What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

Post your rookie drafts - 2019 (2 Viewers)

Super flex, 12 teams

https://www71.myfantasyleague.com/2019/options?L=38483&O=17

1.011.The Never-NudesJacobs, Josh OAK RB (R)Fri May 3 2:18:10 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.022.Rowdy Roddy Peepers 2Montgomery, David CHI RB (R)Fri May 3 4:09:41 a.m. CT 2019 

1.033.The Never-NudesHarry, N'Keal NEP WR (R)Fri May 3 4:17:55 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Flying Monkeys.
Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.044.Smoking Jay CutlerMurray, Kyler ARI QB (R)Fri May 3 4:39:40 a.m. CT 2019 

1.055.Blue PlutoHaskins, Dwayne WAS QB (R)Fri May 3 5:06:22 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Hit Parade.]

1.066.Cloud NineCampbell, Parris IND WR (R)Fri May 3 5:43:15 a.m. CT 2019 

1.077.Blue PlutoSamuel, Deebo SFO WR (R)Fri May 3 6:38:26 a.m. CT 2019 

1.088.Clayton MitchellersSanders, Miles PHI RB(R)Fri May 3 8:13:24 a.m. CT 2019 

1.099.League LynxHockenson, T.J. DET TE(R)Fri May 3 8:38:41 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from AlabamaJama.
Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.1010.Hit ParadeButler, Hakeem ARI WR (R)Fri May 3 9:18:35 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from The Never-Nudes.
Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.1111.League LynxFant, Noah DEN TE (R)Fri May 3 11:42:52 a.m. CT 2019 

1.1212.Hit ParadeBrown, Marquise BAL WR (R)Fri May 3 12:00:12 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Malinas Heat.
Pick traded from Flying Monkeys.
Pick traded from The Never-Nudes.
Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.1313.Tough CrowdMetcalf, DK SEA WR (R)Fri May 3 12:03:29 p.m. CT 2019[Pick added by commissioner.
Pick traded from Smoking Jay Cutler.
Pick traded from Hit Parade.]

2.0114.Blue PlutoIsabella, Andy ARI WR(R)Fri May 3 12:03:29 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Tough Crowd.
Pick made based on Pre-Draft List]

2.0215.Rowdy Roddy Peepers 2Brown, A.J. TEN WR (R)Fri May 3 12:11:18 p.m. CT 2019 

2.0316.The Never-NudesArcega-Whiteside, JJ PHI WR(R)Fri May 3 12:17:40 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Flying Monkeys.]

2.0417.Smoking Jay CutlerHurd, Jalen SFO WR (R)Fri May 3 12:35:57 p.m. CT 2019 

2.0518.Clayton MitchellersHardman, Mecole KCC WR (R)Fri May 3 1:30:19 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Hit Parade.]

2.0619.Cloud NineLock, Drew DEN QB (R)Fri May 3 1:40:38 p.m. CT 2019 

2.0720.Blue PlutoHarmon, Kelvin WAS WR (R)Fri May 3 1:42:42 p.m. CT 2019 

2.0821.Rowdy Roddy Peepers 2Henderson, Darrell LAR RB (R)Fri May 3 4:46:50 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Clayton Mitchellers.]

2.0922.AlabamaJamaHarris, Damien NEP RB (R)Fri May 3 4:59:32 p.m. CT 2019 

2.1023.Flying MonkeysJones, Daniel NYG QB (R)Fri May 3 4:59:32 p.m. CT 2019

 
12 team PPR Superflex (No Kicker or D, start 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 4 Flex spots)

Round 1

  1. Kyler Murray
  2. Miles Sanders
  3. Josh Jacobs
  4. N'Keal Harry
  5. Dwayne Haskins
  6. David Montgomery
  7. AJ Brown
  8. DK Metcalf
  9. Deebo Samuel
  10. Hakeem Hutler
  11. TJ Hockenson
  12. Noah Fant
Round 2

  1. Mecole Hardman
  2. JJ Arcega-Whiteside
  3. Parris Campbell
  4. Marquise Brown
  5. Diontae Johnson
  6. Darrell Henderson
  7. Andy Isabella
  8. Devin Singletary
  9. Drew Lock
  10. Miles Boykin
  11. Daniel Jones
  12. Irv Smith Jr.
Round 3

  1. Terry McLaurin
  2. Kelvin Harmon
  3. Damien Harris




Will post updates once more picks come in. 
Round 2 finished up beginning round 3. 

