washington Redskins, DST21, Bye-4

krsone21

6.13 Eli Manning, NYG, QB14, Bye-9

7.04 Jay Cutler, DEN, QB15, Bye-6

1.04 Brian Westbrook, PHI, RB4, Bye-5

2.13 Cedric Benson, CHI, RB19, Bye-9

8.13 Reuben Droughns, NYG, RB45, Bye-9

12.13 Chris Perry, CIN, RB56, Bye-5

13.04 Brian Leonard, STL, RB59, Bye-9

3.04 Marques Colston, NO, WR12, Bye-4

5.04 Reggie Brown, PHI, WR23, Bye-5

9.04 Eddie Kennison, KC, WR48, Bye-8

10.13 Michael Jenkins, ATL, WR59, Bye-8

14.13 Antwaan Randle El, WAS, WR81, Bye-4

20.13 Johnie Lee Higgens, OAK, WR101, Bye-5

4.13 Alge Crumpler, ATL, TE7, Bye-8

11.04 Heath Miller, PIT, TE19, Bye-6

15.04 Zach Miller, OAK, TE25, Bye-5

18.13 Joe Nedney, SF, K20, Bye-6

19.04 Jeff Reed, PIT, K22, Bye-6

16.13 Jacksonville, Jaguars, DST19, Bye-4

17.04 New York Jets, DST22, Bye-10

Ministry of Pain

8.12 Matt Schaub, HOU, QB19, Bye-10

9.05 Jake Delhomme, CAR, QB23, Bye-7

1.05 Reggie Bush, NO, RB5, Bye-4

2.12 Adrian Peterson, MIN, RB18, Bye-5

3.05 Cadillac Williams, TB, RB22, Bye-10

13.05 Michael Pittman, TB, RB60, Bye-10

4.12 Darrell Jackson, SF, WR20, Bye-6

6.12 Terry Glenn, DAL, WR33, Bye-8

7.05 Kevin Curtis, PHI, WR36, Bye-9

10.12 Marty Booker, MIA, WR58, Bye-9

11.05 Michael Clayton, TB, WR63, Bye-10

14.12 Mark Bradley, CHI, WR80, Bye-9

15.05 Anthony Gonzales, IND, WR84, Bye-6

20.12 Kelly Washington, NE, WR100, Bye-10

5.05 Jason, Witten, DAL, TE9, Bye-8

18.12 Bo Scaife, TEN, TE34, Bye-4

16.12 Josh Brown, SEA, K12, Bye-8

19.05 Mason Crosby, GB, K23, Bye-7

12.12 Dallas Cowboys, DST5, Bye-8

17.05 Tennessee Titans, DST23, Bye-4

NorrisB

6.11 Tony Romo, DAL, QB13, Bye-8

8.11 Ben Roethlesberger, PIT, QB18, Bye-6

1.06 Shaun Alexander, SEA, RB6, Bye-8

3.06 Duece McAllister, NO, RB23, Bye-4

11.06 Correll Buckhalter, PHI, RB52, Bye-5

14.11 Brandon Jackson, GB, RB62, Bye-7

2.11 Larry Fitzgerald, ARI, WR7 , Bye-8

4.11 Hines Ward, PIT, WR19, Bye-6

5.06 Joey Galloway, TB, WR24, Bye-10

7.06 Bernard Berrian, CHI, WR37, Bye-9

10.11 Chris Henry, CIN, WR57, Bye-5

13.06 Joe Jurevicius, CLE, WR74, Bye-7

16.11 Mike Williams, OAK, WR88, Bye-5

19.06 Kevin Walter, HOU, WR95, Bye-10

9.06 Dallas Clark, IND, TE15 , Bye-6

12.11 Marcedes Lewis, JAC, TE22, Bye-4

18.11 Ryan Longwell, MIN, K19, Bye-5

20.11 Josh Huston, NYG, K32, Bye-9

15.06 Green Bay Packers, DST13, Bye-7

17.06 New York Giants, DST24, Bye-9

Prof. Chaos

1.07 Peyton Manning, IND, QB1, Bye-6

9.07 Chad Pennington, NYJ, QB24, Bye-10

3.07 Brandon Jacobs, NYG, RB24, Bye-9

5.07 Kevin Jones, DET, RB31, Bye-6

6.10 Jerious Norwood, ATL, RB36, Bye-8

15.07 Maurice Morris, SEA, RB64, Bye-8

2.10 Terrell Owens, DAL, WR6, Bye-8

7.07 Greg Jennings, GB, WR38 , Bye-7

8.10 Devery Henderson, NO, WR46, Bye-4

11.07 Amani Toomer, NYG, WR64, Bye-9

12.10 Patrick Crayton, DAL, WR71, Bye-8

17.07 Dennis Northcutt, JAC, WR90, Bye-4

4.10 Vernon Davis, SF, TE6, Bye-6

10.10 Eric Johnson, NO, TE17, Bye-4

18.10 Lawrence Tynes, KC, K18, Bye-8

19.07 Rob Bironas, TEN, K24, Bye-4

20.10 Jay Feely, MIA, K31, Bye-9

13.07 Philadelphia Eagles, DST7, Bye-5

14.10 Denver Broncos, DST10, Bye-6

16.10 Kansas City Chiefs, DST18, Bye-8

Ruffrodys05

6.09 Matt Leinart, ARI, QB12, Bye-8

11.08 JaMarcus Russell,OAK, QB31 , Bye-5

1.08 Rudi Johnson, CIN, RB7, Bye-5

4.09 Jamal Lewis, CLE, RB30, Bye-7

8.09 Lorenzo Booker, MIA, RB44, Bye-9

9.08 Corey Dillon, ???, RB48

18.09 Maurice Hicks, SF, RB69, Bye-6

20.09 Travis Minor, STL, RB77, Bye-9

2.09 Reggie Wayne, IND, WR5, Bye-6

5.08 Santana Moss, WAS, WR25, Bye-4

