Dickies
Footballguy
It's not that we need better teachers. I'd argue the vast majority of our teachers are very good. Sure there are a few that are less than stellar, but find a profession where this isn't the case. We need to support them more. Our society values working people to death and it leaves no time for parents to spend with their kids.For much of my adult life I was in favor of vouchers. I was a libertarian, and I read lots of libertarians like Tibor Machan, who argued, open up the marketplace! Make schools competitive with each other. Some close black friends of mine, otherwise liberal, were for the idea. They argued that blacks in inner cities wanted the chance to send their kids to better schools. It never occurred to them, or to me, to question why not improve the public schools they were currently attending.
In any case over time my mind changed on this for two reasons. The first is that all attempts to set guidelines were defeated by the groups that pushed for the vouchers. They didn’t want the parochial schools being told by the government what should and what should not be taught. But they wanted my tax money to pay for tuitions for a school in which the taxpayer had no say as to the curriculum? Screw that. I don’t want to pay for teachers to tell kids that evolution doesn’t exist or that homosexuality isn’t evil or that abortion is immoral. If you want your kids to learn that, you pay for it. And of course, there is all the historical revisionism they teach as well.
The second reason was that I was not aware of the historical context for vouchers. They go back to the civil rights movement. Private schools exploded after integration. But the people who went to them wanted the government to pay, or else they didn’t want to have to pay for public education. So vouchers were created. Are they racist? They’ll insist that they’re not, and they’ll show off the small number of minorities who are lucky enough to go to their otherwise white school. But meanwhile the funding for the inner city schools, where the bulk of minority students attend, is cut. Bad idea, no thanks.
So I’ve come 180 on this. Vouchers are a bad idea. What we need is better teachers and more money for public education.
Vouchers are a terrible idea. The low income families couldn't afford private school even with the vouchers. The upper class families already sending their kids to private school don't need the vouchers to send their kids to school. They only "help" a small segment of the population, but it can be argued the money would be better spent in the public school system. One of my biggest issues with private schools here is that they kick low performers and behavior problems out of their schools and force them on the public system (unless their rich parents pay extra money). My wife has dealt with quite a few private school rejects over the years.