There's been plenty of track stars bust in the NFL, so just being a great athlete usually doesn't translate to being a good football player. I agree that it would be fun watching him try.With his size, weight, and talent hed be top 5 WR hands down in my opinion. Hes pure talent
Was just about to post the same thing. He would've been a blue-chip football recruit if it wouldn't have been for his basketball hobby thingy.Lebron was an All-State high school WR here in Ohio.
link:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LeBron_JamesLebron was an All-State high school WR here in Ohio.
That first route he ran was garbageA couple of his high school football clips...
The more important question is what is his BMI?ETA: I'd love to see him try it.I wonder what his 40 time would be.
and McNabb would have been a decent Basketball player....
if he could've kept himself away from the buffet tables Chunky Soup...
link:http://www.answers.com/topic/wilt-chamberlainWilt Chamberlain was a Olympic Level high jumper, i still can't fathom a guy over 7feet being able to clear 7ft. with his size and freakish athleticism its no wonder he dominated on the way to GOAT. he probably could've made a decent redzone threat
+1Lebron = Kicker in the NFL
You REALLY think he is as FAST as the receivers you mentioned? I think that is very presumptuous, bordering on a little crazy. We don't know for sure so I cant totally discount it, but I dont see anything close to NFL WR top end speed in lebron.That said, he was a great HS football player with immense physical skills, so this is a discussion worth having (unlike with many other athletes)... but as noted, it is likely a discussion as TE because I dont see him getting the seperation as a WR necessary to succeed in the NFL.leave a whisper said:slow ??bet he is just as fast as Owens, Boldin, or Wayne 6'8" 260lbs. & built like a tank .... would have been a bigger stronger Randy Moss
Umm...huh? As for the rest of the thread. I don't think people are saying whether it would have been smart or not money wise.Just how would he have translated.I think pretty well.Given he did have a background in it...he is a ridiculous athlete. Its not just speed...but he has the size and athleticism.Probably a WR/TE type. And not that it means it would be the same for him...but two of the best TEs out there the past several years were not first even football players but basketball.I have no doubt in my mind he could have made it as a pro.Kicker though?Lebron = Kicker in the NFL
I believe I was clear. If he was in the NFL, he would be a kicker.Umm...huh? As for the rest of the thread. I don't think people are saying whether it would have been smart or not money wise.Just how would he have translated.I think pretty well.Given he did have a background in it...he is a ridiculous athlete. Its not just speed...but he has the size and athleticism.Probably a WR/TE type. And not that it means it would be the same for him...but two of the best TEs out there the past several years were not first even football players but basketball.I have no doubt in my mind he could have made it as a pro.Kicker though?Lebron = Kicker in the NFL
You just quoted his measurables, tell me, why would he need to get separation?You REALLY think he is as FAST as the receivers you mentioned? I think that is very presumptuous, bordering on a little crazy. We don't know for sure so I cant totally discount it, but I dont see anything close to NFL WR top end speed in lebron.That said, he was a great HS football player with immense physical skills, so this is a discussion worth having (unlike with many other athletes)... but as noted, it is likely a discussion as TE because I dont see him getting the seperation as a WR necessary to succeed in the NFL.leave a whisper said:slow ??
bet he is just as fast as Owens, Boldin, or Wayne
6'8" 260lbs. & built like a tank .... would have been a bigger stronger Randy Moss
Agreed. You wouldn't be able to get a pass off.He'd probably be better suited to TE, but maybe he could be a Colston type at WR.
I always thought Shaq would be a great left tackle defensive lineman.
Wow... he would have been a completely ridiculous DE. If he doesn't get to the QB, he's swatting down any pass thrown in his direction.Of course, he might last a season or two before an offensive lineman took out one of his knees, but he's dominate for as long as he'd last.Agreed. You wouldn't be able to get a pass off.He'd probably be better suited to TE, but maybe he could be a Colston type at WR.
I always thought Shaq would be a great left tackle defensive lineman.
