Instinctive
Footballguy
I'm maybe a little bit of an insane person so take this with a grain of salt.I'm starting to think about just keeping it and upgrading the stereo that I never got around to doing. The standard issue stinks, no bass in it.
I just think it would be fun to trade it in, the monthly on this thing was about $400, we spent abut $20-$22k on this thing, 4 years later it's worth $12,000...I can cut my monthly expenses on this to about $200 a month for the duration we have owned it, that's pretty good.
Downside is we would have a car payment and probably a balance of $15k on something new or almost new even with the trade.
Could easily drive it for 5 years...let's say down the road the car is worth $5k when it's about 10 years old...$7k in depreciation over the next 60 months...that's pretty good.
I always say the monthly cost for folks who don't have a car payment with maintenance and depreciation is still about $100-$200 a month depending on the car and how long you drive it. Eventually you are going to buy a new car and there is a cost.
Let's say you buy a new car and drive it 10 years...$25,000 over 120 months...that's still over $200 a month without any repairs and up keep.
Am I thinking right/wrong here?
You should basically never ever have a car payment. If you can't afford to pay cash for it up front, you shouldn't be buying it*. A $12k, 5-yr used Subaru is a perfect car to buy, if it's in good condition without insane miles. Why would you sell one of those?
Your thinking about maintenance and depreciation is wrong in one key way: yes, you have those "costs of ownership" even though you have no payment. Yes, they may be close to a payment. However: if you buy it new you still have all those costs AND you're making a car payment. While you make the payment the vehicle is still depreciating and other costs of ownership exist.
*If you can afford to do this AND make more money with your cash in other ways because of a low interest rate AND you actually will do that, it could make sense to have a car payment. But way too many people think that's what they can and should do but they can't and/or don't have the ability and they've been hoodwinked.