7.08 Isaac Bruce, STL, WR39, Bye-9

10.09 Ashley Lelie, SF, WR56, Bye-6

13.08 Dwayne Jarrett, CAR, WR75, Bye-7

14.09 David Givens, TEN, WR79, Bye-4

3.08 Kellen Winslow II, CLE, TE2, Bye-7

12.09 Ben Troupe, TEN, TE21, Bye-4

15.08 David Akers, PHI, K8, Bye-5

19.08 Michael Koenen, ATL, K25, Bye-8

16.09 Arizona Cardinals, DST17, Bye-8

17.08 Seattle Seahawks, DST25, Bye-8

Domination

4.08 Donovan McNabb, PHI, QB4, Bye-5

8.07 Brett Favre, GB, QB17, Bye-7

1.09 Willie Parker, PIT, RB8, Bye-6

5.09 Lamont Jordan, OAK, RB32, Bye-5

7.09 Ladell Betts, WAS, RB39, Bye-4

13.09 Michael Bush, OAK, RB61, Bye-5

20.08 Musa Smith, BAL, RB76, Bye-8

2.08 Marvin Harrison, IND, WR4, Bye-6

3.09 T. J. Houshmandzadeh, CIN, WR13, Bye-5

6.08 Jerricho Cotchery, NYJ, WR32, Bye-10

10.08 Keyshawn Johnson, CAR, WR55, Bye-7

11.09 Dwayne Bowe, KC, WR65 , Bye-8

14.08 Bobby Wade, MIN, WR78, Bye-5

19.09 Sammie Parker, KC, WR96, Bye-8

9.09 Daniel Graham, DEN, TE16, Bye-6

12.08 Greg Olsen, CHI, TE20, Bye-9

15.09 Matt Stover, BAL, K9, Bye-8

18.08 David Rayner, GB, K17, Bye-7

16.08 New Orleans Saints, DST16, Bye-4

17.09 San Francisco 49ers, DST26, Bye-6

DocNiner52

5.10 Matt Hasselbeck, SEA, QB8, Bye-8

9.10 Rex Grossman, CHI, QB25, Bye-9

14.07 Chris Simms, TB, QB37, Bye-10

1.10 Joseph Addai, IND, RB9, Bye-6

4.07 Marshawn Lynch, BUF, RB29, Bye-6

8.07 Dominic Rhoades, OAK, RB43, Bye-5

12.07 Ron Dayne, HOU, RB55, Bye-10

19.10 Noah Herron, GB, RB72, Bye-7

2.07 Torry Holt, STL, WR3, Bye-9

3.10 Lee Evans, BUF, WR14, Bye-6

6.07 Vincent Jackson, SD, WR31, Bye-7

10.07 D.J. Hackett, SEA, WR54, Bye-8

13.10 Nate Washington, PIT, WR76, Bye-6

7.10 Tony Scheffler, DEN, TE13, Bye-6

15.10 Chris Baker, NYJ, TE26, Bye-10

18.07 Dan Campbell, DET, TE33, Bye-6

16.07 Josh Scobee, JAC, K11, Bye-4

20.07 Martin Gramatica, DAL, K30, Bye-8

11.10 San Diego Chargers, DST3, Bye-7

17.10 Buffalo Bills, DST27, Bye-6

Rudy

6.06 Philip Rivers, SD, QB11, Bye-7

9.11 Jason Campbell, WAS, QB26, Bye-4

12.06 Daunte Culpepper, MIA, QB34, Bye-9

1.11 Frank Gore, SF, RB10, Bye-6

3.11 DeAngelo Williams, CAR, RB25, Bye-7

5.11 Fred Taylor, JAC, RB33, Bye-4

20.06 Tony Hunt, PHI, RB75, Bye-5

2.06 Chad Johnson, CIN, WR2, Bye-5

7.11 Brandon Marshall, DEN, WR40, Bye-6

8.06 Arnaz Battle, SF, WR45, Bye-6

10.06 Ronald Curry, OAK, WR53, Bye-5

11.11 Robert Meachem, NO, WR66, Bye-4

16.06 Rod Smith, DEN WR86, Bye-6

19.11 Jason Hill, SF, WR97, Bye-6

4.06 Jeremy Shockey, NYG, TE5, Bye-9

15.11 Alex Smith, TB, TE27, Bye-10

18.06 V. Shiancoe, MIN, TE32, Bye-5

13.11 Adam Vinatieri, IND, K1, , Bye-6

14.06 Nate Kaeding, SD, K5, Bye-7

17.11 Detroit Lions, DST28, Bye-6

milfoshane

2.05 Carson Palmer, CIN, QB2, Bye-5

11.12 Brady Quinn, CLE, QB32, Bye7

18.05 David Carr, CAR, QB37, Bye-7

1.12 Lawrence Maroney, NE, RB11, Bye-10

3.12 Marion Barber III, RB26, Bye-8

10.05 Antonio Pittman, NO, RB50, Bye-4

13.12 Greg Jones, JAC, RB63, Bye-4

14.05 Michael Robinson, SF, RB66, Bye-6

20.05 Priest Holmes, KC, RB74, Bye-8

4.05 Calvin Johnson, DET, WR18, Bye-6

5.12 Chris Chambers, MIA, WR26, Bye-9

6.05 Derrick Mason, BAL, WR30, Bye-8

9.12 Reggie Williams, JAC, WR49, Bye-4

15.12 Derek Hagen, MIA, WR87, Bye-9

7.12 Randy McMichael, STL, TE14, Bye-9

16.05 Joe Klopfenstein, STL, TE31, Bye-9

12.05 Neil Rackers, ARI, K2, Bye-8

19.12 Kris Brown, HOU, K26, Bye-10

8.05 Chicago, D1, Bye-9

17.12 Atlanta Falcons, DST29, Bye-8

NoFBInLA

4.04 Drew Brees, NO, QB3, Bye-4

9.13 Jeff Garcia, TB, QB27, Bye-10

1.13 Clinton Portis, WAS, RB12, Bye-4