 
Inside the 20  (Be sure to click AFC and NFC links...  there are 2 drafts to look at here)

16-team with IDP
unique scoring system.  I would call it balanced.  Be sure to check it out

 

 
Super flex, 12 teams

https://www71.myfantasyleague.com/2019/options?L=38483&O=17

1.011.The Never-NudesJacobs, Josh OAK RB (R)Fri May 3 2:18:10 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.022.Rowdy Roddy Peepers 2Montgomery, David CHI RB (R)Fri May 3 4:09:41 a.m. CT 2019 

1.033.The Never-NudesHarry, N'Keal NEP WR (R)Fri May 3 4:17:55 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Flying Monkeys.
Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.044.Smoking Jay CutlerMurray, Kyler ARI QB (R)Fri May 3 4:39:40 a.m. CT 2019 

1.055.Blue PlutoHaskins, Dwayne WAS QB (R)Fri May 3 5:06:22 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Hit Parade.]

1.066.Cloud NineCampbell, Parris IND WR (R)Fri May 3 5:43:15 a.m. CT 2019 

1.077.Blue PlutoSamuel, Deebo SFO WR (R)Fri May 3 6:38:26 a.m. CT 2019 

1.088.Clayton MitchellersSanders, Miles PHI RB(R)Fri May 3 8:13:24 a.m. CT 2019 

1.099.League LynxHockenson, T.J. DET TE(R)Fri May 3 8:38:41 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from AlabamaJama.
Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.1010.Hit ParadeButler, Hakeem ARI WR (R)Fri May 3 9:18:35 a.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from The Never-Nudes.
Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.1111.League LynxFant, Noah DEN TE (R)Fri May 3 11:42:52 a.m. CT 2019 

1.1212.Hit ParadeBrown, Marquise BAL WR (R)Fri May 3 12:00:12 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Malinas Heat.
Pick traded from Flying Monkeys.
Pick traded from The Never-Nudes.
Pick traded from Tough Crowd.]

1.1313.Tough CrowdMetcalf, DK SEA WR (R)Fri May 3 12:03:29 p.m. CT 2019[Pick added by commissioner.
Pick traded from Smoking Jay Cutler.
Pick traded from Hit Parade.]

2.0114.Blue PlutoIsabella, Andy ARI WR(R)Fri May 3 12:03:29 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Tough Crowd.
Pick made based on Pre-Draft List]

2.0215.Rowdy Roddy Peepers 2Brown, A.J. TEN WR (R)Fri May 3 12:11:18 p.m. CT 2019 

2.0316.The Never-NudesArcega-Whiteside, JJ PHI WR(R)Fri May 3 12:17:40 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Flying Monkeys.]

2.0417.Smoking Jay CutlerHurd, Jalen SFO WR (R)Fri May 3 12:35:57 p.m. CT 2019 

2.0518.Clayton MitchellersHardman, Mecole KCC WR (R)Fri May 3 1:30:19 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Hit Parade.]

2.0619.Cloud NineLock, Drew DEN QB (R)Fri May 3 1:40:38 p.m. CT 2019 

2.0720.Blue PlutoHarmon, Kelvin WAS WR (R)Fri May 3 1:42:42 p.m. CT 2019 

2.0821.Rowdy Roddy Peepers 2Henderson, Darrell LAR RB (R)Fri May 3 4:46:50 p.m. CT 2019[Pick traded from Clayton Mitchellers.]

2.0922.AlabamaJamaHarris, Damien NEP RB (R)Fri May 3 4:59:32 p.m. CT 2019 

2.1023.Flying MonkeysJones, Daniel NYG QB (R)Fri May 3 4:59:32 p.m. CT 2019
Some absolute steals in there. 1.04 Murray, 1.08 Sanders, 1.13 Metcalf, 2.02 Aj Brown, 2.03 Arcega-Whiteside. This year’s rookie drafts have been wild

 
Some absolute steals in there. 1.04 Murray, 1.08 Sanders, 1.13 Metcalf, 2.02 Aj Brown, 2.03 Arcega-Whiteside. This year’s rookie drafts have been wild
After Jacobs it's the wild West

If you want a player you need to just take him. Forget trying to get "value", just go for your targets.

