Long Ball Larry
Footballguy
In this thread, I will meander toward a ranking of every original Rage Against The Machine song. Why am I doing this? Well, everyone else gets to have a self-indulgent music thread, so why not me?! But honestly, no band in my life has had more of an impact on my worldview, general personality, musical tastes, and my own guitar and bass playing. When their first album dropped and that Freedom video came out, it honestly changed everything about what I thought about music, about what was going on the world, and what individuals could do. It made me disillusioned, disgusted, inspired and free all at once. We've actually been watching the Matrix trilogy lately with my daughter and I think that being exposed to Rage Against The Machine was kind of like my red pill moment. (And yes, I am talking about the Matrix, so don't get too excited you word-skimming distractophile incels). Around the same time, I started reading about all different religions throughout the world*, read the book Jack about a kid whose father comes out as being gay** and went on a sailing trip in the Carribean*** where I met a one-legged homeless man named Byron begging on the docks of Antigua who seemed as happy as a clam.
I got angry (yes, Zach, it was gift.) I got inspired to learn more and more and this hit just prior to us getting the internet at home, which fed my insatiable hunger to learn and understand about the "real" world. I got an imprint of anti-establishment edge that has never left me, even as I while away the hours in a square office, living in a bourgeois neighborhood, drinking coffee that is too expensive, spending hours poring over microbrew selections ... well, you know what white people like. I am officially the most militant dilettante.
Anyway, the point is this: I am an affluent caucasian male, so I get to be the arbiter of what is good and bad and make sure everyone else knows about it. Wait, no, that's not it. The point is that for some reason, I have just gotten this bug in my brain (not unlike that of Agent Smith himself) and my soul to re-examine the entire catalog of RATM in a serious way. It doesn't hurt that The Matrix and The Matrix Reloaded end with Rage songs. And it may not hurt that my daughter is 15, and it is interesting to see her own intellectual, emotional and spiritual development.
I will not rank cover songs (from Renegades or otherwise), solo work from Tom Morello, solo work from Zach De La Rocha, Street Sweeper Social Club, The Night Watchman, One Day as a Lion, Audioslave, Prophets of Rage, or any other works not done by Rage Against the machine proper. I will consider these for subsequent rankings.
Rankings will be based on the following dimensions:
Groove
Repeat listenability
Sonic power and feeling
Technical innovation
Guitar Riffs and Solos
Knowledge
Emotion
Lyrical fire
Bass lines
Wild Card!
Some general observations:
1) I had been prepared to obliterate 3 of the 5 songs from the demos that were released, but in re-listening, I could really hear the core elements that they went on to refine and implement in later songs, so I could not completely flay them and none of them will be the song in dead last. Which one will it be?!
2) It's also interesting listening to Zach's vocals in those demos, which are much more calm and lacking passion and really kind of bring of the songs down. He may have been tired after everything he was sending out during his time in Inside Out. It's also really interesting how important that fire is to the band and why the side projects such as Audioslave, Prophets of Rage and Street Sweeper Social Club haven't really worked, despite having the same type of musical beds and seriously amazing vocalists and lyricists in their own right.
3) Snakecharmer on Evil Empire is where it seems like the band really starts taking a turn to more interesting musical composition and sets the stage for a so much of Morello's later work.
All rankings are based on my personal assessment, though should we require and decisions that are final and arbitrary, those will be provided by @hagmania, a fact of which he is just learning at this moment.
*hey, so um, doesn't it kind of seem like each of these is highly geographically-based? So like, isn't around 80% or more of your religious belief just random coincidence? And I'm supposed to just be Presbyterian because? "They have a different system of elders and governance than other Christian sects." That is essentially what I was told when I asked my dad what the difference was between Presbyterians and other religions. That was a cause that I could get behind!
**i took this trip with my uncle, who was a sailor (a rich guy, not like a noble naval soldier), and his family. My couisn was the same age as me and we always got along. His mom suggested to him that he read the book Jack. He ridiculed the notion of reading a book about a kid whose father is guy. Oddly enough, my cousin later came out as gay himself.
***Great encapsulation of my life that even as I am experiencing illuminating truths about the underlying nature of the world, I am doing it from the glass case of decadence.****
****Footnotes, really? Talk about self-indulgent tedium.
RANKINGS
40. (Tie) - Tire Me - Evil Empire
40 (Tie) - Mindset's a Threat - Demos
38. Snakecharmer - Evil Empire
37. Autologic - Demos
36. The Narrows - Demos
35. Sleep Now in the Fire - The Battle of Los Angeles
34. Settle for Nothing - Rage Against the Machine
33. Fistful of Steel - Rage Against the Machine
32. Voice of the Voiceless - The Battle of Los Angeles
31. Township Rebellion - Rage Against the Machine
30. Ashes in the Fall - The Battle of Los Angeles
29. Born as Ghosts - The Battle of Los Angeles
28. Wind Below - Evil Empire
27. Bombtrack - Rage Against the Machine
26. Killing in the Name - Rage Against the Machine
25. No Shelter - Godzilla Soundtrack
24. Born of a Broken Man - The Battle of Los Angeles
23. Take the Power Back - Rage Against the Machine
22. Roll Right - Evil Empire
21. Year of the Boomerang - Evil Empire (pending re-ranking)
20. Bullet in the Head - Rage Against the Machine
19. War Within a Breath - The Battle of Los Angeles
18. Revolver - Evil Empire
17. Vietnow - Evil Empire
16. Calm Like a Bomb - The Battle of Los Angeles
15. New Millenium Homes - The Battle of Los Angeles
14. Clear the Lane - Demos
13. Maria - Evil Empire
12. Mic Check - The Battle of Los Angeles
11. Wake Up - Rage Against The Machine
10. Freedom - Rage Against The Machine
9. Testify - Single
8. Testify - The Battle of Los Angeles
7. Darkness of Greed - Demos
6. Guerrilla Radio - The Battle of Los Angeles
5. Bulls on Parade - Evil Empire
4. Down Rodeo - Evil Empire
3. Without a Face - Evil Empire
2. People of the Sun - Evil Empire
1. Know Your Enemy - Rage Against the Machine
I got angry (yes, Zach, it was gift.) I got inspired to learn more and more and this hit just prior to us getting the internet at home, which fed my insatiable hunger to learn and understand about the "real" world. I got an imprint of anti-establishment edge that has never left me, even as I while away the hours in a square office, living in a bourgeois neighborhood, drinking coffee that is too expensive, spending hours poring over microbrew selections ... well, you know what white people like. I am officially the most militant dilettante.