And I believe I was very clear...if you think that, you don't know much about how athletic the guy is and are severely misguided or you are fishing.I believe I was clear. If he was in the NFL, he would be a kicker.Umm...huh? As for the rest of the thread. I don't think people are saying whether it would have been smart or not money wise.Just how would he have translated.I think pretty well.Given he did have a background in it...he is a ridiculous athlete. Its not just speed...but he has the size and athleticism.Probably a WR/TE type. And not that it means it would be the same for him...but two of the best TEs out there the past several years were not first even football players but basketball.I have no doubt in my mind he could have made it as a pro.Kicker though?Lebron = Kicker in the NFL
Because we are talking about the NFL.At TE, looking for TE type routes (Gates style) and as an endzone target, you don't need as much seperation. On the outside and in the slot as a WR? Oh, you bet - even at 6'8"You just quoted his measurables, tell me, why would he need to get separation?You REALLY think he is as FAST as the receivers you mentioned? I think that is very presumptuous, bordering on a little crazy. We don't know for sure so I cant totally discount it, but I dont see anything close to NFL WR top end speed in lebron.That said, he was a great HS football player with immense physical skills, so this is a discussion worth having (unlike with many other athletes)... but as noted, it is likely a discussion as TE because I dont see him getting the seperation as a WR necessary to succeed in the NFL.slow ??
bet he is just as fast as Owens, Boldin, or Wayne
6'8" 260lbs. & built like a tank .... would have been a bigger stronger Randy Moss
He's was bigger and faster than Gates is now, when he was in HS.He jumps higher than most current or past NBA or NFL players.He has great hands.He has great decision making skills.He's still only 25 years old.I personally would like to see him play free safety, but he could play WR, TE, CB, FS, SS, OLB, ILB, if he wanted to.These are High school measurements...6' 8"250 lbs4.40 40 yd dash
Are you guys really taking his high school 40 times seriously? Ummm, come on now. Hands/decision making on a basket ball court are far different than hands/decision making on a football field.He's was bigger and faster than Gates is now, when he was in HS.He jumps higher than most current or past NBA or NFL players.He has great hands.He has great decision making skills.He's still only 25 years old.I personally would like to see him play free safety, but he could play WR, TE, CB, FS, SS, OLB, ILB, if he wanted to.These are High school measurements...6' 8"250 lbs4.40 40 yd dash
His 40 time now might not be much different.Its not like he is that old or out of shape.I think the point is, his measurables and athleticism and work ethic would be very favorable.IMO, anyone saying he could not do it or would be bad...is completely foolish or just fishing.Are you guys really taking his high school 40 times seriously? Ummm, come on now. Hands/decision making on a basket ball court are far different than hands/decision making on a football field.He's was bigger and faster than Gates is now, when he was in HS.He jumps higher than most current or past NBA or NFL players.He has great hands.He has great decision making skills.He's still only 25 years old.I personally would like to see him play free safety, but he could play WR, TE, CB, FS, SS, OLB, ILB, if he wanted to.These are High school measurements...6' 8"250 lbs4.40 40 yd dash
Why wouldn't we take his HS 40 time seriously? It was timed by college scouts. As far as hands/decision making go, both are harder in the NBA than the NFL.Are you guys really taking his high school 40 times seriously? Ummm, come on now. Hands/decision making on a basket ball court are far different than hands/decision making on a football field.He's was bigger and faster than Gates is now, when he was in HS.He jumps higher than most current or past NBA or NFL players.He has great hands.He has great decision making skills.He's still only 25 years old.I personally would like to see him play free safety, but he could play WR, TE, CB, FS, SS, OLB, ILB, if he wanted to.These are High school measurements...6' 8"250 lbs4.40 40 yd dash
My point is that high school 40 times are notoriously inaccurate and that time was probably largely inflated. So even if he does still have the same kind of speed as he did in high school, that speed is not as fast as that time. I'd love to see him try, but again I doubt he would make it in the NFL.His 40 time now might not be much different.Its not like he is that old or out of shape.I think the point is, his measurables and athleticism and work ethic would be very favorable.IMO, anyone saying he could not do it or would be bad...is completely foolish or just fishing.Are you guys really taking his high school 40 times seriously? Ummm, come on now. Hands/decision making on a basket ball court are far different than hands/decision making on a football field.He's was bigger and faster than Gates is now, when he was in HS.He jumps higher than most current or past NBA or NFL players.He has great hands.He has great decision making skills.He's still only 25 years old.I personally would like to see him play free safety, but he could play WR, TE, CB, FS, SS, OLB, ILB, if he wanted to.These are High school measurements...6' 8"250 lbs4.40 40 yd dash
Im going to really ask why?What about him would make you doubt it?He has the size and frame for it...the athleticism...the work ethic.He does not have to have elite speed to be a very good NFL player whether WR/TE.I'd love to see him try, but again I doubt he would make it in the NFL.
