What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

QB Roulette 2017 - Contest NOW OPEN! (1 Viewer)

Riversco

Riversco

Footballguy
Where are each of these QBs on opening day 2017?  

Rules:

1. I will accept any submission until March 1st 2017 (the deadline for designating transition or franchise players).
2. Only your most recent submission will be accepted. 
3. You may edit your list if you wish, but the edit timestamp will be used.
4. You may select "free agent" instead of a team.
5. The poster with the most correct predictions will win the thing.
6. In case of a tie, you will all win an equal share of the thing.
7. Getting a pick wrong will not count against you, the only thing that matters is the most correct predictions.
8. I will keep a log of everyone's picks in a link in this first post.
9. Scan the field, find the open man, set your feet and throw DARTS!

Format:

1. DeShaun Watson - Bears 
2. Mitch Trubisky - 49ers
3. Jay Cutler - free agent
etc..

THE QUARTERBACKS!

1. DeShaun Watson
2. Mitch Trubisky
3. DeShone Kizer
4. Jimmy Garoppolo
5. Tony Romo
6. Kirk Cousins
7. Pat Mahomes
8. Colin Kapernick
9. Jay Cutler
10. Tyrod Taylor

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel

 
THE QUARTERBACKS!

1. DeShaun Watson - SF
2. Mitch Trubisky - Cleveland
3. DeShone Kizer - KC
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Chicago
5. Tony Romo - Denver
6. Kirk Cousins - WAS
7. Pat Mahomes - NYG
8. Colin Kapernick - Oak
9. Jay Cutler - Cards
10. Tyrod Taylor - SF

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Argos (if he's really trying)

 
1. Watson- ARI

2. Trubisky- SF

3. Kizer- HOU

4. Jimmy G- CHI

5. Romo- BUF

6. Cousins- WAS

7. Mahomes- KC

8. KAP- SEA

9. Cutler- NYJ

10. T-mobile- CLE

11. Manziel- throwing footballs at a machine in a bar near you. 

originally had kap to the argonauts until I saw you already used that joke. 

 
Arizona Cardinals - Palmer (Kizer)

Atlanta Falcons - Ryan 

Baltimore Ravens - Flacco

Buffalo Bills - Cutler

Carolina Panthers - Cam

Chicago Bears - Garapolo

Cincinnati Bengals - Dalton

Cleveland Browns - TT 

Dallas Cowboys - Dak 

Denver Broncos - Romo

Detroit Lions - Stafford

Green Bay Packers - Rodgers

Houston Texans - oz  / Watson

Indianapolis Colts - Luck

Jacksonville Jaguars - Bortles

Kansas City Chiefs - Smith (Mahomes)

Los Angeles Rams - Goff

Miami Dolphins - Tannehill

Minnesota Vikings - Bradford / Bridgewater

New England Patriots - Brady

New Orleans Saints - Brees

New York Giants - Eli

New York Jets - Glennon

Oakland Raiders - Carr

Philadelphia Eagles - Wentz

Pittsburgh Steelers - Ben 

San Diego Chargers - Rivers 

San Francisco 49ers - cousins

Seattle Seahawks - Wilson 

Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Winston

Tennessee Titans - Mariota

Washington Redskins - Trubisky

Manziel will manage to keep himself out of the limelight

The Redskins are this stupid, imo

 
Last edited by a moderator:
1. DeShaun Watson - ARI
2. Mitch Trubisky - CLE - 2nd pick in 1st Rd.
3. DeShone Kizer - BUF
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - CHI
5. Tony Romo - HOU
6. Kirk Cousins - WAS
7. Pat Mahomes - PIT
8. Colin Kapernick - NYJ
9. Jay Cutler - SF
10. Tyrod Taylor - BUF

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Drunk under a table in a Vegas nightclub

 
1. DeShaun Watson - NYJ2. Mitch Trubisky - SF3. DeShone Kizer - NE4. Jimmy Garoppolo - CHI5. Tony Romo - DEN6. Kirk Cousins - WAS7. Pat Mahomes - CLE8. Colin Kapernick - NYG9. Jay Cutler - KC10. Tyrod Taylor - BUF

Johnny Manziel- CAR
 
[SIZE=10.5pt]1. DeShaun Watson - CLE[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]2. Mitch Trubisky - SF[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]3. DeShone Kizer - CHI[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]4. Jimmy Garoppolo - NE[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]5. Tony Romo - DEN[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]6. Kirk Cousins - WAS[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]7. Pat Mahomes - ARI[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]8. Colin Kapernick - DAL[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]9. Jay Cutler - NYJ[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]10. Tyrod Taylor – CHI[/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

[SIZE=10.5pt]Johnny Manziel- Out of Football[/SIZE][SIZE=10.5pt][/SIZE]

 
THE QUARTERBACKS!

