jurb26
Footballguy
This is a cyclical argument and doesn't really provide much to the discussion. In other words, Robinson is a superior talent but not talented enough to move Lee out of his starting role at Z. In your words,"Robinson isn't playing Z because he can do a lot more than catch 5-yard passes."Twist? How about this? Lee gets the "easy" targets because he's less talented. He needs to be "forcefed" the ball in that offense just like Kendall Wright does. Robinson will be used more downfield because he's more talented.That's an interesting way of looking at it. Lee is ahead of him on the depth chart, regardless of the position they play. Lee is first string, Robinson second string. Maybe Robinson moves up but that's where it stands now.Jack made a decision to a place Lee in the vacated Blackmon role, the most important role in the offense for WR. They could have easily made the decision to place Robinson there had they felt he was the better player. This again seems to validate they like him more as a player.Lee is not ahead of Robinson on the depth chart. They don't play the same "position".
They may have chosen Lee ahead of Robinson because they wanted to secure a Blackmon replacement. Robinson becoming a Shorts replacement may have been secondary.
We all know you hate Lee and I'm sure you will look for any way possible to twist this, but there really isn't a whole lot of validity to it.
Lee is first string only because Cecil Shorts doesn't play Z. There isn't anyone else talented enough to play Z over Lee. Those are facts. At X, Shorts has proven very capable that they can't just automatically hand Robinson the job there. Robinson isn't playing Z because he can do a lot more than catch 5-yard passes. Ironically, Robinson was very good on screens in college.
"The vacated Blackmon role" is the most important role in the offense for a WR because???
In the 3 complete games in 2013 that Shorts and Blackmon played together Shorts had the edge in targets: 34 to 28. Shorts left the Denver game in the 1st quarter due to injury and Blackmon got 20 total targets.
If Lee was more talented why isn't he playing outside exclusively? Let's see Lee play outside at the X and Robinson in the slot and see who's more talented.
The narrative could easily be: Robinson is first string because he plays Z. Lee has to fight Shorts because they want him at X.
If Robinson is so talented and can do what Lee can plus, why isn't Jack at least starting there with him and simply getting the best 11 on the field? You know like just about every team tries to do. Teams generally want their most talented players on the field.
You ask the question of why isn't Lee playing outside if he's more talented. A question that is just as applicable, more so actually, is why isn't Robinson playing inside if he's so much more talented? See, it's cyclical.
The narrative could easily be that Lee is playing the Z because he is the most talented WR on the team in the eyes of Jack and that is the opening they have currently. You know, along the lines of the earlier mention of getting the best 11 on the field one way or another.
Perhaps it's a bit of both. It's possible they are equally talented, or at least very close, just in different ways. Lee happens to fall into a more fortunate position of immediate impact thanks to his skill set where as Robinson, not so much. I could agree with this but your overriding theme of Lee sucks just again, falls short. Maybe he crash and burns in the NFL. We will see. The issue at hand is that he has immediate opportunity. Reason that away however you want, it doesn't change his opportunity. It may just cause you to miss it.