Casing point - the owner of 2.11 wanted to trade down, I had one target I wanted that I thought would be there at my next pick (3.03) but I wasn't sure. So I traded up to get Diontae Johnson. Turns out that's the guy he was trading down to get. Meanwhile, Singletary and a couple others were still around. So he's not wrong in that Johnson often would slide, but not this time. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
12 team, ppr, 1 QB

1. Josh Jacobs

2. N'Keal Harry 

3. Miles Sanders (trade pick 1.6 and Ebron for my 1.3)

4. Kyler Murray

5. DK Metcalf 

6. Darrell Henderson (my pick, traded down from pick 3. I took Henderson as I had pick 7, 9, 10 and I wanted to make pick 8 pay up for Montgomery as he was rb needy. Henderson is my RB1 in this class and I didnt want to come away with 2 RBs)

7. David Montgomery (trade pick 8, 13, 16 for pick 7 and 14)

8. JJAW (my pick, my wr2 in this draft. stoked about that)

9. AJ Brown (my pick, will take talent over opportunity with this luxury pick)

10. TJ Hockenson (my pick, best available... gives me Engram, Ebron, Hockenson at TE)

11. Hakeem Butler

12. On The Clock

 
12 team, ppr, 1 QB

1. Josh Jacobs

2. N'Keal Harry 

3. Miles Sanders (trade pick 1.6 and Ebron for my 1.3)

4. Kyler Murray

5. DK Metcalf 

6. Darrell Henderson (my pick, traded down from pick 3. I took Henderson as I had pick 7, 9, 10 and I wanted to make pick 8 pay up for Montgomery as he was rb needy. Henderson is my RB1 in this class and I didnt want to come away with 2 RBs)

7. David Montgomery (trade pick 8, 13, 16 for pick 7 and 14)

8. JJAW (my pick, my wr2 in this draft. stoked about that)

9. AJ Brown (my pick, will take talent over opportunity with this luxury pick)

10. TJ Hockenson (my pick, best available... gives me Engram, Ebron, Hockenson at TE)

11. Hakeem Butler

12. On The Clock
Murray in the first round in 1 Qb is a waste. They will be picking top 4 again probably with picks like that. 

 
Dr. Dan said:
12 team, ppr, 1 QB

1. Josh Jacobs

2. N'Keal Harry 

3. Miles Sanders (trade pick 1.6 and Ebron for my 1.3)

4. Kyler Murray

5. DK Metcalf 

6. Darrell Henderson (my pick, traded down from pick 3. I took Henderson as I had pick 7, 9, 10 and I wanted to make pick 8 pay up for Montgomery as he was rb needy. Henderson is my RB1 in this class and I didnt want to come away with 2 RBs)

7. David Montgomery (trade pick 8, 13, 16 for pick 7 and 14)

8. JJAW (my pick, my wr2 in this draft. stoked about that)

9. AJ Brown (my pick, will take talent over opportunity with this luxury pick)

10. TJ Hockenson (my pick, best available... gives me Engram, Ebron, Hockenson at TE)

11. Hakeem Butler

12. On The Clock
https://youtu.be/FPQlXNH36mI

 
Milkman said:
Couldn't be more wrong......
Any resources spent on a qb in a 12 team leagues is a bad choice. Unless you have a top 3-4 team and just need a qb to round it out. I am also assuming 4 points per passing TD. There are just too many serviceable players 

 
Any resources spent on a qb in a 12 team leagues is a bad choice. Unless you have a top 3-4 team and just need a qb to round it out. I am also assuming 4 points per passing TD. There are just too many serviceable players 
I wonder how safe an assumption this is.

 
Any resources spent on a qb in a 12 team leagues is a bad choice. Unless you have a top 3-4 team and just need a qb to round it out. I am also assuming 4 points per passing TD. There are just too many serviceable players 
4 pt passing league Murray is worth even more. QB is deep. I understand what you're saying but man having the hot QB for that given year gives you such a huge advantage. Lots of people won their leagues because QB like Mahomes, Brady, Manning, Rodgers, Wilson, and Cam when they got hot........

 
4 pt passing league Murray is worth even more. QB is deep. I understand what you're saying but man having the hot QB for that given year gives you such a huge advantage. Lots of people won their leagues because QB like Mahomes, Brady, Manning, Rodgers, Wilson, and Cam when they got hot........
I looked at my 9 leagues-4 redraft and 5 dynasty. Mahomes made the finals in one and lost that. He had a top 3 all time QB fantasy season.  This is a small sample size but all I have access to really. But if a qb mattered it seems like his past season would have propelled more teams to the finals. I do understand lots of surrounding circumstances play a part as well. 