2.04 Edgerrin James, ARI, RB17, Bye-8

8.04 DeShaun Foster, CAR, RB41, Bye-7

10.04 Anthony Thomas, BUF, RB49, Bye-6

20.04 T.J. Duckett, DET, RB73, Bye-6

3.13 Javon Walker, DEN, WR15, Bye-6

6.04 Mike Furrey, DET, WR29Bye-6

7.13 Muhsin Muhammad, CHI, WR41, Bye-9

11.13 Sinorice Moss, NYG, WR67, Bye-9

12.04 Bryant Johnson, ARI, WR70, Bye-8

17.13 Tab Perry, CIN, WR91, Bye-5

19.13 Jeff Webb, KC, WR98, Bye-8

5.12 Cris Cooley, WAS, TE10, Bye-4

14.04 Marcus Pollard, SEA, TE24, Bye-8

16.04 John Kasay, CAR, K10, Bye-7

18.04 Mike Nugent, NYJ, K16, Bye-10

13.13 Cincinnati Bengals, DST8, Bye-5

15.13 Miami Dolphins, DST14, Bye-9

FreeBaGel

8.03 Steve McNair, BAL, QB16, Bye-8

9.14 Damon Huard, KC, QB28, Bye-8

13.14 Andrew Walter, OAK, QB35, Bye-5

1.14 Ronnie Brown, MIA, RB13, Bye-9

3.14 Ahman Green, HOU, RB27, Bye-10

6.03 Warrick Dunn, ATL, RB35, Bye-8

11.14 Adrian Peterson, CHI, RB54, Bye-9

17.14 Kevan Barlow, ???, RB68

2.03 Steve Smith, CAR, WR1 , Bye-7

5.14 Donte Stallworth, NE, WR27, Bye-10

7.14 Joe Horn, ATL, WR42, Bye-8

10.03 Antonio Bryant, ???, WR52

18.03 Bobby Engram, SEA, WR92, Bye-8

20.03 Travis Taylor, MIN, WR99, Bye-5

4.03 Todd Heap, BAL, TE4, Bye-8

15.14 Ben Utecht, IND, TE28, Bye-6

14.03 - Jeff Wilkens, STL, K4, Bye-9

19.14 Phil Dawson, CLE, K27, Bye-7

12.03 New England Patriots, DST4, Bye-10

16.03 Minnesota Vikings, DST15, Bye-4

Orgazmo

5.15 Vince Young, TEN, QB9, Bye-4

10.02 Tarvaris Jackson, MIN, QB30, Bye-5

12.02 Charlie Frye, CLE, QB33, Bye-7

20.02 Derek Anderson, CLE, QB38, Bye-7

1.15 Travis Henry, DEN, RB14, Bye-6

2.02 Willis McGahee, BAL, RB16, Bye-8

6.02 Lendale White, TEN, RB34, Bye-4

8.02 Vernand Morency, GB, RB41, Bye-7

3.15 Plaxico Burress, NYG, WR16, Bye-9

7.15 Matt Jones, JAX, WR43, Bye-4

9.15 Troy Williamson, MIN, WR50, Bye-5

11.15 Demetrius Williams, BAL, WR68, Bye-8

16.02 Shaun McDonald, DET, WR85, Bye-6

4.02 Tony Gonzalez, KC, TE3, Bye-8

15.15 David Martin, MIA, TE29, Bye-9

19.15 Kris Wilson, KC, TE36, Bye-8

14.02 Robbie Gould, CHI, K3, Bye-9

18.02 Jason Hanson, DET, K15, Bye-6

13.15 Indianapolis Colts, DST9, Bye-6

17.15 St. Louis Rams, DST30, Bye-9

lions327

6.01 Jon Kitna, DET, QB10, Bye-6

9.16 Trent Green, KC, QB29, Bye-8

13.16 Josh McCown, OAK, QB36, Bye-5

1.16 Maurice Jones-Drew, JAC, RB15, Bye-4

3.16 Michael Turner, SD, RB28, Bye-7

7.16 Leon Washington, NYJ, RB40, Bye-10

12.01 Mewelde Moore, MIN, RB53, Bye-5

15.16 Kevin Faulk, NE, RB65, Bye-10

4.01 Lavernues Coles, NYJ, WR17, Bye-10

5.16 Mark Clayton, BAL, WR28, Bye-8

8.01 Jerry Porter, OAK, WR44, Bye-5

10.01 Brandon Jones, TEN, WR51, Bye-4

11.16 Reche Caldwell, NE, WR69, Bye-10

14.01 Eric Parker, SD, WR77, Bye-7

2.01 Antonio Gates, SD, TE1 , Bye-7

16.01 Leonard Pope, ARI, TE30, Bye-8

19.16 Matt Bryant, TB, K28, Bye-10

20.01 Rian Lindell, BUF, K29, Bye-6

17.16 Cleveland Browns, DST31, Bye-7

18.01 Houston Texans, DST32, Bye-10

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks Domination,

I really appreciate you taking the lead on this PDSL3 Team thread, it will help all of us a lot.

 
1.04 Brian Westbrook RB Eagles - In this format with the PPR Westbrook can be golden as long as he can stay healthy that is so this was the logical choice to me at this point.

2.13 Cedric Benson RB Bears - I was kinda surprised to still see him available. I know he has had some injury concerns but he is now the man in Chicago so once again if he can stay healthy I believe Benson can be a top 10 back a steal at this point if you ask me.

