In search of programming content, WIP is doing "Once And For All" week, to settle long-standing Philly sports debates. Yesterday's topic - D
onovan McNabb: underrated or overrated?
I agree with the consensus; thought it then and still do now that he was under-appreciated by many of the fans because of not winning a Super Bowl (same with Andy Reid.) My perspective is/was that he's a player that regularly gave us a chance to win it for almost a decade. That was more than what most teams could say about their QB. But it seemed like too many times fans wanted to discount him as a "bum who can't win the big one" and were delusional to think we could just pull someone else who could out of thin air, at a moment's notice.
Even with that said, he's not without flaws. He was/is a big baby about the draft boos, always had an awkward relationship with the fans/city, and definitely "heaved" in the Super Bowl huddle (Jon Runyan, in a small Q&A with season ticket holders that I was at a few years ago said he "absolutely heaved" but couldn't confirm if it was wet or dry), but I've always given him the benefit of the doubt that it was due to heat/exertion/conditioning, and not nerves/wimpiness.