That Dive Master looks pretty cool. It's funny looking back on that post on my first automatic watch. A year and a half later, I'm up to six watches with six different color dials:
http://i.imgur.com/1FUCHib.jpg. From left to right: Stowa Marine Automatic, Orient Blue Mako, Oris Artelier Date, Seiko SARB017 Alpinist, Orient Marshall, Graf Zeppelin Hindenburg LZ129 7060-4. I'd say the Blue Mako has gotten the most wear because it's the one I'll wear in more casual situations without a care. It's the one I'll take on the train to visit my girlfriend for the weekend. The Stowa gets the second most wrist time. It just has a great feel to it with such a comfortable strap, plus it goes well with more of my outfits than any of the others.