3.04 Marques Colston WR Saints - I was happy to see him still on the board. He can be a top 10 receiver with the possible potential of a top 5 receiver in my opinion. Look at his numbers from last year and if he can duplicate that and play a full 16 games easily a top 10 receiver.

4.13 Alge Crumpler TE Falcons - TE's were going of the board like crazy so I wanted to secure a good one before they were all gone. He is a 10 ten tight end so nothing fancy but will do.

5.04 Reggie Brown WR Eagles - I think Reggie Brown will really improve this year and be a top 15 receiver in this league.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I like Lions team as well, I really like Coles' prospects this I could see him being top top ten or even top 5 fairly easy

 
Rody's Post 3rd Round Assessment:

Teams out in front thus far are:

1. Pimpin Ain't Easy

2. tex

3. Ruffrodys05

4. Domination

5. Prof. Chaos

6. DocNiner52

Three (complete) rounds is not much to go on, as most of us should have (at a minimum) 2 quality studs on their team. These are the teams that stuck out to me. It's not too hard to put together a decent starting unit in the first three rounds. The next 5 rounds will be much more revealing as we see who can add the right mix of players to their team to maximize value and stay competitive over the long haul.

Obviously, this is a premature list of quality teams. Those not listed could easily attain top tier status (in my eyes) with a few great picks between now and the conclusion of round 8.

HAPPY DRAFTING!!!!!!!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
QB: Romo, Big Ben

RB: SA, Deuce

WR: Fitzgerald, Ward, Galloway, Berrian

TE: Clark

Ive just gotten great value on all my picks

:bowtie:

 
QB: Romo, Big Ben

RB: SA, Deuce

WR: Fitzgerald, Ward, Galloway, Berrian

TE: Clark

Ive just gotten great value on all my picks

:angry:
NB I hope you don't throw your shoulder out patting yourself on the back. :P
Especially for a team thats middle of the pack.Decent, but nothing to get excited about.
:confused:
Not even close. Just calling it like I see it.Your team is solid, but thats about it. No need to go Lhucks on em, and act like your team is the one to beat. Which BTW is the kiss of death. Or acting like your the only one on the boards who's heard of Romo before :lmao:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
QB: Romo, Big Ben

RB: SA, Deuce

WR: Fitzgerald, Ward, Galloway, Berrian

TE: Clark

Ive just gotten great value on all my picks

:yes:
You've gotten fair value on a couple of those picks. Alexander and Fitz were no-brainers. Just because Fitz fell to you, only means others valued different players higher. You've just about picked your way out of having any decent RB back-ups by ignoring them since the 3rd round. I can't wait to see your evaluations after this is all said and done!I'll be re-doing my TOP 6 TEAMS tomorrow morning. It will be based on the first 8 rounds, unless we get through 9 before then.

 
I'll be re-doing my TOP 6 TEAMS tomorrow morning. It will be based on the first 8 rounds, unless we get through 9 before then.
Here are my overall rankings, now that we have 10 completed rounds and are at the halfway point:these teams are my top 8:

1. tex

2. Pimpin 'Aint Easy

3a. Bruno2

3b. Rudy

4a. Ruffrodys05 (4a to 4d are extremely close, any of us could be on top of the 4's, chose myself)

4b. Domination

4c. DocNiner52

4d. krsone21

these teams are close, but not quite there:

5a. NoFBinLA

5b. Orgazmo

5c. Chaser1439 (amazing huh?)

these teams are in a wee bit of trouble:

6a. Prof. Chaos

6b. FreeBaGel

6c. NorrisB (wee bit more trouble than most others, except....)

these teams need mucho help:

7. lions327

8. Ministry of Pain

Team (#a) is slightly in better shape than team (#b), and team (#b) is slightly better than team (#c), and so on. The groupings are just a way of indicating how tight these teams are. The differences between tex's team and krsone21's team are not that great, in fact quite minimal.

I would say we have the tighest group of teams in all the PDSL's. No clear-cut favorite at this point. Although I'm putting tex at the top right now, it could be any number of us in that spot.

Rody

Edit: BTW, I used a sophisticated software program that I created which took into account the following:

each team's:

draft spot

# of players per position

# of positions with a top 12-16 starter

# of players in top 16-32

value of pick at each round

# of value picks

and other miniscule data produced by inserting the lists/draft into the program... ;) :mellow: ;)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
No comments about my rankings? I knew I would not get a response to the rankings after 3 rounds.....but come on guys, after 10 rounds, I thought I'd at least touch one nerve or two. Oh well, maybe it's the day. Wacky Hump Day Wednesday and all it's glorious BS.

We haven't done much today in the form of drafting at all, either, so I guess it should come as no surprise.

 
What can I say about my ranking no complaints here, about in the middle of the pack looks abour right.

 
I appreciate the confidence in my team, but like you said, they are all fairly close. I got real lucky with the bye weeks and have no conflicts yet and as long as I watch my draft I won't have any. I just need Mike Bell to do something on some weeks. He is the only one that really worries me so far. I think Welker will be a steal. I know the Pats like to spread the ball around, but Welker is a master at finding the opening and Brady always finds the open man, so Welker could catch a lot of balls this year. Unfortunately there won't be many TD's for him. But it will not surprise me at all if Welker becomes Brady's favorite receiver. :wall: Now on to the rest of the draft. :thumbup:

 
Ruffrodys05

6.09 Matt Leinart, ARI, QB12 (8)

11.08 JaMarcus Russell,®, QB31

1.08 Rudi Johnson, CIN, RB7 (5)

4.09 Jamal Lewis, CLE, RB30 (7)

8.09 Lorenzo Booker, ®, RB44

9.08 Corey Dillon, ???, RB48

2.09 Reggie Wayne, IND, WR5 (6)

5.08 Santana Moss, WAS, WR25 (4)

7.08 Isaac Bruce, STL, WR39 (9)

10.09 Ashley Lelie, SF, WR56 (6)

3.08 Kellen Winslow II, CLE, TE2 (7)

My team is the greatest......and I will KRUSH you all. :yes: :yes: :yes:

 
Since I have the free time as we wait.....