His route running would be horrendous. His feet are slow and he would struggle mightily to get off the line vs. NFL CBs (and every CB in the league would get physical with him for that very reason). He has a high center of gravity and runs high in and out of breaks, making him a walking telegraph as to where he is going to NFL DBs. His lateral quickness in not on par with NFL CBs. Sure, he can beat NBA players laterally when it is a foul to get a hand on you and you can set organized picks, but as a WR/TE he would have to create the separation on his own and beat the physical press own his own. Overall James is a lumbering athlete that would struggle to work in space and would hardly ever be able to create separation. Sure, you can say he would be able to catch jump balls, but the effect of that overall to the scheme of the game would be minimal. It doesn't do you much good to catch jump balls if you struggle to get 5 yds down the field and NFL DBs can anticipate the direction you and the ball are going. Bottom line, it doesn't matter how great of an athlete you think he is. One trick ponies are not going to cut it in the NFL on a consistent basis. The athletes are too good. One other little note. There a lot of guys who look like great athletes in shorts but when you put the pads on it's a totally different looking player. There is a reason for that. Overall I think you guys are greatly underestimating the physicality of the NFL. Outside of the jump ball, what exactly do you think he would do well?Im going to really ask why?What about him would make you doubt it?He has the size and frame for it...the athleticism...the work ethic.He does not have to have elite speed to be a very good NFL player whether WR/TE.I'd love to see him try, but again I doubt he would make it in the NFL.
Your right, HS times are inflated going into college as much as college times are inflated going into the pros. But Lebron's reported 40 time was from the college scouts and not the HS coach. Unless your argument is that college scouts can't work a stop-watch, I think you might be wrong here, as almost every college scout in the country paid him a visit.My point is that high school 40 times are notoriously inaccurate and that time was probably largely inflated. So even if he does still have the same kind of speed as he did in high school, that speed is not as fast as that time. I'd love to see him try, but again I doubt he would make it in the NFL.His 40 time now might not be much different.Its not like he is that old or out of shape.I think the point is, his measurables and athleticism and work ethic would be very favorable.IMO, anyone saying he could not do it or would be bad...is completely foolish or just fishing.Are you guys really taking his high school 40 times seriously? Ummm, come on now. Hands/decision making on a basket ball court are far different than hands/decision making on a football field.He's was bigger and faster than Gates is now, when he was in HS.He jumps higher than most current or past NBA or NFL players.He has great hands.He has great decision making skills.He's still only 25 years old.I personally would like to see him play free safety, but he could play WR, TE, CB, FS, SS, OLB, ILB, if he wanted to.These are High school measurements...6' 8"250 lbs4.40 40 yd dash
If the NFL felt they could trust college coaches there would be no need for Pro Days and the combine.Your right, HS times are inflated going into college as much as college times are inflated going into the pros. But Lebron's reported 40 time was from the college scouts and not the HS coach. Unless your argument is that college scouts can't work a stop-watch, I think you might be wrong here, as almost every college scout in the country paid him a visit.My point is that high school 40 times are notoriously inaccurate and that time was probably largely inflated. So even if he does still have the same kind of speed as he did in high school, that speed is not as fast as that time. I'd love to see him try, but again I doubt he would make it in the NFL.His 40 time now might not be much different.Its not like he is that old or out of shape.I think the point is, his measurables and athleticism and work ethic would be very favorable.IMO, anyone saying he could not do it or would be bad...is completely foolish or just fishing.Are you guys really taking his high school 40 times seriously? Ummm, come on now. Hands/decision making on a basket ball court are far different than hands/decision making on a football field.He's was bigger and faster than Gates is now, when he was in HS.He jumps higher than most current or past NBA or NFL players.He has great hands.He has great decision making skills.He's still only 25 years old.I personally would like to see him play free safety, but he could play WR, TE, CB, FS, SS, OLB, ILB, if he wanted to.These are High school measurements...6' 8"250 lbs4.40 40 yd dash
I am about the last guy on earth who would defend Lebron. I'm even a borderline hater. With that being said..Have you ever seen him play? Have you never played basketball before? To say he doesn't have lateral quickness is absurd. You're not driving around guys into the lane without lateral quickness, and he is probably the most devastating player in the league at attacking the rim.His route running would be horrendous. His feet are slow and he would struggle mightily to get off the line vs. NFL CBs (and every CB in the league would get physical with him for that very reason). He has a high center of gravity and runs high in and out of breaks, making him a walking telegraph as to where he is going to NFL DBs. His lateral quickness in not on par with NFL CBs. Sure, he can beat NBA players laterally when it is a foul to get a hand on you and you can set organized picks, but as a WR/TE he would have to create the separation on his own and beat the physical press own his own. Overall James is a lumbering athlete that would struggle to work in space and would hardly ever be able to create separation. Sure, you can say he would be able to catch jump balls, but the effect of that overall to the scheme of the game would be minimal. It doesn't do you much good to catch jump balls if you struggle to get 5 yds down the field and NFL DBs can anticipate the direction you and the ball are going. Bottom line, it doesn't matter how great of an athlete you think he is. One trick ponies are not going to cut it in the NFL on a consistent basis. The athletes are too good. One other little note. There a lot of guys who look like great athletes in shorts but when you put the pads on it's a totally different looking player. There is a reason for that. Overall I think you guys are greatly underestimating the physicality of the NFL. Outside of the jump ball, what exactly do you think he would do well?Im going to really ask why?What about him would make you doubt it?I'd love to see him try, but again I doubt he would make it in the NFL.
