Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

shuke

AAA vs. Allstate motor club vs. ?

12 posts in this topic

I've had AAA forever, mostly in case my wife gets a flat or is out with the kids and needs a jump or something. But I don't think we've used it for the past 4 years and I hate paying for nothing. Curious what everyone else is using.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally, I feel the benefits of AAA have totally outweighed the cost. When I consider a program to join, I look at it long-term. The two I belong to are AAA and AHS (American Home Shield...covers appliances, etc). To me, AAA is a literal "lay-up". When you consider the "spend" per year, one breakdown in the middle of no-where will cost you like 5+ years of payments...that does not account for the times you need to jump the car on the road (I have young kids and they always mess with interior lights, so I have been jumped 9 times in the last 4 years...wish my record was as strong with the wife). AHS is more costly (we pay roughly $650/year) and 2011 is the only year where it has not paid for itself since 2005 when we started it. Wife wanted to drop it, but when we added everything together, we are roughly plus $1,500 and the best part is it is an "expected" payment versus a $800 or so payment right after you book a vacation.

I know there are down times, but for AAA specifically, the service (and discounts...HAVE to take advatnage of those) far out-weigh the cost even in the short-term.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I work an hour from home, and once we had my daughter I signed up for AAA. Don't have 1 bad thing to really say about them. I used them a couple times. One time my SIL was in an accident and we used our AAA for her. Plus the small discounts for hotels, oil changes etc have added up :shrug:

There were a few times I could have called to use them but didn't

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have AAA, and have used them for various stuff throughout the years and have always been happy with the service.

Check your auto insurance policy, though - a lot of companies now offer roadside assistance as part of your policy, either as a free benefit or as an optional coverage, so it may not make sense to also be paying for AAA. No reason to pay for AAA if your auto policy provides the same kind of service (unless you're also taking advantage of other AAA benefits and discounts).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

that Allstate club is making a major marketing push right now, trying to make inroads on AAA. Probably a good time to get a deal. I think they're both quality companies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have AAA, and have used them for various stuff throughout the years and have always been happy with the service.Check your auto insurance policy, though - a lot of companies now offer roadside assistance as part of your policy, either as a free benefit or as an optional coverage, so it may not make sense to also be paying for AAA. No reason to pay for AAA if your auto policy provides the same kind of service (unless you're also taking advantage of other AAA benefits and discounts).

I add roadside assistance on the auto insurance policy.It's $16/yr for '03 Forester and $10/yr for '07 Sonata. Great response time as well when my wife or I has had to use it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have AAA, and have used them for various stuff throughout the years and have always been happy with the service.Check your auto insurance policy, though - a lot of companies now offer roadside assistance as part of your policy, either as a free benefit or as an optional coverage, so it may not make sense to also be paying for AAA. No reason to pay for AAA if your auto policy provides the same kind of service (unless you're also taking advantage of other AAA benefits and discounts).

I add roadside assistance on the auto insurance policy.It's $16/yr for '03 Forester and $10/yr for '07 Sonata. Great response time as well when my wife or I has had to use it.
Wow, that is nice. I will definitely have to check that out through Progressive.We have ours through Verizon. $4/month per line. Used them twice, no problems at all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have AAA, and have used them for various stuff throughout the years and have always been happy with the service.Check your auto insurance policy, though - a lot of companies now offer roadside assistance as part of your policy, either as a free benefit or as an optional coverage, so it may not make sense to also be paying for AAA. No reason to pay for AAA if your auto policy provides the same kind of service (unless you're also taking advantage of other AAA benefits and discounts).

I add roadside assistance on the auto insurance policy.It's $16/yr for '03 Forester and $10/yr for '07 Sonata. Great response time as well when my wife or I has had to use it.
Wow, that is nice. I will definitely have to check that out through Progressive.We have ours through Verizon. $4/month per line. Used them twice, no problems at all.
fwiw I also have Progressive.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have AAA, and have used them for various stuff throughout the years and have always been happy with the service.Check your auto insurance policy, though - a lot of companies now offer roadside assistance as part of your policy, either as a free benefit or as an optional coverage, so it may not make sense to also be paying for AAA. No reason to pay for AAA if your auto policy provides the same kind of service (unless you're also taking advantage of other AAA benefits and discounts).

I add roadside assistance on the auto insurance policy.It's $16/yr for '03 Forester and $10/yr for '07 Sonata. Great response time as well when my wife or I has had to use it.
Doesn't Hyundai give you free road side assistance for 10years 100,000 miles?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have AAA, and have used them for various stuff throughout the years and have always been happy with the service.Check your auto insurance policy, though - a lot of companies now offer roadside assistance as part of your policy, either as a free benefit or as an optional coverage, so it may not make sense to also be paying for AAA. No reason to pay for AAA if your auto policy provides the same kind of service (unless you're also taking advantage of other AAA benefits and discounts).

I add roadside assistance on the auto insurance policy.It's $16/yr for '03 Forester and $10/yr for '07 Sonata. Great response time as well when my wife or I has had to use it.
Doesn't Hyundai give you free road side assistance for 10years 100,000 miles?
The free Roadside assistance only is for the first 5 years (at least it was for my '04 that I bought new). Once that ran out on me, I got AAA. Used Hyundai's program multiple times over those 5 years and had zero complaints. Still have not had to call AAA, but have heard good things from everyone I know that has used it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have AAA, and have used them for various stuff throughout the years and have always been happy with the service.Check your auto insurance policy, though - a lot of companies now offer roadside assistance as part of your policy, either as a free benefit or as an optional coverage, so it may not make sense to also be paying for AAA. No reason to pay for AAA if your auto policy provides the same kind of service (unless you're also taking advantage of other AAA benefits and discounts).

I add roadside assistance on the auto insurance policy.It's $16/yr for '03 Forester and $10/yr for '07 Sonata. Great response time as well when my wife or I has had to use it.
Doesn't Hyundai give you free road side assistance for 10years 100,000 miles?
The free Roadside assistance only is for the first 5 years (at least it was for my '04 that I bought new). Once that ran out on me, I got AAA. Used Hyundai's program multiple times over those 5 years and had zero complaints. Still have not had to call AAA, but have heard good things from everyone I know that has used it.
I didn't buy the Hyundai new so I didn't know about that. I wonder if it even transfers with ownership. Sometimes those perks don't iirc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.