1.13 Clinton Portis, WAS, RB12

There’s always a moment in a draft when you look back and say, hmm, was that the right move? Rarely is that the case first pick. I had picked Travis Henry, but due to some confusion, I found myself able to re-pick. Portis had gone right before my Henry pick and was the guy I had wanted in the first place. Henry could have a huge season for Denver, but I went with my gut instinct and took Portis. I think he’ll do very well this season, even with Betts lightening the load. If he can stay healthy, well worth the #13 pick, IMO. The only question is how good Henry will be, but regardless, I think good value here with this pick.

2.04 Edgerrin James, ARI, RB17

Again, happy with my value. Sure, AD or someone could be brought in as a rook runner. I don’t think it will happen, but it could. But I think ultimately Edge is good for a bounce back year – how much? Well, it’s debatable – not top ten, but certainly worth the #20 pick, 17th RB off the board. The biggest question could be, how do the Cards start the season? If they stumble out of the date, well, could be all she wrote for me.

I had thought very hard about going RB/WR or WR/RB but felt that in both cases, the value of the RBs sitting there by me was solid – I knew a lot of Rbs would go off the board (though not as much as did) and I had a long way to go with picks – I hoped I would find a solid WR and thought the odds were better for that then a solid #2 which I believe Edge is.

3.13 Javon Walker, DEN, WR15

I expected some WRs to go, but not all of them! Well, ok, hyperbole aside, more people went RB/WR than I had anticipated, but I still like this pick. I have no worries about his past injuries – he looked good enough for me. He looked fine last year, is the number 1 in Denver and Cutler is advancing just fine. While he’s no Chad Johnson, I think he’ll put up solid numbers from here on out. Very happy to find him here after watching so many guys fly off the board. I think he’ll be a solid #1.

4.04 Drew Brees, NO, QB3

Normally way too early for me to take my QB. But I had this feeling a run was about to start…. Which wasn’t quite the case. Still he wouldn’t have been there (IMO) at my next pick, so better safe than sorry. I expect Brees to have another year of very good numbers, and believe he will carry me at the QB spot for the year. Again, a little before I was planning to go for the position, but I like him a lot and wanted a stufd QB – I guess you have to pay the toll then.

5.12 Cris Cooley, WAS, TE10

Speaking of the toll – the problem with going with Brees last pick is the last top teir TEs are gone. Luckily Cooley hung on for me – he’s not a Heap, gates or even a Shockey but he’s put up good numbers the last few years and if he can match last years catches (57 to go with 700+ yards and 6 TDs) he should be very good for most of the year. Campbell seems to like him too so that’ something, though as Campbell gets more confidence, he may look away from the TE safety valve more.

6.04 Mike Furrey, DET, WR29

Thought very hard about going RB here but wanted to add to my WR core – I have two Rbs, let’s fill out the other two starting spots of need. Furrey really excelled last season and I think there’s more to come. Now, depending on what the Kitty Cats do in the draft, well that could change his situation. But Martz knows him, he performed well last year and gets a lot of play opposite Williams. If BMW continues to implode, well I think Furrey has no real challengers to his #2 spot. In which case, am happy to get him here. A few of the WRs who go next were on my list so I was glad I grabbed one while I could.

7.13 Muhsin Muhammad, CHI, WR41

Again, filling out my roster. But as this was in the midst of a pretty large WR run I almost felt compelled to get him while he was still there. Sure Grossman is erratic. And sure Muhammed rarely puts up huge #1 style numbers and he’s getting long in the tooth – and Berrian is right there.

Wait, why did I pick him? Oh – I couldn’t possibly pass up a #1 WR at this point in the game and while he’s not spectacular, he’s a good solid player who can put up very good numbers for a #3. Happy to find him here and grab him.

8.04 DeShaun Foster, CAR, RB41

I had targeted about a half dozen RBs for my RB 3 this round – and they pretty much all went before my Muhammad pick. I thought Morency might drop a little more, but he didn’t. While Foster in’t necessarily a workhorse #1, he will keep splitting carries as long as he;s healthy and I think will have a big game here or there. As a #3 he should do all right – I might have waited a round too long, but as I wanted to fill out my WRs, this is the price you pay. I think he’ll be good, though no expectations of great.

9.13 Jeff Garcia, TB, QB27

Well, will he start? I said at the time, I believe he will – I think Spleen Boy and Baldy won’t take the job from him and Gruden wants to win now – and Garcia is his best bet. As long as he’s healthy, he’ll have some good games – especially if the Bucs manage to steal Calvin Johnson.

10.04 Anthony Thomas, BUF, RB49

Again, a tad risky for an RB, even RB4. Even if Buffalo gets a stud RB rookie, I think they may work him in gradualkly and ATrain, while not an every down, #1 back will hopefully put up just enough to give me a sporting chance on bye weeks. Even better, if Buffalo manages to not draft an RB, they might ride ATrain and see what next years free agency and draft bring.

Then again, they might get Mike Turner in which case – AT? Welcome to the bench. ?

11.13 Sinorice Moss NYG WR67

Dunno if Toomer is coming back and I think if he doesn’t Moss has a good chance of maybe being that #2 or at least getting a look. Even if Toomer does come back I think the younger WRs will get more time, even if just so the Giants can see what they have.