 
Any resources spent on a qb in a 12 team leagues is a bad choice. Unless you have a top 3-4 team and just need a qb to round it out. I am also assuming 4 points per passing TD. There are just too many serviceable players 
I disagree wholeheartedly. In the last few years I’ve cleaned up with qb acquisitions flipped at the right time. When you can draft  a  qb that will start in late 2 or later I’ll take it. I’ve made out using a roster spot and a low value rookie pick and flipping it for more when someone has an injury. No one wants to give a pick for an old vet, but a young guy that seems to be on the upswing (Mariota at one time, trubisky, dak are 3 I’ve flipped) for a future 1st or injured player (guice) it can be a solid investment. 

 
I looked at my 9 leagues-4 redraft and 5 dynasty. Mahomes made the finals in one and lost that. He had a top 3 all time QB fantasy season.  This is a small sample size but all I have access to really. But if a qb mattered it seems like his past season would have propelled more teams to the finals. I do understand lots of surrounding circumstances play a part as well. 
That's only one of the monster QB seasons I mentioned but carry on. Murray will be the #1 pick in a lot of drafts late in the rookie drafting season when he starts popping off. 

 
I drafted Mahomes at 1.12 his rookie year. No way I'm going QB before 1.8.
That's a mistake. You pile up talent no matter what position they play. You can flip a young elite QB for a lot or hell just corner the market and kill everyone at that position playing the matchups. 

 
That's only one of the monster QB seasons I mentioned but carry on. Murray will be the #1 pick in a lot of drafts late in the rookie drafting season when he starts popping off. 
So your point was one of the top six QBs was probably in the finals? I agree. There’s a good chance one of 50% of the starting QBs got to the finals.  If Murray is the number one pick in any regular 12 team league. Then that person has zero idea of how fantasy football works. 

 
So your point was one of the top six QBs was probably in the finals? I agree. There’s a good chance one of 50% of the starting QBs got to the finals.  If Murray is the number one pick in any regular 12 team league. Then that person has zero idea of how fantasy football works. 
I'm one of those people then. I would take him 1.01. 

Everybody plays different though. Good luck. 

 
I'm one of those people then. I would take him 1.01. 

Everybody plays different though. Good luck. 
Then you my friend must struggle to win very often. Anyone taking a rookie QB 1.1 in non-SF/2 QB doesn’t know what they’re doing. Fact.

 
Then you my friend must struggle to win very often. Anyone taking a rookie QB 1.1 in non-SF/2 QB doesn’t know what they’re doing. Fact.
I mostly agree, but will also say Treavor Lawrence in 2 years might be my 1.1 I like him that much so far.

 
I mostly agree, but will also say Treavor Lawrence in 2 years might be my 1.1 I like him that much so far.
How many present QBs would you take over Josh Jacobs in 1 QB? For me it’s anywhere from 0-1. Mahomes possibly. I just can’t see the upside if it’s not SF to take even luck or Rodgers let alone an unknown Rookie QB. 

 
That's a mistake. You pile up talent no matter what position they play. You can flip a young elite QB for a lot or hell just corner the market and kill everyone at that position playing the matchups. 
I'd rather pile up RB's and WR's. 

 
There is one player that is likely a transcendent talent. That's Kyler Murray. Pass on him at your own risk. I'm buying everywhere I can.......

 
There is one player that is likely a transcendent talent. That's Kyler Murray. Pass on him at your own risk. I'm buying everywhere I can.......
You can do this intelligently. By taking him later. If someone grabs him a little early then make a move for him by giving that person a little profit rather than spending a premium pick on him off the bat.

 
You can do this intelligently. By taking him later. If someone grabs him a little early then make a move for him by giving that person a little profit rather than spending a premium pick on him off the bat.
In all of my leagues, this never works.

Guys might think long and hard about accepting my 1.10/2.3 for his 1.8 while it’s a pick.  But as soon as it becomes “player X” he isn’t parting with him for less than two 1sts and another prospect.

The endowment effect is extremely strong in my leagues.  

 
Updated:

12 team, ppr, 1 QB

1. Josh Jacobs

2. N'Keal Harry 

3. Miles Sanders (trade pick 1.6 and Ebron for my 1.3)

4. Kyler Murray

5. DK Metcalf 

6. Darrell Henderson (my pick, traded down from pick 3. I took Henderson as I had pick 7, 9, 10 and I wanted to make pick 8 pay up for Montgomery as he was rb needy. Henderson is my RB1 in this class and I didnt want to come away with 2 RBs)

7. David Montgomery (trade pick 8, 13, 16 for pick 7 and 14)

8. JJAW (my pick, my wr2 in this draft. stoked about that)

9. AJ Brown (my pick, will take talent over opportunity with this luxury pick)

10. TJ Hockenson (my pick, best available... gives me Engram, Ebron, Hockenson at TE)

11. Hakeem Butler

12. Marquise Brown

13. Andy Isabella (my pick. Swapped 13 and 14 in my deal for Montgomery. Considered him at 10, glad to get him here).

14. Parris Campbell

15. Mecole Hardman

16. Deebo Samuel (my pick again, this is the extra one I got from the above trade. I think this is an absolute steal)

17. Damien Harris

18. Devin Singletary

19. Miles Boykin

20. Justice Hill

21. Noah Fant

22. Alexander Mattison

 
In all of my leagues, this never works.

Guys might think long and hard about accepting my 1.10/2.3 for his 1.8 while it’s a pick.  But as soon as it becomes “player X” he isn’t parting with him for less than two 1sts and another prospect.

The endowment effect is extremely strong in my leagues.  
When it’s a player in a low demand position that’s being picked in the mid 2nd of drafts on average that someone reaches for a bit I think it’s much more viable. If they reach too far you just let it go and be happy with the value that fell in the process.

 
I wonder where Mahomes would get drafted in a rookie redraft of the 2017 class right now? That class was a lot stronger at RB than this class is. 

 
Dr. Dan said:
Updated:

12 team, ppr, 1 QB

1. Josh Jacobs

2. N'Keal Harry 

3. Miles Sanders (trade pick 1.6 and Ebron for my 1.3)

4. Kyler Murray

5. DK Metcalf 

6. Darrell Henderson (my pick, traded down from pick 3. I took Henderson as I had pick 7, 9, 10 and I wanted to make pick 8 pay up for Montgomery as he was rb needy. Henderson is my RB1 in this class and I didnt want to come away with 2 RBs)

7. David Montgomery (trade pick 8, 13, 16 for pick 7 and 14)

8. JJAW (my pick, my wr2 in this draft. stoked about that)

9. AJ Brown (my pick, will take talent over opportunity with this luxury pick)

10. TJ Hockenson (my pick, best available... gives me Engram, Ebron, Hockenson at TE)

11. Hakeem Butler

12. Marquise Brown

13. Andy Isabella (my pick. Swapped 13 and 14 in my deal for Montgomery. Considered him at 10, glad to get him here).

14. Parris Campbell

15. Mecole Hardman

16. Deebo Samuel (my pick again, this is the extra one I got from the above trade. I think this is an absolute steal)

17. Damien Harris

18. Devin Singletary

19. Miles Boykin

20. Justice Hill

21. Noah Fant

22. Alexander Mattison
Agree...that is a steal on deebo

 
Ratbone said:
Murray in the first round in 1 Qb is a waste. They will be picking top 4 again probably with picks like that. 
I'm in a 10 teamer (start 1 QB) and the guy with the #1 pick (draft in a few weeks) is saying he's taking Murray at #1 overall - saying he's getting the next Mahommes.  I love that league.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Like Breshad Perriman?
Didn't Perriman get injured a lot and couldn't run routes? 

I think this Hollywood guy is something else than Perriman and if he would have been picked by Patriots he would be #1 pick of the whole draft. So situation is not the best, but Hollywood ain't no Perriman.

 
Didn't Perriman get injured a lot and couldn't run routes? 

I think this Hollywood guy is something else than Perriman and if he would have been picked by Patriots he would be #1 pick of the whole draft. So situation is not the best, but Hollywood ain't no Perriman.
Well I was responding to this quote: "but IMO Baltimore didnt spend a 1st round pick on a WR they dont have plans to use effectively" - I'm sure they planned to use Perriman effective as well, but the best laid plans of mice and men...

As far as Brown being the better prospect, maybe you're right about that but both were thought of high enough to be drafted in the first round. Personally I think it was a toss up as they both have their strengths and weaknesses. Brown has a pretty low bar set up in order to surpass Perriman now though.

And as to the situation; "not the best" is a kind way to put it. Brown's situation basically took him off my draft board. We already had an extremely undersized WR to begin with but now he goes to a run first team with a QB that has some serious accuracy issues. I don't want to write Jackson off completely and maybe he shows some improvement as a passer, but I just wouldn't want to rely on a QB catching passes in this offense.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top