PPR ROS - Dion Lewis or Tarik Cohen - WHIR (1 Viewer)

Yes, this is the same dilemma I had last week.  I dropped Lewis and kept Cohen, and was able to pick up Lewis again this week.  I still need to drop one before the weekend to pick up a kicker.  Neither will start for me this week.

Dion Lewis - Wk 8 vs. Chargers, 9 BYE, 10 @ Broncos, 11 @ Raiders, 12 vs. Dolphins, 13 @ Bills, 14 @ Dolphins, 15 @ Steelers, 16 vs. Bills
Tarik Cohen - Wk 8 @ Saints, 9 BYE, 10 vs. Packers, 11 vs. Lions, 12 @ Eagles, 13 vs. 49ers, 14 @ Bengals, 15 @ Lions, 16 vs. Browns

Last week
Cohen - 0 Carries, 1 Catch for 70 yards on 3 targets, played 18% of offensive snaps
Lewis - 13 carries for 76 yards, 1 catch for 6 yards on 1 target, played 35% of offensive snaps

Rest of team
QB - Cam Newton (Bye week 11)
QB - Tyrod Taylor (Bye week 6)
RB - Ezekiel Elliott (Bye wEek 6) - keeping fingers, toes, etc. crossed
RB - Jay Ajayi (Bye week 1)
RB - Doug Martin (Bye week 1)
WR - Julio Jones (Bye week 5)
WR - Deandre Hopkins (Bye week 7)
WR - Devante Parker (Bye week 1)
WR - Corey Davis (Bye week 8)
TE - Hunter Henry (Bye week 9)
TE - Greg Olsen (Bye week 11) - in IR Spot, can return week 12
DST - Jaguars (Bye week 8)
DSt - Eagles (Bye week 10) - will drop them next week to pick up a TE to cover for Hunter Henry
K - vacant

Leave a link and thanks!
 

Both seem to have tough schedules ROS... I would have the same doubt on this and I'm almost answering to choose in a coin toss...

Dion Lewis has better QB play with him. I think he has slightly more upside. If your league starts 2WR/1FLEX probably you wont need none of them during playoffs, as ur RB3, Doug Martin, has softer schedule in wk 14-16.

Help me at https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/762024-trade-advice-kareem-hunt/

Thats a tough call but I think I'd keep Lewis, hopefully you wont have to worry about having to play him if your top guys do well.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/762050-who-do-i-drop-for-a-bye-week-qb/

I would drop Cohen and keep Lewis. He is trending up and is seeing more opportunity right now than Cohen. Howard is basically taking the full share of reps and carries at RB. So if you have to make that choice, I'd keep Lewis.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/762033-roster-evaluation-do-i-need-to-upgrade-anywhere/

I would keep Lewis as well. Chicago seems content with Howard taking the lead role. 

drop Cohen

I’d stick with Lewis. I doesn’t seem like  Cohen is a big part of Chicago’s game plan. Without the one big play, Cohen was not heavily involved. 

KEEP Lewis.