12.04 Bryant Johnson, ARI, WR70

Pure upside. Johnson showed some flashes of ability. I’m just hoping he has a couple of good games. If Leinart progresses well, Johnson could put up ok numbers. Lots of WRs on my board jumped ship prior to this pick, however, so with what I had to choose from, as far as #3s, I liked what Johnson has and his chances.

Despite hindsite being 20/20, I’m pretty happy with the team – as Rody said, could go either way. There are some holes that developed (especially post bye weeks) that needed patching but overall, not bad. Not flashy and wall to wall studs, but from the #13, I’m pretty happy.

Will take a look at other teams later and see how I feel Rody's chart did. :thumbdown:

 
4a. Ruffrodys05 (4a to 4d are extremely close, any of us could be on top of the 4's, chose myself)
A lovely bit of honesty, that. :shrug:I agree that TEx is up at the top -- the Balt D pick only solidifies it.I don't have much criticism of it, thoguh I can only half read it at work. Mop could have the biggest swing depending on Peterson and if Bush progresses well....
 
After a quick look, here's how I'd rank the top 8 teams.

1. Tex

2. Bruno2

3. Ministry of Pain

4. krsone21

5. Domination

6. Ruffrodys05

7. NorrisB

8. NoFBInLA

Tex's strengths are obvious at this point. LT is going to do a ton of the heavy lifting and as long as he picks up one more RB to help Bell cover Jones, he's pretty much set. That's the great thing about having an RB like LT or S-Jax in this format, you lock him up with one other solid starter and your basically set. Then it's just a matter of picking up two more to cover byes/bad week or two/injuries.Driver / Branch / Holmes / Welker all have decent upside and are in good situations. Basically he took great advantage of the leeway LT gave him in selecting overall value and benefited from one or two guys falling into his lap.

Bruno's team is pretty well-rounded and has a lot of studs that I'm surprised he got for value in some cases. Starting a team off with the #2 and 14th ranked RB's, a top-5 QB and a top 10 WR. Seems solid. Oh and then get another #1 WR that finished one spot out of the top 25 and is on a team that could be receiving a QB upgrade this season. Yeah. Seems fine.

MOP's team I think is misunderstood. The team really looks like it's going to win or just completely flame out. In fact I had to heavily consider where exactly to put him considering the make-up of most of the other teams here. Here's the thing, when he grabbed the three running backs off the board, he grabbed guys that all had major upside to them. AP has the potential to be a top 15-20 RB right off the bat if he lands in the right spot. Caddy in the 3rd is great value and if he even cobbles together a half-decent year will be value for where he was taken.

That said, I figured MOP was dead just because of all the value he'd be missing out on. Then he manages this for a WR set-up:

D-Jax, Glenn, Curtis, Booker, Clayton.

I'm certainly not high on D-Jax, but for where he got him, that's great. Glenn and Curtis both easily have potential / situations to finish in the top 25 this year. Hell, Glenn finished in the top 20 in this scoring format in 06. If somebody like Trent Green comes in, Booker could replicate his performance this year, especially considering his numbers in light of who was chucking the ball last year. It's certainly not a great stable of WR, but considering the picks he used to make it, it's solid. Did well for what he was presented with.

His QB's aren't great, but meh. Two starters that have great #1's to throw the ball too. He's going to get production out of them; and this is assuming he doesn't add another.

:boxing: Sleep now though.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ruffrody

6.09 Matt Leinart, ARI, QB12, Bye-8

11.08 JaMarcus Russell,®, QB31

Grade D: Leinart is an average Qb1, and its never a smart idea to draft a rookie QB as your #2

1.08 Rudi Johnson, CIN, RB7, Bye-5

4.09 Jamal Lewis, CLE, RB30, Bye-7

8.09 Lorenzo Booker, ®, RB44

9.08 Corey Dillon, ???, RB48

Grade D: Rudi is a safe bet, then there's alot of crap after that Jamal will likely be a backup, and is washed up anyway Dillon's done. This is a below average group

2.09 Reggie Wayne, IND, WR5, Bye-6

5.08 Santana Moss, WAS, WR25, Bye-4

7.08 Isaac Bruce, STL, WR39, Bye-9

10.09 Ashley Lelie, SF, WR56, Bye-6

13.08 Dwayne Jarrett, ®, WR75

14.09 David Givens, TEN, WR79, Bye-4

Grade B-: Not a great group, Wayne is a good #1, but alot of ? marks after that.

3.08 Kellen Winslow II, CLE, TE2, Bye-7

12.09 Ben Troupe, TEN, TE21, Bye-4

Grade: B+ I like Troupe, Winslow has too many ?? marks surronding him to warrant that pick, would have been better to take a real Rb2 here.

15.08 David Akers, PHI, K8, Bye-5

16.09 Arizona Cardinals, DST17, Bye-8

17.08 Seattle Seahawks, DST25, Bye-8

Grade G-, two defenses with the same bye week = Dumb :thumbup:

Final Grade: F, I dont see how I can give you a passing grade when you put your only QB and both defenses on the same bye week. :yawn:

Live and learn.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's a shame really, if you were going to go to the trouble of evaluating my team to find weaknesses or to smack it around some, you should have tried a little harder.

Some of your comments here are contradicting to previous comments you've made....... When I drafted Leinart, you stated you liked him a lot, now (since you are mad at me) he's just average.

I think you are a wee bit off with your grades, but I'll accept them for what they are.....Ok, so, two 'D's (QB & RB), and two 'B's (WR & TE)...averages out to a 'C'. To go and lump Akers in with the defenses is just too funny. Akers is definately an 'A'. Having two defenses on the same bye, does not warrant an 'F' for the position. I'll get production out of them weekly (except on week 8), so they should at least warrant a 'C-' or 'D+'!!! My team really ranks out to a 'C' or 'C+' if I accept your QB & RB grades, which I stated I would for this exercise.

