I have no doubt he could succeed in the NFL in the right landing spot.
My doubts are regarding his listed height.
Seriously.I'm surprised theres no mlb height measurement from prior to him being drafted.
Plenty of NFL running backs are in that range or shorter and take more hits than QBs.Mike Vick was 2-3 inches taller and 20 lbs heavier. Wilson is just an abnormally. Funny though if Murray were 4 inches or so taller there would be teams trying to sell their mothers to try and trade up for him. I think the size factor is absolutely legit. Someone 5'9-5'10 just cannot play very long in the NFL. Sport is just too brutal now.
Plenty of NFL running backs are in that range or shorter and take more hits than QBs.
The MLB/Oakland A's have him listed at 5"11 ...you don't think they measure these guys in the MLB? You think they are off by 5 inches?You think he would even be considering the NFL if he was 5'6" or 5'7"? Come on. This is getting ridiculous.
I know the depth perception here can be skewed a bit but this pic shows he is way smaller than Tua and he is around 6ft. KM is way shorter.When he is listed 5'10".. how ridiculous is it?
because teams never exaggerate a players measurables...The MLB/Oakland A's have him listed at 5"11 ...you don't think they measure these guys in the MLB? You think they are off by 5 inches?
That’s interesting that mlb is allowing a change based on football season changing things. And that does make it more tempting to go baseball I would think.Rumor is a 15 mill offer from Oakland.
If it's 15 mill I take the money and play baseball
Charles Barkley was listed at 6'7", 6'6"... having shaken hands with him I can tell you he might not be 6'4".The MLB/Oakland A's have him listed at 5"11 ...you don't think they measure these guys in the MLB? You think they are off by 5 inches?
With no standardized way of tracking height, a number of players have seen random, year-to-year growth spurts—or sudden bouts of shrinking—when they change teams. And a handful have seen their heights change even while staying with the same team.
According to the league’s data, which has been kept loosely since 1994, former guard Dan Dickau went from being 6-feet tall with the Clippers in 2008 to 6-foot-3 in training camp with the Suns in 2009. He turned 30 years old in between.
So it happens.. we will see.We counted 28 players that were two inches shorter (and one that was surprisingly two inches taller) than their listed heights. Here are some of the notable players with at least a two-inch discrepancy between their college listings and combine measurements.
That Murray would even consider playing football is an indictment of MLB’s financial system, especially for young players. That signing bonus seems nice right now, but he’d have to play in the minors for a few years for less than a living wage (and deal with all those crappy hotel rooms and long bus rides), then if he makes the majors he’d earn the league minimum for three seasons, then he hits his arbitration years, and only then would he get the chance to hit free agency and sign that first big-money contract. Even if Murray turns out to be an excellent ballplayer, he would be nearing 30 before he’d first be allowed to negotiate for what he’s worth.
And of course, it can’t help matters that Murray is looking at what’s happening this winter, as an entire class of free agents, superstars among them, are going unsigned and receiving offers well below what they expected. It is, simply put, not as lucrative to be a professional baseball player as it ought to be.
Compare this with the path to the NFL. If Murray goes in the first round, he would earn more guaranteed money on his rookie deal than he would from the Athletics’ signing bonus; he would have a chance to start within a year or two; he would be in line for his first big payday in just four years. Even the argument that baseball is safer than football doesn’t particularly apply to quarterbacks.
I don't think if he declares for the draft he has to give up baseball. Although I guess he would have to announce that he was or his draft position would be affected.That's understandable. I just don't think HE would consider the NFL a viable option if he was 5'6"-5'8". He'd know that is insanely unlikely to work out. So if he does declare for the NFL draft and give up baseball, that will be a point in favor of his height. But like you said, no point worrying about it, he'll be measured soon enough.
Lost me here: simply put, not as lucrative to be a professional baseball player as it ought to be.Deadspin article does a good job at summing up why he should choose football.
https://deadspin.com/tell-me-again-why-kyler-murray-would-ever-want-to-play-1831719814
Next to 6' 3" Patrick Vahehttps://247sports.com/college/texas-am/Bolt/Kyle-Allen-sends-cryptic-tweet-amidst-Kyler-Murray-rumors-42093430/
Kyle Allen measured at 6'3" at the combine. If you think Murray is up to 9 inches shorter...
He probably won't make as much in the early years, and can really hit a big pay day a lot sooner in the NFL. Then factor in he can be the "face of the franchise" from almost day 1 and reap the endorsements from there.Lost me here: simply put, not as lucrative to be a professional baseball player as it ought to be.
