Help Deciding on a big trade. (1 Viewer)

Team A: QB - Cousins, Mariota, Bridgewater. RB - Bell, Dixon, Powell, Crowell. WR - Hilton, Watkins, Ty. Williams, Lockett, Crowder, C. Coleman, Treadwell, Carroo. 1.10.

Team B: QB - Ryan, A. Smith. RB - Zeke, D. Johnson, Freeman, T. Coleman, Rawls. WR - Baldwin, Edelman, Crabtree, T. Austin, Green-Beckham, Agholor. 1.12.

Team A gives up Hilton, Dixon, Coleman.

Team B gives up Zeke OR Johnson, Baldwin.

Team A was a playoff team, and Team B is the reigning champion.

Partial point PPR. 13 keepers, mixed FA/rookie draft. Given the makeup of the rosters, which side do you like and why?

I'd tell team B to not do this deal.  IMHO, Elliot or D. Johnson and Baldwin are worth more than Hilton / Dixon / Coleman.

I don't think that I'd give up Elliot or D. Johnson by themselves for that.

Team a wins.

With Zeke and Johnson, you are set at RB for quite awhile. No idea why you'd break that up. 

I would not do it...  not enough for Elliot/Baldwin.  Yes, Team B could use another WR, but I would not do the deal.

I would want the Elliott/Baldwin side all day.  That side has the best player (Zeke) and there isn't much difference between Hilton and Baldwin.  Dixon may not have a job if Baltimore gets and impact RB as it seems they are talking about doing.  Coleman is a nice flex piece but isn't a difference maker.  Easy choice for the Zeke/Baldwin side.

what they said