Straight up trade Mike Evans for Odell Beckham Jr. (1 Viewer)

I have been offered this trade.

I have Evens and the team that offered me the trade has Beckham.

This is a 16 team keeper league.

This is my team:


Philadelphia - Dave Berg


Player


YTD Pts


Bye


Trade?


Stafford, Matthew DET QB


91.95


10


 


Wilson, Russell SEA QB


51.05


5


 


Crowell, Isaiah CLE RB (Q)


42.50


13


 


Henry, Derrick TEN RB (R)


13.80


13


 


Murray, DeMarco TEN RB


55.70


13


 


Boldin, Anquan DET WR


33.50


10


 


Cooks, Brandin NOS WR


51.10


5


 


Evans, Mike TBB WR


69.10


6


 


Jones, Marvin DET WR


70.80


10


 


McDonald, Vance SFO TE(Q)


31.30


8


 


Reed, Jordan WAS TE


51.00


9


 


Tye, Will NYG TE


20.00


8


 


Crosby, Mason GBP PK


22.00


4


 


Lambo, Josh SDC PK


27.00


11


 


Patriots, New England NEP Def


35.00


9


 


15 Total Players


Injured Reserve


Woodhead, Danny SDC RB(I)

So is this good deal or stay put? Which player would you rather have long term both young guys so i've been flip flopping on it since i got the offer.

if i recall correctly TB has the saints week 14 and 16, that is an awfully juicy playoff schedule.  I prefer evans at this point.

Keeper league.  Give me OBJ.  He is simply the better player.

You are correct and Beckhams schedule at that time is not near as easy

OBJ!

Help with mines please.

At the moment, Evans is the safer player. He's bigger, stronger and has less competition on his own team. Has a young QB with a bright future. 

I like them both but I like Evans just a little more. 

If anything, it's a lateral move, not an improvement. 

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/748824-who-would-you-drop-~~whir~~/

I would rather have Evans rest of season.  Shepard and Cruz are cutting into OBJ's value currently.

Keep Evans. I love Evans this year and that playoff schedule is GREAT. I have actually been trying to trade Julio straight up for Evans and Evans owner won't pull the trigger.

Thanks all I ended up keeping Evans just didnt seem to be a upgrade to do the trade.