Seeing you give my team an 'F' only solidifies my thinking that you are a snide, spiteful little man. But that's Ok, you'll get by.

For a lesson on team evaluating see below:

NorrisB

6.11 Tony Romo, DAL, QB13, Bye-8

8.11 Ben Roethlesberger, PIT, QB18, Bye-6

I believe you would have taken Leinart, had I not, but either way, this is the real group of 'average' QB's. Both of these QB's must deal with new coaching regimes, in addition to their own average talents, which might play a little bit into how they produce this year. Personally, I don't like either of them, but that won't effect my grade for them....C/C+

1.06 Shaun Alexander, SEA, RB6, Bye-8

3.06 Duece McAllister, NO, RB23, Bye-4

11.06 Correll Buckhalter, PHI, RB52, Bye-5

14.11 Brandon Jackson, ®, RB62

SA, as I've stated before, was a nice pick. I would have grabbed him, had he slid to me, and would have been thrilled. Not high on Duece, but good value pick here. Buck in the 11th could prove an excellent value, should Westy go down for any amount of time. Reid likes him a lot and is not afraid to use him when neccessary. Don't know much about Jackson at all, other than that he is from Nebraska. If he lands in a good situation, he could prove to be a decent pick. Grade: B-

2.11 Larry Fitzgerald, ARI, WR7 , Bye-8

4.11 Hines Ward, PIT, WR19, Bye-6

5.06 Joey Galloway, TB, WR24, Bye-10

7.06 Bernard Berrian, CHI, WR37, Bye-9

10.11 Chris Henry, CIN, WR57, Bye-5

13.06 Joe Jurevicius, CLE, WR74, Bye-7

16.11 Mike Williams, DET, WR88, Bye-6

Fitz is a great WR, but Boldin is the real monster in Az. Nice pick though, as he fell to you and you could not pass. Ward is just a steady producer. Galloway could prove to be good value here in the 5th, but they have not handed the reins to Garcia just yet. Simms is still the starter (according to the FBG news blogger) and he is still a greenhorn, so I'm not inclined to give Galloway a bump yet. Berrian is Rex's favorite target downfield, but is basically boom or bust week to week. Sucks about Henry. I like him and was looking to nab him, but was willing to wait. Glad I did. No production for 8 weeks is going to hurt. Jurevicius is lost in the folds of the Browns O. He was targetted 65 times by Frye last year, as compared to Winslow, who had 129 targets. Mike Williams? WTF? You do know he is going to get cut by Detroit this year, don't you. What has this guy done? Ever? OC Martz is looking past him at this point and you should not expect much, if anything at all, from Williams this year. Grade: C. Could have been a B, but Henry and company bring it down.

9.06 Dallas Clark, IND, TE15 , Bye-6

12.11 Marcedes Lewis, JAC, TE22, Bye-4

Landing Clark as TE15 is pretty good. Lewis is a nice TE2, as Leftwich likes to dump off to his TE's when the running game is lacking and his WR's are covered tight. Could prove grood value out of the 12th round. Grade: B-

15.06 Green Bay Packers, DST13, Bye-7

17.06 New York Giants, DST24, Bye-9

Both of these defenses are average, at best. Grade: C

What, no kickers yet? Oh well, they are a dime a dozen anyway, so you can't do all that bad with what is left for the pickin'. Considering you have waited on them though, I can only guess that you'll get average to below average value. Grade: C-

Your team is average. Not bottom of the pile, nor sitting at the top. Overall grade: C

Your draft so far has been a far cry from schooling us all. You did state at the beginning of this thing that that is what you would do. But you did not.

I will re-evaluate after this is over, because who knows, you might do something in the last couple rounds which would neccessitate adjustments to your grades.

Good luck, Rody

 
I am going to self analyze my team. I drafted 16th, and with that being the case, I felt the only real shot I had was to take a few chances along the way and hope most pan out. If most don't, I won't last long.

6.01 Jon Kitna, DET, QB10, Bye-6

9.16 Trent Green, KC, QB29, Bye-8

13.16 Josh McCown, DET, QB36, Bye-6

I consider Kitna to be tremendous value as the 10th QB taken. Last season, in his first year playing in Martz' offense, he was 5th-6th in all of my leagues, and I can't see him being any worse this season, with an extra year of experience in that complex offense. Green will be a solid QB2 if he goes to Miami, as I think he will. I wanted someone better, but there was a big QB run, and he was the best available. At QB29, if he goes to Miami, he will be adequate. McCown as my QB3 was an easy choice for me. He will either be Kitna's backup, or start in Oakland. If the latter is true, I could have 3 starting QB's.

Overall, if Kitna stays near his last years ranking of 5th or 6th, this will be a solid group, especially since Kitna was taken as the 10th QB.

QB's: GRADE: B

1.16 Maurice Jones-Drew, JAC, RB15, Bye-4

3.16 Michael Turner, SD, RB28, Bye-7

7.16 Leon Washington, NYJ, RB40, Bye-10

12.01 Mewelde Moore, MIN, RB53, Bye-5

15.16 Kevin Faulk, NE, RB65, Bye-10

This is a group of RB's that could do great, or could fall apart and kill me. Many question marks in this bunch, but drafting 16th, I decided to gamble on upside. MJD was RB15, and finished 8th or about in my leagues last season. I don't expect him to equal last years TD's, but a slight increase in yards and receptions should offset part of the drop in TD's. A borderline top 10 is not out of the question. Of course, sharing with Fred Taylor could hurt his value, but at 1.16, it was an easy decision. Michael Turner is the wild card of my team. RB28 is great value if he gets traded, which I expect to happen. If he does, he could get into the top 15. the bad thing is if he goes to Tennessee, he has the same bye week as MJD, in week 4. That will be the key to my chances of hanging around. If he isn't traded, I'm probably out early. I picked Leon Washington mainly because I wanted someone who will play some every week, and get some receptions. I mainly want him to pick up the slack if my first 2 RB's have an off game. Moore and Faulk were picked because they should get some action as 3rd down backs and possibly have a few decent games between them.