He has the size and frame for it...the athleticism...the work ethic.
He does not have to have elite speed to be a very good NFL player whether WR/TE.
Good luck with that.every CB in the league would get physical with him for that very reason)
You do understand that in the NBA you are not allowed to make contact with the offensive player, right?I am about the last guy on earth who would defend Lebron. I'm even a borderline hater. With that being said..Have you ever seen him play? Have you never played basketball before? To say he doesn't have lateral quickness is absurd. You're not driving around guys into the lane without lateral quickness, and he is probably the most devastating player in the league at attacking the rim.His route running would be horrendous. His feet are slow and he would struggle mightily to get off the line vs. NFL CBs (and every CB in the league would get physical with him for that very reason). He has a high center of gravity and runs high in and out of breaks, making him a walking telegraph as to where he is going to NFL DBs. His lateral quickness in not on par with NFL CBs. Sure, he can beat NBA players laterally when it is a foul to get a hand on you and you can set organized picks, but as a WR/TE he would have to create the separation on his own and beat the physical press own his own. Overall James is a lumbering athlete that would struggle to work in space and would hardly ever be able to create separation. Sure, you can say he would be able to catch jump balls, but the effect of that overall to the scheme of the game would be minimal. It doesn't do you much good to catch jump balls if you struggle to get 5 yds down the field and NFL DBs can anticipate the direction you and the ball are going. Bottom line, it doesn't matter how great of an athlete you think he is. One trick ponies are not going to cut it in the NFL on a consistent basis. The athletes are too good. One other little note. There a lot of guys who look like great athletes in shorts but when you put the pads on it's a totally different looking player. There is a reason for that. Overall I think you guys are greatly underestimating the physicality of the NFL. Outside of the jump ball, what exactly do you think he would do well?Im going to really ask why?What about him would make you doubt it?I'd love to see him try, but again I doubt he would make it in the NFL.
He has the size and frame for it...the athleticism...the work ethic.
He does not have to have elite speed to be a very good NFL player whether WR/TE.
Good luck with that.every CB in the league would get physical with him for that very reason)
Your just making stuff up now! Tell me which CB's would be throwing around a 6' 8" 250 lb WR? The guy is big enough to play tackle for Denver! Also slow feet? Have you watched this guy play? The guy makes 3 moves before a player reacts. The only thing you got partially right may have been the route running, but they don't teach proper route running in HS. There's no way you can be sure he'd blow it in college, let alone the pros.His route running would be horrendous. His feet are slow and he would struggle mightily to get off the line vs. NFL CBs (and every CB in the league would get physical with him for that very reason). He has a high center of gravity and runs high in and out of breaks, making him a walking telegraph as to where he is going to NFL DBs. His lateral quickness in not on par with NFL CBs. Sure, he can beat NBA players laterally when it is a foul to get a hand on you and you can set organized picks, but as a WR/TE he would have to create the separation on his own and beat the physical press own his own. Overall James is a lumbering athlete that would struggle to work in space and would hardly ever be able to create separation. Sure, you can say he would be able to catch jump balls, but the effect of that overall to the scheme of the game would be minimal. It doesn't do you much good to catch jump balls if you struggle to get 5 yds down the field and NFL DBs can anticipate the direction you and the ball are going. Bottom line, it doesn't matter how great of an athlete you think he is. One trick ponies are not going to cut it in the NFL on a consistent basis. The athletes are too good. One other little note. There a lot of guys who look like great athletes in shorts but when you put the pads on it's a totally different looking player. There is a reason for that. Overall I think you guys are greatly underestimating the physicality of the NFL. Outside of the jump ball, what exactly do you think he would do well?Im going to really ask why?What about him would make you doubt it?He has the size and frame for it...the athleticism...the work ethic.He does not have to have elite speed to be a very good NFL player whether WR/TE.I'd love to see him try, but again I doubt he would make it in the NFL.