Keep Carr or Mahommes? (1 Viewer)

Patriots24 · Jan 31, 2018

Between Carr's bad season, Mahommes becoming the starter, and my leagues odd scoring I was wondering which one you guys think I should keep.

.5 per completion

.05 per yard

6 per td

Travieso · Jan 31, 2018

Carr for next year; but I think it is close

Snorkelson · Jan 31, 2018

Mahomes’ upside is too good. Big arm, moves well.

Gally · Feb 1, 2018

Are there any round or salary cap implications associated with keeping one over the other? What other QB's would be available if Mahomes flames out and isn't up to the hype? How long can you keep a player? Can you keep both over some other player? Does your team need upside at the QB position to have a chance to win, in a rebuild mode, or a title contender?

Many variables that would factor into deciding which player to keep but in a vacuum with nothing else known but the scoring system I would go with Carr as the safer play at this point and I would keep him. It is very close and tomorrow I might go the other way.

beerbuff · Feb 1, 2018

Gally said:
Are there any round or salary cap implications associated with keeping one over the other? What other QB's would be available if Mahomes flames out and isn't up to the hype? How long can you keep a player? Can you keep both over some other player? Does your team need upside at the QB position to have a chance to win, in a rebuild mode, or a title contender?

Many variables that would factor into deciding which player to keep but in a vacuum with nothing else known but the scoring system I would go with Carr as the safer play at this point and I would keep him. It is very close and tomorrow I might go the other way.

Another consideration is if the rest of the team is competitive or not. If not roll with Mahomes for upside. If competitive then Carr is the safer play.

Eclipse · Feb 4, 2018

It would be great if you could keep both. Sounds like that is not possible, so I would take Mahomes. This is based on the small sample size of one game, but he looks like real deal. If he is able to emulate Alex Smith's lack of turnovers, you should like that choice. One wildcard is if Chucky can clean up Carr's game. Felt like he really regressed last year.

Search

Search

Keep Carr or Mahommes? (1 Viewer)

Patriots24

Footballguy

Travieso

Footballguy

Snorkelson

Footballguy

Gally

Footballguy

beerbuff

Footballguy

Eclipse

Footballguy

Similar threads

Users who are viewing this thread