Overall, this group lacks depth, but if Turner is traded, it will be solid considering I drafted 16th, and also because Turner was RB28. If he starts, i think he is a top 15-20 RB.

RB's: GRADE: B (if Turner is traded)

RB's: GRADE: E (if Turner isn't traded)

4.01 Lavernues Coles, NYJ, WR17, Bye-10

5.16 Mark Clayton, BAL, WR28, Bye-8

8.01 Jerry Porter, OAK, WR44, Bye-5

10.01 Brandon Jones, TEN, WR51, Bye-4

11.16 Reche Caldwell, NE, WR69, Bye-10

14.01 Eric Parker, SD, WR77, Bye-7

Plenty of question marks here. Because I chose to take Gates at 2.01, I knew I would be lacking at the top of my WR's. Again, I took some chances out of need from picking 16th. Coles and Clayton are both solid, but neither is a WR1. Porter is a risk, but he is capable of putting up WR2 numbers if his attitude is better. Brandon Jones will only get better and I love the value at WR51. Caldwell and Parker are decent depth and both should start.

Overall, considering I took Gates early, I got reasonable value at WR. I have good depth, but no studs.

WR's: GRADE: C

2.01 Antonio Gates, SD, TE1 , Bye-7

16.01 Leonard Pope, ARI, TE30, Bye-8

I decided to take Gates at 2.01 because he has ridiculous value in this scoring format (2 points per reception for TE's). I wanted some kind of big advantage every week, and I have that. Pope, I just hope he has a few decent games, but I'm not counting on much from TE30.

TE's: GRADE: A

17.16 Cleveland Browns DST31, Bye-7

18.01 Houston Texans DST32, Bye-10

At my picks at the 15/16 turn, there were 13 defenses taken. I decided to let them go here and grab one of the few sleeper defenses I liked. By the time it came back to me, these were the last 2 defenses left. Ouch. Cleveland has some decent young players and could be better, Same with Houston. But at best if either was ranked 20th, it would be a surprise.

DST: GRADE: D- (Only because they don't have the same bye week, or else it would be an E)

As of this, I have no kickers.

Overall, picking 16th is not easy, and I think my only chance was to take some chances, such as Turner and Porter. All in all, I think I did pretty decent considering where I drafted from. It's asking a lot for a bunch of things to pan out, but who knows. I definitely dont think my team is bad, but it's not the best either. I consider it middle of the road, which is good picking last. My starters have potential if all the stars align, but a lack of RB depth, and needing too many things to go right will make this difficult. It's not impossible, but the odds are not in my favor. I would like to make to past week 7 or 8 and see what happens. The only way I even have a small chance is if Turner is traded. Even then, it will be difficult.

OVERALL GRADE: C (If Turner is traded)

OVERALL GRADE: D- (If Turner isn't traded)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ruffrodys05 said:
It's a shame really, if you were going to go to the trouble of evaluating my team to find weaknesses or to smack it around some, you should have tried a little harder.

Some of your comments here are contradicting to previous comments you've made....... When I drafted Leinart, you stated you liked him a lot, now (since you are mad at me) he's just average.

I think you are a wee bit off with your grades, but I'll accept them for what they are.....Ok, so, two 'D's (QB & RB), and two 'B's (WR & TE)...averages out to a 'C'. To go and lump Akers in with the defenses is just too funny. Akers is definately an 'A'. Having two defenses on the same bye, does not warrant an 'F' for the position. I'll get production out of them weekly (except on week 8), so they should at least warrant a 'C-' or 'D+'!!! My team really ranks out to a 'C' or 'C+' if I accept your QB & RB grades, which I stated I would for this exercise.

Seeing you give my team an 'F' only solidifies my thinking that you are a snide, spiteful little man. But that's Ok, you'll get by.
I do like Leinart alot, and I have him about 8th overall. Thats an average QB1 in fantasy football, and a very good QB in real life. Then you took a really bad bad QB2, which made your QBs below average which is a D. Then your RBs, you took a RB that I have about 10-12 overall, which is slightly below 8 which is below average, then you didnt take a real RB2, and you'll be lucky if all that crap turns into 1 average RB2, which leads to a D grade. Then you had slightly above average WRs, and good TE's which I was generous with the grading, your grade at this point is probably C-, then you destroyed your team by having your only QB and both defenses on bye on the same week, which pretty much solidified your elimination.

 
I would like to see your analysis how you think that team is a C or even a C+ :cry:
I'll be absolutely more than thrilled to provide you with my championship caliber insight and analysis into my own team and others (including yours, again) when the draft is over. Till then, patience is a virtue.ETA: Exactly how is JaMarcus Russell a "bad, bad QB"? You like to make short blanket statements that have absolutely no merit whatsoever. Try expounding on that thought and convince me (and others) you are right about Russell. Otherwise, you've said nothing to indicate why he is so bad. He'll go early in the draft, if not #1 overall, and nothing that's been said about him (by experts or otherwise) even remotely indicates he's a bad QB.

Everything you've said last night and today just proves you are pissed off and are just trying to get into a pissing match with me. Forget it, you'll lose.....badly. You obviously don't know how to make a valid point when confronted to do so, so why don't you quit while your losing.

More ETA: I gave you a fair asessment of your team to date and did not rip it to shreds, which I could have. Re-read that analysis and see if you can learn something from it, instead of continually showing everyone how angry you are at me for calling you out on your idiocy.

Rody

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is all real good entertainment, isn't it folks? I'll play along for a little while longer, then I'll get bored and move forward.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top