========================Progressions –Biggest area of inconsistency. Fully capable, moves eyes across the set and can work right to left or high to low. Too often predetermines his target, however. Guilty of staring down the barrel. Misses a lot of intermediate routes into the MOF, struggles to see over OL.
Sure, agreed to all.He probably won't make as much in the early years, and can really hit a big pay day a lot sooner in the NFL. Then factor in he can be the "face of the franchise" from almost day 1 and reap the endorsements from there.
I think if he busts in baseball, that 15 mil bonus will be his largest payday every.
NFL he can still bust after his rookie deal at 25-35 mil and probably even gets a second chance somewhere for better money than a major league scrub.
Are those the rule or the exception?I'm laughing at the whole height obsession. Who has done more, Drew Brees or Matthew Stafford? Russell Wilson or Blake Bortles?
I just think he has to be looked at from his skills not his stature. There have been dozens of tall qb prospects that didn't do squat.Are those the rule or the exception?
Trying to figure out which side you think this argument supports.
If he were even 5'11, it would be a different argument imo. But under 5'8? The fact that you have to mention Wilson and Brees, 5'11 and 6'0 to suport the "height doesn't matter" argument, as they could be 4-6" taller, should tell you something.I'm laughing at the whole height obsession. Who has done more, Drew Brees or Matthew Stafford? Russell Wilson or Blake Bortles?
Sure. How many QBs under 5'8 have been successful?I just think he has to be looked at from his skills not his stature. There have been dozens of tall qb prospects that didn't do squat.
OK, but your post above kind of illustrates a different story.I just think he has to be looked at from his skills not his stature. There have been dozens of tall qb prospects that didn't do squat.
Fact, as simple as they come - athletes are regularly listed taller than they are.He’s listed as 5’9 and 5’10... you don’t like him at that height fine but stop spreading this BS about 5’8, 5’7, 5’6 until he’s measured. I’ve seen him clocked at 21 mph and I’ve seen a throw clocked at 54 mph. His ground speed is equivalent to Lamar Jackson and his throw speed is equal to Dak Prescott. Facts, simple.
Here you go: https://twitter.com/mhouckou/status/1084938177956233216?s=21Fact, as simple as they come - athletes are regularly listed taller than they are.
Nobody has spread anything aside from doubt.. for my eyeballs, I won't believe he is 5'9" until he is barefoot against a wall at the combine.
Like I said.. at the combine.
So just to tally this in one place:
So it’s acceptable for people to make up stuff and say 5’6/5’7... that’s unacceptable to me. His linemen all measured at 6’3 and above. I am certain that Texas and Alabama weren’t marching out small DL. Yes, there is variance to collegiate measurements but outright lies is what this board is doing.Like I said.. at the combine.
monk said:
But that guy next to him might only be 5’11”...unless you’ve got a combine measurement for Vahe don’t bring that weak sauce in here.I see him listed at 5.10
https://sportsday.dallasnews.com/college-sports/collegesports/2018/06/06/report-oklahomas-kyler-murray-oakland-agree-deal-worth-nearly-5-million-guaranteed
guy next to him is 6.3
Who has made this up? I don't know how tall he is.. what I know is that his listed heights have him shrinking twice since highschool, he doesn't do interviews with women in heels, his strength coach is defending him by throwing out the shortest height yet and telling us he wore socks.So it’s acceptable for people to make up stuff and say 5’6/5’7... that’s unacceptable to me. His linemen all measured at 6’3 and above. I am certain that Texas and Alabama weren’t marching out small DL. Yes, there is variance to collegiate measurements but outright lies is what this board is doing.
Listed at 6'3"?I see him listed at 5.10
https://sportsday.dallasnews.com/college-sports/collegesports/2018/06/06/report-oklahomas-kyler-murray-oakland-agree-deal-worth-nearly-5-million-guaranteed
guy next to him is 6.3
Wait Wilson is listed at 5'11".Half an inch shorter than Wilson. DEALBREAKER.
not doubting you but where have you seen the football speed at? Google isnt showing me anythingHe’s listed as 5’9 and 5’10... you don’t like him at that height fine but stop spreading this BS about 5’8, 5’7, 5’6 until he’s measured. I’ve seen him clocked at 21 mph and I’ve seen a throw clocked at 54 mph. His ground speed is equivalent to Lamar Jackson and his throw speed is equal to Dak Prescott. Facts, simple.
Can you imagine what is going to happen when Aaron Donald or Mack gets ahold of him?@Iceman03 @Leroy Hoard
My interest in his height is only for the simple fact I don't doubt his abilities. Looks legit.
eta - I could see his size (not just height - maybe even more so being skinny) being the only detractor. The question is how much.