Trade Help: Robinson for McCoy/ baldwin,shepard, jones (1 Viewer)

Was offered a trade this morning I would give up Allen Robinson and acquire McCoy and my choice of Shepard baldwin or Marvin jones I'm in a 10 team PPR my roster goes as followed 

QB - Luck

RB - Gurley, Foster, Blount, Sims, Dion Lewis, Dixon, Vereen

WR - Julio, Odell, Robinson, Cobb 

TE - Kelce, Eifert

do I go with it and what WR would you chose ? Thank you.

Interesting.  I do think you can use the RB help. and Shady should be a back-end RB1, although the Bills might be about to implode.  I do see a lot of people recommending that Allen Robinson is a good buy low, so I hope you are not just looking to dump him.  And thinking a little more I think you've got future potential in your bench with Lewis, Dixon, Sims and Vereen.  So I wouldn't be looking to cut anybody from that list.

If you do take it I would definitely pick Marvin Jones.  

Sorry if that wasn't a definitive answer - it's basically a fair trade I'd say for both sides.

Here's mine

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/748550-ppr-flex-marshall-gore-gio-sims-whir/

I'd keep Robinson, I view him as a great buy low with the breakout right around the corner. He is getting the targets. 

Please help with mine, thank you

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/748529-buy-low-on-ingram/

Disagree. If I was Commish I would consider vetoing McCoy + Baldwin for Robinson as too lopsided in your favor.

cjv123 said:

Disagree. If I was Commish I would consider vetoing McCoy + Baldwin for Robinson as too lopsided in your favor.

Click to expand...

Robinson every day by far.

cjv123 said:

Disagree. If I was Commish I would consider vetoing McCoy + Baldwin for Robinson as too lopsided in your favor.

Click to expand...

Wow really?? I don't know what to do now because the commish actually offered it to me lol

I am an Allen Robinson owner, and I would not except that trade, Allen Robinson will bounce back, it is too early in the season to consider him an under performer.

cjv123 said:

Disagree. If I was Commish I would consider vetoing McCoy + Baldwin for Robinson as too lopsided in your favor.

Click to expand...

This is incorrect, I would be leaving this league as fast as possible, there is no way this trade is too lopsided for the side receiving McCoy + Baldwin.

As mentioned earlier, Robinson currently is an excellent buy low.

I probably am more positive about Robinson than most people. 

I wouldn't do the trade, but it isn't that bad. Leagues that veto trades are for losers.