Anyway, the point is this: I am an affluent caucasian male, so I get to be the arbiter of what is good and bad and make sure everyone else knows about it. Wait, no, that's not it. The point is that for some reason, I have just gotten this bug in my brain (not unlike that of Agent Smith himself) and my soul to re-examine the entire catalog of RATM in a serious way. It doesn't hurt that The Matrix and The Matrix Reloaded end with Rage songs. And it may not hurt that my daughter is 15, and it is interesting to see her own intellectual, emotional and spiritual development.
I will not rank cover songs (from Renegades or otherwise), solo work from Tom Morello, solo work from Zach De La Rocha, Street Sweeper Social Club, The Night Watchman, One Day as a Lion, Audioslave, Prophets of Rage, or any other works not done by Rage Against the machine proper. I will consider these for subsequent rankings.
Rankings will be based on the following dimensions:
Groove
Repeat listenability
Sonic power and feeling
Technical innovation
Guitar Riffs and Solos
Knowledge
Emotion
Lyrical fire
Bass lines
Wild Card!
Some general observations:
1) I had been prepared to obliterate 3 of the 5 songs from the demos that were released, but in re-listening, I could really hear the core elements that they went on to refine and implement in later songs, so I could not completely flay them and none of them will be the song in dead last. Which one will it be?!
2) It's also interesting listening to Zach's vocals in those demos, which are much more calm and lacking passion and really kind of bring of the songs down. He may have been tired after everything he was sending out during his time in Inside Out. It's also really interesting how important that fire is to the band and why the side projects such as Audioslave, Prophets of Rage and Street Sweeper Social Club haven't really worked, despite having the same type of musical beds and seriously amazing vocalists and lyricists in their own right.
3) Snakecharmer on Evil Empire is where it seems like the band really starts taking a turn to more interesting musical composition and sets the stage for a so much of Morello's later work.
All rankings are based on my personal assessment, though should we require and decisions that are final and arbitrary, those will be provided by @hagmania, a fact of which he is just learning at this moment.
*hey, so um, doesn't it kind of seem like each of these is highly geographically-based? So like, isn't around 80% or more of your religious belief just random coincidence? And I'm supposed to just be Presbyterian because? "They have a different system of elders and governance than other Christian sects." That is essentially what I was told when I asked my dad what the difference was between Presbyterians and other religions. That was a cause that I could get behind!
**i took this trip with my uncle, who was a sailor (a rich guy, not like a noble naval soldier), and his family. My couisn was the same age as me and we always got along. His mom suggested to him that he read the book Jack. He ridiculed the notion of reading a book about a kid whose father is guy. Oddly enough, my cousin later came out as gay himself.
***Great encapsulation of my life that even as I am experiencing illuminating truths about the underlying nature of the world, I am doing it from the glass case of decadence.****
****Footnotes, really? Talk about self-indulgent tedium.
RANKINGS
40. (Tie) - Tire Me - Evil Empire
40 (Tie) - Mindset's a Threat - Demos
38. Snakecharmer - Evil Empire
37. Autologic - Demos
36. The Narrows - Demos
35. Sleep Now in the Fire - The Battle of Los Angeles
34. Settle for Nothing - Rage Against the Machine
33. Fistful of Steel - Rage Against the Machine
32. Voice of the Voiceless - The Battle of Los Angeles
31. Township Rebellion - Rage Against the Machine
30. Ashes in the Fall - The Battle of Los Angeles
29. Born as Ghosts - The Battle of Los Angeles
28. Wind Below - Evil Empire
27. Bombtrack - Rage Against the Machine
26. Killing in the Name - Rage Against the Machine
25. No Shelter - Godzilla Soundtrack
24. Born of a Broken Man - The Battle of Los Angeles
23. Take the Power Back - Rage Against the Machine
22. Roll Right - Evil Empire
21. Year of the Boomerang - Evil Empire (pending re-ranking)
20. Bullet in the Head - Rage Against the Machine
19. War Within a Breath - The Battle of Los Angeles
18. Revolver - Evil Empire
17. Vietnow - Evil Empire
16. Calm Like a Bomb - The Battle of Los Angeles
15. New Millenium Homes - The Battle of Los Angeles
14. Clear the Lane - Demos
13. Maria - Evil Empire
12. Mic Check - The Battle of Los Angeles
11. Wake Up - Rage Against The Machine
10. Freedom - Rage Against The Machine
9. Testify - Single
8. Testify - The Battle of Los Angeles
7. Darkness of Greed - Demos
6. Guerrilla Radio - The Battle of Los Angeles
5. Bulls on Parade - Evil Empire
4. Down Rodeo - Evil Empire
3. Without a Face - Evil Empire
2. People of the Sun - Evil Empire
1. Know Your Enemy - Rage Against the Machine
Last edited by a moderator: