We're staying at the W Hoboken.
Pretty sure this is going to be a huge mistake.
Oh no... how was the trip?
Hmm, I guess I didn't ever come back in this thread... after all the planning/advice/suggestions from so many helpful FBG's last year, we didn't end up going. Both of our hotels were out of commission due to Sandy. We got full refunds and took a trip a little closer to home (Ottawa/Montreal). It was fun, but nothing new since I've been to both a few times.
Anyway, we're going to try again from the 19th-23rd of October.
I had an itinerary done for the last trip, so not starting from scratch, but I do have a couple questions.
It looks like South St. Seaport is still suffering from the aftermath and Pier 17 is closing until 2015, I guess I can scratch this off the list?
Is there anything I need to see in Times Square during the day or in Central Park at night?
We don't have a hotel booked yet, I'll likely use Priceline/hotwire - it looks like right now Hoboken/Long Island City are almost as expensive as the hotels in NYC, so we'll likely stay somewhere in Manhattan this time - I'll be driving down, I've seen it suggested to park in Newark and take the train in - any comments on doing this vs. driving in/finding somewhere to park? We'll be leaving here Friday after work, it's about an 8 hour drive, we'll stop at a hotel halfway down Friday night (Syracuse, maybe), then get up early and arrive around 1PM to get to a 3 PM check in on Saturday. Is traffic any better/worse on weekends, or should I not even consider driving? In doing some research, some say Toronto is worse than New York traffic wise, and I drive into downtown T.O. a few times a month. Parking cost would be a factor here too.
In terms of general plan:
Saturday - arrive/check in/get some touristy stuff out of the way - top of the rock, grab quick dinner (pizza spot nearby? Last time Pastafina was recommended but looks like the location near TS closed), times square at night, etc...
Sunday - was thinking of doing Williamsburg Flea/Brooklyn Brewery/Williamsburg area for part of the day and then Greenwich village later on - I see TU recommended John's for pizza dinner/Sweet revenge for beer/desert which sounds good, then it looks like the Comedy Cellar is right in the area as well.
Monday - Some combination of Tom's Restaurant (Seinfeld), Central Park, Museum of Natural History, Shake Shack, The Met - then we have no plans for this evening, so I'm open to suggestions. Maybe TKTS at 3 when it opens and a show later on, or possibly the Jazz Standard which we wanted to do last time.
Tuesday - Will likely do the Wall Street/Brooklyn Bridge/World Trade Memorial/Statue of Liberty early on (lunch recommendation? Made Fresh Daily was recommended last time - not sure its Status now). Not sure about the afternoon, but I wouldn't mind going somewhere to have a few beers, then that evening we're seeing Franz Ferdinand at the Hammerstein ballroom.
Wednesday drive home.
Anyway, I'll take any input/criticism/suggestions over the next few weeks. We want to mix the tourist stuff with seeing as many different areas as we can - so far I think we get to financial district, times square/theatre district/central park/Williamsburg/Greenwich Village, what other areas am I missing. I don't have Chelsea/Soho/East Village in there at all, what am I missing?