SameSongNDance
Footballguy
I'll preface this with saying I never said he possessed elite athleticism, just that he was more athletic than Marcedes Lewis.I'm not saying there is absolutely no correlation. I'm just not sure that's the best metric as it involves a TON of external variables... Number of targets, Types of routes targeted, Defensive coverages faced, Quality of defenses faced, and most obviously an EXTREMELY small sample size in the case of Julius Thomas. You're welcome to make those sort of comparison in the face of that but I'm not comfortable doing so.So there's absolutely no correlation between the number of longer (40+ yard in this case) passes caught and a players athletic ability? Of course, YAC amongst other things would be more telling but to imply that there's no correlation..I'm not sure how number of catches per start is an effective metric for gauging athleticism?Lewis as three 40+ catches in 96 starts. JT had a 44 yard catch and run in what, his 2nd ever start? I mean, I'm 100% convinced he's a no-brainer top 5 after a single performance but I think it's safe to assume he's a bit more athletic than Marcedes Lewis.I'd probably be looking to sell, assuming that I already had a starting TE who I felt good about (and I'm guessing that many JT owners do, especially in dynasty).
The offense is going to be dynamite and maybe it will carry him to a top 5 finish. OTOH, at risk of sounding like a complete hater, I'm not actually convinced that he's an incredible talent. He doesn't look as athletic as Graham or even Finley to me. More like a Marcedes Lewis, with the benefit of playing in a Peyton Manning offense.
He seemed pretty athletic to me on that 44 yard catch and run.
What I AM willing to do, given the absurdly small data set of actual game time (where IMO he looked good but moved akwardly at times).... and look at something fairly standardized: NFL Combine data. Now unfortunately we don't have combine data for Gronk but here's a comparison of Graham and Thomas:
40yd Dash: 4.56 (graham) vs 4.68 (Thomas)
Vert Leap: 38.5" vs 35.5"
Broad Jump: 120" vs 111"
3 Cone Drill: 6.90 vs 6.96sec
60yd Shuttle: 11.76 vs 11.95sec
Height: 6'6" vs 6'5"
Reach: 35" vs 33"
Graham Notes:
STRENGTHSGraham has an outstanding combination of size and speed for the tight end position. A former basketball player, he shows impressive natural athleticism on the gridiron. Despite limited experience, he has capable hands to make a play in traffic. High-character guy. Possesses tremendous potential.
WEAKNESSESGraham lacks game experience with only one year of football under his belt. At this time, work ethic as a pure football player needs to improve. His toughness is in question as he still carries the basketball player label. Blocking tenacity and overall technique need polish and refinement.
Thomas Notes:
STRENGTHSThomas possesses excellent size coupled with enough speed for the NFL. Displays some savvy and athleticism setting up defenders in his stem. Tough matchup for linebackers in man coverage. Has very good ball skills. Plucks and snatches away from frame and adjusts to poorly thrown ball. Can get up the seam for big plays.
WEAKNESSESVery limited football experience. Blocking is not adequate. Lacks the lower body power to get movement. Lacks the upper body power needed to sustain blocks. Very raw in pass protection. Displays hip stiffness cutting out of his stem. Still developing his awareness against zone coverage. Drops the occasional pass.
-
The numbers, combined with the scout analysis of the two players tell me two things. Thomas has very solid speed given his size, but isn't as fluid or naturally athletic as Graham (or Gronk IMO). Notice there are multiple knocks on Thomas' athleticism and they use words like enough and some.... whereas for Graham the knocks are on polish/toughness and they use words like tremendous, impressive, and outstanding describing his athleticism and potential?
Thomas looked very good last night but also looked akward and robotic at times. IMO his long catches had as much to do with Peyton identifying broken coverage as it did with him using his athleticism to get open and to gain YAC. I'm just not ready to put him in the same camp athletically as the elite tight ends. YMMV.
I took the time to read through this entire thread the other day and I believe the comparison to Graham has already been made somewhere in this thread. Then I think someone (was it EBF?) posted Vernon Davis's combine results to show what a true freak looked like. I thought the conclusion drawn was that it's not very fair to compare TEs to both Graham and Davis, at least, I'm not doing so with JT.