1. DeShaun Watson - New Orleans
2. Mitch Trubisky - San Francisco
3. DeShone Kizer - NY Jets
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Chicago
5. Tony Romo - Denver
6. Kirk Cousins - Washington
7. Pat Mahomes - Houston
8. Colin Kaepernick - LA Rams
9. Jay Cutler - Minnesota
10. Tyrod Taylor - Cleveland

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Las Vegas

 
Hawkeye21 said:
So now everyone thinks Jimmy G is going to the Bears?
Click to expand...
I think SF, CHI, and CLE are the front runners for Jimmy G. He is probably the most valuable qb on the list (I like Tyrod better), and requires trading draft stock to get him. I think Shanny will want to groom his own guy and NE would rather trade him out of the AFC. 

 
THE QUARTERBACKS!

1. DeShaun Watson - Redskins
2. Mitch Trubisky - Bears
3. DeShone Kizer - Chiefs
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Patriots
5. Tony Romo - Texans
6. Kirk Cousins - 49ers
7. Pat Mahomes - Bills
8. Colin Kapernick - Cardinals
9. Jay Cutler - Dolphins
10. Tyrod Taylor - Browns

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Hanging out with Kim Kardashian

 
THE QUARTERBACKS!

1. DeShaun Watson - SF
2. Mitch Trubisky - Jets
3. DeShone Kizer - KC
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Cleveland
5. Tony Romo - Texans
6. Kirk Cousins - WAS
7. Pat Mahomes - NYG
8. Colin Kaepernik - SF
9. Jay Cutler - Buffalo
10. Tyrod Taylor - Chicago

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Throwing tequila bottles at TV whenever he sees Garoppolo
 
I'm intrigued that some folks did not assign a QB to every team that needs a starter. Who would be left over to start?

 
THE QUARTERBACKS!

1. DeShaun Watson - Buffalo
2. Mitch Trubisky- SF
3. DeShone Kizer - Zona
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Chicago
5. Tony Romo - Buffalo
6. Kirk Cousins - Wash
7. Pat Mahomes- NYG
8. Colin Kapernick - KC
9. Jay Cutler - Texans
10. Tyrod Taylor - Cleveland

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - out of football

 
The jets probably need a starter but i hear they like hackenberg.  Could be wrong tho. I thought about giving kapernick to the jets but i thought he might be more likely to stay in familiar territory so i assigned him to the cardinals as a backup. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
No one should like Hackenberg.  The Jets had no QB at the end of the year and had nothing to play for. Yet they still wouldn't let him sniff the field of play. He had some horrible evaluation metrics coming out of college. I really doubt he is the answer for the Jets. 

 
1. DeShaun Watson - NYG
2. Mitch Trubisky - SF
3. DeShone Kizer - Arizona
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Chicago
5. Tony Romo - Denver
6. Kirk Cousins - Washington
7. Pat Mahomes - NO
8. Colin Kaepernick - KC
9. Jay Cutler- Buffalo
10. Tyrod Taylor - Cleveland

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - starring in a reality show

Just for S&Gs:

Foles: Houston

Hoyer: SF

Glennon: NYJ

 
1. DeShaun Watson - NYJ2. Mitch Trubisky - SF3. DeShone Kizer - ARI4. Jimmy Garoppolo - CHI5. Tony Romo - HOU6. Kirk Cousins - WAS7. Pat Mahomes - BUF8. Colin Kaepernick - IND9. Jay Cutler - MIA10. Tyrod Taylor - CLE

10/10 should require no tiebreaker, but Manziel will continue to prioritize his partying over a return to football.

Bonus:  Bears acquire Garoppolo, but do so without parting with the #3 pick this year.

 
1. DeShaun Watson - NY Jets
2. Mitch Trubisky - New Orleans
3. DeShone Kizer - Chicago 
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - San Francisco
5. Tony Romo - Denver
6. Kirk Cousins - Washington
7. Pat Mahomes - Jacksonville
8. Colin Kaepernick - Cleveland
9. Jay Cutler - Houston
10. Tyrod Taylor - Buffalo 

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Free Agent

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Anarchy99 said:
I'm intrigued that some folks did not assign a QB to every team that needs a starter. Who would be left over to start?
Click to expand...
Mike Glennon, AJ McCarron, a few other stop gap veterans like Hoyer or Barkley, or an incumbent. It's not like every team will end up with an answer at the position next year.

 
Dr. Octopus said:
Mike Glennon, AJ McCarron, a few other stop gap veterans like Hoyer or Barkley, or an incumbent. It's not like every team will end up with an answer at the position next year.
Click to expand...
I just found in interesting that some folks have teams getting two of the options listed and other teams getting none of them.

 
Anarchy99 said:
I just found in interesting that some folks have teams getting two of the options listed and other teams getting none of them.
Click to expand...
I did it twice. The draft and free agency are two different ways to find an answer and in some cases it may make sense to "double down" (see Cleveland). Also it's Colin Kaepernick who holds the option and I don't see him giving up $15MM (where else will he see that money?). I suppose they can release him, but from what I read I think they are on the hook so long as he takes the option (maybe I'm wrong about that).

 
THE QUARTERBACKS!

1. DeShaun Watson - New Orleans
2. Mitch Trubisky - Chicago
3. DeShone Kizer - Arizona

4. Jimmy Garoppolo - New England
5. Tony Romo - Denver
6. Kirk Cousins - Washington
7. Pat Mahomes - Buffalo
8. Colin Kapernick - San Francisco
9. Jay Cutler - NYJ

10. Tyrod Taylor - Cleveland

 
Dr. Octopus said:
I did it twice. The draft and free agency are two different ways to find an answer and in some cases it may make sense to "double down" (see Cleveland). Also it's Colin Kaepernick who holds the option and I don't see him giving up $15MM (where else will he see that money?). I suppose they can release him, but from what I read I think they are on the hook so long as he takes the option (maybe I'm wrong about that).
Click to expand...
His contract of 14.5 M + 2 M bonus becomes guaranteed on April 1. Don't think there's much of a chance of them paying that so they will cut him if he opts out.  Maybe bring him back at lower price but I kind of doubt it.

 
1. DeShaun Watson - Chicago
2. Mitch Trubisky - New York Jets
3. DeShone Kizer - New Orleans
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Cleveland
5. Tony Romo - Houston
6. Kirk Cousins - Washington
7. Pat Mahomes - San Francisco
8. Colin Kaepernick - San Francisco
9. Jay Cutler - New York Jets
10. Tyrod Taylor - Buffalo

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - out of football

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Tool said:
His contract of 14.5 M + 2 M bonus becomes guaranteed on April 1. Don't think there's much of a chance of them paying that so they will cut him if he opts out.  Maybe bring him back at lower price but I kind of doubt it.
Click to expand...
Thanks  so he has the option but it's not guaranteed then.

 
1. DeShaun Watson - Bears
2. Mitch Trubisky - Jets
3. DeShone Kizer - Browns
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Patriots
5. Tony Romo - Texans
6. Kirk Cousins - Redskins
7. Pat Mahomes - Chiefs
8. Colin Kapernick - 49ers
9. Jay Cutler - Jags
10. Tyrod Taylor - Bills

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Free Agent

 
Soo many variables with the cap and draft and I've never felt that free agency has been logical when it comes to quarterbacks so I'll do something different.

I've been hearing that SF isn't in love with any of the QBs from this draft class and will wait on Kirk Cousins to become a free agent next year so I think they will go with a short-term veteran quarterback.

1.  SF - Jay Cutler/Kaepernick

Kyle Shanahan loves Kirk but will have to wait a year so he goes with the guy who his pop had playing his best football and who fits the Shanahan offensive system.

2.  Chicago - Jimmy Garoppolo

Jimmy is a from the Chicago area.  The Bears probably aren't in love with any of the QBS from this draft class either and wouldn't want to blow the third pick in the draft but 'probably' would part with their 2nd round pick.

3.  NY Jets - Mitch Trubisky

Jets 'reportedly' love Trubisky and he falls into their lap.

4.  Buffalo Bills - DeSaun Watson/Tyrod Tailor

They don't want to pay Tyrod top QB money.  Watson 'probably' has a higher upside and comes much cheaper.  They might have to tag Ty for a year and if a Sam Bradford-type of situation arises later in training camp with another team they 'might' be able to trade him to a desperate team ALA Philly/Minny type deal.

5.  Cleveland - Mike Glennon

I think the Browns will look to next year for their QB and will stockpile extra picks for that time as they 'settle' for an inexpensive bridge QB.

6.  Arizona - ???

I don't think they will make any major moves

7.  Washington - Kirk Cousins

He will force them to tag him for a year and next year they won't be able to afford it and will let him walk.

8.  Houston - DeShone Kizer

Either Kizer or Mahomes but I think DeShone has a higher upside.

9.  KC - Mahomes 

Not sure about this at all but had to plug in Mahomes somewhere.

10.  Denver - Romo

It would seem logical that this happens but FA never seems to be logical so more than likely I've botched every possible destination.

Johnny is done.

 
THE QUARTERBACKS!

1. DeShaun Watson - San Francisco
2. Mitch Trubisky - Jets
3. DeShone Kizer - Arizona
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Chicago
5. Tony Romo - Houston
6. Kirk Cousins - Washington
7. Pat Mahomes - Houston
8. Colin Kapernick - San Francisco
9. Jay Cutler - Buffalo
10. Tyrod Taylor - Cleveland

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Free Agent

 
Today is the last day for the contest, as the deadline for setting transition / franchise players is tomorrow.  

 
1. DeShaun Watson - Cleveland
2. Mitch Trubisky - Washington
3. DeShone Kizer - Arizona
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Chicago
5. Tony Romo - Houston
6. Kirk Cousins - San Fran
7. Pat Mahomes - Arizona
8. Colin Kapernick - San Francisco
9. Jay Cutler - NYJ
10. Tyrod Taylor - buffalo

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Free Agent

 
1. DeShaun Watson - ARZ
2. Mitch Trubisky - SF
3. DeShone Kizer - CHI
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - CLE
5. Tony Romo - DEN
6. Kirk Cousins - WAS
7. Pat Mahomes - PIT
8. Colin Kapernick - HOU
9. Jay Cutler - NYJ
10. Tyrod Taylor - BUF

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - BUF

 
dhockster said:
THE QUARTERBACKS!

1. DeShaun Watson - San Francisco
2. Mitch Trubisky - Jets
3. DeShone Kizer - Arizona
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Chicago
5. Tony Romo - Houston
6. Kirk Cousins - Washington
7. Pat Mahomes - Houston
8. Colin Kapernick - San Francisco
9. Jay Cutler - Buffalo
10. Tyrod Taylor - Cleveland

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Free Agent
Click to expand...
With Tyrod Taylor re-doing his deal I am 0 for 2. Taylor is staying in Buffalo and Cutler won't be going to Buffalo.

 
jtd13 said:
1. DeShaun Watson - NYG
2. Mitch Trubisky - SF
3. DeShone Kizer - Arizona
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Chicago
5. Tony Romo - Denver
6. Kirk Cousins - Washington
7. Pat Mahomes - NO
8. Colin Kaepernick - KC
9. Jay Cutler- Buffalo
10. Tyrod Taylor - Cleveland

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - starring in a reality show

Just for S&Gs:

Foles: Houston

Hoyer: SF

Glennon: NYJ
Click to expand...
Not looking good for me, but at least I got that one right :D

 
Dr. Brew said:
1. DeShaun Watson - Chicago
2. Mitch Trubisky - New York Jets
3. DeShone Kizer - New Orleans
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Cleveland
5. Tony Romo - Houston
6. Kirk Cousins - Washington
7. Pat Mahomes - San Francisco
8. Colin Kaepernick - San Francisco
9. Jay Cutler - New York Jets
10. Tyrod Taylor - Buffalo

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - out of football
Click to expand...
:pickle:  (will pat myself on the back while I can, because this will look UGLY when it's all said and done)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
yellowdog said:
1. DeShaun Watson - Bears
2. Mitch Trubisky - Jets
3. DeShone Kizer - Browns
4. Jimmy Garoppolo - Patriots
5. Tony Romo - Texans
6. Kirk Cousins - Redskins
7. Pat Mahomes - Chiefs
8. Colin Kapernick - 49ers
9. Jay Cutler - Jags
10. Tyrod Taylor - Bills

TIEBREAKER: (only used in case of a tie)

11.  Johnny Manziel - Free Agent
Click to expand...
This was harder than we thought.

This looks like the winning entry unless manziel, romo and kapernick are all rostered on the correct teams by opening day!  He got 5/10 right!

 
Well done. Most of these were down right ugly (not that I would have done any better). Maybe awarding 2 pts in getting a rookie prediction correct and 1 for current NFL players (starters and backups) would spice this thing up. 

 
Update:

Yellowdog current has 5 and now OSUbuckeyeman has 6.  

1. If Romo comes out of retirement before opening day, that might change things.  
Yellowdog - Romo to Texans
OSU - Romo to Broncos

2. If Kapernick signs somewhere before opening day, that could change things.
Yellowdog - Kapernick to 49ers
OSU - Kapernick to Jets

I've got an outside shot with my picks because I also had Cutler to the Dolphins which gives me 3 correct.  I need:
1.  Kirk Cousins to get dealt to the 49ers before opening day.  (maybe the Redskins get a huge offer)
2.  Kapernick to sign with the Cardinals.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

ignatiusjreilly
How many first-round QBs will actually pan out?
Replies
12
Views
371
ignatiusjreilly
ignatiusjreilly
Hot Sauce Guy
2023 NFL Draft Contest!
2 3
Replies
120
Views
3K
eighsse2
eighsse2
Anarchy99
NFL.com QB Prospect Grades Since 2014
Replies
15
Views
966
IHEARTFF
I

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Top