az_prof
Footballguy
Wonder what people's thoughts are on this backfield for 2017.
Martin is sidelined for the first three games, is getting up in age at 28, and had a horrible 2016. He has had two stellar seasons in his career.
Sims is the likely starter while Martin is out but he is 27 and has never done much beyond catch out of the backfield.
Rodgers is 27 and hadn't done much until last year when he filled in for Martin and did pretty well. He is too small to be anything more than a change of pace back IMO.
That leaves the intriguing rookie, McNichols. He is recovering from shoulder surgery so he hasn't been generating a ton of off season news, but he has an opportunity to be a factor even as a rookie despite being only a 5th round pick. I like the following:
a. opportunity
b. size--5'09'' and 214 is compact build and enough size to be an every down back.
c. quickness and elusiveness: his 3 cone drill was the best at the combine and confirms the elusiveness and ability to juke, change direction, and quickly accelerate again that I see on his highlight film.
d. Sims and Rodgers are good receivers too, but McNichols also is an outstanding receiver.
His injury could linger and hamper his development. Sims could improve his running to match his outstanding receiving. Doug Martin could come back after suspension and return to the form he had in 2012 and 2015. But if Martin has lost it, it seems to me that McNichols has as much a shot at getting meaningful work this year as Sims and Rodgers and he is better suited to being the primary runner with them being complementary than the other way around.
Martin is sidelined for the first three games, is getting up in age at 28, and had a horrible 2016. He has had two stellar seasons in his career.
Sims is the likely starter while Martin is out but he is 27 and has never done much beyond catch out of the backfield.
Rodgers is 27 and hadn't done much until last year when he filled in for Martin and did pretty well. He is too small to be anything more than a change of pace back IMO.
That leaves the intriguing rookie, McNichols. He is recovering from shoulder surgery so he hasn't been generating a ton of off season news, but he has an opportunity to be a factor even as a rookie despite being only a 5th round pick. I like the following:
a. opportunity
b. size--5'09'' and 214 is compact build and enough size to be an every down back.
c. quickness and elusiveness: his 3 cone drill was the best at the combine and confirms the elusiveness and ability to juke, change direction, and quickly accelerate again that I see on his highlight film.
d. Sims and Rodgers are good receivers too, but McNichols also is an outstanding receiver.
His injury could linger and hamper his development. Sims could improve his running to match his outstanding receiving. Doug Martin could come back after suspension and return to the form he had in 2012 and 2015. But if Martin has lost it, it seems to me that McNichols has as much a shot at getting meaningful work this year as Sims and Rodgers and he is better suited to being the primary runner with them being complementary than the other way around.
Last edited by a moderator: